6-K
 

 
 
SECURITIES AND EXCHANGE COMMISSION
WASHINGTON, D.C. 20549
Form 6-K
Report of Foreign Private Issuer
Pursuant to Rule 13a-16 or 15d-16
of the Securities Exchange Act of 1934
April 11th, 2006
SCOR
(Exact name of Registrant as specified in its chapter)
1, Avenue du Général de Gaulle
92074 Paris — La Défense Cedex, France
(Address of principal executive offices)
Indicate by check mark whether the registrant files or will file annual reports under cover Form 20-F or Form 40-F.
Form 20-F þ      Form 40-F o
Indicate by check mark whether the registrant by furnishing the information contained in this Form is also thereby furnishing the information to the Commission pursuant to Rule 12g3-2(b) under the Securities Exchange Act of 1934.
Yes o       No þ
If “Yes” is marked, indicate below the file number assigned to the registrant in connection with Rule 12g3-2(b): Not Applicable.
 
 

 


 

Signature
Pursuant to the requirements of the Securities Exchange Act of 1934, the registrant has duly caused this report to be signed on its behalf by the undersigned, thereunto duly authorized.
Dated: April 11th, 2006
         
  SCOR
(Registrant)
 
 
  By:     /s/ MARCEL KAHN    
    Marcel Kahn,   
    Chief Financial Officer   

- 2 -


 

(LOGO)
FINANCIAL REPORT 2005
 
REFERENCE DOCUMENT

Page 1 of 184


 

NOTE
The data contained in this “document de reference” (reference document) may contain information on SCOR objectives or forward-looking statements, particularly in the sections 8.1 – “Strategy” and 8.3 “Recent Trends.” This information is sometimes identified by the use of the future tense or the conditional mood, and terms such as “think,” “are expected to,” “should,” “presume”, “believe,” or “might.”
This information is not historical data and must not be interpreted as guarantees that the stated facts and data will occur or that the objectives will be met. Because of their nature, these objectives might not be met and the assumptions on which they are based may be erroneous. We advise readers of this reference document to not place absolute confidence in the achievement of these objectives or on the accuracy of these forward-looking statements because actual events and results might differ significantly from the stated objectives or results implied by the forward-looking information contained in this reference document.
The Company confirms that the information from third parties, contained in this Reference Document in Sections 2.3 - (SCOR 18-month share performance, 7.13 - Securities Giving Access to Share Capital, 7.17 - Ownership of Share Capital and 8.5 Products and Markets – Competitive Position of our Life Insurance and Non-Life Insurance Activities, has been, to our knowledge, faithfully reported and that, with the publication of the data in this reference document, no material fact has been omitted that would cause the information contained herein to be inexact or incorrect.

Page 2 of 184


 

     
1      GROUP ORGANIZATIONAL CHART
  5
2      SCOR SHARES
  6
2.1           STOCK LISTING
  6
2.2           PER SHARE DATA
  6
2.3           SCOR 18-MONTH SHARE PERFORMANCE
  7
2.4           DIVIDENDS
  7
3      ACTIVITIES OF THE GROUP
  8
4      GROUP KEY FIGURES
  10
5      CONSOLIDATED FINANCIAL STATEMENTS
  11
5.1           CONSOLIDATED BALANCE SHEET
  11
5.2           CONSOLIDATED STATEMENT OF INCOME
  13
5.3           CONSOLIDATED STATEMENT OF CASH FLOWS
  14
5.4           CHANGE IN SHAREHOLDERS’ EQUITY
  15
5.5           SEGMENT INFORMATION
  16
5.6           SIGNIFICANT EVENTS OF THE YEAR
  18
5.7          NOTES TO THE CONSOLIDATED FINANCIAL STATEMENTS
  21
5.8           STATUTORY AUDITORS’ REPORT ON THE CONSOLIDATED FINANCIAL STATEMENTS
  70
6      SCOR PARENT COMPANY FINANCIAL STATEMENTS
  72
6.1           SIGNIFICANT EVENTS OF THE YEAR
  72
6.2           BALANCE SHEET — (SCOR SA FINANCIAL STATEMENTS)
  73
6.3           STATEMENT OF INCOME (SCOR SA CORPORATE FINANCIAL STATEMENTS)
  75
6.4           OFF-BALANCE SHEET ITEMS (SCOR SA CORPORATE FINANCIAL STATEMENTS)
  78
6.5           NOTES TO PARENT COMPANY FINANCIAL STATEMENTS
  79
6.6           GENERAL REPORT OF THE STATUTORY AUDITORS ON THE NON-CONSOLIDATED FINANCIAL STATEMENTS
95
7      GENERAL INFORMATION ABOUT THE COMPANY AND ITS SHARE CAPITAL
  97
7.1           REGISTERED NAME AND CORPORATE HEADQUARTERS
  97
7.2           REGULATORY ENVIRONMENT AND APPLICABLE LEGISLATION
  97
7.3           DATE OF FORMATION AND DATE OF EXPIRATION
  98
7.4           CORPORATE PURPOSE (ART. 3 OF THE BYLAWS)
  98
7.5           COMPANY REGISTRATION
  98
7.6           CONSULTATION OF CORPORATE DOCUMENTS
  98
7.7           FISCAL YEAR (ARTICLE 19 OF THE BYLAWS)
  98
7.8           STATUTORY DISTRIBUTION OF PROFITS (ART. 19 OF THE BYLAWS)
  98
7.9           SHAREHOLDERS’ MEETINGS
  99
7.10         REPURCHASE OF SHARES BY THE CORPORATION
  99
7.11         INFORMATION CONCERNING THE COMMON STOCK
  102
7.12         AUTHORIZED SHARE CAPITAL
  102
7.13         SECURITIES GIVING ACCESS TO SHARE CAPITAL
  102
7.14         PERFORMANCE OF “OCEANE” BONDS SINCE THEIR ISSUANCE
  103
7.15         SCOR SHARE SUBSCRIPTION OPTIONS
  104
7.16         CHANGES IN THE SHARE CAPITAL OF SCOR OVER THE LAST FIVE YEARS
  105
7.17         OWNERSHIP OF SHARE CAPITAL
  106
7.18         EMPLOYEE SHAREHOLDING
  107
7.19         IRP
  107
8      INFORMATION ABOUT THE GROUP’S ACTIVITIES
  109
8.1           STRATEGY
  109
8.2           HISTORICAL BACKGROUND
  109
8.3           RECENT DEVELOPMENTS
  110
8.4           THE REINSURANCE BUSINESS
  110
8.5           PRODUCTS AND MARKETS
  112
8.6           DISTRIBUTION BY GEOGRAPHIC AREA
  114
8.7           FINANCIAL RATINGS
  114
8.8           GROUP EMPLOYEES
  115
8.9           RISK FACTORS AFFECTING THE COMPANY
  115
8.10         UNDERWRITING, RISK MANAGEMENT AND RETROCESSION
  123
8.11         RESERVES
  126
8.12         INVESTMENTS
  128
8.13         BUSINESS OPERATIONS
  129
8.14         PROPERTY AND EQUIPMENT
  130
8.15         INFORMATION TECHNOLOGY
  130
8.16         EXCEPTIONAL EVENTS AND LITIGATION
  130
8.17         REFERENCE SYSTEM
  132
9      CORPORATE GOVERNANCE
  133
9.1           INFORMATION CONCERNING THE MEMBERS OF THE BOARD OF DIRECTORS
  133
9.2           BIOGRAPHICAL INFORMATION ON MEMBERS OF THE BOARD OF DIRECTORS
  142
9.3           TERMS AND CONDITIONS FOR THE PREPARATION AND ORGANIZATION OF WORK OF THE BOARD OF DIRECTORS
  143
9.4           COMMITTEES OF THE BOARD
  143
9.5           EXECUTIVE COMMITTEE
  143
9.6           BIOGRAPHICAL INFORMATION ON THE MEMBERS OF THE EXECUTIVE COMMITTEE
  145
9.7           STATEMENTS ON THE COMPANY’S CORPORATE GOVERNANCE
  146
9.8           COMPENSATION AND BENEFITS OF GROUP DIRECTORS, OFFICERS AND MEMBERS OF THE EXECUTIVE COMMITTEE
  146

Page 3 of 184


 

     
9.9           STOCK OPTIONS HELD BY THE MEMBERS OF THE EXECUTIVE COMMITTEE AT DECEMBER 31, 2005
  151
9.10         OTHER STOCK COMPENSATION
  154
9.11         STOCK OPTIONS GRANTED TO THE TOP TEN NON-OFFICER EMPLOYEES AND EXERCIZED BY THEM DURING FISCAL YEAR 2005
  156
9.12         NUMBER OF SHARES HELD BY DIRECTORS AND EXECUTIVE OFFICERS AT DECEMBER 31, 2005
  156
9.13         REPORT OF THE CHAIRMAN OF THE BOARD OF DIRECTORS ON THE TERMS AND CONDITIONS FOR PREPARING AND ORGANIZING THE WORK OF THE BOARD OF DIRECTORS AND ON INTERNAL CONTROL PROCEDURES IN COMPLIANCE WITH ARTICLE L.225-37 OF THE FRENCH COMMERCIAL CODE
  157
9.14         STATUTORY AUDITORS’ REPORT, PREPARED IN ACCORDANCE WITH ARTICLE L. 225-235 OF THE FRENCH COMMERCIAL CODE, ON THE REPORT PREPARED BY THE CHAIRMAN OF THE BOARD OF DIRECTORS OF SCOR, ON INFORMATION GIVEN ON THE INTERNAL CONTROL PROCEDURES RELATING TO THE PREPARATION AND PROCESSING OF FINANCIAL AND ACCOUNTING INFORMATION
  170
10       AGREEMENTS
  171
10.1         RELATED PARTY-AGREEMENTS SIGNED IN 2005 AS DEFINED BY ARTICLES L.225-38 ET SEQ. OF THE FRENCH COMMERCIAL CODE
  171
10.2         AGREEMENTS APPROVED IN PRIOR FISCAL YEARS AND CONTINUED OR TERMINATED IN 2005
  174
11       ANNUAL INFORMATION DOCUMENT
  176
11.1         PUBLISHED INFORMATION
  176
11.2         INFORMATION AVAILABILITY
  180
12       PERSON RESPONSIBLE FOR THE DOCUMENT
  180
12.1         CERTIFICATION
  180
12.2         INDEPENDENT AUDITORS RESPONSIBLE FOR THE CONTROL OF THE ACCOUNTS
  180
12.3         FEES PAID BY SCOR GROUP TO THE AUDITORS
  181
12.4         FINANCIAL INFORMATION
  181
12.5         INFORMATION INCORPORATED BY REFERENCE
  181
13            CONCORDANCE TABLE
  182

Page 4 of 184


 

1. GROUP ORGANIZATIONAL CHART
SCOR GROUP ORGANIZATIONAL CHART ON DECEMBER 31, 2005
(FLOW CHART)

Page 5 of 184


 

2.       SCOR SHARES
2.1.  STOCK LISTING
SCOR’s shares are listed on the Paris Stock Exchange, on the New York Stock Exchange in the form of American Depositary Shares (ADS), and on the Frankfurt Unlisted Securities Market.
SCOR’s shares are included in the following indexes:
       
       
SBF 80
    DOW JONES EUROPE STOXX 600 INDEX
       
SBF 120
    DOW JONES EURO STOXX INDEX
       
SBF 250
    DOW JONES EUROPE STOXX INSURANCE INDEX
       
CAC MID 100
    DOW JONES EURO STOXX INSURANCE INDEX
       
CAC MID & SMALL 190
    DOW JONES EUROPE STOXX SMALL CAP INDEX
       
EURONEXT PARIS FINANCIERES
    DOW JONES EURO STOXX SMALL CAP INDEX
       
EURONEXT PARIS ASSURANCE
     
       
EURONEXT NEXT 150
     
       
EURONEXT NEXT PRIME
     
       
The most significant trading takes place on the Paris Stock Exchange. The average monthly volume of transactions stood at 118.5 million shares from January through December 2005 inclusive and at 140 million shares from January through March 20, 2006 inclusive.
2.2. PER SHARE DATA
                                   
       
2001

   
2002

   
2003

   
2004

   
2005

 
                                   
 
Number of shares in circulation as of December 31
    41,244,216     136,544,845     136,544,845     819,269,070     968,769,070  
 
Share equivalents:
                               
 
Treasury stock
    (3,630,417)         (489,500)     (9,298,085)     (9,110,915)  
 
Options calculated via “treasury stock method”
    292,065                 1,699,062  
 
Convertible or exchangeable bonds
    4,025,000         (1)     105,485,232     100,000,000  
 
Number of diluted shares as of December 31
    41,930,864     136,544,845     136,055,345     915,456,217     1,061,357,213  
                                   
 
Average number of diluted shares
    38,288,065     136,591,766     136,300,095     529,159,021     989,324,565  
                                   
 
Share Price (in )*
                               
 
high
    58.20     46.80     2.86 (3)     1.80     1.89  
 
low(2)
    24.47     3.42     1.15     1.00     1.38  
 
at December 31 (2)
    35.41     5.05     1.31     1.39     1.82  
                                   
 
Market capitalization at December 31
(in millions of euros)
    1,460     689     1,073(4)     1,139     1,763(5)  
                                   
 
Diluted Price/ Income ratio (in )
                               
 
high
    N.S     N.S     N.S     20     12  
 
low
    N.S     N.S     N.S     11     9  
 
at December 31
    N.S     N.S     N.S     15     11  
                                   
 
Yield at December 31
                               
 
net of tax credit
    0.8%     N.S     N.S     2.2%     2.7%  
 
with tax credit – individuals
    1.3%     N.S     N.S     2.2%     2.7%  
 
with tax credit – other shareholders
    1.0%     N.S     N.S     2.2%     2.7%  
                                   
(1)   At the end of 2003, taking into account the share price and the conversion price, the convertible or exchangeable bonds and the stock options no longer have a dilutive effect on the calculation of income and net asset per share. (2) After detachment of the preferential subscription rights, SCOR’s share price at closing was at its lowest on December 22, 2003, which was the closing date of the share capital increase subscription period. (3) After application of the adjustment coefficient of 0.45046. (4) After the share capital increase, the number of shares in circulation stood at 819,269,070. (5) After the share capital increase of June 30, 2005, the number of shares in circulation stood at 968,769,070.
The EPS calculation is defined in Note 26 of the consolidated financial statements.

Page 6 of 184


 

2.3 SCOR 18-MONTH SHARE PERFORMANCE
Source Euronext
The SCOR share data presented below comprise data concerning OTC trading.
                                               
                TOTAL TRANSACTIONS

    HIGH/LOW

   
                        Capital

    High

    Low

   
  Year     Month     Volume     (millions )     (In )     (In )    
           
 
2000
      N/A     31,170,203       1,504       60       40.05    
 
2001
      N/A     20,995,851       927       58.2       24.47    
 
2002
      N/A     61,661,310       1,033       29.09       3.42    
 
2003
      N/A     313,568,011       1,062       6.48       1.14    
           
 
 
    1st quarter     672,606,238       1,020       1.74       1.20    
           
 
 
    2nd quarter     230,611,977       298       1.53       1.15    
           
 
2004
    3rd quarter     264,966,780       319       1.39       1.00    
           
 
 
    October     40,935,858       51       1.30       1.19    
           
 
 
    November     121,426,933       168       1.48       1.21    
           
 
 
    December     104,900,657       150       1.53       1.36    
           
 
 
    January     75,708,878       113       1.58       1.38    
           
 
 
    February     72,874,922       115       1.64       1.50    
           
 
 
    March     84,488,496       138       1.70       1.52    
           
 
 
    April     85,991,664       138       1.69       1.49    
           
 
 
    May     96,236,888       155       1.71       1.46    
           
 
 
    June     168,580,282       272       1.69       1.54    
           
 
2005
    July     203,006,449       342       1.76       1.57    
           
 
 
    August     176,179,929       302       1.84       1.59    
           
 
 
    September     141,487,164       237       1.74       1.60    
           
 
 
    October     110,820,086       187       1.77       1.61    
           
 
 
    November     98,436,676       166       1.75       1.62    
           
 
 
    December     108,573,398       198       1.89       1.71    
           
 
2006
    January     194,052,142       380       2.11       1.81    
           
 
 
    February     144,931,333       297       2.19       1.97    
           
 
 
    March                                  
 
 
    (to March 20)     79,720,876       166       2.21       1.99    
           
2.4 DIVIDENDS
                         
Year     Dividend     Distribution     Total Income (1)
            Rate      
                  Individuals and      
                  Parent Company     Others
                         
2001
    0.30     NA     0.45     0.345
2002
    0     NA     NA     NA
2003
    0     NA     NA     NA
2004
    0.03     35.80%     0.03     0.03
                         
2005
    0.05     36.50%     0.05     0.05
                         
(1)   The special tax credit attached to dividends (“Avoir Fiscal”) was abandoned in 2004.
No dividend was distributed in 2002 and 2003, based on decisions made by the General Meeting of Shareholders of May 15, 2003 and May 18, 2004. A dividend of 0.03 per share was distributed in 2004 based on the decision made by the General Meeting of Shareholders of May 31, 2005. The resolution that will be presented to the General Meeting of Shareholders held to approve the accounts for the year ending 2005 includes a dividend of 0.05 per share for 2005.
Dividends are forfeited after 5 years. Dividends not claimed are forfeited to the French State (administration des domaines).

Page 7 of 184


 

3. ACTIVITIES OF THE GROUP
1. Global business in 2005 was in line with forecasts at the beginning of the fiscal year.
Gross premiums written in 2005 totaled 2,407 million, in line with forecasts, compared to 2,561 for 2004, representing a decrease of 6% (8% at constant exchange rates). This contraction was mainly due to the decline in savings in the United States.
2. The Group’s global income reflects its technical profitability
Operating income for 2005 reached 242 million, versus 199 million in 2004.
Net income attributable to the Group in 2005 increased to 131 million, versus net income of 75 million in 2004.
Group operating cash flow for 2005 totaled -594 million. Excluding commutations of approximately 600 million, cash flow became positive again.
Liabilities from contracts net of retrocession reached 8,866 million at December 31, 2005, versus 9,020 million at December 31, 2004, representing a decline of 1.7%. This decline was due to the impact of commutations and foreign exchange fluctuations.
The adequacy of the Group’s reserves was confirmed by internal and external reviews by actuaries during the closing of the accounts.
Group shareholders’ equity stood at 1,719 million at December 31, 2005, versus 1,335 million at December 31, 2004. This rise in shareholders’ equity includes the share capital increase of June 30, 2005 for the net amount of 224 million.
Group general expenses reached 200 million in 2005 versus 196 million in 2004.
Total Group staff declined by 5.5% to 994 persons at December 31, 2005.
3. Results by business operation
3.1. The Non-Life Reinsurance business (Property and Casualty, Large Corporate Accounts,Credit and Surety and CRP treaties) generated premium income of 1,383 million for 2005, down 1% compared to 2003 (-4% at constant exchange rates).
Non-Life Reinsurance income (net operating income before general expenses and financial income) declined to 29 million in 2005 versus 85 million in 2004.
This income was affected by the cost of major natural disasters that occurred in 2005 in the United States and Mexico (Katrina, Wilma, Rita) as well as in Europe (the Gudrun storm, floods in Eastern Europe) in the amount of 168 million. Major natural catastrophes are defined by SCOR as events that result in a net retrocession cost for the Group that exceeds 10 million.
The net combined ratio of Non-Life Reinsurance business was 106.5% in 2005, versus 101.8% in 2004. Excluding CRP, the net combined ratio of Non-Life Reinsurance business was 102.8% in 2005. Excluding CRP and major natural catastrophes, this ratio would be 90.8%.
The net operating income for the Non-Life Reinsurance business increased to 159 million in 2005, versus 153 million in 2004. Net operating income benefited from strong technical performance as well as improved performance in the financial markets.
Liabilities relating to policies, net of retrocession from the Non-Life Reinsurance business amounted to 5,652 million at December 31, 2005, compared to 5,785 million at December 31, 2004, down 2% due to the impact of currency exchange and to significant liquidations and commutations in the portion of the SCOR U.S. portfolio in run-off.
3.2. The Life reinsurance business (individual and group policies, long-term care insurance, financing, accidents, disability, unemployment) reflected a decline in revenues in 2005 to 1,024 million, a contraction of 12% versus 2004 due to a drop in savings in the United States.
The operating income from Life reinsurance business reached 83 million in 2005 versus 46 million in 2004, representing an 8.2% margin of net premiums.
Net technical reserves from Life reinsurance business stood at 3,214 million at December 31, 2005 versus 3,235 million at December 31, 2004, representing a decline of 1%.

Page 8 of 184


 

4. Asset Management in 2005
Financial income net of expenses (excluding borrowing costs) stood at 426 million in 2005 versus 315 million in 2004. Financial income from operations, net of expenses, dropped to 288 millions versus 309 millions in 2004. Capital gains from investments net of depreciation stood at 91 million versus 20 million in 2004 with foreign exchange gains reflecting a profit of 8 million versus a loss of -13 millions in 2004.
The change in investments adjusted to reflect income at market value generated a profit of 39 million versus a loss of -1 million in 2004.
Total investments reached 9,743 million at December 31, 2005, a decline of 2.9% as compared to December 31, 2004. The breakdown includes bonds (56%), loans and cash deposits (14%), shares and equity interests (10%), real estate investments (3%) and cash equivalents (17%).

Page 9 of 184


 

4. GROUP KEY FIGURES
                 
 
    IFRS  
In millions of EUR   2005     2004  
 
               
 
 
               
Gross premiums written
    2,407       2,561  
 
Gross premiums earned
    2,387       2,728  
 
Current operating result
    242       199  
 
Group net results after tax
    131       75  
 
 
               
Insurance business investments
    8,082       8,211  
 
Cash and cash equivalents
    1,667       1,826  
 
               
Policy-linked net liabilities
    8,858       9,020  
 
Borrowings and debts
    954       1,342  
 
Group shareholders’ equity
    1,719       1,335  
 
               
 
In euros
               
 
               
Number of SCOR equity shares in circulation at December 31
    968,769,070       819,269,070  
 
Earnings per share
    0.15       0.09  
 
Earnings per share (diluted)
    0.14       0.09  
 
Book value per share
    1.79       1.65  
 
Diluted book value per share
    1.78       1.63  
 
Share price at end of year
    1.82       1.39  
 

Page 10 of 184


 

     
SCOR GROUP
  CONSOLIDATED FINANCIAL STATEMENTS UNDER IFRS
5. CONSOLIDATED FINANCIAL STATEMENTS
5.1 CONSOLIDATED BALANCE SHEET
                                                         
     
  In millions of EUR                              
              IFRS               French GAAP (1)  
  ASSETS           2005   2004           2004   2003  
 
 
                                                     
                             
 
Intangible assets
    Note 1       230       215                   226       296    
 
Goodwill
            200       200                   177       202    
 
Value of business acquired
            17       3                   37       79    
 
Other intangible assets
            13       12                   12       15    
 
 
                                                     
 
Tangible assets
            10       10                   10       13    
 
 
                                                     
 
Insurance business investments
            8,082       8,211                   8,093       7,415    
 
Real-estate investments
    Note 2       317       319                   226       215    
 
Investments available for sale
    Note 3       5,963       5,541                   6,352       5,813    
 
Investments at fair value by income
    Note 3       395       781                   9       56    
 
Loans and accounts receivable
    Note 4       1,372       1,541                   1,506       1,331    
 
Derivative instruments
    Note 5       35       29                                
 
 
                                                     
 
Investments in affiliated companies
    Note 6       23       21                           13    
 
 
                                                     
 
Share of retrocessionnaires in technical reserves and financial liabilities
    Note 11       983       878                   880       1,028    
 
 
                                                     
 
Other assets
            2,693       2,314                   2,429       3,224    
 
Deferred tax assets
    Note 15       229       226                   235       255    
 
Accepted insurance and reinsurance accounts receivable
    Note 7       1,326       1,201                   1,293       1,693    
 
 
                                                     
 
Accounts receivable from reinsurance ceding transactions
    Note 7       229       106                   106       308    
 
Other assets
            356       271                   277       484    
 
Deferred acquisition costs
    Note 8       553       510                   518       484    
 
 
                                                     
 
Cash and cash equivalents
    Note 9       1,667       1,826                   1,799       1,826    
 
 
                                                     
                             
 
TOTAL ASSETS
            13,688       13,475                   13,437       13,815    
                             
(1)   The “French GAAP” data is classified according to IFRS and valued in accordance with French principles. The reclassifications made are explained in the note “Explanation of the Transition to IFRS.”

Page 11 of 184


 

     
SCOR GROUP
  CONSOLIDATED FINANCIAL STATEMENTS UNDER IFRS
                                                         
     
  In millions of EUR                              
              IFRS               French GAAP(1)  
  LIABILITIES           2005   2004           2004   2003  
                             
 
 
                                                     
 
Group shareholders’ equity
    Note 10       1,719       1,335                   1,324       619    
 
Share capital
            763       645                   645       136    
 
Additional paid-in capital
            147       55                   11       1    
 
Consolidated reserves
            661       510                   599       796    
 
Asset revaluation reserve
            5       43                                
 
Consolidated result
            131       75                   69       (314 )  
 
Share-based payments
            12       7                                
 
 
                                                     
 
Minority interests
                                        183       172    
 
 
                                                     
 
 
                                        1,507       791    
 
Total shareholders’ equity
            1,719       1,335                                
 
 
                                                     
 
Financial debt
    Note 12       954       1,342                   1,083       836    
 
Subordinated debt
            233       222                   225       230    
 
Financial debt securities
            520       934                   769       509    
 
 
                                                     
 
Financial debt to entities in the banking sector
            201       186                   89       97    
 
 
                                                     
 
Contingency reserves
    Note 13       61       58                   35       20    
 
 
                                                     
 
Policy-linked liabilities
    Note 11       9,849       9,898                   9,956       10,971    
 
 
                                                     
 
Technical reserves linked to insurance contracts
            9,686       9,742                   9,956       10,971    
 
Liabilities associated with financial contracts
            163       156                                
 
 
                                                     
 
Other liabilities
            1,105       842                   856       1,197    
 
Deferred tax liabilities
    Note 15       86       70                   25       35    
 
Derivative instruments liabilities
    Note 5       6       3                                
 
 
                                                     
 
Accepted insurance and reinsurance accounts payable
    Note 7       138       181                   181       679    
 
Retrocession accounts payable
    Note 7       645       412                   474       279    
 
Other liabilities
            230       176                   176       204    
 
 
                                                     
                             
 
TOTAL LIABILITIES
            13,688       13,475                   13,437       13,815    
                             
(1)   The “French GAAP” data is classified according to IFRS and valued in accordance with French principles. The reclassifications made are explained in the note “Explanation of the Transition to IFRS.”

Page 12 of 184


 

     
SCOR GROUP
  CONSOLIDATED FINANCIAL STATEMENTS UNDER IFRS
5.2 CONSOLIDATED STATEMENT OF INCOME
                                                         
     
  In millions of EUR           IFRS               French GAAP (1)  
              2005   2004           2004 (2)   2003  
                             
 
Gross premiums written
    Note 18       2,407       2,561                   2,528       3,691    
 
Change in unearned premiums
            (20 )     167                   156       340    
                                 
 
Gross premiums earned
            2,387       2,728                   2,684       4,031    
                                 
 
Other revenues from operations
            1       7                   8       5    
 
Investment revenues
    Note 19       460       346                   336       626    
                                 
 
Total revenues from ordinary activities
            2,848       3,081                   3,028       4,662    
                                 
 
Expenses relating to contract benefits
    Note 20       (1,843 )     (1,971 )                 (1,864 )     (3,568 )  
 
Gross commission on earned premiums
            (532 )     (612 )                 (671 )     (865 )  
 
Net income (loss) from reinsurance operations
    Note 21       (22 )     (104 )                 (100 )     (145 )  
 
Financial management expenses
            (34 )     (31 )                 (31 )     (27 )  
 
Acquisitions and operational expenses
            (99 )     (98 )                 (98 )     (107 )  
 
Other current operational expenses
            (60 )     (66 )                 (62 )     (73 )  
                                 
 
Total other current revenues and expenses
            (2,590 )     (2,882 )                 (2,825 )     (4,785 )  
                                 
 
INCOME/LOSS FROM CURRENT OPERATIONS
            258       199                   203       (123 )  
                                 
 
Goodwill — value changes
            (3 )     0                   (19 )     (19 )  
 
Other operational expenses
            (13 )     0                                
                                 
 
INCOME(LOSS) FROM OPERATIONS
            242       199                   185       (142 )  
                                 
 
Financing expenses
    Note 22       (57 )     (78 )                 (48 )     (51 )  
 
Share in results of associated companies
                                                1    
 
Income tax
    Note 23       (54 )     (46 )                 (44 )     (96 )  
                                 
 
NET INCOME (LOSS) OF CONSOLIDATED ENTITY
            131       75                   93       (289 )  
                                 
 
Minority interests
            0       0                   (24 )     (26 )  
                                 
 
GROUP NET INCOME (LOSS)
            131       75                   69       (314 )  
                                 
     
                             
 
Earnings per share
    Note 26       0.15       0.09                   0.08       -2.31    
 
Diluted earnings per share
            0.14       0.09                   0.08       -2.31    
                             
(1)   The “French GAAP” data is classified according to IFRS and valued in accordance with French principles (2). The reclassifications made are explained in the note “Explanation of the Transition to IFRS.”
 
(2)   The reclassifications made are given in the Note “Explanation of the transition to IFRS”

Page 13 of 184


 

     
SCOR GROUP
  CONSOLIDATED FINANCIAL STATEMENTS UNDER IFRS
5.3 CONSOLIDATED STATEMENT OF CASH FLOWS
                                         
     
  In millions of EUR     IFRS     French GAAP (1)  
        2005   2004     2004 (2)   2003  
                 
 
Net income (loss)
      131       75         93       (288 )  
                 
 
Capital gains and losses on investment disposals
      (90 )     (42 )       (42 )     (175 )  
 
Change in amortizations and non-technical reserves
      38       55         59       78    
 
Change in deferred acquisition costs
      (10 )     (20 )       (20 )     (60 )  
 
Increase of technical reserves and financial liabilities
      (789 )     (379 )       (384 )     397    
 
Change in faire value of financial instruments recognized at market value by income (excl. cash and cash equivalents)
      (39 )     4                      
                 
 
Change in deferred taxes and other items not involving cash outlay included in income (loss) from operations
      (37 )     40         24       (111 )  
                 
 
Cash flow from operations excluding working capital changes
      (796 )     (267 )       (270 )     (159 )  
                 
 
Change in loans and accounts receivable
      174       40         39       32    
 
Cash flows from other assets and liabilities
      28       15         15       51    
 
Net taxes paid
                        1       62    
                 
 
Net cash flow from operations
      (594 )     (212 )       (215 )     (14 )  
                 
 
Acquisitions of consolidated companies, net of cash earned
              (3 )       (3 )          
 
Disposal of consolidated acquisitions, net of cash paid
              13         13            
                 
 
Cash flows linked to change in consolidation scope
              10         10            
                 
 
Purchases/disposals of real estate
      1       16         16       197    
 
Purchases/disposals of financial assets
      542       (531 )       (531 )     210    
                 
 
Cash flows linked to acquisitions, issue and disposal of financial assets
      543       (515 )       (515 )     407    
                 
 
Cash flows from investing activities
      543       (505 )       (505 )     407    
                 
 
Issue of capital instruments
      224       737         708       (3 )  
 
Reimbursement of capital instruments
      (183 )     (13 )       (13 )     (39 )  
 
Transactions on treasury stock
      (5 )     (10 )       (10 )     (2 )  
 
Dividends paid
      (24 )                            
                 
 
Cash flows linked to transactions with shareholders
      12       714         685       -44    
                 
 
Cash generated by issuance of financial debt
      9       156         156            
 
Cash flow impacted by reimbursement of financial debt
      (268 )     (24 )               (48 )  
 
Interest paid on financial debt
                                     
                 
 
Cash flows linked to Group financing
      (259 )     132         156       (48 )  
                 
 
Cash flows arising from financing activities
      (247 )     846         841       (92 )  
                 
 
 
                                     
                 
 
Cash and cash equivalents at January 1
      1,825       1,836         1,824       1,788    
                 
 
Net cash flow from operations
      (594 )     (212 )       (215 )     (14 )  
 
Cash flows from investing activities
      543       (505 )       (505 )     407    
 
Cash flows arising from financing activities
      (247 )     846         841       (92 )  
 
Foreign exchange variation impact on cash equivalents
      140       (140 )       (147 )     (265 )  
                 
 
Cash and cash equivalents at end of year
      1,667       1,825         1,798       1,824    
                 
The “French GAAP” data is classified according to IFRS and valued in accordance with French principles.
The reclassifications made are explained in the note “Explanation of the Transition to IFRS.”

Page 14 of 184


 

     
SCOR GROUP
  CONSOLIDATED FINANCIAL STATEMENTS UNDER IFRS
5.4 CHANGE IN SHAREHOLDERS’ EQUITY
                                                                 
in millions of EUR                   Consolidated                            
            Additional   reserves   Asset                   Share-    
    Share   paid-in   (including   Revaluation   Treasury   Translation   based   Other
    capital   capital   net income)   reserves   stock   adjustment   payments   reserves
 
Shareholders’ equity at January 1, 2004 in French GAAP
    137       1       569               -2       -86                  
 
Impact of adopting IFRS (1)
            14       -162       31               86       1          
 
Shareholders’ equity at January 1 2004 in IFRS
    137       15       407       31       -2               1          
 
Available-for-sale assets ( AFS)
                            21               -6                  
Hedging
                                                               
“Shadow accounting” gross deferred taxes
                            -3               2                  
Effect of changes in foreign exchange rates
                                            -62                  
Actuarial gains and losses not recognized in net income
                                                            10  
Taxes payable or deferred taken directly or transferred to capital
                            -6                               -6  
 
Share-based payments
                                                    6          
 
Other changes
            15                       -11       3               -1  
 
Net income recognized in shareholders’ equity
            15               12       -11       -63       6       3  
 
Consolidated net income (loss) for the fiscal year
                    75                                          
 
Total revenues and losses recognized for the period
            15       75       12       -11       -63       6       3  
 
Capital transactions
    508       25       176                                          
 
Dividends paid
                                                               
 
Shareholders’ equity at December 31, 2004 in IFRS
    645       55       658       43       -13       -63       7       3  
 
Impact of revaluations
                                                               
Available-for-sale assets ( AFS)
                            -89                       4          
Hedging
                                                               
“Shadow accounting” gross deferred taxes
                            45                       -5          
Effect of changes in foreign exchange rates
                                                    97          
Taxes payable or deferred taken directly or transferred to capital
                            6                               -2  
 
Share-based payments
                                                    5          
 
Other changes
                                    -2                       -5  
 
Net income recognized in shareholders’ equity
                            -38       -2       96       5       -7  
 
Consolidated net income (loss) for the fiscal year
                    131                                          
 
Total revenues and losses recognized for the period
                    131       -38       -2       96       5       -7  
 
Capital transactions
    118       106       -1                                          
 
Dividends paid
            -14       -10                                          
 
Shareholders’ equity at December 31, 2005 in IFRS
    763       147       778       5       -15       33       12       -4  
 
(1)   The impact of adopting IFRS standards is explained in the note entitled “Explanation of the Transition to IFRS Standards.”

Page 15 of 184


 

     
SCOR GROUP
  CONSOLIDATED FINANCIAL STATEMENTS UNDER IFRS
5.5 SEGMENT INFORMATION
The following information presents the operating income for each of the Group’s business segments as well as certain items included under assets and liabilities for the years ended 2004 and 2005.
                                                                       
     
      At December 31, 2005     At December 31, 2004  
                      Intra-                             Intra-      
  In millions of EUR   Life   Non Life   group   Total     LIFE   Non Life   group   Total  
           
 
Gross premiums written
    1,024       1,383               2,407         1,165       1,396               2,561    
 
Change in unearned premiums
    18       (38 )             (20 )       (48 )     215               167    
           
 
 
                                                                   
 
Gross premiums earned
    1,042       1,345               2,387         1,117       1,611               2,728    
           
 
Other revenues from operations
            12       (11 )     1                 18       (11 )     7    
 
Investment revenues
    136       186               322         134       206               340    
 
Capital gains and losses on investment disposals
    27       63               90         12       23               35    
 
Change in fair value of investments accounted for at fair value by income
    8       31               39         (10 )     9               (1 )  
 
Change in investment depreciation
    (1 )     2               1         (1 )     (14 )             (15 )  
 
Currency gains
    5       3               8         3       (16 )             (13 )  
               
 
Investment revenues
    175       285               460         138       208               346    
           
 
Total revenues from ordinary business operations
    1,217       1,642       (11 )     2,848         1,255       1,837       (11 )     3,081    
           
 
 
                                                                   
 
Expenses relating to contract benefits
    (838 )     (1,005 )             (1,843 )       (896 )     (1,075 )             (1,971 )  
 
 
                                                                   
 
Gross commissions earned
    (237 )     (295 )             (532 )       (241 )     (371 )             (612 )  
 
Retroceded written premiums
    (32 )     (102 )             (134 )       (37 )     (83 )             (120 )  
 
Change in retroceded unearned reserves
            (16 )             (16 )               (66 )             (66 )  
 
 
                                                                   
 
Retroceded earned premiums
    (32 )     (118 )             (150 )       (37 )     (149 )             (186 )  
 
Retroceded claims ratio
    20       96               116         9       60               69    
 
Retrocession earned commission
    6       6               12         4       9               13    
               
 
Net income from reinsurance operations
    (6 )     (16 )             (22 )       (24 )     (80 )             (104 )  
               
 
Financial management expenses
    (1 )     (33 )             (34 )       (2 )     (29 )             (31 )  
 
Acquisitions and operational expenses
    (30 )     (69 )             (99 )       (32 )     (66 )             (98 )  
 
Other current operational expenses
    (20 )     (51 )     11       (60 )       (14 )     (63 )     11       (66 )  
 
Other revenues from current operations
                                                                   
           
 
Total other current revenues and expenses
    (1,132 )     (1,469 )     11       (2,590 )       (1,209 )     (1,684 )     11       (2,882 )  
           
 
INCOME/LOSS FROM CURRENT OPERATIONS
    85       173               258         46       153               199    
           
 
Goodwill – value changes
            (3 )             (3 )                                    
 
Other operational expenses
    (2 )     (11 )             (13 )                                    
 
Other revenues from operations
                                                                   
           
 
INCOME(LOSS) FROM OPERATIONS
    83       159               242         46       153               199    
           
The gross premiums generated by geographic zone are as follows:
                                     
  In millions of EUR   LIFE   Non Life  
      2005   2004   2005   2004  
 
Gross premiums written
    1,024       1,165       1,383       1,396    
     
 
Europe
    710       724       1,025       1,010    
 
North America
    314       441       218       234    
 
Asia and rest of world
                    140       152    
     

Page 16 of 184


 

     
SCOR GROUP
  CONSOLIDATED FINANCIAL STATEMENTS UNDER IFRS
The gross premiums are broken down according to the geographic location of the subsidiary.
A breakdown of the gross premiums by location of ceding company is presented in the appendix under “Geographic Concentration of Insurance Risks.”
Assets and liabilities by activity are broken down as follows:
                                                 
In millions of EUR   2005   2004
    LIFE     Non Life     Total     LIFE     Non Life     Total  
         
Insurance business investments
    3,115       4,967       8,082       3,206       5,005       8,211  
         
Investments in affiliated companies
            23       23               21       21  
         
 
Policy-linked liabilities
    -3,615       -6,234       -9,849       -3,596       -6,302       -9,898  
         
Share of retrocessionnaires in technical reserves and financial liabilities
    401       582       983       361       517       878  
         
 
Total Assets
    4,346       9,342       13,688       4,303       9,172       13,475  
         
The breakdown by geographic zone is according to the location of the subsidiary.
                                                                 
In millions of EUR   2005   2004
                    Asia and                             Asia and        
            North     rest of                     North     rest of        
    Europe     America     world     TOTAL     Europe     America     world     TOTAL  
     
Insurance business investments
    5,071       2,897       114       8,082       5,102       2,976       133       8,211  
         
Investments in affiliated companies
    23                       23       21                       21  
         
 
Total assets
    9,923       3,417       348       13,688       9,808       3,339       328       13,475  
The Cash Flow Statement at 12/31/2005 is presented as follows:
                         
 
In millions of EUR   LIFE     NON LIFE        
 
Cash and cash equivalents at January 1
    219       1,606       1,825  
 
Net cash flow from operations
    -134       -460       (594 )
Cash flows from investing activities
    154       389       543  
Cash flows arising from financing activities
    -10       -237       (247 )
Foreign exchange variation impact on cash and cash equivalents
    71       69       140  
 
Cash and cash equivalents at end of year
    300       1,367       1,667  
 

Page 17 of 184


 

     
SCOR GROUP
  CONSOLIDATED FINANCIAL STATEMENTS UNDER IFRS
5.6 SIGNIFICANT EVENTS OF THE YEAR
Group net income for 2005 was €131 million. This result comprises technical costs net of retrocessions (with reinstatement premiums) for major natural catastrophes* of €168 million, including Katrina in August, with a net technical cost of approximately €82 million. The after tax impact on the accounts of these major natural catastrophes totalled €166 million. Excluding these major natural catastrophes, technical activity for the year reflects the continuation of the trends observed since the end of 2003.
During the first six months of 2005, the Group significantly reduced its reserves in the United States following several commutations made by two subsidiaries in the United States and in Bermuda, SCOR U.S. and CRP.
In June 2005, SCOR acquired the minority interests of the Irish company IRP Holdings Limited for €183 million. On June 30, 2005, SCOR issued 149,500,000 shares for a net amount of €224 million. This share capital increase enabled the Group to refinance the acquisition of the minority interests of IRP Holdings Limited, as well as reinforce the Group’s financial strength, with a view to upgrading its financial rating.
On August 1, 2005, the Group’s financial rating (Standard & Poor’s) was upgraded to “A- stable outlook.” This rating confirms the solidity of the Group’s financial foundations and its high level of solvency and will enable the Group to implement a complete underwriting policy centred on profitability and risk selection.
In order to adapt the Group’s structure to its level of business, in July 2005 the SCOR Group announced a Group reorganization program called “New SCOR.” To this end, SCOR recognized a restructuring reserve for its French companies in the accounts at December 31, 2005 of €12 million.
*   Major natural catastrophes are defined by SCOR as occurrences where the cost, net of retrocession, for the Group exceeds €10 million.
Premium Income
In 2005, gross written premiums of the SCOR Group stood at €2,407 million, a decline of 6% versus those of 2004.
At constant exchange rates, gross written premiums of the SCOR Group declined by 8% versus those of 2004.
Premiums from life insurance / non-life insurance
Breakdown of premium income by business operation (1)
(Millions of euros, at current exchange rates)
                                                       
 
    2005 PI     2004 PI     Variation
                                          Current rate       Constant rate
                                          of       of
    2005     %     2004     %       exchange       exchange
                   
Non Life reinsurance
    1,383       57 %       1,396       55 %       -1 %       -4 %
Life Reinsurance
    1,024       43 %       1,165       45 %       -12 %       -13 %
                   
TOTAL
    2,407       100 %       2,561       100 %       -6 %       -8 %
                   
Geographic breakdown of premium income (1)
(Millions of euros, at constant exchange rates)
                                   
 
    2005     %     2004     %
       
Europe
    1,336       55 %       1,347       52 %
North America
    594       25 %       762       30 %
Asia-Pacific
    217       9 %       202       8 %
Rest of the World
    260       11 %       250       10 %
       
TOTAL
    2,407       100 %       2,561       100 %
       
(1) Gross premiums written broken down by location of ceding companies
Non-life reinsurance (Property and Casualty, Large Corporate Accounts, Credit and Surety), premium income reached €1,383 million, basically unchanged from 2004.

Page 18 of 184


 

     
SCOR GROUP
  CONSOLIDATED FINANCIAL STATEMENTS UNDER IFRS
Life Reinsurance (individual and group life, long-term care, financing, disability, unemployment), premium income stood at €1,024 million, a decline of 12% over 2004.
Technical results
The combined ratio “(claims + commissions + overheads) / earned premiums” for non-life reinsurance totalled 106.5% in 2005 versus 101.8% in 2004. This ratio, which includes major natural catastrophes, reflects the technical performance of recent underwriting years (2002 and after).
Net combined ratio * Non-Life insurance
(BAR CHART)
* (claims + commissions + overheads) / premiums earned
The ratio is calculated net of reinsurance and does not include the restructuring reserve, which does not constitute a return on a service rendered.
The net combined ratios are based on estimates of ultimate loss of the technical reserves established by Group actuaries.
Financial results
Investment income net of fees (excluding borrowing costs) in 2005 was €426 million, versus €315 million in 2004, or an increase of 36%. This increase was due primarily to capital gains made in the second half of 2005 and to the positive developments in the financial markets.

Page 19 of 184


 

     
SCOR GROUP
  CONSOLIDATED FINANCIAL STATEMENTS UNDER IFRS
(BAR CHART)
Taxes
Taxes in 2005 stood at €(54) million versus €(46) million in 2004. This expense included a write-up of €43 million of the deferred assets relating to the French tax-consolidated Group.
Group net income for the period
Group net income for the period stood at €131 million, compared to €75 million in 2004.

Page 20 of 184


 

SCOR GROUP   CONSOLIDATED FINANCIAL STATEMENTS UNDER IFRS
     
5.7   NOTES TO THE CONSOLIDATED FINANCIAL STATEMENTS
Accounting methods and principles
Approval of the consolidated financial statements
The financial statements were presented by the Group Management to the Audit Committee. The Management and the Audit Committee report to the Board of Directors, which approved the financial statements on March 21, 2006. Shareholders can ask for an amendment to the financial statements.
The financial statements are then presented for approval to the General Meeting of May 16, 2006.
Presentation of applied standards and interpretations
The Group’s financial statements were prepared in conformity with international accounting standards (International Financial Reporting Standards’ – IFRS) and the interpretations issued on December 31, 2005, as adopted by the European Union.
As of January 1, 2004 SCOR has also applied IFRS 4, IAS 32 and 39 and the amendment of IAS 19 concerning the accounting of actuarial differences as equity.
Details of the transition of the accounts published under French GAAP to IFRS standards are published under “Explanation of transition to IFRS.”
IFRS standards that can be adopted in anticipation
SCOR’s financial statements at December 31, 2005 do not integrate the impact of standards and interpretations, the application of which may be delayed until the opening of the accounts on January 1, 2006, with the exception of the amendment of IAS 19 regarding the recording of actuarial differences in shareholders’ equity.
Description of accounting options for the first-time adoption of IFRS
IFRS financial information is established in accordance with the provisions of IFRS 1 “First-Time Adoption of IFRS.” For this first financial year, SCOR has adopted the following additional options in accordance with IFRS 1 with regard to the retrospective accounting of assets and liabilities under IFRS.
Business combinations
SCOR has opted not to restate business combinations prior to January 1, 2004, as permitted under IFRS 3. As permitted under IFRS 1, SCOR will not apply IAS 21 “Effects of Changes in Foreign Exchange Rates” retrospectively to goodwill resulting from business combinations that occurred before the transition to IFRS. Consequently, goodwill remains in the functional currency of the acquiring entity.
Actuarial gains and losses on pension plans
SCOR has decided to adopt the option provided for in IFRS 1, whereby unrecognized actuarial gains and losses are recorded against consolidated shareholders’ equity at January 1, 2004.
Unrecognized actuarial gains and losses (SORIES) after January 1, 2004 are reflected in shareholders’ equity.
Translation adjustments
With regard to the conversion into euros of subsidiary accounts having a foreign functional currency, SCOR transferred Translation adjustments at January 1, 2004 into consolidated reserves. The new IFRS value of translation adjustment at January 1, 2004 is therefore returned to zero. In the event of the subsequent disposal of these subsidiaries, the income or loss from the disposal will not include the recovery of exchange rate difference prior to January 1, but will include translation adjustments recorded after January 1, 2004.
Assessment of certain intangible / tangible assets at fair value
SCOR opted not to apply the option offered by IFRS 1 that allows for the assessment at January 1, 2004 of certain intangible and tangible assets at their fair value on that date.
Share-based compensation
SCOR opted to apply the provisions of IFRS 2 solely to equity-based compensation granted after November 7, 2002, for which the rights acquisition date falls after December 31, 2003.
IFRS consolidation principles

Page 21 of 184


 

SCOR GROUP   CONSOLIDATED FINANCIAL STATEMENTS UNDER IFRS
     
Methods of consolidation
All the companies in which SCOR has a controlling interest, which include companies in which it has the power to direct financial and operational policy in order to obtain benefits from their operations, are fully consolidated.
Subsidiaries are consolidated as of the moment the Group takes control of them until the date on which this control is transferred outside the Group. Where control of a subsidiary is lost, the consolidated financial statements for the year include profit and loss for the period during which SCOR held control.
The Group’s investment in an affiliated company is recorded in the accounts using the equity method. An affiliated company is an entity in which the Group exercises significant influence but which is neither a subsidiary of the Group nor a joint venture.
The Group does not have any equity interest in joint ventures.
The Group controls in substance a separate legal structure (“ad hoc entity”) that it consolidates in the absence of any capital links. The following assessment criteria were used to determine the existence of control:
    The entity’s business is conducted exclusively on behalf of the Group, so that the Group may enjoy the benefits;
    The Group holds the decision-making and management power to obtain the maximum benefits relating to the entity’s operational activity; this power was delegated through the implementation of a self-management system;
    The Group may benefit from the majority of the entity’s advantages;
    The Group retains the majority of the risks relating to the entity.
The Group also fully consolidates the mutual funds that it holds as part of its business. These entities could not be consolidated under French accounting standards.
 
 
Harmonization of accounting principles
The financial statements of the subsidiaries are prepared for the same accounting period as that of the parent company. Consolidation adjustments may be made in order to harmonize all the Group’s accounting methods and principles.
All intra-group balances and transactions including internal results resulting from intra-company transactions are fully eliminated.
Translation methods
The Group’s consolidated financial statements are presented in euros (EUR) and all values are rounded off to €millions except where expressly stated otherwise.
Translating the financial statements of a foreign entity
Where the functional currency of Group entities is not the same as the reporting currency used to present the Group’s consolidated financial statements, the balance sheet is translated using the closing date exchange rate and the income statement is converted using the average exchange rate for the period. Exchange rates differences are posted directly as equity under “translation adjustments.”
Translation of transactions denominated in foreign currencies
Transactions denominated in foreign currencies (currencies other than the functional currency) are converted into the functional currency at the rate of exchange in force on the date of the transaction (for practical purposes, an average rate is used).
At each closing date, the entity must convert the foreign-currency items on its balance sheet into the functional currency, using the following procedures:
    monetary items (specifically bond investments, accounts receivable and payable, technical insurance assets and liabilities) are converted at the closing date exchange rate and the resulting gains and losses are recorded in the income statement,
    non-monetary items are converted:
  *   using the exchange rate on the transaction date if they are assessed at historical cost (particularly real estate investments) and,
  *   using the exchange rate at the date of the fair value assessment if they are assessed at fair value (particularly equity investments).
      When a gain or loss on a non-monetary item is recorded directly in shareholders’ equity (shares available for sale, for example), the exchange adjustment resulting from the conversion of this item is also directly recorded in shareholders’ equity. Conversely, when a gain or loss on a non-monetary item is recorded in profit and loss (shares

Page 22 of 184


 

SCOR GROUP   CONSOLIDATED FINANCIAL STATEMENTS UNDER IFRS
     
      at fair value by income; for example), the exchange adjustment resulting from the conversion of this item is also recorded on the income statement.
    The gains and losses resulting from the conversion of hedging on foreign net investments are recorded in shareholders’ equity until the withdrawal of the net investments, at which time they are recorded on the income statement.
Goodwill and business combinations
Goodwill represents the excess of an acquisition cost over the fair value of the Group’s share of the acquired company’s net assets at the date of acquisition. The goodwill on fully consolidated subsidiaries is included under intangible assets. Goodwill on companies accounted for by the equity method is included in the value of securities accounted for by the equity method.
Goodwill is recorded at historical cost, less any possible accumulated loss in value.
In order to establish possible losses in value, goodwill is allocated to each cash-generating unit (CGU). A CGU is defined as an entity with separate identifiable cash flows. Each CGU represents the Group’s investment in each country in which it is active according to the primary segment information, either non-life reinsurance or life reinsurance.
Each CGU to which goodwill is allocated should correspond as closely as possible to the level at which the group is monitoring the rate of return on its investment. A CGU should not be any larger than a primary or secondary level segment as defined for the needs of segment reporting set forth under IAS 14.
In order to assess any loss in value, a goodwill impairment test is conducted:
    each year on the same date for each cash-generating unit, but not necessarily on the closing date;
    more frequently if an unfavourable event occurs between the two annual tests;
    mandatorily before the completion of entity acquisition.
A loss in value is recorded where the net book value of the CGU, to which goodwill has been allocated, is higher than its recoverable value. The recoverable value is the highest amount between: (1) the fair value net of sales costs and (2) the value in use (future discounted cash flow) of this unit.
If the assets of the CGU Group or the unit included in the CGU group to which goodwill has been allocated are tested for impairment on the same date as the CGU that includes the goodwill (or if there is a loss in value index for one of the assets), this test should be conducted before the goodwill impairment test.
Accounting principles
The financial information has been prepared in accordance with the historical cost agreement, with the exception of certain categories of assets and liabilities. The relevant categories are mentioned in the following notes. The consolidated IFRS information is presented in euros and all values are rounded off to the nearest million unless otherwise indicated.
Use of estimates
In order to prepare the financial information in accordance with generally accepted accounting principles, certain assumptions were made. Assumptions are made that affect the reported amounts of assets and liabilities, the disclosure of contingent assets and liabilities at the date of the financial statements and the amounts reported as income and loss for the year.
Management reviews these estimates and assessments constantly, based on its past experience and on various other factors it deems reasonable, thereby reaching its assessments on the carrying value of the assets and liabilities. The actual results could differ substantially from these estimates under different assumptions or conditions that may arise at a later date.
Real estate assets
Classification of buildings:
All buildings currently held by the Group are investment properties. In certain cases, buildings may be partially occupied by entities of the Group.
Accounting method
The buildings are recorded at historical amortized cost. Their value is broken down as follows:
    land, not amortized;
    four technical components:
  *   structure, or carcass, depreciated over a term of 30 to 80 years according to the type of construction;
  *   wind and water tightness, depreciated over a period of 30 years;
  *   technical installations, depreciated over a term of 20 years;
  *   decor fixtures and improvements, depreciated over a term of 10 to 15 years according to type.

Page 23 of 184


 

SCOR GROUP   CONSOLIDATED FINANCIAL STATEMENTS UNDER IFRS
     
The costs, rights and acquisition (or development) fees are integrated in the value of the building.
The relative weight of each technical component and the length of depreciation are set according to a schedule of components showing eight types of construction. This schedule was prepared based on the Group’s own experience and on schedules prepared by professional authorities.
Appraisal
Each building is subject to an in-depth analysis of its market value or “fair value” by an independent appraiser every 5 years at year-end. Its market value is reassessed by the same appraiser at the end of each of the 4 subsequent years depending on the changes that have occurred to its rental status, works completed and developments in the local real estate market.
If the market value of a building appears lower than its net book value, a decrease in value is recorded as a loss equal to the difference between its utility value and the net book value. With regard to investment properties, their utility value is considered a long-term investment based primarily on the sum of estimated future cash flows that are discounted on the basis of current market assumptions. SCOR has not retained any residual value.
Finance lease
Investment properties financed by financial rental agreements are recorded on the balance sheet as assets based on the current value of rents and the option to buy. Once they have been recorded on the balance sheet, they are treated like other investment properties at amortized historic cost.
On the liabilities side, a corresponding debt is recorded under “financial liabilities.” It is amortized in accordance with the effective interest rate method.
Leasing agreements
In December 2003, the SCOR Group sold its headquarters building. A net capital gain of €44 million was realized under local standards.
The Group will remain a tenant of this building until December 2012. The owner of the building has a bank guarantee corresponding to SCOR’s rating. SCOR has pledged an asset amount of the same value with the bank that issued this guarantee.
In application of IAS 17, this capital gain was maintained in the IFRS accounts.
Rental income
Rental income from investment properties is recorded on a straight-line basis over the term of the current rental agreements.
Financial investments
The Group classifies its financial assets in the following categories: available-for-sale financial assets, fair market assets by income, loans and other accounts receivable and derivative instruments. There are currently no assets classified as assets held to maturity.
The sale and purchase of assets is entered in the accounts on the settlement date. Once it has been posted, an asset is assessed according to its asset category, determined according to the methods set forth below.
Financial assets are taken off the balance sheet when their contractual rights to the cash flow of the financial asset expire or are transferred, and when the Group has substantially transferred the risks and advantages inherent to ownership of the financial asset.
At each closing date, the Group assesses whether there is an objective indication of loss in value. The amount of the loss in value is posted in the accounts by asset category, in accordance with the terms and conditions set forth below.
For equity instruments listed on an active market, a drop in price of more than 20% or a consistent decline over a period of more than six months constitutes an objective indication of loss in value. For unlisted equity instruments, fair value is determined according to commonly used valuation techniques. For debt instruments and loans and accounts receivable, an objective indicator of a loss in value relates to a proven credit risk.
Available-for-sale financial assets
Available-for-sale assets include non-derivative assets that are classified as either available for sale or those that are allocated to any other category.
Available-for-sale financial assets are posted at their fair value. Unrealized profits and losses resulting from variations in the fair value of a non-hedged asset are recorded directly in shareholders’ equity, with the exception of profits and losses from foreign

Page 24 of 184


 

SCOR GROUP   CONSOLIDATED FINANCIAL STATEMENTS UNDER IFRS
     
exchange gains and losses on a monetary financial asset held for sale which are recorded on the income statement for the share of exchange profits and losses applied at amortized cost, and in shareholders’ equity for the portion of profits and losses related to fair value. Foreign exchange profits and losses on the fair value of non-monetary financial available-for-sale assetsare recorded under shareholders’ equity.
When there is an objective indication of loss in value, the amount of the accumulated loss posted directly to shareholders’ equity is recorded on the income statement. Losses in value may only be carried forward on debt instruments when the fair value increases during a subsequent financial year due to an event that occurs after the loss in value has been posted.
When the asset is sold, all the accumulated equity gains and losses are included in the capital gains and losses from the sale of investments on the income statement, less the amounts previously posted to income.
Interest on debt instruments is calculated in accordance with the interest method in effect, which integrates the amortization of premiums/discounts and is recorded on the income statement. Dividends on equity instruments are recorded on the income statement when the Group’s right to receive payment for them has been established.
Financial assets at fair value by income
This category includes two classes of assets: financial assets held for transactional purposes and those designated at fair value by income upon initial recognition in the accounts.
Profits and losses from changes in the fair value of financial assets classified under this category are reflected on the income statement in the period in which they occur.
The main financial assets evaluated at fair value by income are securities held in major mutual funds, bonds convertible into shares, derivatives, investments representing Unit-linked policies and certain shares.
Loans and accounts receivable
This category includes non-derivative financial assets where payment is fixed or fixable and which are not listed on an active market, with the exception of accounts receivable from reinsurance transactions.
These assets are recognized at amortized cost using the effective interest rate method where this method has a significant impact compared to the nominal contractual method. Loans and short-term accounts receivable are recorded at cost.
Cash and cash equivalents
The heading “Cash and cash equivalent” includes cash, negative bank balances and short term loans (cash mutual funds). This heading is defined in identical terms in French standards and in IFRS standards.
Treasury stocks
Treasury stocks are deducted from shareholders’ equity, regardless of the purpose for which they are held, and the related income or loss is eliminated from the consolidated income statement.
Financial liabilities
Financial liabilities, with the exception of liabilities resulting from reinsurance transactions, are classified into financial debts, financial liability instruments and other liabilities.
Subordinated financial debts or debt securities
These items combine the various subordinated or unsubordinated bonds issued by the Group.
These debts are posted at amortized cost using the effective interest rate method.
Borrowings that include a derivative instrument have been stripped. The portion that relates to the equity component, determined on the date of issue, is reflected in shareholders’ equity. It is not subsequently reassessed.
Interest on financial debts are posted under charges.
Financial debts owed to entities in the banking sector
This item combines mortgage loans and medium-term notes. These debts are recognized at amortized cost using the effective interest rate method where this method has a significant impact compared to the nominal contractual rate method.
Interest on financial debts are posted under charges.

Page 25 of 184


 

SCOR GROUP   CONSOLIDATED FINANCIAL STATEMENTS UNDER IFRS
     
Derivative and hedging instruments
Derivative instruments are recorded at fair value from inception and are assessed at fair value at each account closure.
The accounting method varies according to whether the derivative instrument is designated as a hedging instrument or not, as described in the note below “Hedging Instruments.”
When the Group has not designated the derivative as a hedging instrument, profits and losses resulting from the variation of the fair value of the instrument are recorded under income in the period in which they occur. The Group uses the following derivative instruments to reduce its exposure to various risks: interest rate swaps, futures and foreign currency forward contracts, caps and floors, stock option puts and calls.
Embedded derivative instruments
An embedded derivative is a component of a hybrid instrument which includes a non-derivative host contract, which causes part of the hybrid instrument’s cash flow to vary in the same way as that of a freestanding derivative.
The embedded derivative is separate from the host contract and is posted as a derivative where its economic features and risks are not closely linked to the economic features of the host contract, where the embedded instrument has the same conditions as a separate derivative instrument, and where the embedded instrument is not assessed at fair value through the income statement.
Where an embedded derivative has been separated from its host contract, it is posted in accordance with the provisions relating to the posting of derivative financial instruments.
Where the embedded derivative represents a significant part of the instrument and cannot be separated from the host contract, the hybrid instrument is treated as an instrument held for trading. Profits and losses resulting from variations in the fair value of the hybrid are posted in profit and loss in the period during which they occur.
Hedging Instruments
A hedging instrument is a designated derivative instrument or, in the case of a single foreign currency hedge, a designated non-derivative asset or liability where the fair value or cash flow offset variations in the fair value or cash flow of the hedged item.
The hedged item may be an asset, a liability, a firm underwriting, a highly profitable scheduled transaction or a net investment in a foreign business that exposes the Group to fair market valuation risk or future cash flow risk, and which is designated as being hedged.
The performance of hedges is monitored periodically in order to ensure, with regard to variations in the fair value or cash flow of the item, the degree of compensation attributable to hedged risk through variations in fair value or cash flow of the hedged instrument.
Hedges for net investments in a foreign business are recorded as follows:
    the portion of profit or loss on the hedging instrument considered as the effective portion of the hedge is recorded directly in shareholders’ equity;
    the ineffective portion of the hedge is recorded on the income statement.
The primary hedging instruments consist of forward foreign currency forward purchases and sales.
Accounting principles and methods specific to reinsurance transactions
Classification and accounting treatment of reinsurance treaties
The reinsurance treaties accepted and retroceded by the Group are subject to different IFRS accounting rules depending on whether they fall under IFRS4 or IAS39.
Reinsurance acceptance and retrocession transactions that involve a significant insurance risk transfer are posted in the accounts in accordance with IFRS4, in other words according to the accounting principles in existence prior to the implementation of IFRS standards and used until December 31, 2004 to prepare SCOR’s consolidated accounts in conformity with CRC 2000-05, with the exception of the equalization reserves described below.
Acceptance and retrocession transactions that do not transfer a significant risk are posted in the accounts in accordance with IAS39, which means that while premiums collected are no longer recognized as premium income, and technical reserves and deferred acquisition expenses that are recorded as assets or liabilities on the balance sheet are reclassified as financial assets or liabilities by assimilation to a deposit as “financial contract liabilities” and “financial contract assets” on the balance sheet. These deposits are assessed on the basis of financial flows alone and no longer on the basis of estimated maximum fluctuations as set forth in the accounting principles applicable to insurance transactions.

Page 26 of 184


 

SCOR GROUP   CONSOLIDATED FINANCIAL STATEMENTS UNDER IFRS
     
Premium income from these transactions is equal to the deductions made by SCOR. It is recorded under “other operating income” on the income statement.
French accounting principles applicable to contracts classified as “insurance” contracts under IFRS 4Accounting for ceding companies’ accounts
SCOR Group reinsurance companies record accounts transmitted by ceding companies upon receipt. At year end, estimates are made for those accounts not yet received from ceding companies. Under this method, the situation recorded in the financial statements reflects as closely as possible the real reinsurance commitments made by the Group. This method impacts the majority of contracts underwritten during the year, and even the prior year.
Recording of reinsurance estimates
Non-Life premiums recorded in the year reflect the estimated premium expected at the time of writing of the policy. It is regularly reviewed during the year to adjust for possible adjustment in premiums paid under the policy. An unearned premium reserve is calculated, either pro rata temporis contract by contract, or using a statistical method when this yields a result close to that obtained via the contract-by-contract method.
The difference between the maximum expected loss based on premiums, net of commissions, and losses reported by ceding companies, is recorded under accounts receivable or liabilities arising from accepted reinsurance transactions. The difference between expected final loss experience based on earned premiums thus calculated and losses reported by ceding companies is recognized in unpaid claims reserves under liabilities.
In Life reinsurance for so-called “insurance” policies, given the type of business written, valuations are obtained by estimating ceding companies’ missing accounts in addition to information actually received and booked. For the sake of consistency with the Non-Life sector, estimated claims are booked under claims reserves.
Claims reserve
Claims reserves must be sufficient to cover all of the Group’s liabilities.
In Non-life reinsurance, SCOR is required to maintain its reserves at a sufficient level to cover the estimated amount of its direct commitments and adjustment expenses for reported and unreported claims, at the end of each fiscal year (net of estimates of recovery and subrogation). These reserves, which pertain to all claims, whether reported or not yet reported, are calculated on the basis of their ultimate cost undiscounted, except for workers’ compensation claims in the United States, which are discounted in the U.S. and in the Bermudas. Claims expense is estimated at the policy’s expiration in the light of statistical experience of similar policies. Claims reserves including estimated claims paid and LAE are calculated in light of expected earnings and supplement the information communicated by assigning companies.
In Life reinsurance, estimates based on statistical experience and information supplied by the underwriters are added to mathematical reserves recorded by the ceding companies.
Acquisition costs of reinsurance transactions
In reinsurance, the costs associated with the acquisition of new contracts, chiefly comprising commissions, are recorded as assets on the balance sheet, to the extent that contracts are profitable. They are written down over the residual life of non-life contracts, at the same rate that estimated future margins are recorded on life insurance contracts.
 
 
Sufficiency test for liabilities
Liabilities relating to contracts are subjected each year to a sufficiency test (IFRS 4).
IFRS accounting principles applied to IFRS4 contracts and different from French GAAP
Equalization reserves
IFRS accounting principles do not provide for the possibility of establishing reserves for risks on future contracts. When such reserves do exist, they are eliminated from SCOR’s consolidated accounts under IFRS standards.
Shadow Accounting:
According to IFRS accounting principles (see note on financial investments), financial assets are valued at fair value. This means that recognized but unrealized capital gains or losses on portfolio securities are recorded in SCOR’s accounts, either in the income statement or as an increase or decrease to shareholders’ equity, depending on the asset classification.
SCOR has elected to apply shadow accounting under the terms of IFRS 4. Consequently, recognized but unrealized capital gains and losses on investments affect the valuation of technical assets and liabilities in the same way as realized gains and

Page 27 of 184


 

SCOR GROUP   CONSOLIDATED FINANCIAL STATEMENTS UNDER IFRS
     
losses. The corresponding adjustment to insurance liabilities (or deferred acquisition costs or intangible assets) is recorded in shareholders’ equity once the unrealized capital gains or losses are directly recorded in equity. Otherwise, it is recorded in the income statement according to the same scheme in use for realized capital gains and losses. The primary technical items affected by these adjustments are:
    deferred acquisition costs and contract portfolios, where amortization occurs according to the technical and financial profits from contracts (“shadow DAC” and “shadow VOBA”),
    technical reserves, where the discounted rate used depends directly on the performance of the assets (“shadow PM”).
Embedded derivatives
IFRS 4 provides for the separation of embedded derivatives in insurance contracts, particularly when these hybrid contracts are not assessed at fair value by income and when the features of the embedded derivatives are not closely linked with the features and risks of the host contract, and when the embedded derivative corresponds to the definition of a derivative instrument. Embedded derivatives corresponding to the definition of an insurance contract are not separated. SCOR has identified no embedded derivatives in its contracts.
Pension liabilities and similar benefits
Pension liabilities
The SCOR Group is involved in creating pensions for its staff, in accordance with the laws and practices of each country. Group staff in certain countries receives additional pension payments, paid as an annuity or in capital on retirement. The main countries concerned are France, the United States and Germany.
The benefits granted to Group employees are either in the form of defined contributions or defined benefit plans. Defined contribution plans are those where an employer pays fixed contributions into a separate entity, with no legal or constructive obligation to pay further contributions. As a result, only contributions paid or due as part of the financial year appear in the Group accounts. Defined benefit plans are those where a sum is paid to the employee upon retirement, which usually depends on one or several factors such as age, years of service and salary.
Obligations recognized on the balance sheet as defined benefit plans are recorded at the current value of the defined benefit obligation at the date of closure, less the market value of any plan assets, where appropriate, both having been adjusted by actuarial gains and losses and unacknowledged past services. The current value of the obligation is calculated annually by independent actuaries using the projected unit credit method. It is established by discounting the future expected benefits on the basis of Tier 1 bond market rates in the same currency as the benefits to be paid, and for a similar duration to the underlying obligation.
Actuarial gains and losses arising from adjustments linked to experience and the effects of changes in actuarial assumptions are reflected in shareholders’ equity.
Past service costs generated at the adoption or modification of a defined benefit plan are recognized as an expense on a straight-line basis, over the average period until the benefits become vested. When benefit rights are acquired upon the adoption of a plan or its modification, past service cost is immediately recognized as an expense.
Other long-term benefits
In some countries, the SCOR Group rewards employees for length of service by granting them a lump sum after certain periods of service. This occurs primarily in France, where the current value of the obligation is calculated annually by an independent actuary using the projected unit credit method. The obligation is recognized on the balance sheet.
Termination benefits
Employees are entitled to termination benefits when the Group makes one or more employees redundant, or encourages voluntary redundancies. The Group posts these payments into the accounts when it is demonstrably committed by means of a detailed formal plan for termination, which it could not realistically retract. Benefits payable more than twelve months after the closing date are discounted.
Share-based payment and share options
The SCOR Group grants its employees stock option plans. The fair value of the services received in exchange for the granting of options is recognized as an expense. The total amount that is recognized over the vesting period is established by reference to the fair value of options granted, excluding conditions of attribution that are not linked to market conditions. (ROE, for example). These conditions are taken into account when determining the probable number of options to be acquired by the beneficiaries. At each closing date, the company reviews the estimated number of options to be acquired. Any impact is then posted in the income statement against shareholders’ equity for the remaining vesting period.
The Group also allocated shares to all its employees in 2004 and 2005. This allocation is reflected by posting of personnel expenses against an increase in shareholder’s equity over the vesting period.

Page 28 of 184


 

SCOR GROUP   CONSOLIDATED FINANCIAL STATEMENTS UNDER IFRS
     
The dilutive effect of outstanding options is reflected in the calculation of the diluted earnings per share.
Taxes
Deferred tax assets and liabilities are recognized using the balance sheet liability method of tax allocation for all temporary differences on the closing date between the tax base of assets and liabilities and their carrying value on the balance sheet.
Deferred tax assets are recorded when temporary tax differences occur that are associated with investments in subsidiaries and affiliated companies, unless the date on which this temporary difference reverses is controllable and if it is probable that the temporary difference will be reversed in the foreseeable future.
Deferred tax on the restatement of capitalization reserves is recorded without including the probability of capital losses from asset disposals of securities subject to taxes from these reserves.
Deferred tax liabilities are not recorded in cases of temporary differences associated with investments in subsidiaries and affiliated companies unless it is probable that the temporary difference will be reversed in the foreseeable future and if it is likely that there will be a taxable profit to which the temporary difference can be imputed
The book value of deferred tax assets is reviewed at each closing date and reduced when it is no longer possible that a sufficient taxable benefit will be available to enable all or part of these deferred tax assets to be utilized.
Deferred tax assets and liabilities are assessed at the tax rate applicable in the fiscal year in which the asset will be sold or the liability settled, based on the tax rates (and tax regulations) that have been adopted or substantially adopted at the closing date.
Tax rates relating to items recorded directly as shareholders’ equity are recorded as equity and not in the income statement.
Principles for presentation of financial statements
Allocation of expenses by function
In conformity with the option offered by IAS 1, the Group opted to present its expenses by function on the income statement. This presentation provides information that is more relevant to readers than expenses by nature, but costs are allocated to different functions based on applied costs and are thus subject to decisions of judgment.
This method is identical to the method for presenting overhead expenses that was used for SCOR’s consolidated accounts under French GAAP. Operating expenses are divided into five categories: acquisition costs, claims settlement expenses, administrative expenses, investment portfolio management expenses, and other underwriting expenses. These expenses are allocated to the categories set out above, company by company.
Segment information
The Group’s business is divided into two distinct sectors: Non-Life insurance and Life insurance. Previously, SCOR’s segment information was divided into three areas: Non-Life Reinsurance, Life/Accident & Health and CRP. The legal structure has recognized these two areas since 2003. Each sector offers different products and services, which are marketed via separate channels. Given their specific nature, these sectors constitute the primary level of segment information.
Management has evaluated the performance of these segments and allocates resources to them in accordance with various performance indicators. The sum from inter-segment transactions, related to gross written premiums, is not significant.

Page 29 of 184


 

SCOR GROUP   CONSOLIDATED FINANCIAL STATEMENTS UNDER IFRS
     
Explanation of the transition to IFRS
Impact on the Group’s shareholders’ equity at 1/1/2004
The Group’s share of net shareholders’ equity at 1/1/2004 totaled €589 million under IFRS versus €619 million under French GAAP.
This change results primarily from:
    the net positive impact on investments, particularly the fair value adjustments to investment securities;
    the negative impact resulting from the application of “shadow accounting”, adjusting underwriting assets and liabilities to reflect the fair value of investment securities;
    the positive impact of canceling equalization reserves;
    the negative impact resulting from accounting for deferred taxes against the capitalization reserve;
    the negative impact of accounting for employee benefits under IAS 19;
    the negative impact resulting from the application of the component-based method used for real-estate assets;
    the positive impact of posting capital-based instrument component included in our OCEANE debt instrument.
               
           
 
Group’s share of shareholders’ equity at 1/1/2004 under French GAAP (millions of euros)
      619 *  
 
 
           
           
 
Net impact of asset revaluation reserve for available-for-sale assets under IAS 32 / 39
      65    
 
Net impact of “shadow accounting”
      (34 )  
 
Other net impacts of financial assets under IAS32 / 39 and SIC 12
      (24 )  
 
Impact of financial liabilities under IAS32 / 39
      4    
 
Net impact of equalization reserves under IFRS 4
      27    
 
Impact of deferred taxes on capitalization reserve
      (40 )  
 
Impact of employee benefits under IAS 19
      (21 )  
 
Net impact of investment property under IAS 40
      (2 )  
 
Other impacts
      (5 )  
 
 
           
           
 
Group share of shareholders’ equity at 1/1/2004 restated under IFRS
      589    
 
 
           
           
* before capital increase on 1/7/2004 for an amount net of expenses of 708 million.
In addition, as permitted under IFRS 1 (first-time adoption), SCOR chose not to restate the accumulated translation adjustments prior to January 1, 2004. Thus, in the event of a future disposal of a business or subsidiary, where the transactions are denominated in a currency different from the consolidation currency, the gains or losses from the disposal will not have an impact on the translation adjustments generated before January 1, 2004.
As a result of adopting this optional treatment, we reclassified €-86 million in the balance sheet on the transition date between translation adjustments and consolidated reserves, with no impact on shareholders’ equity at January 1, 2004. This restatement had no impact on IFRS income for 2004.
Reconciliations provide quantitative information on the significant adjustments arising from the conversion of the SCOR Group consolidated accounts into IFRS standards. These reconciliations were made on the transition date of January 1, 2004 and on December 31, 2004, and had the following impact:

Page 30 of 184


 

SCOR GROUP   CONSOLIDATED FINANCIAL STATEMENTS UNDER IFRS
     Impact on balance sheet at January 1, 2004
                                                             
 
Assets – in millions of EUR   French   IFRS   Note   Reclassified   Impact of   Note   IFRS   Denominated in IFRS
Denominated in French   GAAP   reclassifications       French   conversion       2003    
GAAP   2003               GAAP                
 
 
                            296                       254    
Intangible assets
Goodwill
    202                       202       -3       (1)       199     Goodwill
Intangible assets
    94                                                      
Contract portfolios
    79                       79       -39               40    
Value of business acquired
Others
    15                       15                       15    
Other intangible assets
 
                                                           
 
            13               13                       13    
Tangible assets
Investments
    7,360                       7,415                       7,701    
Insurance business investments
Land and buildings
    217       -2       (2)       215       93       (2)       308    
Real-estate investments
Investments in subsidiaries (a) or with
    35       -35 ü
ú
ú
ý
ú
ú
þ
 


(3)
                                       
Other investments
    7,108       -7,108                       ü
ú
ú
ý
ú
ú
þ
                 
 
            5,813           5,813       -475    
(3)
      5,338    
Investments available for sale
 
            56               56       699           755    
Investments at fair valueby income
 
            1,331               1,331       -71             1,260    
Loans and accounts receivable
 
                                    40             40    
Derivative instruments
 
                                                           
Equity method investments
    13                       13                       13    
Investments in affiliated companies
Share of assignees and retrocessionnaires in technical reserves
    1,157       -129       (4)       1,028                       1,028    
Share of retrocessionnaires in technical reserves and financial liabilities
 
                            3,224                       3,157     Other assets
 
            255 ü
ú
ý
ú
þ
    (5)       255       25       (5)       280    
Deferred tax assets
Insurance or reinsurance receivables
    772       921     (4)       1,693       18       (4)       1,711    
Receivables resulting from reinsurance accepted
 
            308               308                       308    
Receivables resulting from or reinsurance operations
Receivables from companies in the banking sector
    1,824       -1,824       (6)                                      
 
                                                         
Taxes receivable
Other receivables
    620       -136               484       -108               376    
Other receivables
Other assets
    13                                                      
Tangible assets
    13       -13                                              
Accruals
    1,848                                                      
Deferred acquisition costs
    484                       484       -2               482    
Deferred acquisition costs
Others
    1,364       -1,364       (7)                                     Others
 
            1,826       (6)       1,826       10               1,836    
Cash and cash equivalents
 
TOTAL ASSETS
    13,903       -88               13,815       187               14,002     TOTAL ASSETS
 
 
     
(a)   or with which an equity interest relationship exists

Page 31 of 184


 

SCOR GROUP   CONSOLIDATED FINANCIAL STATEMENTS UNDER IFRS
                                                             
 
Liabilities – in millions of   French   IFRS   NOTE   Reclassfied   Impact of   Note   IFRS   Denominated in IFRS
EUR   GAAP   reclassifications       French   conversion       2003    
Denominated in French   2003               GAAP                    
GAAP                                
 
Group shareholders’ equity
    619                       619                       589    
Group shareholders’ equity
Share capital
    136                       136       1               137    
Share capital
 
            1               1       14               15    
Additional paid-in capital
Consolidate reserves
    797       -1               796       -77       (11)       719    
Consolidated reserves
Consolidated result
    -314                       -314                       -314    
Consolidated result
 
                                    31               31    
Asset revaluation reserve
 
                                    1       (12)       1    
Payments Based on Shares
Minority interests
    172                       172       -172       (9)            
Minority interests
 
                            791                       589    
Total shareholders’ equity
 
                            836                       1,199    
Financial debt
Subordinated liabilities
    230                       230       -3       (8)       227    
Subordinated debt
 
            509       (8)       509       264       (8)       773    
Financial debt securities
 
            97       (8)       97       102       (8)       199    
Financial debt to entities in the banking sector
Gross technical reserves
    10,923       48       (4)       10,971       -78       (4)       10,893    
Policy-linked liabilities
Contingency reserves
    26       -6               20       31       (10)       51    
Contingency reserves
 
                            1,197                       1,270    
Other liabilities
 
            35       (5)       35       67       (5)       102    
Deferred tax liabilities
 
                                    6       (3)       6    
Derivative instruments liabilities
Insurance or reinsurance accounts payable
    343       336               679                       679    
Accepted insurance and reinsurance accounts payable
 
            279               279                       279    
Retrocession accounts payable
Liabilities represented by securities
    509       -509       (8)                                      
Liabilities to companies in the banking sector
    97       -97       (8)                                      
 
                                                          Taxes payable
Other liabilities
    738       -534               204                       204     Other liabilities
Accruals
    246       -246                                              
 
TOTAL LIABILITIES
    13,903       -88               13,815       187               14,002     TOTAL LIABILITIES
 

Page 32 of 184


 

SCOR GROUP   CONSOLIDATED FINANCIAL STATEMENTS UNDER IFRS
Impact on balance sheet at December 31, 2004
                                                             
 
Assets – in millions of EUR   French   IFRS reclassify-   Note   Reclassified   Impact of   Note   IFRS   Denominated in IFRS
Denominated in French GAAP   GAAP   cations       French   conversion       2004    
    2004           GAAP                
 
 
                            226                       215     Intangible assets
Goodwill
    177                       177       23       (1)       200     Goodwill
Intangible assets
    49                                                      
Contract portfolios
    37                       37       -34               3    
Life reinsurance portfolio
Others
    12                       12                       12    
Other intangible assets
 
            10               10                       10    
Tangible assets
Investments
    7,985                       8,093                       8,211    
Insurance business investments
Land and buildings
    228       -2       (2)       226       93       (2)       319    
Real-estate investments
Investments in subsidiaries (a) or with
    36       -36 ü
ú
ú
ú
ý
ú
ú
ú
þ
    (3)                                      
Other investments
    7,721       -7,721                                          
 
            6,352           6,352       -811 ü
ú
ú
ý
ú
ú
þ
    (3)       5,541    
Investments available for sale
 
            9           9       772           781    
Investments at fair value by income
 
            1,506           1,506       35           1,541    
Loans and accounts receivable
 
                                    29           29    
Derivative instruments
Equity method investments
                                    21               21    
Investments in affiliated companies
Share of assignees and retrocessionnaires in technical reserves
    908       -28       (4)       880       -2       (4)       878    
Share of retrocessionnaires in technical reserves and financial liabilities
 
                            2,429                       2,314     Other assets
 
            235 ü
ú
ý
ú
þ
    (5)
(4)
      235       -9       (5)       226    
Deferred tax assets
Insurance or reinsurance receivables
    443       850           1,293       -92       (4)       1,201    
Receivables resulting from reinsurance accepted
 
            106           106                       106    
Retrocession accounts receivable in reinsurance
Receivables from companies in the banking sector
    1,798       -1,798       (6)                                      
 
                                                          Taxes receivable
Other receivables
    482       -205               277       -6               271    
Other receivables
Other assets
    10                                                      
Tangible assets
    10       -10                                              
Accruals
    1,598                                                      
Deferred acquisition costs
    518                       518       -8               510    
Deferred acquisition costs
Others
    1,080       -1,080       (7)                                      
 
            1,799       (6)       1,799       27               1,826    
Cash and cash equivalents
 
TOTAL ASSETS
    13,450       -13               13,437       38               13,475     TOTAL ASSETS
 
 
(a)   or with which an equity interest relationship exists

Page 33 of 184


 

SCOR GROUP   CONSOLIDATED FINANCIAL STATEMENTS UNDER IFRS
                                                             
 
Liabilities – in millions of EUR   French   IFRS   Note   Reclassified   Impact of   Note   IFRS   Denominated in IRFS
Denominated in French GAAP   GAAP   reclassif-       French   conversion       2004    
    2004   cations       GAAP                
 
Group shareholders’ equity
    1,324                       1,324                       1,335    
Group shareholders’ equity
Share capital
    645                       645                       645    
Share capital
 
            11               11       44               55    
Additional paid-in capital
Consolidate reserves
    610       -11               599       -89       (11)       510    
Consolidated reserves
Consolidated result
    69                       69       6               75    
Consolidated result
 
                                    43               43    
Asset revaluation reserve
 
                                    7       (12)       7    
Payments Based on Shares
Minority interests
    183                       183       -183       (9)            
Minority interests
 
                            1,507                       1,335    
Total shareholders’ equity
 
                            1,083                       1,342     Financial debt
Subordinated liabilities
    225                       225       -3       (8)       222     Subordinated debt
 
            769       (8)       769       165       (8)       934    
Financial debt securities
 
            89       (8)       89       97       (8)       186    
Financial debt to entities in the banking sector
Gross technical reserves
    9,938       18       (4)       9,956       -58       (4)       9,898    
Policy-linked liabilities
 
                                                    9,742    
Technical reserves linked to insurance contracts
 
                                                    156    
Liabilities associated with financial contracts
Contingency reserves
    39       -4               35       23       (10)       58     Contingency reserves
 
                            856                       842     Other liabilities
 
            25       (5)       25       45       (5)       70    
Deferred tax liabilities
 
                                    3       (3)       3    
Derivative instruments liabilities
Insurance or reinsurance accounts payable
    227       -46               181                       181    
Accepted insurance and reinsurance accounts payable
 
            474               474       -62               412    
Retrocession accounts payable
Liabilities represented by securities
    769       -769       (8)                                      
Liabilities to companies in the banking sector
    89       -89       (8)                                      
 
                                                          Taxes payable
Other liabilities
    604       -428               176                       176     Other liabilities
Accruals
    53       -53                                              
 
TOTAL LIABILITIES
    13,450       -13               13,437       38               13,475     TOTAL LIABILITIES
 
Corrections have been made to the balance sheet under IFRS standards as at December 31, 2004 by comparison with the versions published in the quarterly financial reports for the 2005 financial period. The impact of these corrections on the net position as at December 31, 2004 is €9 million.

Page 34 of 184


 

SCOR GROUP   CONSOLIDATED FINANCIAL STATEMENTS UNDER IFRS
Impact on net income at December 31, 2004
                                                             
 
Statement of income – in millions of EUR           IFRS           Reclassified   Impact            
Denominated in French GAAP           reclassifi           French   of       IFRS   Denominated in
            -cations   Note   GAAP   conversion   Note   2004   IFRS
 
Gross premiums written
    2,528                       2,528                       2,561    
Gross premiums written
Net premiums written
    2,417                                                      
Change in unearned premiums
    94                       156                       167    
Change in unearned premiums
Net premiums earned
    2,511       173       (4)       2,684       44       (4)       2,728    
Gross premiums earned
 
            8               8       -1               7    
Other revenues from operations
Net financial revenues
    217       119       (13)       336       10       (3)       346    
Investment revenues
Total revenues from current operations
    2,728                       3,028                       3,081    
Total revenues from ordinary activities
Claims expenses
    -1,802       -62
ü
ú
ú
ý
ú
ú
þ
   
(4)
      -1,864       -107
ü
ý
þ
    (4)       -1,971    
Expenses relating to contract benefits
Management expenses
    -820       149           -671       59           -612    
Gross commission on earned premiums
 
            -100           -100       -4               -104    
Net income (loss) from reinsurance operations
 
            -31           -31                       -31    
Financial management expenses
 
            -98               -98                       -98    
Acquisitions and operational expenses
 
            -62               -62       -4               -66    
Other current operational expenses
 
                                                         
Other revenues from current operations
Total current operational expenses
    -2,622                       -2,825                       -2,882    
Total other current revenues and expenses
NET INCOME/LOSS FROM CURRENT OPERATIONS
    107                       203       -4               199    
INCOME/LOSS FROM CURRENT OPERATIONS
Goodwill amortization expense
    -19                       -19       19       (1)            
Change in value of goodwill
Other net revenues
    49       -49                                            
Other operational expenses
 
                                                         
Other revenues from operations
 
                            185                       199     INCOME (LOSS) FROM OPERATIONS
 
            -48       (8)       -48       -30       (8)       -78     Financing expenses
Share of net income – Equity method investments
                                                         
Share in results of associated companies
Income tax
    -44                       -44       -2               -46     Income tax
NET INCOME (LOSS) OF CONSOLIDATED ENTITY
    93                       93                       75    
NET INCOME (LOSS) OF CONSOLIDATED ENTITY
Minority interests
    -24                       -24       24       (9)             Minority interests
GROUP NET INCOME (LOSS)
    69                       69       6               75    
GROUP NET INCOME (LOSS)
 

Page 35 of 184


 

SCOR GROUP   CONSOLIDATED FINANCIAL STATEMENTS UNDER IFRS

Note 1 Business Combinations
As authorized under IFRS 3, SCOR elected not to restate business combinations carried out prior to January 1, 2004. As permitted by IFRS 1, SCOR will not apply IAS 21 “Effects of changes in foreign exchange rates” to goodwill from prior acquisitions arising from business combinations before the IFRS transition date. Consequently, this goodwill is maintained in the functional currency of the acquiring company.
Pursuant to IFRS 3, goodwill will no longer be amortized as of January 1, 2004.
Note 2 Property
Restatements arising from implementation of the components-based amortized cost method will have little impact on the consolidated statements.
Under French GAAP, SCOR did not use the preferential method which allows finance lease transactions to be reported on the balance sheet. Under IFRS, this generates an increase in investment properties and a corresponding increase in financial liabilities. This restatement had no impact on IFRS income.
Note 3 Financial Investments
Business combinations under French GAAP are not identical to IFRS standards where investments are classified according to categories: financial assets available for sale, assets at fair value by income, loans and other accounts receivable and derivatives (see Note on Accounting Standards) which are associated with accrued interest and classified as adjustment accounts under French GAAP.
A large portion of financial investments are recorded on the balance sheet at their market value. This revaluation, net of deferred taxes is accounted for according to the classification of securities, either against shareholders’ equity or income. (See Note on Financial Investments.) Pursuant to IAS 39, derivatives are recorded on the balance sheet at their fair value. Losses and gains arising from changes in market value on the closing date of derivatives not designated as hedging instruments are reported under income. Associated with the consolidation of mutual funds and ad hoc entities that are comprised primarily of financial assets and liabilities that fall under IAS 32 and 39, the primary effect of these restatements is an increase in the value of investments and financial liabilities.
Note 4 – Reporting of reinsurance transactions
In conformity with IFRS 4 (See “Principles and methods relating to reinsurance operations”) which requires that all contracts be classified as either “financial” contracts or “insurance” contracts, presentations have been reclassified to reflect these new classifications. In addition, profits from retrocessions must be presented separately under IFRS, representing a major change over previous presentations.
The share of retrocessionnaires in the technical reserves includes the reinsurance loss estimates, and the other reinsurance estimates (premiums, commissions) are classified as accounts receivable resulting from reinsurance transactions net of reserves for depreciation.
IFRS accounting policies do not provide for the possibility of setting aside reserves for future risks under forward contracts. Thus when such reserves exist, they are eliminated from SCOR’s consolidated accounts under IFRS.
SCOR has also opted to use the option offered by IFRS 4 to adopt shadow accounting. This method consists of adjusting underwriting assets and liabilities to take account of capital gains and losses on investments accounted for under IFRS but unrealized. These restatements are not allowed under French GAAP.
Note 5 Deferred Taxes
Under IFRS, deferred taxes are presented on a specific line on the balance sheet.
Under French GAAP, CRC Regulation 2000-05 provides exceptions to the application of the general principles of deferred taxes when the capitalization reserve is cancelled except in cases where there is a strong likelihood that
there will be a loss on the sale of securities included in the capitalization reserve. IFRS standards do not provide for such an exception. Thus, deferred taxes generated from the restatement of capitalization reserves are reported without taking into account the probability of losses on the sale of securities included in this reserve.
Note 6 Accounts Receivable from Companies in the Banking Sector
Accounts receivable from businesses in the banking sector and accrued interest are accounted for as cash and equivalents.
Note 7 Adjustment Accounts
Other adjustment accounts are associated with primary accounts, as indicated below with regard to accrued interest payable on investments and reinsurance estimates.
Note 8 Financial Liabilities
Financial liabilities include all debt securities and loans from banking sector companies.
The debenture loans convertible into shares (OCEANEs) issued by SCOR in 1999 and 2004 are financial instruments that include several components, according to IAS 32, including a liability and equity component (See “Accounting principles and methods relating to financial liabilities”).
The restatements linked to the OCEANE bonds results in a higher financing expense on the IFRS income statement.
Financial liabilities will also be impacted by the consolidation of the Horizon structure on the opening balance sheet for 2004, on finance leases and on leasing commitments. See also Note 2 and 9.
Note 9 Commitments to Repurchase Minority Interests
SCOR extended to the shareholders of its fully consolidated subsidiaries commitments to repurchase their minority interest. Under French GAAP, these commitments to repurchase minority investments are reported as off-balance sheet items. Where appropriate, reserves were made for the anticipated loss on the repurchase value.
Under IFRS, the following accounting treatment has been temporarily adopted in accordance with current IFRS standards:
when posted on the balance sheet for the first time, the commitment to repurchase the minority interest is recognized as a financial liability at the discounted value of the exercise price agreed upon for the repurchase commitment, offset against minority interests;
future changes in the commitment value is recognized as “Financing Expenses”.
The change in the value of the commitment is accounted for as “Financing Expenses” in the 2004 IFRS income statement, offset against minority interests.
Note 10 Pensions and Post-Retirement Obligations
The method for measuring pension commitments and post-retirement obligations, under the rules specified in IAS 19 (employee benefits), resulted in an increase in its contingency and related reserves.

Note 11 Translation Adjustment
Under IFRS 1 (first-time adoption of IFRS) a company may elect not to recognize accumulated translation adjustments prior to January 1, 2004. As a result, in the event of a future disposal of a business or subsidiary, where the transactions are denominated in a currency different from the consolidation currency, the gains or loss from the disposal will not have an impact on the translation adjustments generated before January 1, 2004.
As a result of adopting this optional treatment a translation adjustment reclassification appears on the balance sheet on the transition date.
Note 12 Share-based payments
Application of IFRS 2 results in a change in the accounting method for stock option plans (options for subscriptions or purchases of stocks awarded by SCOR to its employees and the employees of its subsidiaries) and the awarding of free shares to employees. SCOR elected to adopt the early application of this standard in 2004. Only plans announced after November 7, 2002 where rights will be


Page 36 of 184


 

SCOR GROUP   CONSOLIDATED FINANCIAL STATEMENTS UNDER IFRS

acquired on January 1, 2004 are included on the balance sheet.
Under IFRS 2, benefits granted to employees through the granting of stock options (value of the option on the grant date) and shares (share value on the grant date) are accounted for as additional compensation. This additional compensation is recognized as personnel expenses, spread out over the term of the acquisition of the benefits granted.
The fair value of these options determined on their respective grant dates represents deferred compensation, with no impact on the shareholders’ equity of the transition balance sheet on January 1, 2004. Accounting for this deferred compensation is spread over the vesting period, but not on a straight-line basis, given the vesting terms, which vary according to the characteristics of the benefit granted.
This is a non-cash expense and is offset against consolidated reserves. Consequently, the application of this standard had no net impact on the shareholders’ equity on January 1 and December 31, 2004.
Note 13 Financial Income net of Expenses
Under French GAAP “Financial Income Net of Expenses” corresponds to financial income from business activities. Financial income from non-technical activities corresponds to “Other Net Income.”
Under IFRS “Financial Income Net of Expenses” includes financial income (technical and non-technical) except:
(I) financing charges classified in a specific IFRS line item
(II) financial management expenses classified in a specific IFRS line item
(III) and other operating income


Primary impact on cash flow
In the SCOR Group balance sheet, the definition of cash flow is identical under French and IFRS standards. (Cash and cash equivalents). At January 1 and December 31, 2004, cash flow under IFRS stood at € 1,836 million and €1,826 million respectively. The impact from the passage to IFRS on the opening cash flow of €12 million at January 1, 2004 and €27 million at December 31, 2004 are primarily due to the consolidation of mutual funds.
Restatements have no major impact on cash flow statement

Page 37 of 184


 

SCOR GROUP   CONSOLIDATED FINANCIAL STATEMENTS UNDER IFRS
ANALYSIS OF MAIN BALANCE SHEET ITEMS
Note 1 Intangible assets
                                 
In millions of EUR                    
            Value of business        
At January 1, 2004   Goodwill   acquired   Others   Total
 
Gross value
    383       125       17       525  
Amortization
            45       3       48  
Depreciation
    184                       184  
 
Shadow accounting
            39               39  
 
Net book value
    199       41       14       254  
 
 
                               
At December 31, 2004
                               
Net book value on opening
    199       41       14       254  
Exchange rate variation
    1       -3       -1       -3  
Increases
                    0       0  
Change in consolidation scope
                               
Amortization for the period
            37       1       38  
Depreciation from the period
                               
Shadow accounting
            2       -1       1  
 
Net book value at closing
    200       3       12       215  
 
 
                               
At December 31, 2004
                               
Gross value
    381       116       14       511  
Amortization
            79       2       81  
Depreciation
    181                       181  
 
Shadow accounting
            34               34  
 
Net book value
    200       3       12       215  
 
 
                               
At December 31, 2005
                               
Net book value on opening
    200       3       12       215  
Exchange rate variation
            0       1       1  
Increases
                    0       0  
Change in consolidation scope
                               
Amortization for the period
            4               4  
Depreciation from the period
            13               13  
Shadow accounting (1)
            -31               -31  
 
Net book value at closing
    200       17       13       230  
 
 
                               
At December 31, 2005
                               
Gross value
    390       73       15       478  
Amortization
            48       2       50  
Depreciation
    190                       190  
Shadow accounting
            8               8  
 
Net book value
    200       17       13       230  
 
(1)   After disposal of a portfolio of EUR 61 million.
Goodwill represents the excess of the cost of acquisition over the fair value of the Group’s share of the net identifiable assets of the acquired company on the date of acquisition.
In accordance with the accounting principles presented in the section “Goodwill and business alliances,” the main assumptions used in the impairment tests to calculate the useful value are as follows:

Page 38 of 184


 

SCOR GROUP   CONSOLIDATED FINANCIAL STATEMENTS UNDER IFRS
  -   Determination of the discounted value of income over the period 2006-2008(1),
 
  -   Determination of standardized profits used to calculate terminal value. In the case of SCOR US, the normative income used is based on the 2006-2008 subscription plan and a schedule of losses,
 
  -   2% growth rate for all non-Life insurance companies and 1% for SCOR US,
 
  -   Cash flow approach after income tax except for SCOR US (use of current tax losses through the consumption of DTAs),
 
  -   Cost of capital assets: 10% for all non- Life companies.
Life Insurance Companies: the value of SCOR VIE and SCOR Life Re Insurance Company is calculated on the basis of the revalued net worth of the portfolio (external valuation study of the embedded value).
IRP activities were discontinued on December 31, 2004. The goodwill at December 31, 2003 cannot be verified according to the DCF method and must therefore be depreciated by 100% (€2.6 million) offset against the net worth at opening.
During 2004 and 2005, no loss in value was recorded for the various CGUs, except the goodwill recorded upon the repurchase of minority interest from IRP Holdings Limited and fully depreciated at December 31, 2005.
The main goodwill items concern the following entities:
                         
 
  In millions of EUR       Gross value         Net value    
 
SCOR US
      188         116    
 
SCOR Italia
      99         17    
 
SCOR (SOREMA SA)
      35         29    
 
CRP
      24            
 
The acquisition value of the Life-Reinsurance portfolios appears on the balance sheet as €17 million and corresponds to the valuation of the life insurance portfolio of SCOR Life U.S. Re Insurance Company. This acquisition value is amortized in line with recognition of future contract margins.
Other intangible assets essentially represent the insurance licenses held by SCOR U.S.
 
(1)   The discount rate is a rate before taxes, which reflects current market assessments of the time value of the money and the specific risks of the assets for which the estimates of future cash flows have not been adjusted.

Page 39 of 184


 

SCOR GROUP   CONSOLIDATED FINANCIAL STATEMENTS UNDER IFRS
Note 2 Investment property
The changes in the net book value of investment properties are as follows:
In millions of EUR
                                 
    Real estate           Financing    
At December 31, 2003   investment           contract   Total
 
Gross value
    278               106       384  
Amortization, depreciation
    -71               -5       -76  
 
Net book value
    207               101       308  
 
 
                               
Exchange rate variation
                               
Increase
    24         a)             24  
Decrease
                               
Change in consolidation scope
                               
Amortization for the period
    -9               -4       -13  
Depreciation from the period
    1                       1  
Others
    -1                       -1  
 
Net book value at closing
    222               97       319  
 
 
                               
 
Fair value at December 31, 2004
    275               105       380  
 
 
                               
At December 31, 2004
                               
Gross value
    301               106       407  
Amortization, depreciation
    -79               -9       -88  
 
Net book value
    222               97       319  
 
 
                               
Exchange rate variation
    1                       1  
Increase
    12         b)             12  
Decrease
    -13         c)             -13  
Change in consolidation scope
                               
Amortization for the period
    1               -4       -2  
Depreciation from the period
                               
Others
    1                       1  
 
Net book value at closing
    224               93       317  
 
 
                               
At December 31, 2005
                               
Gross value
    300               106       407  
Amortization, depreciation
    -77               -13       -90  
 
Net book value
    224               93       317  
 
 
Fair value at December 31, 2005
    275               109       384  
 
 
(a)   purchase of a building in Trappes for 24 million
 
(b)   purchase of a building in La Plagne for 12 million
 
(c)   disposal of a building in Velizy with gross value of 13 million and net value of €7 million

Page 40 of 184


 

SCOR GROUP   CONSOLIDATED FINANCIAL STATEMENTS UNDER IFRS
All the properties held by the SCOR Group are considered investment property. They consist of:
  a)   office or housing buildings which the Group owns and leases. The minimum rents planned are presented in Note 17.
 
  b)   office buildings and warehouses capitalized under finance lease contracts. The minimum rents planned are presented in Note 17.
Note 3 Financial assets
The breakdown of financial assets is as follows, by classification and by type:
                                 
             
in millions of EUR   2005     2004  
    Net book           Net book        
    value     Fair value       value   Fair value      
             
Real-estate investments
    317       384       319       380  
             
Bonds
    5,233       5,233       5,290       5,290  
             
Equities
    730       730       251       251  
             
AFS
    5,963       5,963       5,541       5,541  
             
Equities
    229       229       196       196  
             
Bonds
    166       166       585       585  
             
Fair value by income
    395       395       781       781  
             
Loans and deposits
    94       94       119       119  
             
Receivables for deposited cash
    1,278       1,278       1,422       1,422  
             
Loans and receivables
    1,372       1,372       1,541       1,541  
             
Derivative instruments – fair value by income
    35       35       29       29  
             
Insurance business investments
    8,082       8,148       8,211       8,272  
 
                               
Derivative instruments - hedging (liabilities)
    (6 )     (6 )     (3 )     (3 )
             
 
                               
Cash and cash equivalents
    1,667       1,667       1,826       1,826  
 
             
Unlisted securities stood at €64 million at the end of 2005 and €72 million in 2004.
Page 41 of 184

 


 

SCOR GROUP   CONSOLIDATED FINANCIAL STATEMENTS UNDER IFRS
The change in net book value of AFS and fair value by income securities is as follows:
         
in millions of EUR        
Gross value
    6,127  
Depreciation
    (34 )
 
Net book value at 01/01/2004
    6,093  
 
 
       
Exchange rate variation
    (353 )
Increases / Decommissioning, Disposals, Acquisitions
    531  
Change in consolidation scope
       
Change in fair value by income and shareholders’ equity
    55  
Depreciation
    (4 )
Others
       
 
Net book value at 12/31/2004
    6,322  
 
 
       
Gross value
    6,359  
Depreciation
    (38 )
 
Net book value at 12/31/2004
    6,322  
 
 
       
Exchange rate variation
    522  
Increases / Decommissioning, Disposals, Acquisitions
    (542 )
Change in consolidation scope
       
Disposals (sales and reimbursements)
       
Change in fair value by income and shareholders’ equity
    40  
Depreciation
    16  
Others
       
 
Net book value at 12/31/2005
    6,358  
 
 
       
Gross value
    6,380  
Depreciation
    (22 )
 
Net book value at 12/31/2005
    6,358  
 
As at December 31, 2003, the net book value under French GAAP for AFS and JVR investments was respectively €5,813 million and €56 million.
Page 42 of 184

 


 

SCOR GROUP   CONSOLIDATED FINANCIAL STATEMENTS UNDER IFRS
Note 4 Loans and accounts receivable
The breakdown of loans and accounts receivable is as follows:
                 
in millions of EUR   2005     2004  
Loans greater than one year
    67       70  
Deposits
    28       18  
Receivables for cash deposited with ceding companies
    1,278       1,457  
Depreciation
    -1       -4  
 
Loans and accounts receivable
    1,372       1,541  
 
Loans and accounts receivable consist essentially of cash deposits made at the request of ceding companies as cover for our commitments (underwriting reserves).
Note 5 Derivatives
Derivatives consist primarily of options indexed on the S&P 500 for which the fair value amounts to €33.8 million and the forward currency contracts shown in the following table:
                                             
                     
        Forward sales       Forward purchases    
  In million EUR     Nominal       Fair Value       Nominal       Fair Value    
                             
 
TOTAL
      414         412         266         266    
                             
Note 6 Investments in affiliated companies
The Group holds investments in affiliated companies. The following table provides a summary of the financial information for these companies expressed at local standards.
                                             
in millions of EUR  
    COUNTRY   Total assets     Total liabilities     Premium     Net income     Percentage  
                excluding     Income     at 100%     held  
                shareholders’                    
Equity method companies             equity                    
 
ASEFA
  Spain     355       337       110       3       40 %
Mutre
  France     234       219       120               33 %
SCOR Gestion Financière
  France     5                               100 %
SCORLUX
  Luxembourg     7       1                       100 %
Euroscor
  Luxembourg     4       1                       100 %
 
2004 Total (1)
                                           
 
ASEFA
  Spain     522       499       137       7       40 %
Mutre
  France     352       336       112               33 %
SCOR Gestion Financière
  France     5                               100 %
SCORLUX
  Luxembourg     6                               100 %
Euroscor
  Luxembourg     4       1                       100 %
 
 
                                           
Total 2005(2)
                                           
 
(1)   Data based on 2003 accounts except EUROSCOR which is based on 2002 accounts
 
(2)   Data based on 2004 accounts except EUROSCOR which is based on 2003 accounts
Page 43 of 184

 


 

SCOR GROUP   CONSOLIDATED FINANCIAL STATEMENTS UNDER IFRS
Note 7 Accounts receivable and debts on ceding and retroceding companies
                                                 
in millions of EUR   2005     2004  
    LIFE     Non Life     Total     LIFE     Non Life     Total  
                 
Gross debtor companies
    134       295       429       66       285       351  
Depreciation
    -2       -15       -17       -2       -13       -16  
Reinsurance technical valuations
    418       497       915       445       420       866  
                 
Accepted insurance and reinsurance accounts receivable     550       776       1,326       509       692       1,201  
                 
Retrocession debtor companies
    2       227       229       22       84       106  
                 
Retrocession accounts receivable
    2       227       229       22       84       106  
                 
                                                 
in millions of EUR   2005     2004  
    LIFE     Non Life     Total     LIFE     Non Life     Total  
                 
Creditor companies — acceptance
    -63       -75       -138       -77       -104       -181  
                 
Accepted insurance and reinsurance accounts payable     -63       -75       -138       -77       -104       -181  
                 
Liabilities for cash deposits
    -263       -88       -351       -283       -105       -387  
Retrocession creditor companies
    -5       -211       -216       -16       -31       -46  
Technical retrocession valuations
    -51       -27       -78       -46       67       22  
                 
Retrocession accounts payable
    -320       -325       -645       -344       -68       -412  
                 
Recoverable accounts receivable and due debt regarding ceding and retroceding companies are mostly due at less than one year.
The reinsurance technical valuations include ceding company accounts not yet received and reinsurance estimates (See Note on “Accounting Principles”).
Note 8 Deferred acquisition costs
                                                 
             
In millions of EUR           2005                     2004        
    Life     Non Life     Total     Life     Non Life     Total  
Gross value at 01/01
    577       126       703       508       119       627  
Accumulated amortization and loss in value
    -193               -193       -145               -145  
             
Net value at 01/01
    385       126       511       363       119       482  
             
Capitalization of new contracts for the period
    70       135       205       104       126       230  
             
Change in consolidation scope and contract portfolio exchanges                                                
Amortization for the period     -68       -131       -199       -79       -116       -195  
             
Capitalized interest
    17               17       14               14  
Losses in value recognized during the period                                                
Amortization and losses in value     -10               -10       -9               -9  
Exchange rate variation
    30       5       35       -8       -3       -11  
Other changes
    -6               -6                          
             
Gross value at December 31
    633       135       768       577       126       703  
             
Accumulated amortization and losses in value
    -215               -215       -193               -193  
             
Net value at December 31/12
    418       135       553       385       126       511  
             
Note 9 Cash and cash equivalent
                 
in millions of EUR   2005     2004  
                 
Cash on hand
    857       697  
Short-term loans
    810       1,129  
 
           
 
    1,667       1,826  
 
           
Bank overdrafts stood at €13.5 million in 2005 (€0.70 million in 2004).
Page 44 of 184

 


 

SCOR GROUP   CONSOLIDATED FINANCIAL STATEMENTS UNDER IFRS
Cash and cash equivalent earn yields based on the posted daily deposit interest rates. Short term loans do not exceed periods of three months. They earn the rates posted for short term deposits. The fair value of cash and cash equivalents stood at €1,667 million and €1,826 million for 2005 and 2004 respectively.
The blocked bank accounts concern primarily SCOR SA for an amount of €155 million as at December 31, 2005.
At December 31, 2005 credit facilities were granted to the Group from various banks. The unused credit facilities at December 31, 2005 stood at €199 million (€44 million in 2004).
Note 10 Information on share capital and consolidated reserves
During the year, share capital and additional paid-in capital increased respectively by €117,760,736 and €105,910,795, through the creation of 149,500,000 shares of €1.56 each, bringing share capital to €763,096,714.
The number of shares in circulation was as follows:
                 
   
    2005     2004  
 
               
 
Beginning of Year
    819,269,070       136,544,845  
 
               
Share capital Increase on January 7, 2004
            682,724,225  
 
               
Share capital Increase on June 30, 2005 at a price of €1.56 per share
    149,500,000          
 
               
End of Year
    968,769,070       819,269,070  
 
               
 
The number of treasury stock held by the company or its affiliates stood at 9,110,915 shares for the year 2005 (9,298,085 for the year 2004).
These shares are not entitled to dividends.
The shares acquired at December 31, 2005 through stock-option plans granted to employees totaled 20,712,100 shares.
At December 31, 2005, the Group had one (OCEANE) convertible bond issue; it also had another convertible bond issue at December 31, 2004 that was fully redeemed in 2005; the respective breakdown of shares is as follows:
                 
   
    2005     2004  
 
               
 
 
               
1999 convertible bond issue of €58 each
            4,025,000  
 
               
2004 convertible bond issue of €2 each
    100,000,000       100,000,000  
 
               
At year end
    100,000,000       104,025,000  
 
The asset revaluation reserves are used to account for the changes in fair value of the available-for-sale financial assets adjusted to reflect the effects of (“shadow accounting”), if any.
The Translation Adjustments line item records the differences between the exchange rates resulting from the conversion of foreign currencies on the financial statements of foreign subsidiaries. This account is also used to record the impact of any hedges made for net investments outside France.
The item entitled “Share-based payments” is used to offset the cost of services received for the granting of shares, stock options or for employee stock purchase plans.
A breakdown of the various reserves is provided in the Table of Changes in Shareholders’ Equity.
Page 45 of 184

 


 

SCOR GROUP   CONSOLIDATED FINANCIAL STATEMENTS UNDER IFRS
Note 11 Liabilities relating to policies
                                                                 
             
  in millions of EUR     LIFE       Non Life       Total    
        2005       2004       2005       2004       2005       2004    
                                         
 
Mathematical reserve
      2,063         2,045         -2                   2,061         2,045    
 
Unearned premiums reserves
      57         14         637         557         693         571    
 
Claims reserves
      1,387         1,441         5,544         5,684         6,931         7,126    
 
Reserves relating to financial contracts
      108         96         55         61         163         156    
                                         
 
Liabilities relating to contracts (gross reserves)
      3,615         3,596         6,234         6,302         9,849         9,898    
                                         
 
Ceded mathematical reserves
      -311         -286                             -311         -286    
 
Ceded unearned premiums reserves
      -4         -4         -24         -36         -29         -40    
 
Ceded claims reserves
      -85         -60         -558         -481         -643         -541    
 
Reserves relating to financial contracts
                -11                                       -11    
                                         
  Share of retrocessionnaires in technical reserves and financial liabilities       -401         -361         -582         -517         -983         -878    
                                         
 
TOTAL NET TECHNICAL RESERVES
      3,214         3,235         5,652         5,785         8,866         9,020    
                                         
Underwriting reserves are subject to estimate. Payments linked to these reserves are not usually fixed, either by amount or by due date. A projection of the settlement timings, founded on past experience and our own judgment, leads to the following estimated timetable:
- non-life underwriting reserves: settlement of about 30% of reserves in less than one year, 25% within 2 to 3 years, 20% within 4 to 5 years and 25% beyond that.
- Life Underwriting reserves: settlement of about 25% of reserves within one year, 10% within 2 to 3 years, 10% within 4 to 5 years and 55% beyond that.
The projected settlements can differ in a significant manner from future payments. Differences which may be noted in relation to these projections are normal. However estimates for claims reserve as at December 31, 2005 do not take into account the effect of settlements bearing on future business.
The breakdown of claims reserve is as follows:
                                                                 
             
  in millions of EUR     LIFE       Non Life       Total    
        2005       2004       2005       2004       2005       2004    
 
“Property and Casualty” claims reserves
      869         884         5,508         5,666         6,377         6,550    
 
“Property and Casualty” claims estimates
      0         0         35         18         35         18    
 
“Provident” claims reserves
      691         673                             691         673    
 
“Provident” claims estimates
      -173         -115                             -173         -115    
                                         
 
Claims reserves (gross reserves)
      1,387         1,442         5,544         5,684         6,931         7,126    
                                         
 
“Property and Casualty” claims reserves
      -10         -27         -545         -509         -554         -536    
 
“Property and Casualty” claims estimates
      -12         12         -13         28         -25         40    
 
“Provident” claims reserves
      -64         -45                             -64         -45    
 
“Provident” claims estimates
                                                             
                                         
 
Share of retrocessionnaires in claims reserves
      -85         -60         -558         -481         -643         -541    
                                         
 
TOTAL NET CLAIMS RESERVES
      1,302         1,382         4,986         5,203         6,288         6,585    
                                         
Page 46 of 184

 


 

SCOR GROUP   CONSOLIDATED FINANCIAL STATEMENTS UNDER IFRS
The change in reserves for “Property & Casualty” claims is as follows:
                         
             
  In millions of EUR     2005       2004    
                 
 
Gross claims reserve at January 1
      6,550         7,454    
 
Reinsurers share in reserves for outstanding claims at January 1
      -536         -691    
                 
 
Net claims reserve at January 1
      6,014         6,763    
                 
 
Claims expense for current financial period
      1,585         1,525    
 
Bonuses/losses from previous periods
      -334         -419    
                 
 
Total claims expense
      1,251         1,106    
                 
 
Payment for claims for current period
      -753         -429    
 
Payment for claims for previous periods
      -896         -1,309    
                 
 
Total payments
      -1,649         -1,738    
                 
 
Exchange rate variations
      208         -118    
                 
 
Net reserves for outstanding claims at December 31
      5,824         6,014    
                 
 
Including reinsurers’ share
      -554         -536    
                 
The change in mathematical reserves was as follows:
                         
             
  In millions of EUR     2005       2004    
                 
 
Gross technical reserves at January 1
      2,045         2,035    
                 
 
Net premiums
      472         380    
 
Claims expense
      -699         -267    
 
Technical result and other
      -10         10    
 
Change in shadow accounting
      1         2    
 
Impact of foreign exchange
      255         -115    
                 
 
Gross technical reserves at December 31
      2,063         2,045    
                 
 
                 
 
Share of reinsurers in gross technical reserves at January 1
      286         353    
                 
 
Net premiums
      24         19    
 
Claims expense
      -43         -48    
 
Technical result and other
      1         -13    
 
Impact of foreign exchange
      42         -25    
                 
 
Share of reinsurers in gross technical reserves at December 31
      311         286    
                 
Page 47 of 184

 


 

SCOR GROUP   CONSOLIDATED FINANCIAL STATEMENTS UNDER IFRS
Note 12 Financing liabilities
                                 
In millions of EUR   2005     2004  
    Net book     Fair Value     Net book     Fair Value  
    value           value        
            (EUR, in millions)          
Subordinated debt
    233       233       222       222  
Subordinated loans
                               
Loans of USD 100 million nominal
    84       84       73       73  
Loans of €100 million nominal
    99       99       99       99  
Non-amortizable loans of €50 million nominal
    50       50       50       50  
Liabilities represented by securities
    520       576       934       1,015  
Bond borrowings
                               
OCEANE borrowings
                    227       265  
OCEANE 2 borrowings
    194       250       186       230  
Senior Loans
    208       208       208       208  
Horizon Loan
    83       83       94       94  
Medium-term notes
    35       35       35       35  
IRP minority interests
                    183       183  
Liabilities to companies in the banking sector
    201       201       186       186  
Financing contract
    93       93       97       97  
Other financial liabilities
    108       108       89       89  
     
TOTAL
    954       1,010       1,342       1,424  
     
OCEANE Bonds
On May 6, 1999, the Board of Directors decided, and the Mixed General Meeting of Shareholders authorized, the issuance of a loan materialized by OCEANE bonds. Issued on June 28, 1999, the total nominal amount was €233.45 million, represented by 4,025,000 OCEANE bonds with a nominal value of €58 each. The bonds carry an interest rate of 1% payable each year on January 1. The loan had a term of 5 years and 187 days.
The gross actuarial yield was 3.12% on the date of payment. Amortization was as follows:
  -   Normal amortization: the bonds were required to be fully amortized by January 1, 2005 at a price of €65.28
  -   Early amortization: either through repurchasing on the market, over the counter, or through a public offering as from January 1, 2003 under certain conditions.
At any time since June 28, 1999, bondholders may request the conversion and/or exchange of these bonds at a rate, since December 31, 2002, of 1.714 shares per bond. The Company may provide new shares to be issued and/or existing shares at its discretion.
This bond had been fully repaid by January 2005.
On June 21, 2004, the Board of Directors decided to issue a loan materialized by SCOR OCEANE bonds, with the authorization of the Combined General Meeting of Shareholders on May 18, 2004, delegating its chairman with the authority required to carry out such transactions. Issued on July 2, 2004, following the decisions of the CEO on June 23 and 24, 2004, the nominal amount of this loan was set at €200 million, represented by 100 million OCEANE bonds with a nominal value of €2. The bonds carry an interest rate of 4.125% payable on January 1 of each year. The loan has a term of 5 years and 183 days.
The gross actuarial yield is 4.125% on the date of payment. Amortization is as follows:
Normal amortization: the bonds will be fully amortized on January 1, 2010 at the price of €2 per bond.
Early amortization: by purchase on or off the stock market or public offer and under other conditions detailed in the offering circular approved by the AMF under No. 04-627 on June 24, 2004.
At any time since July 2, 2004 and until the seventh day preceding the normal or early redemption date, bondholders may request conversion or exchange of the bonds for shares until the amortization date at the rate of one share for one bond. The Company may provide new shares to be issued and/or existing shares at its discretion.
Page 48 of 184

 


 

SCOR GROUP   CONSOLIDATED FINANCIAL STATEMENTS UNDER IFRS
Subordinated debt and Senior characteristics:
Issue during 1999:
- €50 million in Perpetual Step-Up subordinated notes issued on March 23, 1999. These notes are callable after 15 years, and at 5-yearly intervals thereafter, at SCOR’s discretion. The floating-rate notes will bear interest indexed on the 6-month Euribor plus (i) 0.75% for the first fifteen years of the issue, and (ii) 1.75% thereafter.
- 30-year subordinated bonds for USD 100 million issued on June 7, 1999, callable at SCOR’s discretion each quarter as from the tenth year. These floating-rate bonds will bear interest indexed on the 3-month Libor rate plus (i) 0.80% for the first ten years of the issue, and (ii) 1.80% thereafter.
Issue during 2000:
- the Company issued on July 6, 2000 €100 million in 20-year subordinated bonds, callable at SCOR’s discretion each quarter as from the tenth year following their issuance. These floating-rate bonds bear interest indexed on the 3-month Euribor plus (i) 1.15% for the first ten years, and (ii) 2.15% thereafter.
Issue during 2002:
- SCOR issued €200 million in 5-year unsubordinated notes on June 19, 2002, listed on the Luxembourg Stock Exchange. The notes pay 5.25% fixed-rate interest plus an additional 2.50% payment by decision of the Meeting of note holders on December 20, 2002. This additional payment will be reduced to 1.50% if the rating of these notes is raised to A+ or equivalent by Standard and Poor’s, Fitch or AM Best. It will be reduced to zero if the rating is raised to AA- or equivalent.
Horizon Loan
A debenture loan issued in 2002 whose reimbursement depends on the variations of an index.
Note 13 Contingency reserves
                                 
In millions of EUR   Reserves for     Reserves     Other     Total  
    employee benefits     for taxes     reserves          
    post-retirement                          
At January 1 2004
    44               1       46  
Acquisition of a subsidiary
    18       1       8       27  
Allowances for the fiscal year
                               
Use
    -2                       -2  
Amounts not used taken back
    -3                       -3  
Variation in exchange rate
                               
Adjustment of the discount rate Others
    -10                       -10  
 
At December 31, 2004
    48       1       9       58  
 
Current 2004
    8       1       8       17  
Non current 2004
    40               1       41  
 
 
    48       1       9       58  
 
                               
At January 1, 2005
    48       1       9       58  
Acquisition of a subsidiary
                               
Allowances for the fiscal year
                    13       13  
Use
                               
Amounts not used taken back
                    2       2  
Variation in exchange rate
                               
Adjustment of the discount rate
    -8                       -8  
Others
                               
 
At December 31, 2005
    40       1       20       61  
 
Current 2004
                    13       13  
Non current 2004
    40       1       7       48  
 
 
    40       1       20       61  
The other reserves reflected in 2005 primarily include:
an estimate of the future cost of benefits to employees granted during their professional life (long service medals, etc.) a provision for employment safeguard plans (See highlights).
Page 49 of 184

 


 

SCOR GROUP   CONSOLIDATED FINANCIAL STATEMENTS UNDER IFRS
Note 14 Provision for employee benefits
                                 
   
    Pension commitments  
            including the             including the  
In millions of EUR   2005     United States:     2004     United States:  
 
 
                               
Projected commitments on opening
    -57       -30       -67       -29  
Standard cost
    -2       -1       -5       -1  
Interest on the commitment
    -3       -2       -4       -2  
Benefit paid
    1       1       1       1  
Actuarial gains (losses)
    -2       0       10       -1  
Settlement
    0       0       4       0  
Plan changes
    0       0       0       0  
Exchange rate variation
    -5       -4       2       2  
 
                               
 
Projected commitments at closing
    -67       -36       -57       -30  
 
 
                               
Market value of appropriated assets, at opening
    22       16       17       15  
Actual yield from assets
    1       1       1       1  
Employer contributions
    4       4       4       2  
Benefits paid
    -1       -1       -1       0  
Exchange rate variation
    2       2       -3       -1  
 
                               
 
Market value of appropriated assets, at closing
    27       21       18       16  
 
 
                               
 
Net commitment
    -40       -15       -39       -14  
 
 
                               
Actuarial (gains)/losses not recognized
    0       9       -10       1  
Cost of prior service not recognized
    0       0       0       0  
 
                               
 
Cost of benefits (to be funded)/paid in advance
    -40       -6       -48       -12  
 
Statement of products and losses recognized for period
                 
In millions of EUR   2005     2004  
 
               
Assets available for sale (AFS)
    -85       15  
Hedging
    40       -1  
“Shadow accounting” gross of deferred tax
    40       -1  
Effect of changes in the conversion rates
    97       -62  
Actuarial spreads not recognized in income
            10  
Due or deferred tax taken directly or transferred to capital
    4       -12  
Sher-based payment
    5       6  
Other changes
    -7       6  
 
Net revenue recognized in stockholders’ equity
    54       -38  
 
Consolidated net result for the period
    131       75  
 
Total products and losses recognized for period
    185       37  
 
Attributable to:
               
 
Stockholders in the parent company
    185       38  
 
Minority interests
    -       -  
 
The suppositions used for calculating the reserves for benefits to employees are described in the paragraph “Rules for the use of estimates.”
Page 50 of 184

 


 

SCOR GROUP   CONSOLIDATED FINANCIAL STATEMENTS UNDER IFRS
Note 15 Deferred taxes
Deferred tax revenue and expenses at December 31 included the following items:
                                 
in millions of EUR   Balance Sheet   Income Statement
    12/31/2005     12/31/2004     12/31/2005     12/31/2004  
 
Deferred tax liabilities
                               
Deferred acquisition costs
    -76       -84       9       2  
Unrealized revaluations and temporary differences on investments
    -57       -49       -1       1  
Equalization reserves
    -11       -12       1       2  
Goodwill valuation
    -5       -5       0       0  
Financial instruments
    0       -1       0          
Capitalization reserve
    -44       -42       -2       -2  
Temporary differences and others
    -54       -59       -7       -15  
 
                 
Total deferred tax liabilities
    -247       -253                  
                 
 
                               
Deferred tax receivables
                               
Unrealized revaluations and temporary differences on investments
    33       29       -17       0  
Retirement plan
    9       8       1       -1  
Deferred losses
    600       553       -37       2  
Financial instruments
    1       1       0       0  
Claims reserves
    0       2       -2       0  
Shadow accounting
    6       19       0          
Elimination of internal capital gains
    -2       12       -15       4  
Temporary differences and others
    -2       16       23       13  
 
                               
                 
Total deferred tax receivables
    645       641                  
                 
Depreciation
    -256       -233       29       -8  
                 
Receivable (payable) net of deferred tax
    142       155                  
     
Income (loss) related to deferred taxes
                    -18       -2  
                     
A reconciliation of the corporate income tax, obtained by applying the French tax rate of 34.43% for 2005 and 34.93% for 2004 to pre-tax income (losses), minority interest and gains (losses) associated with using the equity method are presented in the table below.
                 
in millions of EUR   2005     2004  
 
Net income before tax
    185       121  
 
               
Theoretical tax expense
    -64       -42  
 
               
Non-taxable net income
    -21       -12  
 
               
Tax losses – non-activated
    -9       -16  
 
               
Net activation of deferrable tax losses from prior years
    4          
 
               
Reversals of deferred tax writedowns
    38       12  
 
               
Changes in tax rates
    -1       -8  
 
               
Different tax rates
    4       13  
 
               
Non taxable revenue and non deductible expenses
    -6       15  
 
               
Change in consolidation scope
            -8  
 
               
Tax expense accounted for
    -54       -46  

Page 51 of 184


 

     
SCOR GROUP   CONSOLIDATED FINANCIAL STATEMENTS UNDER IFRS
Note 16 Information on affiliated parties
                                                     
                                 
          2005       2004 PERCENTAGE       METHOD OF  
          PERCENTAGE                  
    COUNTRY     Control       Interest       Control       Interest       CONSOLIDATION  
                                 
REINSURANCE-INSURANCE BUSINESS
                                                   
                                 
SCOR
  France       100         100         100         100       PARENT  
SCOR VIE
  France       100         100         100         100       Global  
SCOR Financial Services
  Ireland       100         100         100         100       Global  
SCOR Life US Re Insurance (US) *
  United States       100         100         100         100       Global  
SCOR Life Insurance Company
  United States       100         100         100         100       Global  
Investors Insurance Corporation
  United States       100         100         100         100       Global  
SCOR Italia Riassicurazioni
  Italy       100         100         100         100       Global  
SCOR Deutschland
  Germany       100         100         100         100       Global  
SCOR UK Group
  Great Britain       100         100         100         100       Global  
SCOR UK Company Ltd
  Great Britain       100         100         100         100       Global  
IRP Holdings Limited
  Ireland       100         100         53.35         53.35       Global  
Irish Reinsurance Partners Ltd
  Ireland       100         100         53.35         53.35       Global  
SCOR Asia Pacific
  Singapore       100         100         100         100       Global  
SCOR Re Co. (Asia) Ltd
  Hong Kong       100         100         100         100       Global  
SCOR Canada Reinsurance Company
  Canada       100         100         100         100       Global  
SCOR US Corporation
  United States       100         100         100         100       Global  
California Re Management & Corporation
  United States       100         100         100         100       Global  
SCOR Reinsurance Company
  United States       100         100         100         100       Global  
General Security National Insurance Company
  United States       100         100         100         100       Global  
General Security Indemnity Company of Arizona
  United States       100         100         100         100       Global  
American Underwriting Managers Inc.
  United States       100         100         100         100       Global  
Sorema NA Holding Corporation
  United States       100         100         100         100       Global  
Commercial Risk Partners Ltd
  Bermuda       100         100         100         100       Global  
Commercial Risk Reinsurance Company
  Bermuda       100         100         100         100       Global  
Commercial Risk Re-insurance Company
  United States       100         100         100         100       Global  
Commercial Risk Services
  United States       100         100         100         100       Global  
                                 
REAL ESTATE BUSINESS
                                                   
                                 
Immobilière Sébastopol SNC
  France       100         100         100         100       Global  
IMMOSCOR SCI
  France       100         100         100         100       Global  
FERGASCOR
  France       100         100         100         100       Global  
EUROFINIMO
  France       100         100         100         100       Global  
FINIMOFRANCE
  France       100         100         100         100       Global  
SCOR AUBER
  France       100         100         100         100       Global  
Société Putéolienne de Participations
  France       100         100         100         100       Global  
FINIMO REALTY Pte Ltd
  Singapore       100         100         100         100       Global  
                                 
FINANCIAL ACTIVITY
                                                   
                                 
HORIZON
  Great Britain       100         100         100         100       Global  
EUROSCOR-ACTISCOR
  Luxembourg       100         100         100         100       Global  
EUROSCOR-GESCOR
  Luxembourg       100         100         100         100       Global  
EUROPE MID CAP
  Luxembourg       100         100         100         100       Global  
PICKING
  Luxembourg       100         100         100         100       Global  
AVANCE
  Germany       100         100         100         100       Global  
                                 
SCOR had made a commitment to the shareholders of IRP Holdings Limited to purchase their minority interests. This commitment was recognized as “Financial Debt” for the discounted value of the exercise price for the firm purchase commitment. The subsequent change in the value of the commitment was recorded as “Financing expense” in the IFRS 2004 income statement.
The accumulated remuneration paid in 2005 to Group Directors amounted to 4,019,558. The total amount paid or set aside by the Group for the departure of members of the Executive Committee in 2005 was 3,992,964.
The reference document contains a detailed description of remuneration and benefits for Group directors.

Page 52 of 184


 

     
SCOR GROUP   CONSOLIDATED FINANCIAL STATEMENTS UNDER IFRS
Note 17 Commitments received and given
                 
In millions of EUR:   2005     2004  
 
 
Commitments received
    1,201       971  
 
               
Unused credit lines
    199       44  
Endorsements and sureties
    12       47  
Letters of credit
    990       867  
Other commitments received
            13  
 
               
Commitments given
    2,912       2,687  
 
               
Endorsements and sureties
    25       47  
Letters of credit
    645       656  
Pledged securities
    2,080       1,885  
Other commitments given
    162       99  
 
               
Securities received as collateral from reinsurers and retrocessionnaires
    27       29  
 
The regulatory environment governing the reinsurance industry requires disclosure of underwriting commitments represented by pledged assets, cash deposits or letters of credit.
In reinsurance, commitments are stated as liabilities within underwriting reserves while the corresponding assets are disclosed as assets to guarantee claims. When underwriting reserves are not covered by cash deposits with ceding companies, they may be covered by pledged securities or in the form of letters of credit granted to our ceding companies and disclosed within off balance sheet commitments.
Commitments received include available unused credit lines granted by various banks totaling 199 million. In 2005, the Group also had letters of credit received from banks amounting to 990 million.
Letters of credit granted for 645 million consist of commitments made to reinsurers/ceding companies in return for the underwriting liabilities arising from the business ceded.
Certain assets have been pledged to financial institutions as security for the letters of credit received by the Group. These assets are principally OAT French government securities, mortgaged properties and investment securities for an amount of 2,080 million.
The Group entered into finance leases for two investment properties with the option to buy. The amount of the minimum payments and their discounted values are as follows:
                                 
In millions of EUR:   Minimum     Including     Minimum     Including  
    payments     amortization     payments     amortization  
            of capital             of capital  
Less than a year
    10       5       10       4  
From one to five years
    40       21       40       20  
More than five years
    7       5       17       10  
 
Total minimum payments
    57       30       67       38  
Less payments representing loan charges
    27               32          
 
Discounted value of minimum payments
    30       30       34       34  
 
In addition, various entities in the Group rent their office headquarters. The largest lease contract is by Scor Paris for its headquarters located at La Défense with a residual life of 7 years. The minimum payments are as follows:
                 
In millions of EUR:   2005     2004  
    Minimum payments     Minimum payments  
Less than a year
    12       11  
From one to five years
    45       45  
More than five years
    22       33  
 
Total minimum payments
    79       90  
 

Page 53 of 184


 

     
SCOR GROUP   CONSOLIDATED FINANCIAL STATEMENTS UNDER IFRS
In its property business, SCOR leases or subleases its investment buildings and warehouses. The leases generally conform with local market conditions and have annual indexation clauses.
The projected minimum rents are as follows:
                 
In millions of EUR:   2005     2004  
    Minimum payments     Minimum payments  
Less than one year
    27       29  
From one to five years
    81       81  
More than five years
    29       56  
 
Total minimum payments
    137       166  
 
ANALYSIS OF MAIN BALANCE SHEET ITEMS
Note 18 Written premiums
                           
       
In millions of EUR   2005   2004     Change
       
Non-life gross premiums written
    1,383       1,396         -1 %
Life gross premiums written
    1,024       1,165         -12 %
       
Premiums written
    2,407       2,561         -6 %
       
Note 19 Investment income
                 
 
in millions of EUR            
    2005     2004  
 
Dividends
    8       6  
Interest
    223       243  
 
               
Building rental income
    29       28  
Interest on cash deposits
    10       16  
Income from cash and cash equivalents
    52       47  
Currency gains
    8       -13  
 
               
Change in Fair Value of Fair Value by Income
    39       -1  
 
               
Realized capital gains and losses
    90       35  
 
               
Depreciation allowance
    1       -15  
 
TOTAL
    460       346  
 
Net revenue from leasing investment properties includes the following items:
                 
in millions of EUR   2005     2004  
 
Building rental income
    29       28  
Leased buildings’ expenses
    -4       -4  
 
           
Net rental income
    25       24  
 
           

Page 54 of 184


 

     
SCOR GROUP   CONSOLIDATED FINANCIAL STATEMENTS UNDER IFRS
Note 20 Expenses relating to contract benefits
Expenses relating to contract benefits consist primarily of the following:
         
 
  -   claims paid by our ceding companies,
 
 
  -   changes in the claims and mathematical reserves,
 
 
  -   incurred claims settlement expenses.
Note 21 Net income (losses) from reinsurance operations

                                                                       
in millions of EUR
    2005                 2004  
      LIFE       Non Life       Total                 LIFE       Non Life       Total  
                                           
Retroceded written premiums
      -32         -102         -134                   -37         -83         -120  
Changes in unearned retrocession premiums
                          -16                   -16         -66         -66  
 
                                                                     
Retroceded earned premiums
      -32         -118         -150                   -37         -149         -186  
 
                                                                     
Retroceded claims ratio
      20         96         116                   9         60         69  
 
                                                                     
Retroceded commissions
      6         6         12                   4         9         13  
                                           
 
                                                                     
Net income from reinsurance operations
      -6         -16         -22                   -24         -80         -104  
Note 22 Financing expenses
                 
 
in millions of EUR   2005     2004  
 
Interest and financial expenses
    22       41  
Expenses related to long-term borrowings
    35       37  
 
TOTAL
    57       78  
 
Note 23 Taxes
The main components of deferred taxes for 2005 and 2004 are presented below:
                 
in millions of EUR
  2005     2004  
 
In the consolidated income statement
               
Current tax
    -35       -44  
Current tax expense for the fiscal year
    -35       -44  
Tax expense adjustment relating to prior fiscal years
            0  
Deferred tax
    -19       -2  
 
Total income tax by income
    -54       -46  
 
 
               
In consolidated reserves
               
Deferred tax relating to items debited or credited directly by reserves
               
Revaluation of AFS
    10       -8  
Others
    -14       -8  
 
Total income tax by reserves
    -4       -16  
 
The amount of tax withdrawn in 2005 by Group companies is 25 millions.

Page 55 of 184


 

     
SCOR GROUP
  CONSOLIDATED FINANCIAL STATEMENTS UNDER IFRS
Note 24 Expenses by type
                 
 
 
In millions of EUR   2005     2004  
 
 
Personnel expenses
    102       96  
Taxes and duties
    12       16  
Outsourced services
    86       84  
 
Total general and administrative expenses
    200       196  
 
Note 25 Cost of Employee benefits
                                 
   
In millions of EUR   Retirement commitments  
 
Charge for period   2005     Including the     2004   Including the United  
          United States           States  
 
Normal cost
    -2       -1       -5       -1  
Interest on the commitment
    -3       -2       -4       -2  
Expected yield from assets
    2       1       1       1  
Amortization of gains/losses, not recognized
    1       0       0       0  
Amortization of cost of above service, not recognized
    0       0       0       0  
Settlement
    0       0       4          
 
Cost for the period
    -3       -2       -3       -2  
 
The Group grants its employees options or share subscription plans under the following terms:
                     
    Date   Options availability   Plan   Price
PLAN   of grants   dates   expiration   for the fiscal
    by the board       dates   year
 
1995
  May 15   May 15, 1996 (30%)   May 14, -05     6.59  
 
 
      May 15, 1997 (30%)            
 
 
      May 15, 1998 (40%)            
 
1996
  Sep 5   Sept. 5, 1997 (30%)   Sept. 4, 2006     11.70  
 
 
      Sept. 5, 1998 (30%)            
 
 
      Sept. 5, 1999 (40%)            
 
1997
  Sep 4   Sept. 4, 2002   Sept. 3, 2007     15.03  
 
1998
  Sep 4   Sept. 4, 2003   Sept. 3, 2008     22.72  
 
1999
  Sep 4   Sept. 3, 2004   Sept. 2, 2009     18.58  
 
2000
  May 4   May 5, 2004   May 3, 2010     19.39  
 
2000
  Aug 31   Sept. 1, 2005   Aug. 30, 2010     18.17  
 
2001
  Sep 4   Sept. 4, 2005   Sept. 3, 2011     19.39  
 
2001
  Oct 4   Oct. 4, 2005   Oct. 2, 2011     13.73  
 
2003
  Feb 28   Feb. 28, 2007   Feb. 27, 2013     2.86  
 
2003 (1)
  Jun 3   June 3, 2007   June 2, 2013     3.94  
 
2004
  Aug 25   Aug. 26, 2008   Aug. 25, 2014     1.14  
 
2005
  Sep 16   Sept. 16, 2009   Sept. 16, 2015     1.66  
 
(1)   with performance condition
Changes are acquired after 4 or 5 years from the grant date if the employee is still actively employed.

Page 56 of 184


 

     
SCOR GROUP
  CONSOLIDATED FINANCIAL STATEMENTS UNDER IFRS
The table below presents the changes and the current stock option plans at the end of the year along with the average corresponding exercise price.
                                 
    2005   2004
    Average exercise           Average exercise    
    price   Number   price   Number
    in EUR per share   of options   in EUR per share   of options
 
Life options at January 1
    7.69       17,055,698       10.95       12,342,962  
Options granted during the period
    1.66       7,260,000       1.14       5,990,000  
Options exercized during the period
    -       -       -       -  
Options expired during the period
    6.59       (192,782 )     7.02       (113,809 )
Options cancelled during the period
    5.42       (3,410,816 )     8.63       (1,163,455 )
 
                               
     
Life options at December 31
    5.91       20,712,100       7.69       17,055,698  
     
The average remaining life of the options and the average exercise price for 2005 are presented below.
                         
    Life options
            Life term   Exercise price
    Number of   average   weighted
    options   residual   average
Exercise price range   in life   weighted   in euros
(EUR)                   (EUR)
from 1 to 5
    15,344,490       8.91       1.81  
from 6 to 10
    -       -       -  
from 11 to 15
    1,852,878       2.17       13.57  
from 16 to 20
    2,654,236       4.72       18.83  
from 21 to 25
    860,496       2.68       22.72  
from 1 to 25
    20,712,100       7.51       5.91  
The fair value of the options and the share subscription prices are estimated by using the binomial method which takes into account the terms and conditions under which the options were granted. The following table lists the characteristics used at the end of 2005 and 2004:
                 
    2005     2004  
Market price of the SCOR equity share
    1.68       1.14  
Exercise price of the option
    1.66       1.14  
Exercise of options
  4 years   4 years
Historical volatility
    29.70 %     39.62 %
Dividend (1)
    0.0695       0.0364  
Risk-free interest rate
    3.243 %     4.20 %
(1)   The dividend rate indicated above is an average of the dividend series estimated during the life of the option.
The cost of services received in 2005 is reported at 5 million (6 million in 2004) with respect to the stock option plan and the granting of bonus shares.

Page 57 of 184


 

     
SCOR GROUP
  CONSOLIDATED FINANCIAL STATEMENTS UNDER IFRS
The Group also awards bonus shares to its employees under the following terms:
                         
            Number of shares   Price estimate
            allocated at the   on the allocation
Allocation date   Acquisition date   origin   date
September 22, 2004   January 10, 2005   1,962,555   €1.20
December 7, 2004   January 10, 2005   2,434,453   €1.41
December 7, 2004   November 10, 2005   2,418,404   €1.41
November 7, 2005   August 15, 2007   8,471,998   €1.584
The 2005 finance law instituted a new incentive tax and social regime for bonus share allotments, the purpose of which is to encourage employee savings. Thus, French beneficiaries had the possibility of waiving the transfer of November 10, 2005 in consideration for a 2005 reallotment plan approved by the Board of Directors on August 31, 2005 for this purpose.
As a result, 33 beneficiaries waived the transfer of their shares in November 2005, representing 833,570 shares. In consideration, they benefited from a reallotment, increased by 40%, representing a total of 1,166,998 shares.
On August 31, 2005, the SCOR Board of Directors, pursuant to the delegation granted by the General Shareholders’ Meeting of May 31, 2005 and on the recommendation of the Compensation and Nominating Committee, set up a new stock bonus allotment plan intended for corporate officers and certain executives of Group companies, to allot 7,305,000 shares.
A total of 8,471,998 shares will be transferred in September 2007, subject to the conditions on employment of the beneficiaries within the Group and must be held until September 2009.
Note 26 Earnings per share
Net earnings per share is calculated by dividing the net income for the year attributable to shareholders of the parent company by the average weighted number of shares at the end of the year.
The diluted income per share is calculated by dividing the net income attributable to shareholders of the parent company (after deduction of interest from convertible OCEANE bonds) by the number of average weighted shares at the end of the year plus the average weighted number of shares that would have been issued by converting all the share plans at the end of the year (OCEANE and stock option plans).
                                                 
    At December 31, 2005     At December 31, 2004  
in millions of EUR   Net income           Net     Net income              
    (numerator)     Share(1)     income     (numerator)     Shares (1)     Net income  
    in EUR     (denominator)     per share     in EUR     (denominator)     per share  
    millions     (thousands)     (EUR)     million     (thousands)     (EUR)  
     
Net income (loss)
    131                       75                  
     
 
                                               
     
Earnings per share
                                               
Net income distributable to ordinary shareholders
    131       887,626       0.15       75       803,051       0.09  
     
 
                                               
     
Diluted earnings per share
                                               
     
Dilutive effects
                                               
Stock options and equity-based compensation
            10,157                       1,174          
Convertible bonds
    8       100,000       -0.01       6       53,642       0.00  
     
Net income distributable to ordinary shareholders and estimated conversions
    139       997,783       0.14       81       857,866       0.09  
     
(1)   Average number of share for the fiscal year
There are no other transactions that involve common stock or rights to shares between the closing date of the accounts and the publication of the financial statements.
The earnings per share and the diluted earnings per share are as follows:
Dividends payable to shareholders of the company rose to 24 million in 2005 (none in 2004), or 0.03 per share.
At the General Meeting of Shareholders it was proposed that dividends for 2005 be paid in 2006 in the amount of 48 million or 0.05 per share.

Page 58 of 184


 

     
SCOR GROUP
  CONSOLIDATED FINANCIAL STATEMENTS UNDER IFRS
Analysis Of The Main Items On The Statement Of Cash Flow
Cash flows reflect the Group’s continuing restructuring and repositioning activities.
In 2005, operating cash flow reached -594 million due to the payment of commutations during the 1st half of 265 million for life insurance and 339 million for non-life insurance.
Financing cash flow totaled -247 million consisting of the following amounts:
  -   Redemption for OCEANE bonds 1999-2005 of 225 million,
  -   Payment of IRP Holdings Limited minority interests of 183 million,
  -   The increase in share capital on June 30, 2005 for an amount of 226 million.
Note 27 Rules for Using Estimates
The assumptions used for calculating reserves for employee benefits are as follows:
                                 
Assumptions used   2005             2004        
    excluding the United             excluding the        
    States:     United States     United States:     United States  
Discount rate
  from 3.63% to 3.75 %     5.50 %     4.99 %     6.00 %
Expected yield from assets
    3.80 %     8.00 %     8.04 %     9.00 %
Increase in salaries
    1.75 %     3.50 %     3.00 %     4.00 %
Note 28 Certain Risk Factors Affecting the Company
Maturity and interest rates for financial assets and liabilities
                                                                           
  In millions of EUR     Interest     Fixed rate     Variable       Total    
        rate       Less than       Between       Greater than       Total        rate            
                1 year       1 and 5 years       5 years                            
                                               
 
Assets AFS
      4.76         463         2,370         1,778         4,611         622         5,233    
                                               
 
Assets at Fair Value by Income
      4.58         17         42         42         101         65         166    
                                               
 
Financial assets exposed to fair value risk (A)
      4.77         480         2,412         1,820         4,712                   5,399    
                                               
 
Financial assets exposed to cash flow risk (B)
      4.5                                                 687              
                                               
 
Financial assets exposed to rate risk (A) + (B)
      4.76         480         2,412         1,820         4,712         687         5,399    
                                               
                                                                           
  In millions of EUR     Interest     Fixed rate     Variable       Total    
        rate       Less than       Between       Greater than       Total        rate            
                1 year       1 and 5 years       5 years                            
                                               
 
-Subordinated debt
      3.5                                                 -233         -233    
                                               
 
-Financial liabilities represented by securities
      5.72                   -402                   -402         -118         -520    
                                               
 
-Financial liabilities to companies in the banking sector
                                                        -201         -201    
                                               
 
Financial liabilities exposed to fair value risk (A)
      5.94                   -402                   -402                   -402    
                                               
 
Financial liabilities exposed to cash flow risk (B)
      3.28                                                 -552         -552    
                                               
 
 
                                                                       
                                               
 
Financial liabilities exposed to rate risk (A) + (B)
      4.83                   -402                   -402         -552         -954    
                                               

Page 59 of 184


 

     
SCOR GROUP
  CONSOLIDATED FINANCIAL STATEMENTS UNDER IFRS
The timetable for financial variable-rate debts is set out in the following table:
                                             
       
         
  In millions of EUR   Variable rates  
        Less than 1       Between 1       More than 1            
        year       to 5 years       year       Total    
                             
 
Subordinated debts
                          -233         -233    
 
Financial liabilities represented by stocks
      -53         -65                   -118    
 
Financial liabilities towards banking sector firms
      -18         -110         -73         -201    
                             
 
TOTAL
      -71         -175         -306         -522    
                             
A variation of 1 basis point in the “less than one year” interest rate will impact on the charge for borrowing for less than one year by about 5 million.
Portfolio Rating – Exposure to Credit Risk
The following table presents the Group’s bond portfolio by counterparty credit quality as of December 31, 2005:
                                                         
     
In millions of EUR   AAA     AA     A     BBB     < BBB     Not rated     Total  
 
 
                                                       
AFS bonds
    3,726       544       596       302       20       46       5,233  
 
                                                       
 
 
                                                       
Bonds at Fair Value by Income
    99       29       25       8       2       3       166  
 
                                                       
 
Total
    3,824       573       621       310       22       49       5,399  
 
Exposure to Currency Fluctuations – Exchange Rate Risk
The following table presents the consolidated net position of assets and liabilities broken down by currency:
                         
 
in millions of EUR   Assets     Liabilities     Net position  
 
Euro
    7,171       6,486       685  
Swiss franc
    59       57       3  
Pound sterling
    469       446       24  
Japanese yen
    68       70       -2  
US Dollar
    4,626       3,822       804  
Canadian dollar
    673       362       311  
Australian dollar
    53       43       10  
Singapore Dollar
    29       27       2  
Hong-Kong Dollar
    18       43       -25  
Other currencies
    521       615       -94  
 
 
Total Balance sheet
    13,688       11,969       1,719  
 
Sensitivity to exchange and interest rates
Analysis of the sensitivity to exchange rates reflects an instant 10% variance in the exchange rate of currencies other than those fixed against the Euro in relation to their respective rates at December 31, 2004 and 2005, with all other variables remaining constant. At the end of 2005, the Euro’s appreciation (depreciation) against other currencies would have resulted in a decline (increase) before tax of 426 million in the fair value of financial investments (423 million at December 31, 2004).
Analysis of the sensitivity of interest rates reflects changes in market interest rates against a scenario whereby rates would increase or decrease by 100 basis points over their level at December 31, 2004 and 2005 with all other variables being

Page 60 of 184


 

     
SCOR GROUP
  CONSOLIDATED FINANCIAL STATEMENTS UNDER IFRS
constant. At the end of 2005, the increase (or decrease) of 100 basis points in market interest rates would generate a decline (increase) of 204 million in the fair market value of financial instruments before tax (220 million at December 31, 2004).
                                                 
  2005   2004
            Exchange     Interest rate             Exchange     Interest rate  
            rate risk     risk             rate risk     risk  
In millions of EUR   Net     10% variation     100 basis     Net book   10%     100 basis  
    book     in exchange     points     value   variation in     points  
    value     rates     variation in           exchange     variation in  
                interest rates           rates     interest rates  
    (EUR, millions)     (EUR, millions)  
Increase
                                               
 
                                               
AFS bonds
    5,233       -392       -201       5,290       -397       -209  
 
                                               
AFS
    730       -20               251       -7          
 
                                               
Bonds, Fair Value by Income
    166       -1       -3       585       -4       -12  
Equities, Fair Value by Income
    229       -12               196       -10          
Derivative instruments
    35                       29                  
 
                                               
Total
                                               
 
                                               
Decrease
                                               
 
                                               
AFS bonds
    5,233       392       201       5,290       397       209  
 
                                               
AFS
    730       20               251       7          
 
                                               
Bonds, Fair Value by Income
    166       1       3       585       4       12  
Equities, Fair Value by Income
    229       12               196       10          
Derivative instruments
    35                       29                  
 
                                               
Total
                                               
Risk sensitivity of shares
For all the stocks held, directly or indirectly, through an mutual fund, an analysis of the sensitivity of the Group results to a drop of 10% in the FTSEurofirst 300 reference index, indicates -23 million for the results and -73 for shareholders’ equity, as shown in the following table:
                         
 
  In millions of EUR     Position of third party shares or       Impact of a drop of 10% in the    
        Equity UCITS       market value of the share    
 
Position on asset side
      959         -96    
 
of which AFS
      730         -73    
 
of which JVR
      229         -23    
 

Page 61 of 184


 

     
SCOR GROUP
  CONSOLIDATED FINANCIAL STATEMENTS UNDER IFRS
Liquidation triangle for technical reserves
The liquidation triangle for “Property & Casualty” underwriting reserves, over five years is presented as follows:
Five-year loss development net of retrocession (1)
                                         
     
    2001     2002     2003     2004     2005  
     
Initial gross claims reserves (1)
    8,402       8,244       7,044       6,137       5,970  
Retroceded initial claims reserves
    1,462       1,313       691       536       554  
     
Net initial claims reserves (1)
    6,940       6,930       9,353       5,600       5,416  
 
                                       
Payments made (cumulative)
                                       
1 year after
    2,514       2,627       1,425       896          
2 years after
    4,496       3,735       2,119                  
3 years after
    5,425       4,557                          
4 year after
    6,309                                  
 
                                       
Revised claim reserves
                                       
1 year after
    8,161       8,191       6,772       5,934          
2 years after
    8,831       8,128       6,779                  
3 years after
    8,925       8,435                          
4 year after
    9,135                                  
 
                                       
Cumulative surplus/deficit before change in premiums
    (2,195 )     (1,505 )     (426 )     (334 )        
Percentage before change in premiums
    (32 )%     (22 )%     (7 )%     (6 )%        
Change in premiums
    1,238       701       358       337          
Cumulative surplus/deficit after change in premiums
    (957 )     (804 )     (68 )     3          
Percentage after change in premiums
    (13.79 )%     (11.60 )%     (1.07 )%     (0.05 )%        
 
                                       
Gross revised claims reserves at December 31, 2005
    11,306       10153       7,553       6,622          
Revised retrocession at December 31, 2005
    2,172       1,695       774       688          
             
Net revised reserves at December 31, 2005
    9,135       8,435       6,779       5,934          
Cumulative gross surplus deficits before change in premiums
    (2,904 )     (1,887 )     (509 )     (485 )        
Change in gross earned premiums
    1,168       770       522       401          
Cumulative gross surplus deficits after change in premiums
    (1,737 )     (1,117 )     13       (84 )        
Percentages
    (20.67 )%     (13.55 )%     0.18 %     (1.37 )%        
(1)   Claims reserve under French GAAP restated in IFRS
- Gross underwriting reserves for 2005 differ by 409 million from the amount indicated in the table in Note 12 under “Claims reserve.” This amount corresponds to the reserves for increasing risks which until 2004 were posted under unearned premiums reserve.
- The reserves for 2001 and 2002 are presented on an IFRS pro-forma basis by deducting reserves under French GAAP from the equalization reserve.
Geographic concentration of insurance risks
     
Exposure to catastrophic loss (1)   Countries concerned – December 2005
(in millions of EUR)    
100 to 200
  Canada, United States, Mexico, Israel, Italy, Turkey
200 to 300
  Chile, Portugal, Taiwan
300 and over
  Japan, Europe
(1)   Calculated at the maximum potential loss for a given commitment period before retrocession.

Page 62 of 184


 

     
SCOR GROUP
  CONSOLIDATED FINANCIAL STATEMENTS UNDER IFRS
The breakdown of gross written premiums according to the location of the ceding company is as follows:
                                       
           
  In millions of EUR   LIFE     Non Life  
      2005   2004     2005   2004  
           
 
 
    1,024       1,165         1,383       1,395    
 
Europe
    564       546         772       801    
 
North America
    379       542         215       220    
 
Asia-Pacific and Rest of World
    81       77         396       375    
           
Concentration by sector and maximum insurance losses
                                 
    Year ending December 31
    Asbestos (1)   Environment (1)
    2005   2004   2005   2004
     
Gross reserves, including IBNR reserves
    111       98       39       54  
% of gross Non-Life reserves
    1.7 %     1.6 %     0.6 %     0.9 %
Claims paid
    12       15       7       5  
% net of Group Non-Life claims
    0.7 %     0.8 %     0.4 %     0.3 %
                 
    Year ending December 31, 2005
    Asbestos   Environment
 
Number of claims notified under non- proportional and facultative treaties
    7,961       7,219  
Average cost per claim (1)
  14,689.00     4,338.00  
EXCEPTIONAL EVENTS AND LITIGATION
The Group is a party to one lawsuit concerning old claims related to the environment. However, the Group believes it is sufficiently funded on the basis of the information it has on this date.
In addition, we are involved in the following litigation:
In the United States:
  -  
In December 2002, a petition was filed by Dock Resins Corporation and Landec Corporation before a U.S. Federal District Court in New Jersey against SCOR’s subsidiary SOREMA North America Reinsurance Company (now General Security National Insurance Company or GSNIC), for an alleged denial of coverage by GSNIC concerning business interruption suffered by the plaintiffs. GSNIC filed a cross claim for fraud and misrepresentation seeking to void the policy and preserve GSNIC’s right to recover the costs incurred in litigating the case. The plaintiffs claim an unspecified amount of damages in excess of policy limits, which are capped under the insurance policy at an aggregate total of USD 15 million. The policy has been retroceded at 80% outside of the SCOR Group. GSNIC has paid the undisputed portions of the claim. On January 27, 2006, motions to obtain a partial provisional order and the cross claims filed by the different parties were upheld, and the rulings issued by the U.S. Federal District Court were in favor of the defendants. The Court granted the GSNIC motion seeking a partial provisional order and dismissed all arguments against the motion, which were based on an alleged bad-faith refusal of coverage and the allegation that GSNIC had conspired with its consultants to reject the insurance claim without grounds. In addition, the requests for compensatory and punitive damages and the motion for payment of attorneys’ fees were also dismissed. The plaintiff’s cross claim seeking a partial order dealing with the affirmative defense of GSNIC against the insurance fraud claim was also dismissed. As a result of those decisions, the plaintiffs now can only bring action against GSNIC on a contractual basis, based on the insurance policy. It is highly probable that the discovery procedure will be completed by spring 2006. The judgment date has been provisionally set at June 2006.
 
  -  
Certain Highfields Funds—Highfields Capital LTD, Highfields Capital I LP and Highfields Capital II LP (the “Highfields Funds”), as minority shareholders of IRP Holdings Limited, in March 2004 have filed a complaint against SCOR in the District Court of the State of Massachusetts. The complaint alleges raud and violations of Massachusetts law with regard to the acquisition by the Highfields Funds of a stake in IRP Holdings Limited in December 2001. The damages (including punitive damages) owed, if any, cannot be calculated as of this date and will be determined by the Court at the end of the trial which is scheduled to begin in May 2007. On September 28, 2005, the District Court of the State of

Page 63 of 184


 

     
SCOR GROUP
  CONSOLIDATED FINANCIAL STATEMENTS UNDER IFRS
     
Massachusetts rejected SCOR’s motion to dismiss and issued an order scheduling the timing of discovery and the trial. The discovery procedure has commenced and is scheduled to proceed until March 2007 based on the calendar set by the Court. The trial is scheduled to start in May 2007.
 
  -  
Beginning in October 2001, various lawsuits were brought and cross claims filed to determine whether the terrorist attack on the World Trade Center (WTC) on September 11, 2001 constituted one or two occurences under the terms of the applicable coverage issued to the lessees of the WTC and others parties. Although SCOR, as a reinsurer, is not a party to such lawsuits, the ceding company Allianz Global Risks U.S. Insurance Company (Allianz), which insured a portion of the WTC, and which is reinsured by SCOR, is a party to the legal action.
 
     
The first two phases of the trial were completed in 2004. At the end of the first phase, the court ruled that nine of the twelve insurers involved were bound by the definition of the term “occurence” that as a matter of law has been found to mean that the attack on the WTC constituted one occurence. Allianz did not participate in that first phase, but has participated in the second phase of the trialon December 6, 2004. The New York jury named in the second phase of the litigation determined that the attack on the WTC towers on September 11, 2001 constituted two occurences under the terms of the property insurance coverages issued by Allianz and by eight other insurers of the WTC towers. SCOR, a reinsurer of Allianz, considers the jury verdict to be contrary to the terms of the insurance coverage in force and to the intent of the parties. SCOR fully supported Allianz, in its efforts to overturn the verdict. The jury verdict has been appealed to the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Second Circuit and a decision is expected in 2006.
 
     
The verdict in the second phase of the litigation did not determine the amount of damages owed by the insurers. A separate, court-supervised appraisal procedure is in progress to determine the amount owed by the insurers for the damages resulting from the destruction of the WTC towers. The final decision from the appraisal procedure is expected at the end of 2006 or early in 2007.
 
     
In the Group’s original calculations of its technical reserves, the WTC attack was treated as one occurrence for purposes of the underlying insurance coverage since the terrorist attack on September 11, 2001 was a single, coordinated occurence. As a result of the jury verdict described above in the second phase of the trial, the Group has increased the reserves based on the initial replacement value established by the ceding company. The gross amount of reserves has accordingly been increased from USD 355 million as of December 31, 2003 to USD 422 million as of December 31, 2004, and net of retrocession from USD 167.5 million to USD 193.5 million. These amounts did not change significantly in 2005. In addition, the Company issued two letters of credit for a total amount of USD 145,320,000 to Allianz on December 27, 2004, as required by Allianz to guarantee payment to the ceding company if the jury verdict is not reversed by the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Second Circuit or if the appraisal process placed under court supervision in 2005 results in an increase in the amounts to be paid in the future.
 
     
Allianz has instituted an arbitration proceeding against the Company in order to clarify the extent of the Company’s obligations under the reinsurance treaty entered into with it. The arbitration proceedings has been stayed by the court responsible for evaluating the damages pending certain events related to the second phase of the lawsuit. The arbitration proceeding has not been reactivated.
 
  -  
The Group is also involved in various arbitration proceedings relating to the underwriting business, now in run off, primarily relating to the Bond risk. See Section 6.5 – Notes to the parent company financial statements– Note 16.
 
  -  
In January 2005, Continental Casualty Company (CCC), a CAN’s subsidiary, initiated an arbitration proceeding to obtain a declaration that six contracts signed with Commercial Risk Re-Insurance Company (CRRC) should contain the so called “insolvency” clause. CRRC issued a counter demand for arbitration proceeding to obtain from CCC access to all relevant books and records.
 
     
On November 2, 2005, the panel rendered its award stating that the six contracts were supposed to contain this insolvency clause. Following this ruling, CRRC filed motions to vacate the panel’s final award in the US Federal District Courts for Connecticut and the Northern District of Illinois seeking voidance of the arbitration tribunal’s ruling.
 
      In its counter demand, CRRC is requesting, pursuant to the provisions of the contracts in question, an order giving it full access to all relevant books and records at CCC and its agent. The organization meeting on this second arbitration was held in October 2005 and the parties are presently submitting their respective schedule to the panel.
 
  -  
In August 2005, certain American subsidiaries of Royal & Sun Alliance (RSA) initiated four arbitration proceedings against Commercial Risk Re-Insurance Company Limited and Commercial Risk Reinsurance Company (Commercial Risk) relating to seven reinsurance treaties signed by RSA and Commercial Risk. RSA is alleging breach of the contracts and is seeking full payment of balances due under these contracts, plus interest and expenses, for a total of about USD 23 million. Commercial Risk has denied these balances due asserting that the losses are outside the scope of application and the terms of the treaties.
 
     
No significant activity has occurred in any of the arbitration. One panel was constituted and the organisational meeting was held on February 22, 2006. The parties are currently selecting panels for the remaining arbitrations.
 
  -  
At the end of February 2006, Security Insurance Company of Hartford, Orion Insurance Company and other subsidiaries of Royal Insurance Company (Security of Hartford) instituted a litigation against SCOR Reinsurance Company (SCOR Re) in the Supreme Court of the State of New York alleging breach of contract and seeking recovery of claimed loss balances of approximately USD 48.9 million allegedly due as losses under two quota share treaties between the parties (the “Treaties”).
 
     
SCOR Re is seeking to dismiss or stay the Supreme Court litigation and is demanding that the issues raised in the litigation be submitted to arbitration pursuant to the arbitration clauses contained in the Treaties. At the appropriate

Page 64 of 184


 

     
SCOR GROUP
  CONSOLIDATED FINANCIAL STATEMENTS UNDER IFRS
     
time in either the litigation or arbitration, SCOR Re will assert its own defenses and claims or counterclaims concerning the substantive issues raised in the litigation.
 
     
In February 2006, SCOR received an arbitration notice from the “captive” of a pharmaceutical laboratory concerning the settlement of a claim under civil liability for a laboratory product. SCOR denied owing this amount and claims that the captive is not required to indemnify the pharmaceutical laboratory. The maximum potential commitment of SCOR is USD 17.5 million.
In Europe:
  -  
SCOR VIE, as the reinsurer of an insurance company, is a party to a proceeding relating to a life insurance policy for approximately 4.5 million. The beneficiary of the policy was a person killed in 1992. In June 2001, a Spanish court ordered the ceding company to pay approximately 16 million under the insurance policy, including accumulated interest since 1992, plus damages. Following this decision, SCOR VIE recognized a technical reserve for 17.7 million for fiscal year 2001. Since a contrary decision was rendered in favor of the ceding company in May 2002 by the Court of Appeals of Barcelona, the dispute has been filed in the Spanish Supreme Court by the victim’s heirs. The provision was maintained at end of December 2005.
 
  -  
The French Autorité des Marchés Financiers (AMF), initiated an investigation on October 21, 2004 in connection with the financial information and trading activity surrounding the issue of the SCOR OCEANE bonds in July 2004. The Company has received no additional information about this investigation to date.
 
  -  
The AMF also initiated an investigation on October 5, 2005 concerning the market for the SCOR share as of June 1, 2005.
 
  -  
Since February 2005, the SCOR company has been the subject of an accounting audit for the period from January 1, 2002 to December 31, 2003. On December 21, 2005, this audit resulted in an initial adjustment proposal, excluding late penalties, for an additional assessment for the corporate income tax base for 2002 of 26,870,073.77, an assessment for the withholding stipulated by Article 119 bis 2 of the General Tax Code of 5,788,871 and an additional assessment for the employer’s payroll tax of 27,891. The Company has challenged this adjustment proposal. This proposal, which interrupts the statute of limitations, will be followed in 2006 with a definitive proposal also covering fiscal 2003.
 
  -  
The ACAM launched an audit of the SCOR VIE company in January 2006.
The Company is involved in legal and arbitration proceedings from time to time in the ordinary course of its business. However, other than the proceedings mentioned above, to our knowledge, there are no other litigation matters that are likely to have a material impact on the Group’s financial position, activities or results of operations.
AGREEMENTS
RELATED PARTY-AGREEMENTS SIGNED IN 2005 AS DEFINED BY ARTICLES L. 225-38 ET SEQ. OF THE FRENCH COMMERCIAL CODE.
   
Renewable credit facility agreement with a banking syndicate represented by BNP Paribas as agent and lead manager
At its meeting of May 9, 2005, the Board of Directors authorized the signature of a renewable credit facility agreement with a banking syndicate represented by BNP Paribas as Agent and Lead Manager (the “Credit Facility Agreement”), the purpose of which is to provide the Company with short-term cash facilities to finance its general cash needs.
The Credit Facility Agreement was signed on May 18, 2005 for a term of twelve months from the date of signature. The credit may be used in the form of revolving drawdowns up to a maximum of 75,000,000 over a period ending one month before the final expiration of the credit facility.
The breakdown of the banking syndicate and the share of each Lender in the total commitment is as follows:
                 
                 
  Lenders  
 
Credit  
 
Commitment as a %  
 
 
             
 
BNP Paribas
    24,750,000      33%   
 
CALYON
    18,750,000      25%   
 
Natexis Banques Populaires
    15,000,000      20%   
 

Page 65 of 184


 

     
SCOR GROUP
 
CONSOLIDATED FINANCIAL STATEMENTS UNDER IFRS
                 
                 
  Lenders  
 
Credit  
 
Commitment as a %  
 
Crédit Industriel et Commercial
    7,500,000      10%   
 
Ixis Corporate & Investment Bank
    5,250,000      7%   
 
Caisse Régionale de Crédit Agricole Mutuel de Paris et d’Ile-de-France
    3,750,000      5%   
 
Total Commitment
    75,000,000      100%   
 
To guarantee its obligations under the Credit Facility Agreement, the Company is required to pledge a first-tier financial instruments account to the Lenders and BNP Paribas as Agent under the terms of a pledge agreement signed with the Lenders and Agent and the related declaration of pledge, and to pledge, as a condition precedent for each draw and at the Company’s discretion, either French Treasury Bonds (OAT) in an amount at least equal to 105% of the draw amount, or shares for an amount at least equal to 125% of the draw amount, or bonds in an amount at least equal to 110% of the draw amount.
The Board authorized as needed the signature of an amendment to the Credit Facility Agreement providing for the pledge of Luxembourg open-end investment fund shares (SICAV) and a pledge agreement governed by Luxembourg law, between the Company, the Lenders and BNP Paribas as Agent, concerning the pledge of said Luxembourg SICAV shares (hereinafter referred to, with the aforementioned financial instruments pledge, as the “Sureties”).
The margin applicable to each draw is based on the type of securities pledged prior to the draw. If stocks are pledges (including shares of Luxembourg SICAVs), the applicable margin is set at 0.45% per annum; if bonds are pledged, the applicable margin is set at 0.25% per annum; and, if OATs are pledged, the applicable margin is set at the higher of (i) 0.15% per annum or (ii) the rate of the non-utilization commission applicable on the date of the draw in question.
The interest period is set at the Company’s discretion for each draw at 1, 2, 3 or 6 months. The interest rate applicable to the amount drawn is equal to the sum of (i) the EURIBOR for the relevant interest period, (ii) the margin applicable to the draw in question plus, as applicable, (iii) the required costs applicable under the terms of the agreement.
The bank fees stipulated under the Credit Facility Agreement are as follows:
non-use commission: payable quarterly when due on the basis of a rate applied to the amount of the credit available, which varies on the basis of the Company’s credit rate (“Counterparty Credit Rating”) given by Standard & Poors’:
         
BBB or lower:
 
 
 
0.28% per annum
 
 
 
 
 
BBB+
 
:
 
0.20% per annum
 
 
 
 
 
A-
 
:
 
0.15% per annum
 
 
 
 
 
A or higher
 
:
 
0.12% per annum
If, on the calculating date, Standard & Poors’ no longer gives a rating to the Company, the rate will then be determined on the basis of the credit rating (“Counterparty Credit Rating”) given by the Moody’s ratings agency as follows:
     
Baa2 or lower:
 
0.28% per annum
 
 
 
 
 
Baa1     :
 
0.20% per annum
 
 
 
 
 
A3     :
 
0.15% per annum
 
 
 
 
 
A2 or higher:
 
0.12% per annum
In the event Standard & Poors’ and Moody’s no longer assign the aforementioned credit ratings to the Company and in the event there is a Default Event, the applicable rate would then be set at the maximum applicable rate, i.e. 0.28% per annum.
  -  
participation commission: 0.20% of the total commitments of each Lender, payable on the date of signature of the Credit Facility Agreement;
  -  
Agent commission: 10,000 (excluding VAT), payable in one sum;
  -  
Lead Manager commission: 0.10% flat (excluding VAT), calculated on the credit facility of 75,000,000 and payable in one payment.
The representations and warranties of the Company under the Credit Facility Agreement and the default events are similar in all points to those stipulated in the credit facility agreement useable through the issue of letters of credit, as amended, entered into on December 26, 2002.
The director concerned by this agreement is Mr. Kessler.
   
Signature of an agency letter and an underwriting agreement between the Company and BNP Paribas within the context of a share capital increase on June 30, 2005

Page 66 of 184


 

     
SCOR GROUP
 
CONSOLIDATED FINANCIAL STATEMENTS UNDER IFRS
At its afternoon meeting of May 31, 2005, the Board of Directors authorized, pursuant to Article L. 225-38 of the Commercial Code, within the framework of the proposed share capital increase of June 30, 2005, the signature by SCOR and BNP Paribas of an agency letter and an underwriting agreement for the offering and placement of the shares to be issued.
The director concerned by this agreement is Mr. Kessler.
   
Signature of a novation agreement (hereinafter the “Global Novation Agreement”) between SCOR, party of the first part; Irish Reinsurance Partners Limited (“IRP”) party of the second part; and SCOR, SCOR Italia Riassicurazioni, SCOR UK Company Ltd, SCOR Deutschland, SCOR Asia Pacific, SCOR Re Co (Asia) Ltd, SCOR Asia Pacific Australian Branch, SCOR Asia Pacific Labuan Branch and SCOR Re Asia Pacific PTE Ltd Korea Branch, (referred to as the “Subsidiaries”).

At its meeting of August 31, 2005, the Board of Directors authorized, pursuant to Article L. 225-38 of the Commercial Code, the signature of the Global Novation Agreement, under the terms of which SCOR will be substituted for IRP in the rights and obligations resulting from the Quota Share Retrocession Agreements, the list of which is attached to the Global Novation Agreement.

The officers concerned are Messrs. Kessler and Thourot.
   
Signature of a novation agreement (hereinafter the “SCOR Re Novation Agreement”) between SCOR, Irish Reinsurance Partners Limited (“IRP”), and SCOR Reinsurance Company (SCOR Re).
At its meeting on August 31, 2005, the Board of Directors authorized, pursuant to Article L. 225-38 of the Commercial Code, the signature of the SCOR Re Novation Agreement, under the terms of which SCOR will be substituted for IRP in the rights and obligations resulting from the Quota Share Retrocession Agreement defined by said contract.
The officers concerned by this agreement are Messrs. Kessler, Chapin, Lebègue and Thourot.
   
Signature of a novation agreement (hereinafter the “Canada Novation Agreement”) between SCOR, Irish Reinsurance Partners Limited (“IRP”), and SCOR Canada Reinsurance Company (SCOR Canada)
At its meeting of August 31, 2005, the Board of Directors authorized, pursuant to Article L. 225-38 of the Commercial Code, the signature of the Canada Novation Agreement, under the terms of which SCOR will be substituted for IRP in the rights and obligations resulting from the Quota Share Retrocession Agreement defined by said contract.
The officers concerned by this agreement are Messrs. Kessler, Lamontagne and Thourot.
   
Signature of a guarantee known as the Indemnity Agreement (hereinafter the “Guarantee” granted by SCOR to Irish Reinsurance Partners Limited)
At its meeting of August 31, 2005, the Board of Directors authorized, pursuant to Article L. 225-38 of the Commercial Code, the signature of a guarantee requested by the IRP Board of Directors from SCOR in order to guarantee any liability that might be incurred by Irish Reinsurance Partners Limited resulting from the execution of the novation agreements described above.
The officers concerned by this agreement are Messrs. Kessler and Thourot.
Parent company guarantees
At its meeting of August 31, 2005, the Board of Directors authorized, pursuant to Articles L. 225-38 and L. 225-35 of the Commercial Code, the renewal of the parent company guarantees granted by SCOR to allow the Group’s reinsurance subsidiaries to obtain a financial rating equivalent to the rating for SCOR itself. SCOR stood surety for the obligations of said subsidiaries under the insurance and reinsurance treaties they signed, particularly under the parent company guarantee which the Board last authorized on December 19, 2002.
During the past 2004/2005 period, the subsidiary General Security Indemnity Company of Arizona had to produce the guarantee once for a specific intermediary.
In addition, the Board of Directors also authorized a new parent company guarantee granted by SCOR to Commercial Risk Reinsurance Company and Commercial Risk Re-Insurance Limited.
Pursuant to Article L. 225-38 of the Commercial Code and because of the positions they held on the Board of Directors of some of these subsidiaries, Messrs. Chapin, Lamontagne, Lebègue and Kessler did not participate in the vote. For the same reason, particularly for the parent company guarantee given to SCOR VIE, only Mrs. Aronvald was authorized to vote.
The benefit of the parent company guarantee was given to the following subsidiaries of the SCOR Group under insurance and/or insurance contracts entered into by these subsidiaries:
- SCOR Reinsurance Co. Ltd (US)
- General Security Indemnity Co. of Arizona
- General Security National Insurance Co.
- Commercial Risk Reinsurance Company
- Commercial Risk Re-Insurance Limited
- Investors Insurance Corp.

Page 67 of 184


 

     
SCOR GROUP
 
CONSOLIDATED FINANCIAL STATEMENTS UNDER IFRS
- SCOR Life Insurance Company (ex. Republic-Vanguard Life Insurance Co).
- SCOR Asia-Pacific Pte Ltd
- SCOR Canada Reinsurance Co.
- SCOR Channel
- SCOR Deutschland
- SCOR Financial Services Ltd
- SCOR Italia Riassicurazioni SpA
- SCOR Life U.S. Re Insurance Co.
- SCOR Reinsurance Co. (Asia) Ltd
- SCOR U.K. Co. Ltd
- SCOR VIE
This new authorization became effective on September 3, 2005 and will expire no later than September 2, 2006.
The officers in question were Messrs. Chapin, Lamontagne, Lebègue, Thourot and Kessler. With regard to the parent company guarantee granted to SCOR VIE, the directors concerned were Messrs. Kessler, Havis, Chapin, Simonnet, Seys, Levy-Lang, Borges, Schimetschek, Tendil, Acutis, Lamontagne, Valot, Lebègue and Le Pas de Sécheval.
Project Triple X
At its meeting of November 2, 2005, the Board of Directors authorized, pursuant to Article L. 225-38 of the Commercial Code, the issue of a parent company letter of guarantee intended to cover the financial obligations of SCOR VIE under the terms of an agreement to issue letters of credit that would be signed by SCOR VIE, SCOR Financial Services Limited (SFS) and CALYON.
These proposed agreements to issue letters of credit and a parent company guarantee are part of an operation intended to provide SCOR Life U.S. Reinsurance Company (SLR) additional financial resources so that it can satisfy the financial coverage requirements stipulated by the American prudential regulations known as Triple X.
Under the terms of the contract described above, CALYON has committed itself to issuing or causing to issue to SLR one or more letters of credit for a period of five years for a total commitment equal to the smaller of the following two amounts: (a) USD 250 million or (b) the sum equal to the difference between the (i) so-called Triple X reserves and (ii) 150% of the amount of the reserves required in the accounting plan (net of deferred acquisition costs).
The transaction was submitted to the Department of Insurance of the State of Texas (United States of America) insofar as it requires a certain number of amendments to the retrocession treaty (Automatic Coinsurance Retrocession Treaty) signed on December 31, 2003 by SLR and SFS. In a letter dated September 30, 2005, the competent authorities of the State of Texas indicated that they had no comments on the amendments that would be made to that agreement. The Irish administrative authorities (IFSRA) were also informed of the transaction and they also indicated their lack of any objection.
The transaction was finalized at the end of December 2005.
The directors concerned are Messrs. Kessler, Havis, Chapin, Simonnet, Seys, Levy-Lang, Lebègue, Borges, Schimetschek, Tendil, Acutis, Lamontagne, Valot and Le Pas de Sécheval.
   
Approval of the Credit Facility Agreement
The Company terminated, effective December 31, 2005, the credit facility agreement as amended that was signed on December 26, 2002 with a banking syndicate represented by BNP Paribas (the “Bank”). The Company’s objective is to give priority to bilateral relations with one or more banking partners for coverage of its reinsurance commitments by letters of credit. The Company asked the Bank not to terminate certain stand-by letters of credit issued under said credit agreement and to assume on its own a portion of the related banking commitments (so that these letters of credit are automatically renewed for another year as of December 31, 2005) and proposed to the Bank, subject to approval by its own Board, that it issue new letters of credit under a new agreement.
At its meeting of November 2, 2005, the Board of Directors authorized, pursuant to Article L. 225-38 of the Commercial Code, the signature of a new credit facility agreement with the Bank (the “Credit Facility Agreement”), the purpose of which is to guarantee the performance of the Company’s obligations for its reinsurance operations. The credit facility is useable through the issuance of revolving letters of credit and/or counter-guarantees (stand-by letters of credit or “SBLC”) up to a maximum of USD 85,000,000 (USD Eighty Five Million) over a utilization period from January 4, 2006 to December 31, 2008.
In order to guarantee its obligations under the terms of the Credit Facility Agreement, SCOR pledged a first-tier financial instruments account to the Bank under the terms of a pledge agreement entered into with the Bank (and the related pledge declaration) and pledged (i) on the date of the signature of the pledge agreement, a number of OATs for a minimum amount equal to 5,000 (Five Thousand Euros); (ii) on December 30, 2005, an additional number of OATS for an amount equivalent to the value in euros of 105% of the Initial SBLCs (corresponding to the letters of credit issued under the old credit agreement and

Page 68 of 184


 

     
SCOR GROUP
 
CONSOLIDATED FINANCIAL STATEMENTS UNDER IFRS
assumed and extended by the Bank); and (iii) is required to pledge before each new utilization a number of OATS for an amount equivalent to the value in euros of 105% of the amount of the new utilization.
The bank fees stipulated under the Credit Facility Agreement are as follows:
   
non-use commission: 0.05% per annum as of January 1, 2006, calculated on the unused and un-canceled amount of the credit and payable quarterly when due;
 
   
Utilization commission: 0.10% per annum as of January 1, 2006, calculated on the basis of the loan outstanding and payable monthly in advance;
 
   
Other Bank fees:
  -  
flat fee of USD 400 (USD Four Hundred) for each SBLC issued;
  -  
flat fee of USD 100 (USD One Hundred) for each change in SBLC;
  -  
flat fee of USD 100 (USD One Hundred) for each annual extension of SBLC.
The director concerned is Mr. Kessler.
AGREEMENTS APPROVED IN PRIOR FISCAL YEARS AND CONTINUED OR TERMINATED IN 2005.
   
Underwriting agreement entered into with BNP Paribas, Goldman Sachs International and HSBC CCF for the OCEANE bond issue.
The Board of Directors, at its meeting of June 21, 2004, authorized the bond issue approved by the AMF on June 24, 2004 under Number 04-627, through the issuance of bonds convertible and/or exchangeable for new or existing shares (OCEANE) with a nominal unit value of 2 with normal amortization on January 1, 2010.
In the context of this operation, the Board at the same meeting authorized the signature of an underwriting agreement for the placement and subscription of the bonds convertible and/or exchangeable for new or existing shares which was signed on June 24, 2004 by SCOR and the BNP Paribas, Goldman Sachs International and HSBC CCF banks. This agreement specified a placement commission, a success commission and a guarantee commission. The total amount of these commissions is 4,175,000.
The board members concerned are Messrs. Kessler and Borgès.
   
SCOR AUBER Agreement in connection with a real estate acquisition
The Board of Directors, at its meeting held on June 21, 2004, authorized, pursuant to Article L. 225-38 of the French Commercial Code, the signature of a Loan Agreement with SCOR AUBER, dated June 29, 2004, in connection with the acquisition by SCOR AUBER of a real estate asset consisting of a logistics platform on June 30, 2004.
For this purpose, SCOR made available 23,570,000 to SCOR AUBER in the form of a loan at the market rate, knowing that, out of this aggregate amount, 10 million was capitalized by SCOR AUBER following a share capital increase.
The person concerned by this agreement is Mr. Thourot.
   
Acquisition of SOREMA securities and grant by Groupama to SCOR of guarantees relating to SOREMA
It is recalled that the SCOR Board of Directors on May 10, 2001 authorized the signature of a plan for SCOR’s acquisition of the securities of SOREMA S.A. and SOREMA N.A. Under this acquisition, a guarantee of the technical reserves and a guarantee of liabilities were made by Groupama to SCOR for a period of six years.
In the context of the purchase of SOREMA S.A. and SOREMA N.A., Groupama provided two guarantees. Groupama could indemnify SCOR in the event of negative developments concerning significant liabilities related to social security and income taxes or related to the technical reserves for 2000 and the prior year writings, as they will be valued on December 31, 2006.
The amount of the guarantee charged to Groupama in the accounts as of December 31, 2004 amounted to 233.5 million. This amount may be increased or decreased at the end of the guarantee period that expires June 30, 2007.
The Board member concerned by this agreement was Mr. Baligand.
POST-BALANCE SHEET EVENTS
None

Page 69 of 184


 

     
SCOR GROUP
 
CONSOLIDATED FINANCIAL STATEMENTS UNDER IFRS
5.8 Statutory Auditors’ Report on the consolidated financial statements
(Free translation of a French language original)
This is a free translation into English of the statutory auditors’ report issued in the French language and is provided solely for the convenience of English speaking readers. This report includes information specifically required by French law in all audit reports, whether qualified or not, and this is presented below the opinion on the financial statements. This information includes explanatory paragraphs discussing the auditors’ assessments of certain significant accounting matters. These assessments were made for the purpose of issuing an opinion on the financial statements taken as a whole and not to provide separate assurance on individual account captions or on information taken outside of the consolidated financial statements. The report also includes information relating to the specific verification of information in the group management report.
This report, together with the statutory auditors’ report addressing financial and accounting information in the Chairman’s report on internal control, should be read in conjunction with, and is construed in accordance with French law and professional auditing standards applicable in France.
To the Shareholders
In compliance with the assignment entrusted to us by your Annual General Meeting, we have audited the accompanying consolidated financial statements of Scor for the year ended December 31, 2005.
The consolidated financial statements have been approved by the Board of Directors. Our role is to express an opinion on these financial statements based on our audit.
These financial statements have been prepared for the first time in accordance with IFRS as adopted by the European Union. They include comparative information in respect of financial year 2004 restated in accordance with the same standards.
I - Opinion on the consolidated financial statements
We have conducted our audit in accordance with the professional standards applicable in France; those standards require that we plan and perform the audit to obtain reasonable assurance about whether the consolidated financial statements are free of material misstatement. An audit includes examining, on a test basis, evidence supporting the amounts and disclosures in the financial statements. An audit also includes assessing the accounting principles used and significant estimates made by the management, as well as evaluating the overall financial statements presentation. We believe that our audit provides a reasonable basis for our opinion.
In our opinion, the consolidated financial statements give a true and fair view of the assets, liabilities, financial position and results of the consolidated Group as at December 31, 2005 in accordance with IFRS as adopted by the European Union.
II - Justification of our assessments
In accordance with the requirements of article L. 823-9 of the French Company Law (Code de commerce) relating to the justification of our assessments, we bring to your attention the following matters:
o As stated in notes 5.7 “Use of estimates” and “Accounting principles and methods specific to reinsurance business”, notes 7, 8 and 11 to the consolidated financial statements, the technical accounts specific to reinsurance are estimated on the basis of reinsurance commitments or on statistical and actuarial bases, particularly in the case of accounts not received from ceding companies, technical reserves, and policy acquisition costs. The methods used to calculate these estimates are described in the notes to the consolidated financial statements.
Our audit work consisted in assessing the data and assumptions on which the estimates are based, especially those used by the internal and external actuaries, and confirmed by the Group actuarial review, reviewing the Company’s calculations, comparing estimated accounts from prior periods with actual outturns, and examining senior management’s procedures for approving these estimates.
Our work enabled us to assess that the data and assumptions used provide a reasonable basis for the estimates made.
o Note 5.7 “Business combinations” , “Assessment of certain intangible and tangible assets at fair value” and “Goodwill and Business combinations” , and note 1 to the consolidated financial statements describe the policies and methods used to update estimates of goodwill and the value of life reinsurance portfolios acquired, and corresponding impairment recognized during the year.
Each year, the Company carries out impairment tests of Goodwill and undefined lifetime assets and also estimates the existence of a long term asset loss of value index. The methods used to carry out these impairment tests are described in note 1 to the consolidated financial statements. We have assessed the approaches used in impairment test, the forecasted cash flows and the consistency of the assumptions used. We have verified that the information described in note 1 to the consolidated financial statements is appropriate.
Our work enabled us to assess the consistency of the estimates made with the assumptions of the strategic plan “Moving Forward”.
o Notes 5.7 “real estate investments”, “financial assets” and “derivatives instruments” and “hedging instruments” and notes 2, 3, 4, 5, 6 and 9 to the consolidated financial statements describe the policies and methods used to update estimates of investments and derivatives instruments.
We have assessed the approaches used in valuing these assets, described in the notes to the financial statements, and, on the basis of information available at that time, we have conducted tests to verify the application of these methods.
Our work enabled us to assess that the approaches used provide a reasonable basis for the estimates made.

Page 70 of 184


 

     
SCOR GROUP
 
CONSOLIDATED FINANCIAL STATEMENTS UNDER IFRS
o Notes 5.7, 15 and 23 to the consolidated financial statements describe the policies and methods used to update valuation of deferred tax assets.
The Company, at closing date, systematically carries out a deferred tax assets impairment test described in note 5.7 “Taxes” to the consolidated financial statements. We have assessed the approaches used in impairment test, the forecasted cash flows and the consistency of the assumptions made. We have verified that the information described in note 5.7 “Taxes” to the consolidated financial statements is appropriate.
Our work enabled us to assess the consistency of the estimates made with the assumptions of the strategic plan “Moving Forward”.
o With respect to risks and litigation, we have obtained assurance that the Group’s procedures allow these to be satisfactorily identified, evaluated and reflected in the financial statements.
We have also obtained assurance that possible uncertainties identified in applying this approach are described as appropriate in notes 28 “Exceptional events and litigation” to the consolidated financial statements.
o Note 5.7 “Actuarial gains and losses on pension plans” , “Pension liabilities and similar benefits” , and notes 13 and 14 to the consolidated financial statements describe the policies and methods used to update estimates of pension liabilities and similar benefits. These benefits have been estimated by the internal and external actuaries. Our work consisted in assessing the data and assumptions on which the estimates are based, reviewing the Company’s calculations and verifying that the information in note 5.7 “Actuarial gains and losses on pension plans”, “Pension liabilities and similar benefits”, and notes 13 and 14 to the consolidated financial statements are appropriate.
These assessments were thus made in the context of the performance of our audit of the consolidated financial statements taken as a whole and therefore contributed to the formation of our audit opinion expressed in the first part of this report.
III - Specific verification
In accordance with professional standards applicable in France, we have also verified the information given in the group management report. We have no matters to report regarding its fair presentation and conformity with the consolidated financial statements.
Paris, March 24, 2006
Statutory Auditors
     
ERNST & YOUNG AUDIT
 
MAZARS & GUERARD
Pierre PLANCHON
 
Lionel GOTLIB
 
 
Jean Luc BARLET

Page 71 of 184


 

     
SCOR GROUP
 
CONSOLIDATED FINANCIAL STATEMENTS UNDER IFRS
6 SCOR PARENT COMPANY FINANCIAL STATEMENTS
6.1 SIGNIFICANT EVENTS OF THE YEAR*
Business in 2005 resulted in a profit of 57 million, due in particular to the improvement in technical earnings despite the occurrence of hurricanes in the United States (Katrina, Rita and Wilma) and floods in Europe and in India.
In addition, SCOR carried out the following transactions in 2005:
  -  
repayment of an amount of 263 million in January 2005 corresponding to the OCEANE loan,
  -  
increase of US $120 million in the share capital of its subsidiary, SCOR U.S. in January 2005,
  -  
acquisition in June 2005 of the outstanding stocks of IRP Holdings Limited held by Highfields Investment Funds in the amount of 183 million, which brought the participation of SCOR in IRP Holdings Limited to a total of 351 million.
     
This equity interest was reduced to 0.8 million at the end of 2005, after IRP Holdings Limited reduced its share capital.
The share capital increase on 30 June 2005 in the net amount of 224 million after expenses, and the considerable improvement in the Group’s earnings and outlook, led the rating agency Standard & Poor’s to raise the rating of SCOR to A- with stable prospects on August 1, 2005.
*
 
“Significant events of the year” are an integral part of the notes to the parent company financial statements.

Page 72 of 184


 

     
SCOR
  PARENT COMPANY FINANCIALS STATEMENTS     
6.2 BALANCE SHEET – (SCOR SA FINANCIAL STATEMENTS)
BALANCE SHEET – ASSETS
                                                 
 
in EUR millions           Gross     Depreciation and     2005     2004     2003  
            amount     reserves     Net                  
 
Intangible assets
  Note 3     86       16       70       79       82  
 
                                               
Investments
  Note 2 & 4     5,596       1,109       4,487       4,479       4,047  
Real estate investments
            193       19       174       181       162  
Investments in affiliates and subsidiaries
            2,723       1,086       1,637       1,605       1,698  
Other investments
            2,467       4       2,463       2,490       1,974  
Accounts receivable for cash deposited with other ceding companies
    213               213       203       213  
Investments representing contracts in units of account
  Note 2                                      
 
                                               
Share of retrocessionnaires in underwriting reserves
  Note 4     432               432       699       790  
Reinsurance reserves (Life)
                                               
Claims reserve (Life)
                                               
Reserves for unearned premiums (Non-Life)
            22               22       105       134  
Claims reserve (Non-Life)
            410               410       594       656  
Other underwriting reserves (Non-Life)
                                               
 
                                               
Accounts receivable
  Note 4     620       10       610       399       584  
Accounts receivable from reinsurance transactions
    323       10       313       158       362  
Other accounts receivable
            297               297       241       221  
 
                                               
Other assets
            322       6       316       214       169  
Current property, plant and equipment
  Note 3     28       6       22       21       21  
Bank accounts and cash
            279               279       181       146  
Treasury stock
            15               15       12       2  
 
                                               
Accrued income and deferred charges
  Note 4     356               356       405       371  
Earned interests and rents not yet matured
            23               23       26       32  
Deferred acquisition costs – Acceptance (Non-Life)
    104               104       102       67  
Reinsurance estimates – Acceptance
            217               217       269       257  
Other accruals and prepaid expenses
            12               12       8       15  
Repayment premiums for debenture loans
            0               0       1       6  
 
                                               
Net translation adjustment
            0               0       0       0  
 
 
 
                                               
TOTAL
            7,412       1,141       6,271       6,276       6,049  
 
Page 73 of 184

 


 

     
SCOR
  PARENT COMPANY FINANCIALS STATEMENTS     
BALANCE SHEET – LIABILITIES (SCOR SA CORPORATE FINANCIAL STATEMENTS)
                                         
   
in EUR millions           2005 before     2005 after     2004     2003  
            appropriation of     appropriation of                  
            earnings     earnings                  
 
 
 
Equity and reserves
  Note 5     1,079       1,031       792       88  
 
Common stock
            763       763       645       136  
Additional paid-in capital
            118       118       12        
Asset revaluation reserves
                               
Unavailable reserve
                               
Other reserves
            14       17       14       13  
Capitalization reserve
            124       124       121       112  
Retained earnings
            3       9             (173 )
Income for the year
            57                    
 
                                       
Other capital base
            50       50       50       50  
 
                                       
Gross underwriting reserves
  Note 4     4,029       4,029       3,774       4,191  
Reinsurance reserve (Life)
                              25  
Claims reserves (Life)
                              5  
Unearned premiums reserves (Non-Life)
            458       458       430       447  
Claims reserves (Non-Life)
            3,539       3,539       3,310       3,678  
Other underwriting reserves (Non-Life)
                               
Equalization reserve (Non-Life)
            32       32       34       36  
Underwriting reserves for unit-linked contracts
                               
 
                                       
Contingency reserves
  Note 6     44       44       24       15  
 
                                       
Liabilities for cash deposits received from retrocessionnaires
  Note 4     52       52       314       294  
 
                                       
Other liabilities
  Note 4     947       995       1,204       1,073  
 
                                       
Liabilities arising from reinsurance transactions
            87       87       120       105  
Convertible bond issue
            208       208       431       265  
Debts to credit institutions
            14       14       1       1  
Negotiable debt securities issued by the company
            35       35       35       35  
Other loans, deposits and guarantees received.
            529       529       519       569  
Other liabilities
            74       122       98       98  
Accrued liabilities
  Note 4     48       48       98       157  
Deferred commissions received from reinsurers (Non-Life)
            2       2       23       19  
Estimate of reinsurance -Retrocession
            33       33       64       128  
Other prepayments and deferred expenses
            13       13       11       10  
Net translation adjustment
            22       22       20       181  
 
 
                                       
TOTAL
            6,271       6,271       6,276       6,049  
 
Page 74 of 184

 


 

     
SCOR
  PARENT COMPANY FINANCIALS STATEMENTS     
     6.3 STATEMENT OF INCOME (SCOR SA CORPORATE FINANCIAL STATEMENTS)
   
in EUR millions                   Net                  
    Gross     Retroceded     operations              
    operations     operations     2005     2004     2003  
 
TECHNICAL ACCOUNT FOR NON-LIFE INSURANCE
                                       
 
                                       
Premiums earned
    969       (112 )     857       575       1,107  
 
                                       
Premiums
    977       (25 )     952       561       698  
 
                                       
Changes in unearned premiums
    (8 )     (87 )     (95 )     14       409  
 
                                       
Gains from allocated investment
    17               17       33       (288 )
 
                                       
Other technical income
    6               6       23       41  
 
                                       
Claims expenses
    (621 )     94       (527 )     (409 )     (1,136 )
 
                                       
Benefits and costs paid
    (579 )     311       (268 )     (639 )     (910 )
 
                                       
Reserves for claims and claims expense
    (42 )     (217 )     (259 )     230       (226 )
 
                                       
Expenses for other underwriting reserves
                                     
 
                                       
Acquisition and administration costs
    (250 )     3       (248 )     (173 )     (287 )
 
                                       
Acquisition costs
    (233 )     22       (211 )     (202 )     (368 )
 
                                       
Administration costs
    (17 )             (17 )     (18 )     (5 )
 
                                       
Commissions received from reinsurers
            (19 )     (19 )     47       86  
 
                                       
Other underwriting expenses
    (57 )             (57 )     (53 )     (54 )
 
                                       
Change in equalization reserve
    (4 )             (4 )     1       (3 )
 
                                       
Change in liquidity reserve
                                   
 
                                       
 
 
                                       
NON-LIFE TECHNICAL INCOME
    60       (15 )     45       (3 )     (620 )
 
Page 75 of 184

 


 

     
SCOR
  PARENT COMPANY FINANCIALS STATEMENTS     
STATEMENT OF INCOME (SCOR SA CORPORATE FINANCIAL STATEMENTS)
   
in EUR millions               Net              
    Gross     Retroceded     operations              
    operations     operations     2005     2004     2003  
 
TECHNICAL ACCOUNT –LIFE
                                       
 
                                       
Premiums
                            -       434  
 
                                       
Income from investments
                            -       3  
Investment income
                                    2  
 
                                       
Other investment products
                                    -  
 
                                       
Profits from investments made
                                    1  
 
                                       
Unit-linked policies adjustments (capital gain)
                            -       -  
 
                                       
Other technical income
                            -       -  
 
                                       
Claims expenses
                            (25 )     (482 )
Benefits and costs paid
                            (30 )     (604 )
 
                                       
Claims reserve expense
                            5       122  
 
                                       
Expenses for Life reinsurance and other underwriting reserves
                            25       174  
Life reinsurance reserves
                            25       166  
 
                                       
Int-linked contract
                                    8  
 
                                       
Other underwriting reserves
                                    -  
 
                                       
Acquisition and administration costs
                            -       (154 )
Acquisition costs
                                    (153 )
 
                                       
Administration costs
                                    (2 )
 
                                       
Commissions received from reinsurers
                                    1  
 
                                       
Investment expenses
                            -       (5 )
Internal and external investment management costs and interests
                                    (1 )
Other investment expenses
                                    (4 )
 
                                       
Losses from investments
                                    -  
 
                                       
Unit-Linked policies adjustments (capital loss)
                            -       -  
 
                                       
Other underwriting expenses
                            -       (2 )
 
                                       
Variance in liquidity reserve
                            -       -  
 
 
 
                                       
LIFE TECHNICAL INCOME (LOSS)
    0       0       0       0       (32 )
 
Page 76 of 184

 


 

     
SCOR
  PARENT COMPANY FINANCIALS STATEMENTS     
STATEMENT OF INCOME (SCOR SA CORPORATE FINANCIAL STATEMENTS)
                         
 
in EUR millions   2005 net     2004 net     2003 net  
    transactions     transactions     transactions  
 
NON-TECHNICAL ACCOUNT
                       
 
                       
Non-Life technical income (loss)
    45       (3 )     (620 )
 
                       
Life technical income (loss)
    0       0       (32 )
 
                       
Investment gains
    300       432       333  
Investment income
    231       199       210  
Other investment gains
    30       5       2  
Profits from investments made
    39       228       121  
 
                       
Investment expenses
    (278 )     (391 )     (667 )
Internal and external investment management costs and financial costs
    (83 )     (85 )     (84 )
Other investment expenses
    (106 )     (281 )     (538 )
Losses from realization of investments
    (89 )     (25 )     (45 )
 
                       
Gains from transferred investments
    (17 )     (33 )     288  
 
                       
Other non-technical gains
            -       -  
 
                       
Other non-technical expenses
            -       (1 )
 
                       
Extraordinary income
    (13 )     1       1  
 
                       
Employee profit sharing
    (3 )     -       -  
 
                       
Income taxes
    23       7       1  
 
                       
 
 
                       
INCOME FOR THE YEAR
    57       13       (697 )
 
 
                       
 
NET EARNINGS PER SHARE (in EURO)
    0.06       0.02       (5.11 )
 
Page 77 of 184

 


 

     
SCOR
  PARENT COMPANY FINANCIALS STATEMENTS     
6.4 OFF-BALANCE SHEET ITEMS (SCOR SA CORPORATE FINANCIAL STATEMENTS)
                                         
 
    Linked     Others     2005     2004     2003  
in EUR millions   companies                          
 
 
COMMITMENTS RECEIVED
Note 15
            1,041       1,041       674       1,558  
 
 
                                       
Rate swaps
            41       41       43       92  
Asset swap (Horizon)
            83       83       94       102  
Index default swap (Horizon)
            83       83       94       102  
Forward purchase of exchange
            75       75       75       75  
Treasury bills
                                    -  
Confirmed credits
            100       100       -       50  
Foreign currency forward purchases
            249       249       -       354  
Performance bond
                            -       -  
Mortgages
                            1       1  
Leases of financed leased buildings
            44       44       52       60  
Letters of credit
            358       358       268       676  
Endorsements and sureties
            8       8       47       46  
 
                                       
 
COMMITMENTS GIVEN
Note 15
    572       2,264       2,836       2,395       4,279  
 
 
                                       
Endorsements, sureties and credit guarantees given
    43       303       346       278       669  
Endorsements, sureties
            9       9       47       48  
Letters of credit
    43       294       337       231       621  
 
                                       
Securities and assets acquired with commitment for resale
                            -       -  
 
                                       
Other commitments on securities, assets or revenues
            220       220       217       276  
Rate swaps
            41       41       43       92  
Forward sales of exchange
            75       75       75       75  
Asset swaps (Horizon)
            83       83       94       102  
Underwriting commitments
            21       21       5       7  
 
                                       
Other commitments given
    529       1,741       2,270       1,900       3,334  
Value of assets pledged with ceding companies
    529       951       1,480       1,523       762  
Investment securities pledged to financial institutions
            328       328       206       854  
Equity investments pledged to financial institutions
                            -       1,189  
Real estate mortgages
                                    30  
Other guarantees given to financial institutions
            155       155       95       96  
Contract termination indemnities
            1       1       1       1  
 
                                       
Foreign currency forward sales
            249       249       -       317  
Real estate leasing
            57       57       75       85  
 
                                       
 
 
                                       
COLLATERAL RECEIVED FROM RETROCESSIONAIRES
            22       22       29       34  
 
Page 78 of 184

 


 

     
SCOR
  PARENT COMPANY FINANCIALS STATEMENTS     
6.5   NOTES TO PARENT COMPANY FINANCIAL STATEMENTS
NOTE 1- ACCOUNTING POLICIES
The financial statements for fiscal 2005 are presented in accordance with the European Directive of December 19, 1991, the French Decree 94-481 of June 8, 1994, and the Decision of June 20, 1994 as amended by the Decision of July 28, 1995, whose application has been extended to include reinsurance companies. The statement of income has been split between technical and other income. In addition to underwriting data, the technical accounts include operating expenses and income from investments relating to reinsurance activities. Income from invested shareholders’ equity is recorded in non-technical account.
1.1 – Intangible assets
Intangible assets consist of business assets that are not subject to depreciation and software acquired or created by the company, fixed and amortized over a period of between 1 to 5 years.
1.2 – Investment assets
Investment assets are recorded at purchase cost, net of expenses, with the exception of fixed-income securities. Valuation of investments is carried out in keeping with the category of the assets and the length of time over which they are held.
          1.2.1 – Real estate assets
Real estate assets are buildings held for rental, which are intended to be kept in the Company’s possession, and whose reference value for the purpose of evaluation is their yield value based on future rental income.
As from January 1, 2005, SCOR has applied the components-based accounting method, in accordance with the new accounting rules issued in Regulation 2002-10 adopted on December 12, 2002 by the Committee of Accounting Regulations (CRC).
Buildings are entered at their historic cost, amortized with a value which breaks down into several components:
- acquisition (or development) costs, rights and fees amortized over the average amortization period of the technical components.
- land, not amortized
- four technical components:
    the structure, or main work amortized over 30 to 80 years according to the type of construction
    wind and water tightness, amortized over 30 years
    technical installations, amortized over 20 years,
    fixtures and furnishing, amortized over 10 to 15 years, according to their category
The relative weight of each technical component and its amortization period are set in a grid of components, distinguishing eight types of construction. This grid was established based on the Group’s experience and the grids proposed by the professional bodies.
Impairment reserves are systematically recognized in so far as the reference value shows a discount in relation to the net book value (excluding acquisition rights and costs). In the case of buildings held for sale, the likely sale value is recorded.
Reserves for major maintenance or repairs:
Since the entry into force of regulations CRC 2002-10 and CRC 04-15, the provision for major repairs covers only second-category expenses, i.e. expenses covered by multi-year major maintenance or inspection programs intended to verify the correct operating condition of the facilities and to provide maintenance without extending the useful life. As this possibility is left to the assessment of the company and SCOR does not implement a detailed multi-annual program for such works (primarily because a large portion of the cost of such works is paid by tenants), it does not recognize a provision for major maintenance or repairs.
In this context, SCOR does not record a provision for major maintenance or repairs.
Impact of the change in the components-based accounting method and variances in fiscal 2005
                         
       
        Valuation by the former       Valuation by the    
  in EUR millions     method       components method    
                 
 
Net book value 01/01/2005 *
      98         101    
                 
 
 
                     
 
Net book value 01/01/2005 excluding Velizy building sold in 2005
      93         94    
 
 
                     
 
Depreciations and allowances in 2005
      (2 )       (3 )  
 
 
                     
 
Net book value 12/31/2005
      91         91    
 
 
                     
                 
Page 79 of 184

 


 

     
SCOR
  PARENT COMPANY FINANCIALS STATEMENTS     
*The impact of the change in accounting method at the beginning of the year was recognized as a net position (retained earnings) 3 million.
1.22 – Equity interests
The reference value of equity interests corresponds to their fair value, which depends on the utility of the investment to the company, its share price, share capital and reserves after revaluation, profits and future prospects.
For active reinsurance companies, the reference value corresponds to the net consolidated situation, excluding goodwill and before cancellation of shares, increased by unrealized capital gains and by the embedded value of their Life and Non-Life reinsurance book, net of tax. It does not include the value of future writings.
At each closing, if the reference value of any fixed income security, thus calculated, is inferior to its purchase value, an analysis is conducted in order to determine if it is necessary to impair this security. The hypotheses and conclusions of this analysis conducted on December 31, 2004, are detailed in paragraph 2.1.
For real estate and financial companies, the reference value corresponds to the share in net assets, plus unrealized capital gains net of tax. A valuation allowance is recorded on a line-by-line basis where the cost price is greater than the reference value.
1.23 – Stocks and other variable revenue securities
Stocks and other variable revenue securities are registered at their cost price, net of fees.
The sale value on the balance sheet date is determined according to Article R.332-20 of the Insurance Code, and corresponds, for listed securities, to the share price on the day of the inventory and for unlisted securities, their market value determined according to the net position.
As stipulated in the Notice issued on December 18, 2002 by the Emergency Committee of the French National Accounting Commission, an allowance for long-lived impairment is recognized in income, on a line-by-line basis, when the sale price shows a discount of more than 20% of purchase cost over a period of more than 6 consecutive months.
1.24 – Bonds and other fixed revenue shares
Bonds and other fixed revenue shares are recorded at their cost price excluding accrued coupons The difference between the cost price and the redemption value is compared to the income for the outstanding period until the redemption date according to a yield-to-maturity method, pursuant to the provisions of Article R.332-19 of the French Insurance Code.
No impairment allowance is recognized for the possible capital losses resulting from the comparison between the net book value, diminished or increased by the amortization of the differences resulting from the redemption and the sale value. An impairment allowance is only recorded in case of debtor default.
The realized capital gain or loss is assigned to the capitalization reserve.
1.2.5 – Other assets
A reserve for impairment of loans or other accounts receivable due in more than one year is recorded if their fair value is less than their acquisition cost.
1.2.6 – Liquidity risk reserve
A liquidity risk reserve is recorded for the possible need to liquidate assets in order to make immediate payment on major claims. This reserve is classified as a technical reserve and is made when the total net book value of assets, excluding bonds and other fixed revenue securities (investments measured according to article R. 332-19 of the Insurance Code), exceeds their sale value. The latter corresponds to the share price for listed securities, the market price for securities not listed and the appraisal value for real estate.
The modifications brought up by the CNC in their Notice of January 21, 2004 do not apply to the Company.
The calculations carried out lead to the conclusion that no reserve was recognized in the financial statements for 2003, 2004 and 2005.
1.3 – Current property, plant and equipment
Items under this heading are carried at cost.
Equipment, furniture and fixtures are depreciated on a straight-line or accelerated basis depending on their estimated useful lives:
Page 80 of 184

 


 

     
SCOR
  PARENT COMPANY FINANCIALS STATEMENTS     
             
- equipment, furniture
      5 - 10 years    
- installations
      10 years    
- vehicles
  4 - 5 years        
Deposits and security deposits are mainly constituted as security for rents.
1.4 – Accounts receivable
Claims from reinsurance transactions and claims from several debtors are written down if there is a risk that they cannot be recovered.
1.5 – Financial borrowings
Issuance expenses on different loans and the redemption premium on the Senior bond are amortized over the duration of the respective loans.
1.6 – Recording of reinsurance operations
Acceptances:
Accepted reinsurance is recorded at receipt of the accounts transmitted by the ceding company.
Pursuant to the provisions of Article R.332-18 of the Insurance Code, accounts not received from the ceding companies on the balance sheet date are estimated, in order to record the position of reinsurance commitments made by SCOR in the financial statements as accurately as possible. This method concerns the majority of the contracts signed during the fiscal year, and even the previous year.
Estimates of premiums and commissions not received from ceding companies on the closing date are recorded in the income statement with a regularization account entitled “ Estimates of reinsurance acceptance as counter entry.
Overall, the premiums booked in the fiscal year (premiums shown in the accounts received from ceding companies and estimated premiums) correspond to the estimated premium expected at the time of writing the policy.
Estimated claims expenses are posted directly under claims reserves.
Retrocessions:
The retroceded portion of accepted reinsurance, determined according to treaties, is recorded on a separate line from accepted operations.
The share of retrocessionaires in estimates of premiums and commissions accepted is shown in the regularization account under liabilities in the balance sheet, entitled “Estimates of reinsurance retrocessions”.
Cash deposits received from retrocessionnaires are posted under liabilities in the balance sheet.
Securities remitted as collateral by reinsurers to guarantee their commitment are valued at their market value on the date of closing and are recognized as off-balance sheet items.
1.7 – Technical reserves
An unearned premium reserve is calculated, either pro rata temporis contract by contract, or using a statistical method when this yields a result close to that obtained via the contract-by-contract method.
SCOR determines the amount of claims reserve at the end of the accounting period, at a level that allows hedging of the estimated amount of its own commitments and the claims management costs for reported and unreported claims (net of estimates of recovery and subrogation. These reserves, which pertain to all claims, reported or yet to be reported, are evaluated on the basis of their ultimate cost undiscounted. Claims expense is estimated at the policy’s expiration in the light of statistical experience for similar policies.
Claims reserves, including estimated claims paid are calculated in light of expected earnings and supplement the information communicated by assigning companies.
1.8 – Transactions conducted in foreign currencies
Pursuant to the provisions of Article R. 341-7 of the Insurance Code, foreign exchange operations performed by the company are entered in their original currency.
For preparing the financial statements, balance sheet items are converted into euros at the last-known exchange rate at year-end.
Page 81 of 184

 


 

     
SCOR
  PARENT COMPANY FINANCIALS STATEMENTS     
Differences on completed transactions are recognized in income. For open positions, conversion differences are recorded as conversion adjustments under either assets or liabilities.
An allowance for currency risk is recorded for translation adjustments under either assets or liabilities.
ANALYSIS OF MAIN BALANCE SHEET ITEMS
NOTE 2 – INVESTMENTS
2.1 – Changes in investment portfolio items
                                 
 
GROSS VALUE   Gross value at     Acquisition/     Disposals and     Gross value at  
in EUR millions   start of fiscal year     creations     decommissionings     end of fiscal year  
 
Land
    33       10       1       42  
Construction
    85       4       24       65  
Shares and advances to real estate companies
    2                       2  
Shares and advances to unlisted SCIs
    83       9       8       84  
Investment securities
    2,388       277       362       2,303  
Ceding companies deposited cash (subsidiaries and affiliates)
    24       115               139  
Loans (subsidiaries and affiliates)
    191       90               281  
Other investments
    2,511       4,354       4,398       2,467  
Other ceding companies deposited cash
    203       10               213  
 
TOTAL
    5,520       4,869       4,793       5,596  
 
 
                               
 
                                 
 
DEPRECIATION AND ALLOWANCES   Depreciation/     Allocations of     Recoveries/     Depreciations/  
    allowances at     fiscal year     depreciations/     allowances at  
    beginning of           allowances     the end of  
in EUR millions   fiscal year                 fiscal year  
 
Land
            2               2  
Construction
    19       4       8       15  
Shares and advances to real estate companies
    3                       3  
Investment securities
    998       24       9       1,013  
Loans (subsidiaries and affiliates)
            72               72  
Other investments
    21               17       4  
 
TOTAL
    1,041       102       34       1,109  
Investment securities:
Annual movements in investment securities mainly concern the repurchase of minority holdings of IRP Holdings Limited (183 million) followed by a share capital reduction (350 million), and a share capital increase of SCOR U.S. (US$ 120 million, or 101 million).
Supplementary loans were granted in 2005 to CRP subsidiaries (USD 38 million, or 32 million) and SCOR VIE (30 million).
Reserves on equity investments are broken down as follows, on December 31, 2005 (in EUR millions):
           
SCOR U.S.
    585    
CRP
    358    
SCOR Italy
    52    
SCOR Germany
    13    
Others
    5    
The allowances for fiscal 2005 (24 million) mainly concern the securities of SCOR Italy (9 million) and SCOR Germany (13 million).
Ø   SCOR U.S. securities were valued according to the following methodology and hypotheses:
Specifically, the valuation of the enterprise value carried out using several methods (Net asset value (NAV) per share, Discounted cash flow), led to the valuation of the net book value.
For the Discounted Cash Flow method, the valuations were based on projections retained in the SCOR Moving Forward plan with a type A rating, for the Group and its subsidiaries, for estimating the volume of premiums underwritten for 2006 and beyond.
Page 82 of 184

 


 

     
SCOR
  PARENT COMPANY FINANCIALS STATEMENTS     
     
Furthermore, the following hypotheses were used in the valuation of SCOR U.S.:
    Repayment of part of excess capital base over 8 years, Erosion of deficits that can be carried forward over 25 years,
    DCF Method: Use of a WACC of 10%, less 3% return on share capital and a growth rate to infinity of 1%
Ø   CRP securities are funded at 100% and loans to the level of the net negative position that is 72 million.
Ø   The securities of SCOR Italy and SCOR Germany were valued as follows:
    For the valuation of subsidiaries (Net Asset Value method), the financial statements at December 31, 2005 were retained, increased by the cancelled equalization reserve, unrealized capital gains on securities and a discount on technical reserves.
Ø   Analysis conducted on other equity investments did not entail any other impairment.
2.2 – Schedule of investments
                         
   
in EUR millions   Gross value     Net value     Realization  
                    value  
 
1 – Real estate investments and real estate investments in process
    193       173       195  
- OCDE
    193       173       195  
- excluding OCDE
                       
2 - Stocks and other variable-income securities other than mutual fund shares
    2,801       1,786       2,587  
- OCDE
    2,391       1,737       2,453  
- excluding OCDE
    410       49       134  
3 - Mutual fund shares (other than those in 4)
    164       164       178  
- OCDE
    164       164       178  
- excluding OCDE
                       
4 - Mutual fund shares exclusively invested in fixed-income securities
    205       205       208  
- OCDE
    205       205       208  
- excluding OCDE
                       
5 - Bonds and other fixed-income securities
    1,592       1,581       1,574  
- OCDE
    1,584       1,573       1,566  
- excluding OCDE
    8       8       8  
6 - Mortgage loans
                       
7 - Other loans and similar bills
    289       216       216  
- OCDE
    177       104       104  
- excluding OCDE
    112       112       112  
8 - Deposits with ceding companies
    352       352       352  
- OCDE
    352       352       352  
- excluding OCDE
                       
9 - Cash deposits (other than those in 8) and security deposits
                       
10 - Assets representative of unit-linked policies
                       
- OCDE
                       
- excluding OCDE
                       
- Amortization premium/discount
            11          
11 - Total of lines 1 to 10 including
    5,596       4,487       5,310  
 
- investments valued according to Article R.332-19
    1, 540       1, 539       1, 521  
- investments valued according to Article R.332-20
    4, 056       2, 948       3, 789  
- investments valued according to Article R.332-5
                       
 
Page 83 of 184

 


 

     
SCOR
  PARENT COMPANY FINANCIALS STATEMENTS     
2.3 – Subsidiaries and affiliates
On December 31, 2005, loans and advances granted by SCOR to its subsidiaries reached 281 million (191 million as of December 31, 2004) and the loans contracted by SCOR from its subsidiaries totaled 80 million (78 million as of December 31, 2004). For 2005, SCOR recognized EURO 11.5 million in financial income on loans and EURO 1.9 million in interest on borrowings.
                                                                                                 
   
Name                                   Gross                     Receivables     Securities                    
            Share             (MO)     book     Net book     Loans     from     and (2)     Premium     Net     Dividends  
    Currency     capital     Reserves     share     value     value     and advances     issuers     guarantees     Income     income     received  
(Amounts in millions)   (MO)     (MO)     (MO)     of     ()     ()     ()     ()     given()     (MO)     (MO)     ()  
 
Subsidiary businesses
                                                                                               
 
SCOR VIE (France)
  EUR     250       134       100.00       370       370       30       52       -       1,115       42       10  
1, avenue du Général de Gaulle, 92800 Puteaux
 
                                                                                               
FERGASCOR (France)
  EUR     38       49       100.00       85       85       -       -       -       -       1       -  
1, avenue du Général de Gaulle, 92800 Puteaux
 
                                                                                               
Immobilière Sébastopol (France) (2)
  EUR     22       (2 )     100.00       22       22       -       -       -       -       1       -  
1, avenue du Général de Gaulle, 92800 Puteaux
 
                                                                                               
- SCOR Italia Riassicurazioni S.p.A (Italy)
  EUR     16       32       100.00       136       84       -       39       -       75       7       -  
Via della Moscova, 3 – 20121 Milan
 
                                                                                               
SCOR UK Group Ltd (Great Britain)
  GBP     33       1       100.00       44       44       -       -       -       -       0       15  
LUC, 3 Minster Court, Mincing Lane, UG Floor, London
 
                                                                                               
SCOR Reinsurance Asia-Pacific (Singapore);
  USD     49       47       100.00       48       48       -       1       -       67       3       -  
143 Cecil Street, HEX 20-01, GB Building, Singapore 069542
 
                                                                                               
- Commercial Risk Partners (Bermuda)
  USD     1       (9 )     100.00       358       0       112       1       49       -       (57 )     -  
The waterfront, 96 Pittsbay road, PO Box HM 440, Hamilton
 
                                                                                               
- SCOR Deutschland (Germany)
  EUR     26       44       100.00       140       127       -       -       -       109       6       -  
Seehorststrasse 3, 30175 Hanover
 
                                                                                               
SCOR US Corp. (United States)
  USD     -       713       100.00       1,057       472       133       136       523       191       (21 )     -  
199 Water Street, suite 2001 New York, NY 10038-3526, USA
 
                                                                                               
SCOR Canada Reinsurance (Canada)
  CAD     50       90       100.00       39       39       -       -       -       98       16       -  
BCE Place, 161 Bay Street, Toronto, Ontario M5J 2S1
 
                                                                                               
SCOR Auber (France)
  EUR     10       4       100.00       28       28       11       -       -       -       1       -  
1, avenue du Général de Gaulle, 92800 Puteaux
 
                                                                                               
Immoscor (France) (2)
  EUR     8       -       100.00       8       8       1       -       -       -       1       -  
1, avenue du Général de Gaulle, 92800 Puteaux
 
                                                                                               
IRP Holdings Limited (Ireland);
  EUR     1       -       100.00       1       1       -       50       -       -       12       90  
Unit 12, Beacon Court, 2nd Floor, Sandyford, Dublin 18
 
                                                                                               
Euroscor (Luxembourg)(3)
  EUR     3       -       100.00       3       3       -       -       -       -       -       -  
2 rue du Fort Wallis – L1012 Luxembourg
 
                                                                                               
TOTAL A
                                    2,339       1,331       286       279       572       -       -       118  
 
 
 
                                                                                               
 
                                                                                               
B – Affiliated businesses
                                                                                               
 
1. Detailed information about investments (+ than 10% of the share capital held directly or + than 50% in non insurance/ reinsurance activities)
 
                                                                                               
ASEFA (Spain) (3)
  EUR     10       6       39.97       6       6       -       -       -       137       7       1  
Orense 58, 28020 Madrid
 
                                                                                               
SCOR Gestion Financière (France)
  EUR     4       1       100.00       6       6       -       -       -       -       -       -  
1 avenue du Général de Gaule, 92800 Puteaux
Page 84 of 184

 


 

     
SCOR
  PARENT COMPANY FINANCIALS STATEMENTS     
                                                                                                 
   
Name                                   Gross                     Receivables     Securities                    
            Share             (MO)     book     Net book     Loans     from     and (2)     Premium     Net     Dividends  
    Currency     capital     Reserves     share     value     value     and advances     issuers     guarantees     Income     income     received  
(Amounts in millions)   (MO)     (MO)     (MO)     of     ()     ()     ()     ()     given()     (MO)     (MO)     ()  
 
                                                                                               
 
Assedile (Italy)(3)
  EUR     13       7       10.00       4       3       -       -       -       44       1       -  
Via de Togni 2, 20123 Milan
 
                                                                                               
2. General information about other subsidiaries and equity interests                                                                
 
                                                                                               
In French companies
                                            2       0               12       2                  
In non-French companies
                                            4       3               -       87                  
 
                                                                                               
TOTAL B
                                            22       18               12       89               1  
 
                                                                                               
GENERAL TOTAL
                                            2,361       1,349       2       98       368               119  
 
(1)   SCOR guarantees fully, without limitation on amounts, the technical commitments of its subsidiaries, particularly their obligations for the payment of claims
 
(2)   SCOR as the parent company is indefinitely liable for the SCI and SNC they hold (Immoscor, Sébastopol)
 
(3)   Data on the basis of the 2004 financial statements
 
 
NOTE 3 – TANGIBLE AND INTANGIBLE ASSETS
                                 
 
in EUR millions   Gross values     Acquisitions/     Disposals and     Gross values  
    at beginning of     creations     decommissionings     at end of  
    fiscal year                 fiscal year  
 
GROSS VALUES
                               
 
                               
Intangible assets
    86                       86  
 
                               
Goodwill
    70                       70  
 
                               
Set-up costs
    15                       15  
 
                               
Other intangible assets
    2                       2  
 
                               
Tangible assets
    26       1               27  
 
                               
Deposits and security bonds
    17                       17  
 
                               
Equipment, furniture, fittings and fixtures
    9       1               10  
 
                               
DEPRECIATION AND ALLOWANCES
    12       10               22  
 
                               
Other intangible assets (excluding goodwill)
    7       9               16  
 
                               
Equipment, furniture, fittings and fixtures
    5       1               6  
 
A value of 70 million for goodwill was entered in the accounts at the merger of SCOR and SOREMA S.A. in 2001.
A total of 15 million was recognized as set-up costs connected with the share capital increase on December 31, 2002 and was totally amortized at the end of 2005.
Page 85 of 184

 


 

     
SCOR
  PARENT COMPANY FINANCIALS STATEMENTS     
NOTE 4 – TRANSACTIONS WITH SUBSIDIARIES AND AFFILIATES
                                                                 
 
            2004                             2005              
in EUR millions   Subsidiaries     Affiliates     Others     Total     Subsidiaries     Affiliates     Others     Total  
 
HOLDINGS AND ACCOUNTS RECEIVABLE (Gross)
                                                               
 
Investments
    2,633       47       2,840       5,520       2,752       47       2,797       5,596  
. Real estate
    75       1       127       203       75       1       117       193  
. Shares other than variable revenue securities and bonds
    2,365       24       2,504       4,893       2,288       15       2,459       4,762  
. Loans
    191               6       197       281               8       289  
. Cash deposits with ceding companies
    2       22       203       227       108       31       213       352  
 
                                                               
Share reinsurance technical reserves
    319               380       699       14               418       432  
 
                                                               
Accounts receivable
    34       3       371       408       225       4       391       620  
. Accounts receivable from reinsurance transactions
    3       3       161       167       146       4       173       323  
. Other accounts receivable
    31               210       241       79               218       297  
 
                                                               
Accrued income and deferred charges
    (16 )     39       382       405       (71 )     56       371       356  
 
. Deferred acquisition costs
    5       22       75       102       7       31       66       104  
. Other reinsurance acceptance operations
    (21 )     17       273       269       (79 )     25       271       217  
. Other accruals and prepaid expenses
                    34       34       1               34       35  
 
 
 
                                                               
LIABILITIES
                                                               
 
                                                               
Gross underwriting reserves
    868       77       2,829       3,774       1,018       103       2,908       4,029  
 
                                                               
Liabilities for cash deposits
    254               60       314                       52       52  
 
                                                               
Other liabilities
    150               1,054       1,204       92               903       995  
 
. Liabilities arising from reinsurance operations
    72               48       120       12               76       88  
. Financial liabilities
    78               908       986       80               705       785  
. Other creditors
                    98       98                       122       122  
 
                                                               
Accrued liabilities
    70               28       98                       48       48  
. Deferred retrocession, acquisition costs
    19               4       23                       2       2  
Other retrocession reinsurance transactions,
    51               13       64                       33       33  
Other accruals
                    11       11                       13       13  
 
Liabilities other than financial borrowings and accounts receivable mature in less than one year. Long-term financial liabilities consist of an OCEANE loan for 200 million, the characteristics of which are described in the chapter entitled “Information concerning the Company’s share capital,” a perpetual loan of 50 million, two subordinate loans of US$ 100 million et 100 million and a five-year senior debt of 200 million.
Page 86 of 184

 


 

     
SCOR   PARENT COMPANY FINANCIALS STATEMENTS
NOTE 5 – SHAREHOLDERS’ EQUITY
The common stock at December 31, 2005 consisted of 968,769,070 shares and amounted to 763,096,714.
                         
 
in EUR millions   2004 shareholders’     Movements for the year     2005 shareholders’ equity  
    capital after             before appropriation  
    appropriation                  
 
Share capital
    645       118       763  
Additional paid-in capital
    12       106       118  
Re-valuation reserves
                 
Other reserves
    14               14  
Capitalization reserves
    121       3       124  
Retained earnings
            3       3  
Net income
            57       57  
TOTAL
    792       287       1,079  
 
    The profit for fiscal 2004, 12.7 million, increased by a share premium writeback of 13.7 million, was appropriated as follows: 0.6 million to the statutory reserve; 1.4 million as retained earnings; and the balance of 24.4 million paid in dividends.
 
    The share capital increase of January 7, 2005 in the amount of 233 million was allocated as follows: 118 million to common stock and the balance of 115 million, as well as expenses for this increase (-9 million) to the share premium.
NOTE 6 – CONTINGENCY RESERVES
The contingency reserves amounted to 44 million, of which:
    12.5 million for stock-option plans,
    18.3 million in reserves for benefits (retirement allowances, severance pay, supplementary retirement and long-service awards),
    10.5 million in restructuring reserves in the framework of the Employment Safeguard Plan,
    1.3 million in reserves for contingencies and currency exchange losses,
    0.8 million in reserves for taxes
Notice 2004-05 of March 25, 2004 from the CNC requires the recognition of a provision for service awards as of fiscal year 2004: The valuation of this provision amounted to 3.2 million at the end of 2005.
The total amount paid or set aside by the Company for the departures of SCOR directors in 2005 was 3,979,558.
Note 7 – Assets – Liabilities by currency
                                 
 
Currency   Assets     Liabilities     Surplus     Surplus  
in EUR millions   2005     2005     2005     2004  
 
Euro
    4,235       4,215       20       177  
Pound sterling
    105       95       10       (6 )
Swiss franc
    40       23       17       6  
Japanese yen
    4       11       (7 )     (15 )
Australian dollar
    3       25       (22 )     (2 )
Canadian dollar
    67       41       26       18  
US dollar
    1,602       1,417       185       41  
Norwegian crown
    24       19       5       (20 )
Danish crown
    5       30       (25 )     (18 )
Swedish crown
    6       20       (14 )     (20 )
Other currencies
    180       375       (195 )     (161 )
 
 
Total
    6,271       6,271       0       0  
 
ANALYSIS OF THE MAIN INCOME STATEMENT ITEMS
NOTE 8 – ANALYSIS OF GROSS PREMIUMS BY GEOGRAPHIC AREA (RISK COUNTRY)
                 
 
in EUR millions   2004     2005  
 
France
    176       180  
Europe except France
    367       409  
North America
    42       94  
South America
    37       45  
Far East
    50       99  
Rest of the world
    129       150  
 
TOTAL
    801       977  
 

Page 87 of 184


 

     
SCOR   PARENT COMPANY FINANCIALS STATEMENTS
NOTE 9 – ANALYSIS OF INVESTMENT INCOME AND EXPENSES BY KIND
                                                 
 
in EUR millions   2004     2005  
     
    Subsidiaries     Others     Total     Subsidiaries     Others     Total  
 
Revenues from securities
    83       58       141       118       56       174  
Revenues from real estate investments
    12       19       31       1       19       20  
Revenues from other investments
    8       18       26       21       15       36  
Other gains
            195       195               36       36  
Profits from realization
            42       42               50       50  
 
Total investment income
    103       332       435       140       176       316  
 
 
                                               
Management costs and financial costs
    9       49       58       2       50       52  
Other investment expenses
    260       33       293       94       34       128  
Losses on realization
            12       12       52       31       83  
 
Total investment expenses
    269       94       363       148       115       263  
 
The income (or loss) from operations on financial instruments (rate swaps, exchange options) is recognized in investment income for a net amount of — 2 million en 2005 against — 4 million en 2004. Furthermore, currency exchange operations resulted in a loss of — 12 million in 2005 versus a profit of 181 million in 2004.
Dividends received from subsidiaries amounted to 118 million, 90 million of which came from IRP Holdings Limited, whose share capital reduction generated a disposal capital loss of 52 million.
An additional depreciation on investment securities of 22 million was recognized for SCOR Italia ( 9 million) and SCOR Deutschland ( 13 million).
The CRP loans were written down to the level of the subsidiary’s net negative position, i.e., 72 million.
NOTE 10 – ANALYSIS OF OPERATING EXPENSES BY KIND
                 
 
in EUR millions   2004     2005  
 
Salaries
    27       27  
Retirement pensions
    4       4  
Benefits
    8       9  
Others
    5       5  
   
Total personnel expenses
    44       45  
   
Other general expenses
    69       71  
   
Total general expenses by kind
    113       116  
 
Work force
               
   
Executives
    325       331  
Employees/ Supervisors
    131       119  
 
Total current workforce
    456       450  
 
The cumulative remuneration paid in 2005 to SCOR directors amounted to 3,639,008.
NOTE 11 – ANALYSIS OF INCOME TAX
SCOR Group is a tax-consolidated group, with SCOR as its leading company, and SCOR VIE, SGF, FERGASCOR, Eurofinimo, Finimofrance, SCOR Auber, Navi Partenaires and Société Putéolienne de Participations as its subsidiaries. Under the tax agreement, SCOR benefits from the deficits of its subsidiaries, and tax benefits are transferred back to the individual subsidiary concerned, if that company becomes profitable again at some future date.
Tax deficits and long-term capital losses accumulated by the French-consolidated Group reached 963 million et 893 million respectively, on December 31, 2005.

Page 88 of 184


 

     
SCOR PARENT COMPANY FINANCIALS STATEMENTS    
NOTE 12 – STOCK OPTIONS
                                                                                                                         
 
  Plan     Date of     Date of       Date options       Expiry       Number of       Number of       Number       Of which       Subscription       Number of       Number       Number of    
        General     Board of       made available       Date of       beneficiaries       options       of which,       the first       or purchase       shares       of options       options    
        Meeting     Directors                 Plans                 granted       to Group       ten       price in       bought or       cancelled       outstanding    
              meeting                                               Directors       granted to                 subscribed       during       at    
                                                                          employees                           period       31/12/2005*    
 
1992
    24/06/1992       28/09/1992       Closed     Closed         76         318,800         42,000         54,000                                      
 
1994
    09/05/1994       09/05/1994       Closed     Closed         104         429,000         59,000         64,000                                      
 
1995
    09/05/1995       15/05/1995       Closed     Closed         99         430,000         82,000         68,000                           192,782            
 
1996
    13/05/1996       05/09/1996       5 sept. 1997 (30%)       04/09/2006         122         480,000         83,000         70,000         11,7                 42,096         661,689    
 
 
                    5 sept. 1998 (30%)                                                                                            
 
 
                    5 sept. 1999 (30%)                                                                                            
 
1997
    12/05/1997       04/09/1997       4 sept. 2002       03/09/2007         113         481,500         112,000         72,000         15,03                   59,429         806,014    
 
1998
    12/05/1998       03/09/1998       4 sept. 2003       03/09/2008         134         498,000         130,000         71,500         22,72                   76,764         860,496    
 
1999
    06/05/1999       02/09/1999       3 sept. 2004       02/09/2009         145         498,500         130,000         71,000         18,58                   86,667         817,168    
 
2000
    06/05/1999       04/05/2000       05-mai-04       03/05/2010         1,116         111,600         600         1,000         19,39                   25,647         161,601    
 
2000
    06/05/1999       31/08/2000       1 sept. 2005       30/08/2010         137         406,500         110,000         63,000         18,17                   86,420         675,049    
 
2001
    19/04/2001       04/09/2001       4 sept.2005       02/10/2011         162         560,000         150,000         77,000         19,39                   137,430         1,000,418    
 
2001
    19/04/2001       03/10/2001       4 oct.2005       02/10/2011         1,330         262,000         1,200         2,000         13,73                   60,137         385,175    
 
 
          Totals                                     4,475,900         899,800         613,500                                            
              Totals recalculated after the increase of share capital of December 31, 2002       11,088,489         2,229,143         1,519,870                                            
 
2003
    04/18/2002       02/28//2003       Feb. 28 2007       02/27/2013         65         1,435,688         655,233         247,532         2,86                 104,840         1,170,713    
 
2003
    04/18/2002       06/03//2003       June-03 - 07       06/02/2013         1,161         2,266,927         420,441         177,787         3,94                 2,026,386         1,628,777    
              Attributions sous condition de ROE non réalisées (1)       2,266,929         420,441         177,787                                            
 
 
          Tataux                                                                                                      
              Totals recalculated after the increase of share capital of January 7, 2004       17,058,033         3,725,259         2,122,975                                            
 
2004
    05/18/2004     Aug 25     Aug -26-08       08/25/2014         171         5,990,000         1,335,000         920,000         1,14                 450,000         5,540,000    
 
2005
    05/31//2005     Aug 31     Sept..-16- 2009       09/16/2015         219         7,260,000         1,650,000         1,420,000         1,66                 255,000         7,005,000    
              Totals as at December 31, 2005       30,308,033         6,710,259         4,462,975                             3,603,598         20,712,100    
 
(1)   Half of the options granted in June 2003 were subject to the condition of the realization of a return on the Group’s capital base of above 10% for fiscal 2003 and 12% for fiscal 2004. As those conditions were not met, the options were cancelled.

Page 89 of 184


 

     
SCOR   PARENT COMPANY FINANCIALS STATEMENTS
Following the share capital increase on December 31, 2002, the Company has adjusted the price of the shares covered by granted options and the number of shares under option, pursuant to Articles L225-181 of the French Commercial Code and of D174-8 of the March 23, 1967 Decree.
The price of shares under option, as set prior to this operation, has been reduced by an amount equal to the product of this price multiplied by the ratio between a) the value of the preferential subscription right and b) the value of the share prior to removal of this right, i.e.:
Former offer price * value of the preferential share right (average of listed prices during the subscription period)
 
Value of the share after clipping of the share right (average of the initial prices listed during the subscription period) + value of the preferential share right
Because the initial value of the option is supposed to remain constant, the new number of shares eligible for subscription is equal to the initial value of the option divided by the new offer price, i.e.:
    Initial number of options * former offer price    
New offer price as defined above
These calculations have been performed individually and by plan, and rounded up to the nearest unit.
The same calculations have been applied after the share capital increase of January 7, 2004.
The table below summarizes the status of the various option plans for 2005:
                                 
Status on December 31, 2005  
    Exercise price     Balance of exercisable     Number of cancelled     Balance of  
    (in )     options at end of 2004     rights in 2005     exercisable options  
                            end 2005  
1995
    6.59       192,782       192,782        
   
1996
    11.7       703,785       42,096       661,689  
   
1997
    15.03       865,443       59,429       806,014  
   
1998
    22.72       937,260       76,764       860,496  
   
1999
    18.58       903,835       86,667       817,168  
   
2000
    19.39       187,248       25,647       161,601  
   
2000
    18.17       761,469       86,420       675,049  
   
2001
    19.39       1,137,848       137,430       1,000,418  
   
2001
    13.73       445,312       60,137       385,175  
   
2003
    2.86       1,275,553       104,840       1,170,713  
   
2003
    3.94       3,655,163       2,026,386       1,628,777  
   
2004
    1.14       5,990,000       450,000       5,540,000  
   
2005 (1)
    1.66                   7,005,000  
 
Total
            17,055,698       3,410,816       20,712,100  
 
(1)   out of the 7,260,000 options granted in 2005, 255,000 were cancelled due to the departure of certain beneficiaries
The option plans for the years 1995 to 1997, 2003 and 2005 are share subscription plans giving rise to an increase in the share capital. The other plans provide for the purchase of existing shares.
There are no stock option plans providing for the purchase of or subscription to shares in Group subsidiaries.
NOTE 13 – EMPLOYEE SHARE-OWNERSHIP PLANS
13.1 – Employee profit-sharing and incentive plan agreements
Under these agreements, employees of SCOR and certain subsidiaries are entitled to invest the amounts due to them under the profit-sharing and incentive plans in a closed-end investment fund entirely invested in SCOR stock.
                                                 
 
In EUR thousands   1999     2000     2001     2002     2003     2004  
 
Amount distributed under the profit-sharing plan
    1,271       7,479       4,053       0       0       439  
Amount distributed under the collective incentive plan
    0       3,029       0       0       0       1,688  
 
An estimate of the employees’ 2005 collective incentive and profit-sharing plans was recognized in the accounts for 2,404,000 and 3,723,000, respectively.

Page 90 of 184


 

     
SCOR   PARENT COMPANY FINANCIALS STATEMENTS
13.2 – Amount paid into corporate employee savings plan:
                                                 
 
in EUR thousands   2000     2001     2002     2003     2004     2005  
 
Collective incentive plan *
    0       2 008       0       0       0       822  
Profit sharing *
    489       1 360       627       0       0       60  
 
Voluntary payments
    970       266       713       208       264       144  
Total payments
    1,459       3,634       1,340       208       264       1,026  
Increase
    699       1,289       667       181       313       584  
 
*   for the previous fiscal year
NOTE 14 – SUMMARY OF INCOME (LOSS) OVER LAST FIVE YEARS
                                         
 
YEARLY INDICATIONS   2001     2002     2003     2004     2005  
 
FINANCIAL POSITION (in EUR millions)
                                       
Share capital
    157       520       136       645       763  
Number of shares issued
    41,244,216       136,544 845       136,544 845       819,269 070       968,769 070  
OPERATIONS AND INCOME
                                       
Premium income before taxes
                                       
Gross premiums written
    2,522       2,834       1,584       801       977  
Investment income
    360       387       350       435       316  
Income before taxes, depreciation and non-technical reserves
    (210 )     (552 )     (123 )     304       146  
Tax on profits
    0.4       (10 )     0       4       23  
Income after taxes, depreciation and reserves
    (233 )     (784 )     (697 )     13       57  
Amount of benefits distributed
    11                         24  
EARNINGS PER SHARE (in )
                                       
Net earnings before depreciation and non-technical reserves
    (5.09 )     (3.97 )     (0.90 )     0.38       0.19  
Earnings after taxes, depreciation and reserves
    (5.65 )     (5.74 )     (5.11 )     0.02       0.06  
Net dividend allocated per share
    0.30                           0.03  
PERSONNEL
                                       
Workforce
    686       653       504       456       450  
Payroll amount
    41       36       32       27       27  
Sums spent for social security expenses and benefits
    18       17       15       12       13  
 
NOTE 15 – ANALYSIS OF COMMITMENTS GIVEN AND RECEIVED
                                                   
       
in EUR millions   Commitments received       Commitments given  
    2003     2004     2005       2003     2004     2005  
       
Ordinary business operations ( note 15.1)
    1,354       486       875         4,177       2,301       2,753  
 
                                                 
Financial instruments ( note 15.1.1)
    521       119       365         484       119       365  
Confirmed credits, letters of credit and guarantees given (note 15.1.2)
    726       268       458         2,791       531       820  
Other commitments given and received (note 15.1.3)
    107       99       52         902       1,651       1,568  
 
                                                 
Hybrid transactions (note 15.2)
    204       188       166         102       94       83  
       
       
Total
    1,558       674       1,041         4,279       2,395       2,836  
       

Page 91 of 184


 

     
SCOR   PARENT COMPANY FINANCIALS STATEMENTS
15.1 COMMITMENTS RECEIVED AND GIVEN IN THE ORDINARY BUSINESS OPERATIONS
15.1.1 — Financial instruments given and received
The use and recording of hedges complies with the French General Statement of Accounting Principles (“Plan Comptable Général”) of 1982 and French Decree N° 2002-970 dated July 4, 2002, relating to the use of hedges by French insurance companies.
Such hedges may consist of foreign rate and currency swaps, caps and floors, currency futures contracts, together with puts and calls on equities and fixed-income securities.
Income and losses in the form of interest or premiums are recorded pro rata temporis over the lifetime of the contracts. Commitments given and received recorded at closing date reflect the nominal amount of current transactions.
                                                   
       
in EUR millions   Commitments received       Commitments given
    2003     2004     2005       2003     2004     2005  
       
Rate swaps
    92       44       41         92       44       41  
Caps and floors
    75       75       75         75       75       75  
Currency futures purchases/sales
    354       0       249         317       0       249  
       
       
Total
    521       119       365         484       119       365  
       
15.1.2 — Confirmed credits, letters of credit and guarantees received and given
                                                   
       
in EUR millions   Commitments received       Commitments given
    2003     2004     2005       2003     2004     2005  
       
Confirmed credits
    50             100                      
Letters of credit
    676       268       358         621       230       337  
Investment securities pledged to financial institutions
                            854       206       328  
Investment shares pledged to financial institutions
                            1,189              
Real estate mortgages
                            30              
Other guarantees given to financial institutions
                            97       95       155  
                                                   
Total
    726       268       458         2,791       531       820  
       
SCOR has signed an agreement with different financial institutions concerning the granting of letters of credit for EURO 358 million.
15.1.2.1 Letters of credit received
The commitments received for letters of credit in the amount of EURO 358 million correspond to agreements signed with BNP (USD 115 million and EURO 7 million), Deutsche Bank (US$ 180 million) and Natexis (US$ 120 million).
The commitments received from BNP and Deutsche Bank are covered by pledges on OAT securities (158 million for each bank).
The agreement with Natexis for EURO 101 million primarily concerns our commitments for the claims generated by the World Trade Center disaster, 100% collateralized, i.e. US$ 120 million (other guarantees given).
15.1.2.2 Letters of credit given
In consideration for technical reserves, SCOR has given commitment for letters of credit in the amount of EURO 337 million to the benefit of the ceding companies, to be compared with a total of EURO 358 million in letters of credit received from the banks.

Page 92 of 184


 

     
SCOR   PARENT COMPANY FINANCIALS STATEMENTS
15.1.3 Other commitments given and received
                                                   
       
in EUR millions   Commitments received       Commitments given
    2003     2004     2005       2003     2004     2005  
       
Commercial paper
                                                 
Performance bond
                                                 
Mortgages
    1       1                                    
Leases for leased buildings
    60       52       44                            
Guarantees and securities
    46       46       8         48       47       9  
Underwriting commitments
                              7       5       21  
Assets pledged to ceding companies
                              761       1,523       1,480  
Contract termination indemnities
                              1       1       1  
Real estate lease
                              85       75       57  
       
       
Total
    107       99       52         902       1,651       1,568  
       
Securities pledged with ceding companies in consideration for technical commitments total EURO 1,480 million, including EURO 952 million in assets pledged to ceding companies, and EURO 529 million to subsidiaries (SCOR US EURO 522 million in Trust Funds, CRP EURO 7 million).
The financial building leases (EURO 57 million given versus EURO 44 million received) concern:
  -   an office building in Paris (London Budapest). At the end of 2005, the commitment made represented EURO 46 million for a commitment received of EURO 38 million
  -   a warehouse in Chilly-Mazarin, with a commitment for EURO 11 million at the end of 2005 with a commitment of EURO 6 million received
The security deposit given to KanAm, owner of the SCOR building, within the framework of the rental contract, was reduced in 2005 because of the rise in the Standard & Poor’s rating to A-, dropping from 46 million to 8 million.
Similarly, the joint surety of HSBC was reduced from 51 million to 9 million.
15-2 Commitments given and received in respect of hybrid transactions
                                                   
       
in EUR millions   Commitments received       Commitments given
    2003     2004     2005       2003     2004     2005  
       
Asset SWAP (Horizon)
    102       94       83         102       94       83  
Index default swap (Horizon)
    102       94       83                        
 
   
Total
    204       188       166         102       94       83  
       
In 2002, SCOR placed a EURO 130 million index-linked defeasance vehicle on the financial markets, designed to reduce the Group’s credit reinsurance risk profile. This defeasance vehicle is fully guaranteed by triple A-rated assets.
No facts in connection with the aforementioned commitments given and received have come to our knowledge that may have an adverse impact on cash streams, or on our need for funds. In the best knowledge of the Company, there was, as at December 31, 2005, no other outstanding significant financial commitment requested by a Group entity within the framework of the procedures described above.
NOTE 16 – LITIGATION
  -   Beginning in October 2001, various lawsuits were brought and cross claims filed to determine whether the terrorist attack on the World Trade Center (WTC) on September 11, 2001 constituted one or two occurences under the terms of the applicable coverage issued to the lessees of the WTC and others parties. Although SCOR, as a reinsurer, is not a party to such lawsuits, the ceding company Allianz Global Risks U.S. Insurance Company (Allianz), which insured a portion of the WTC, and which is reinsured by SCOR, is a party to the legal action.
 
      The first two phases of the trial were completed in 2004. At the end of the first phase, the court ruled that nine of the twelve insurers involved were bound by the definition of the term “occurence” that as a matter of law has been found to mean that the attack on the WTC constituted one occurence. Allianz did not participate in that first phase, but has participated in the second phase of the trialon December 6, 2004. The New York jury named in the second phase of the litigation determined that the attack on the WTC towers on September 11, 2001 constituted two occurences under the terms of the property insurance coverages issued by Allianz and by eight other insurers of the WTC towers.

Page 93 of 184


 

     
SCOR   PARENT COMPANY FINANCIALS STATEMENTS
      SCOR, a reinsurer of Allianz, considers the jury verdict to be contrary to the terms of the insurance coverage in force and to the intent of the parties. SCOR fully supported Allianz, in its efforts to overturn the verdict. The jury verdict has been appealed to the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Second Circuit and a decision is expected in 2006.
 
      The verdict in the second phase of the litigation did not determine the amount of damages owed by the insurers. A separate, court-supervised appraisal procedure is in progress to determine the amount owed by the insurers for the damages resulting from the destruction of the WTC towers. The final decision from the appraisal procedure is expected at the end of 2006 or early in 2007.
 
      In the Group’s original calculations of its technical reserves, the WTC attack was treated as one occurrence for purposes of the underlying insurance coverage since the terrorist attack on September 11, 2001 was a single, coordinated occurence. As a result of the jury verdict described above in the second phase of the trial, the Group has increased the reserves based on the initial replacement value established by the ceding company. The gross amount of reserves has accordingly been increased from USD 355 million as of December 31, 2003 to USD 422 million as of December 31, 2004, and net of retrocession from USD 167.5 million to USD 193.5 million. These amounts did not change significantly in 2005. In addition, the Company issued two letters of credit for a total amount of USD 145,320,000 to Allianz on December 27, 2004, as required by Allianz to guarantee payment to the ceding company if the jury verdict is not reversed by the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Second Circuit or if the appraisal process placed under court supervision in 2005 results in an increase in the amounts to be paid in the future.
 
      Allianz has instituted an arbitration proceeding against the Company in order to clarify the extent of the Company’s obligations under the reinsurance treaty entered into with it. The arbitration proceedings has been stayed by the court responsible for evaluating the damages pending certain events related to the second phase of the lawsuit. The arbitration proceeding has not been reactivated.
 
  -   The Group is also involved in various arbitration proceedings relating to the underwriting business, now in run off, primarily relating to the Bond risk. See Section 6.5 – Notes to the parent company financial statements– Note 16.
 
  -   Certain Highfields Funds—Highfields Capital LTD, Highfields Capital I LP and Highfields Capital II LP (the “Highfields Funds”), as minority shareholders of IRP Holdings Limited, in March 2004 have filed a complaint against SCOR in the District Court of the State of Massachusetts. The complaint alleges raud and violations of Massachusetts law with regard to the acquisition by the Highfields Funds of a stake in IRP Holdings Limited in December 2001. The damages (including punitive damages) owed, if any, cannot be calculated as of this date and will be determined by the Court at the end of the trial which is scheduled to begin in May 2007. On September 28, 2005, the District Court of the State of Massachusetts rejected SCOR’s motion to dismiss and issued an order scheduling the timing of discovery and the trial. The discovery procedure has commenced and is scheduled to proceed until March 2007 based on the calendar set by the Court. The trial is scheduled to start in May 2007.
 
  -   In February 2006, SCOR received an arbitration notice from the “captive” of a pharmaceutical laboratory concerning the settlement of a claim under civil liability for a laboratory product. SCOR denied owing this amount and claims that the captive is not required to indemnify the pharmaceutical laboratory. The maximum potential commitment of SCOR is USD 17.5 million.
 
  -   The French Autorité des Marchés Financiers (AMF), initiated an investigation on October 21, 2004 in connection with the financial information and trading activity surrounding the issue of the SCOR OCEANE bonds in July 2004. The Company has received no additional information about this investigation to date.
 
  -   The AMF also initiated an investigation on October 5, 2005 concerning the market for the SCOR share as of June 1, 2005.
 
  -   Since February 2005, the SCOR company has been the subject of an accounting audit for the period from January 1, 2002 to December 31, 2003. On December 21, 2005, this audit resulted in an initial adjustment proposal, excluding late penalties, for an additional assessment for the corporate income tax base for 2002 of 26,870,073.77, an assessment for the withholding stipulated by Article 119 bis 2 of the General Tax Code of 5,788,871 and an additional assessment for the employer’s payroll tax of 27,891. The Company has challenged this adjustment proposal. This proposal, which interrupts the statute of limitations, will be followed in 2006 with a definitive proposal also covering fiscal 2003.
NOTE 17 – POST BALANCE SHEET EVENTS
None

Page 94 of 184


 

     
SCOR   PARENT COMPANY FINANCIALS STATEMENTS
6.6 General Report of the statutory auditors on the non-consolidated financial statements
This is a free translation into English of the statutory auditors’ report issued in the French language and is provided solely for the convenience of English speaking readers. This report includes information specifically required by French law in all audit reports, whether qualified or not, and this is presented below the opinion on the financial statements. This information includes explanatory paragraphs discussing the auditors’ assessments of certain significant accounting matters. These assessments were made for the purpose of issuing an opinion on the financial statements taken as a whole and not to provide separate assurance on individual account captions or on information taken outside of the annual financial statements. The report also includes information relating to the specific verification of information in the management report.
This report, together with the statutory auditors’ report addressing financial and accounting information in the Chairman’s report on internal control, should be read in conjunction with, and is construed in accordance with French law and professional auditing standards applicable in France.
To the Shareholders
In compliance with the assignment entrusted to us by your shareholders’ annual general meeting, we hereby report to you, for the year ended December 31, 2005, on:
o   the audit of the accompanying annual financial statements of Company,
 
o   the justification of our assessments,
 
o   the specific verifications and information required by law.
These financial statements have been approved by the Board of Directors. Our role is to express an opinion on these financial statements based on our audit.
I - Opinion on the financial statements
We conducted our audit in accordance with the professional standards applicable in France; those standards require that we plan and perform the audit to obtain reasonable assurance about whether the financial statements are free of material misstatement. An audit includes examining, on a test basis, evidence supporting the amounts and disclosures in the financial statements. An audit also includes assessing the accounting principles used and significant estimates made by the management, as well as evaluating the overall financial statements presentation. We believe that our audit provides a reasonable basis for our opinion.
In our opinion, the financial statements present fairly, in all material respects, the financial position of the Company as of December 31, 2005, and the results of its operations for the year then ended in accordance with the accounting rules and principles applicable in France.
Without qualifying our opinion, we draw attention to the matter discussed in Note 1.21 to the financial statements relating to the change in accounting method related to the accounting of assets broken down into technical components in application of “règlement CRC n° 2002-10 du Comité de la Réglementation Comptable”.
II - Justification of our assessments
In accordance with the requirements of article L. 823-9 of the French Company Law (Code de commerce) relating to the justification of our assessments, we bring to your attention the following matters:
o Within the framework of our assessment of the accounting rules and policies applied by the Company, we are satisfied with the fact that the change in accounting method mentioned above and its presentation in the consolidated financial statements were adequate.
o As stated in notes 1.6 and 1.8 to the financial statements, the technical accounts specific to reinsurance are estimated on the basis of reinsurance commitments or on statistical and actuarial bases, particularly in case of accounts not received from ceding companies, accrued assets and liabilities, and technical reserves. The methods used to compute these estimates are described in the notes to the financial statements.
Our audit work consisted in assessing the data and assumptions on which the estimates are based, especially those used by the internal actuaries, reviewing the company’s calculations, comparing estimated accounts from prior periods with actual outturns, and examining senior management’s procedures for approving these estimates. Our work enabled us to assess that the data and assumptions used provide a reasonable basis for the estimates.
o Notes 1.21 to 1.22 and 2.1 to the financial statements describe the policies and methods used to update the valuation of real estate investments, investments in subsidiaries and affiliates, derivatives instruments and corresponding impairments. We have assessed the approaches used by the Company in valuating these assets, described in the notes to the financial statements, and, based on the information available for our audit, we have conducted tests to verify the application of these methods and the consistency of the assumptions with forecast data established by the Company.
Our work enabled us to assess that the methods and assumptions used provide a reasonable basis for the valuations.
o Note 6 to the financial statements describes the policies and methods used to update estimates of pension liabilities and similar benefits. These benefits are estimated by internal and external actuaries. Our work consisted in assessing the data

Page 95 of 184


 

     
SCOR   PARENT COMPANY FINANCIALS STATEMENTS
and assumptions on which the estimates are based, reviewing the Company’s calculations and verifying that the information in note 6 to the consolidated financial statements is appropriate.
Our work enabled us to assess that the data and assumptions used provide a reasonable basis for the estimates made.
o With respect to risks and litigations, we have obtained assurance that the Company’s procedures allow these to be satisfactorily identified, evaluated and reflected in the financial statements. We have also obtained assurance that possible uncertainties identified in applying this approach are described as appropriate in notes 6 and 16 to the financial statements.
The assessments were thus made in the context of the performance of our audit of the financial statements taken as a whole and therefore contributed to the formation of our audit opinion expressed in the first part of this report.
III — Specific verifications and information
We have also performed the specific verifications required by law in accordance with professional standards applicable in France.
We have no matters to report regarding the fair presentation and the conformity with the financial statements of the information given in the Directors’ Report, and in the documents addressed to the shareholders with respect to the financial position and the financial statements.
     
Paris, March 24, 2006
   
 
   
Statutory Auditors
   
 
   
ERNST & YOUNG AUDIT
  MAZARS & GUERARD
Pierre PLANCHON
  Lionel GOTLIB
 
  Jean Luc BARLET

Page 96 of 184


 

7. GENERAL INFORMATION ABOUT THE COMPANY AND ITS SHARE CAPITAL
7.1 REGISTERED NAME AND CORPORATE HEADQUARTERS
SCOR
1, avenue du Général de Gaulle
92800 PUTEAUX
Tel.: +33 (0)1 46 98 70 00
Fax: +33 (0)1 47 67 04 09
www.scor.com
E-mail: scor@scor.com
7.2 REGULATORY ENVIRONMENT AND APPLICABLE LEGISLATION
SCOR is a French société anonyme (joint stock company) governed by French legislation on corporations, subject to specific provisions applicable to it as a company engaged in reinsurance. Since law n° 94-679 of August 8, 1994, reinsurance companies in France are subject to State control under the conditions defined in Book III of the French Insurance Code.
The terms and scope of this control were considerably reinforced by law No. 2001-420 of May 15, 2001. For example, the law introduced the main provisions below:
  the institution of a prior authorization procedure for French companies whose exclusive business is reinsurance, before they are permitted to engage in this business. However, as the application texts were not adopted, this procedure has not yet come into effect;
 
  possibility for the French Insurance Control Commission (A.C.A.M.) to send warnings when a company infringes on a legislative or regulatory provision applicable to it;
 
  introduction of new sanctions to be inflicted by the A.C.A.M. on reinsurance companies when they infringe on a legislative or regulatory provision applicable to it;
 
  possibility of withdrawing an approval in case of extended inactivity, failure to maintain a balance between the company’s financial means and its activity or, if general interest requires, substantial modification in the company’s stock ownership or governing bodies.
At the present time, there is no European framework of regulations harmonizing the conditions for carrying out reinsurance activities in the member states of the Community. On November 16, 2005, Directive No. 2005/68/EC was adopted by the European Parliament and the Council. This directive introduces for reinsurance companies located in the Union: (i) a single approval system granted by the regulating authority of the State in which the company headquarters are located, an approval recognized in all EU member States, as well as (ii) financial oversight by that same authority. Furthermore, this directive sets the rules relating to the solvency of reinsurance companies located in the Community, thus aiming to harmonize the prudential controls which regulate these companies. The provisions of the directive must be transposed into the legislations of the different member States no later than December 10, 2007. During this same period, companies already engaged in reinsurance activities must conform to the provisions of the directive relating to the performance of their activities. Nevertheless, at the transposition of the directive, the legislators of the different member States may grant an additional 12 month period (i.e., until December 10, 2008) to businesses already engaged in reinsurance activities, to allow them to conform to certain of the provisions, notably those related to requirements in matters of technical reserves, the solvency margin and guarantee funds.
In the United States, the Group’s reinsurance and insurance subsidiaries are regulated primarily by the insurance regulators in the State in which they are domiciled, but they are also subject to regulation in each State in which they are authorized or licensed. SCOR Reinsurance Company, the Group’s principal Non-Life subsidiary in the United States, is domiciled in New York State and SCOR Life U.S. Reinsurance Company, the principal Life insurance subsidiary in the United States, is domiciled in Texas. The Group’s other subsidiaries in the United States are domiciled in Arizona, Delaware, Texas and Vermont, and one subsidiary is also commercially domiciled in California.
Solvency Margin
In the reinsurance industry, the solvency margin is defined as the ratio between shareholders’ equity and net premiums, and serves to indicate the amount of capital base required to underwrite reinsurance treaties.
The book solvency margin is defined as the ratio to book shareholders’ equity, while the economic solvency margin also comprises certain components of long-term borrowing that qualify for inclusion in equity.

Page 97 of 184


 

Even though to date, there is no regulatory minimum solvency margin defined in the reinsurance sector in the European Union (except in the United Kingdom), European reinsurance companies consider appropriate economic solvency margins of between 40% and 50% of net written premiums. This ratio is between 80% and 100% for American reinsurance providers. In light of the loss registered in 2003, the Group’s solvency margin has been reduced. But, following the share capital increases in 2002, 2004 and 2005 and the reduction in premium income, the solvency margin very clearly improved in 2004 and 2005.
7.3 DATE OF FORMATION AND DATE OF EXPIRATION
- Formed: on August 16, 1855 under the name Compagnie Générale des Voitures de Paris; name changed to SCOR S.A. on October 16, 1989, and to SCOR on May 13, 1996.
- Expiration: June 30, 2024 unless otherwise extended or previously dissolved.
7.4 CORPORATE PURPOSE (Art. 3 of the bylaws):
The Company’s corporate purpose is, either directly or indirectly, and in all countries:
a.   to conduct reinsurance business or retrocession of all types, in all branches and in all countries; to assume, in whatever form, reinsurance treaties or commitments for all French or foreign companies, agencies, enterprises or associations, and to create, acquire, rent, lease, install and operate all establishments connected with these activities;
 
b.   to build, rent, operate and purchase all buildings;
 
c.   to acquire and manage all securities and other equity rights, by all means, and in particular by means of subscription, contributions of acquired equity securities, bonds, equity interests, partnerships or other equity rights;
 
d.   to acquire equity investments or interests in all companies and in all industrial, commercial, agricultural, financial, securities or real estate companies, the creation of all companies, contributions to all share capital increases, mergers, split-offs and partial contributions;
 
e.   to administer, operate, and manage all companies or corporations, direct or indirect participation in all transactions carried out by these companies or enterprises, by all means, and notably in all companies or equity interests;
 
    and, in general, all industrial, commercial, financial, securities or real estate transactions that may be directly connected with the aforementioned objects, or capable of facilitating their application or development.
7.5 COMPANY REGISTRATION
R.C.S. number: Nanterre B 562 033 357
A.P.E. Code: 660 F
7.6 CONSULTATION OF CORPORATE DOCUMENTS
During the term of validity of this reference document, the bylaws, the statutory auditors’ reports and financial statements for the last three fiscal years, as well as any other document required by law, may be consulted at the corporate headquarters at 1 avenue du Générale de Gaulle, 92800 PUTEAUX.
7.7 FISCAL YEAR (Article 19 of the bylaws)
The fiscal year shall last one year. It starts on January 1 and ends on December 31 of the same year.
7.8 STATUTORY DISTRIBUTION OF PROFITS (Art. 19 of the bylaws)
After approval of the accounts and recognition of the existence of distributable funds, constituted from the profits of the fiscal year, less prior losses and plus, if applicable, any profit carried forward, the General Meeting shall distribute them as follows:
1/ The sums to be transferred to reserves as required by law.
2/ All sums that the Shareholders’ Meeting may decide to appropriate to any discretionary, ordinary or extraordinary reserves, or to retained earnings.

Page 98 of 184


 

3/ The balance, if any, shall be distributed among all of the stocks in proportion to their paid-in and unamortized amount.
The General Shareholder’s Meeting may decide to distribute sums taken from the discretionary reserves, to furnish or complete a dividend, or as a special distribution.
Each share confers the right to a quota in proportion to the number and par value of the existing shares, of the capital assets, of profits or of liquidation bonuses.
7.9 SHAREHOLDERS’ MEETINGS
Notice of Meetings/Attendance of Meetings/Voting rights (Arts. 8 and 18 of the bylaws)
Shareholders’ meetings shall be convened and be conducted in accordance with French law. They shall consist of all shareholders, regardless of the number of shares held. Each share shall carry the right to one vote in the meetings. The bylaws make no provision for shares carrying dual voting rights.
The meetings take place at corporate headquarters, or elsewhere as indicated in the meeting notice.
All shareholders may attend, in person or through a proxy, the Meetings, upon verification of identity and of the ownership of securities, either in the form of a signature registered under his name or a certificate from an authorized intermediary designated as account keeper.
The Board of Directors determines the time period during which formalities for the immobilization of bearer shares must be completed. This period is 24 hours under ordinary circumstances.
Shareholders may, under conditions set by the laws and regulations, send their power of attorney or vote by mail concerning any Shareholder’s Meeting, either in paper form or, by decision of the Board of Directors, by teletransmission.
The deadline for returning the voting forms by mail is set by the Board of Directors.
The Board of Directors may likewise decide that the shareholders may participate and vote at any General Shareholder’s Meeting by videoconference or by any means of telecommunication that allows them to be identified and in compliance with the conditions set by applicable regulations.
Reporting requirements for holdings exceeding specific thresholds (Art. 7 of the bylaws)
In addition to the legal notification requirements applicable to shareholders who directly or indirectly come to hold an interest in the share capital of the corporation, all shareholders must, subject to the sanctions provided in Sections L. 233-7 and L. 233-14 of the French Commercial Code, notify the corporation by registered mail, with acknowledgment of receipt, of the total number of shares they hold, within five stock market trading days from the date on which they come to hold, either directly or indirectly, within the meaning of Section L. 233-7 of the French Commercial Code, a number of shares in the corporation resulting in the crossing of an ownership threshold, either above or below 2.5% of the common stock.
Identification of shareholders: (Art. 7 of the bylaws)
The shares of the company may be either registered or bearer shares, at the holder’s discretion.
The Corporation has the right to request at any time from the central depository, which keeps its securities issue accounts, such information enabling, under the legal conditions and regulations in effect, identification of the holders of securities, which confer immediate or deferred right to vote at meetings, as well as the quantity of securities held by each of them and, if applicable, the restrictions that may affect the shares.
7.10 REPURCHASE OF SHARES BY THE CORPORATION
Share Repurchase Plan for 2005
After having received the Board of Directors’ report and the information notice drafted in connection with the Repurchase Plan, approved by the Autorité des Marchés Financiers [Financial Markets Authority] on May 11, 2005 under Approval number 05-374), SCOR’s General Shareholders’ Meeting on May 31, 2005 has:
    authorized the Board of Directors, which may delegate this authority, under the conditions provided by law, to buy and sell the Corporation’s shares under the provisions of Articles L 225-209 et seq. of the Commercial Code and according to the applicable provisions of European Regulations No 2273/2003 of December 22, 2003 and of the AMF’s General Regulations;
 
    decided that purchases and sales could be carried out for all allowed purposes or those that could be authorized under the laws and regulations in effect, and notably in view of the following objectives:

Page 99 of 184


 

  -   trading on the secondary market or dealing in the liquidity of the Corporation’s shares through an investment services provider, by means of a liquidity contract pursuant to a code of professional conduct recognized by the Financial Market Authority;
 
  -   implementation of any of the Company’s stock option plan within the framework of the provisions of Articles L. 225-177 et seq., of the Commercial Code;
 
  -   allocation of bonus shares to employees and/or corporate officers;
 
  -   allocation of shares to employees and, if applicable, corporate officers based on sharing in the benefits of the company’s expansion and the implementation of any employees’ savings plan, under the conditions provided by the law, especially in the framework of Articles L. 443-1 et seq. of the French Labor Code;
 
  -   purchase of shares for conservation and subsequent return for exchange or as payment in the framework of possible mergers and acquisitions;
 
  -   remittance of shares at the exercise of rights attached to securities giving access to share capital;
 
  -   cancellation of shares bought in that way, within the limits set by law and subject to adoption by the Special Shareholders’ Meeting of the seventeenth resolution of said Meeting.
    decided that the acquisition, sale or transfer of shares could be done by any means, on a regulated market or over the counter, including block purchases or sales (without limiting the part of the Purchase Plan that may be carried out through this means), or by utilizing derivative financial instruments, negotiated on a regulated market or by OTC transactions, or the development of option strategies under the conditions authorized by market authorities. These operations may be carried out any time, including during the period of public offering, in compliance with applicable regulations;
 
    set the maximum purchase price at 2.20 per share (excluding acquisition costs), on the understanding that, in case of share capital increase by capitalization of reserves and a bonus share issue, as well as in case of splitting or combination of securities, the maximum price shall be adjusted by a multiplier coefficient equal to the ratio between the number of securities constituting the share capital before the transaction and the number after the transaction.
 
    decided that the maximum number of shares to be bought under this authorization is set at 10% of the common stock, specifying that such limit applies to a number of shares, which will, if applicable, be adjusted in order to take into account the operations affecting the common stock after said Meeting, acquisitions made by the Corporation may in no case bring it to hold, directly or indirectly, more than 10% of the common stockl, on the understanding that the overall amount that the Corporation may use to purchase its own shares shall comply with the provisions of Article L. 225-210 of the Commercial Code;
 
    duly noted that shareholders will be informed at the next ordinary annual Shareholders’ Meeting of the precise allocation of purchased shares to the different objectives pursued under this share purchase plan and the procedures for the repurchases made during the fiscal year;
 
    with regard to the shares acquired before October 13, 2004, gave as needed, all powers to the Board of Directors to:
  -   either allocate them to an objective with the irrebuttable presumption of legitimacy envisioned by European Regulation No. 2273/2003 of December 22, 2003;
 
  -   or allocate them to one of the two market practices accepted by the financial market Authority (liquidity contract with an investment service provider acting under the conditions determined for that practice, conservation and later return for exchange or in payment in the framework of possible merger and acquisition transactions);
    conferred all powers to the Board of Directors which may delegate this authority under the conditions provided for by law, to place all stock market orders, conclude all agreements, particularly with a view to keeping share purchase and sale registers, to prepare all documents, notably information reports, carry out all disclosures and formalities with the Financial Market Authority and all other organizations and, in general, to do everything that is necessary;
 
    decided that this authorization is given for a period that will end at the next annual Shareholders’ Meeting for the approval of the accounts without, however, exceeding a maximum period of eighteen months from the date of the said meeting; and
 
    decided that this authorization supersedes the authorization given by the mixed Shareholder’s Meeting of May 18, 2004 in its fourteenth resolution.
The Corporation is authorized to carry out Share Repurchase Plans until the Shareholders Meeting that will approve the accounts for fiscal year 2005, date of expiration of the validity of this program, and at the latest until November 30, 2006, i.e., a maximum length of 18 months.
In addition, the SCOR General Shareholders Meeting of May 31, 2005, convened for extraordinary purposes, after receiving the report of the Board of Directors and the Statutory Auditors’ special report, authorized the Board of Directors to reduce the common stock, in one or several transactions, in the proportions and at the times it shall decide, by retiring any quantity of

Page 100 of 184


 

treasury stock it shall decide upon, within the limits set by law, pursuant to the provisions of Articles L. 225-209 et seq. of the Commercial Code. The maximum number of shares that may be retired by the Corporation under this authorization is 10% of the shares constituting the Corporation’s share capital, by twenty-four month period, it being specified that this limit applies to the number of shares that will be adjusted, if applicable, to take into account the operations affecting the common stock subsequent to said meeting.
The authorization to cancel its own shares acquired during the repurchase program was granted to the Board, which may delegate such authority, for a period of 18 months from May 31, 2005, so as to carry out all acts, formalities, and disclosures in order to cancel shares and to finalize share capital decreases, and consequently to modify the Company’s bylaws accordingly. Share repurchases must not have the effect of reducing the share capital to a lesser amount than the sum of the issuer’s share capital and its non-distributable reserves. Therefore, when the authorization was voted on May 31, 2005, given the level of reserves and the number of shares already owned by the Company, it was limited to a number of shares representing 9.4% of the share capital.
Moreover, SCOR signed a liquidity contract with the Exane company on July 25, 2005. The purpose of this program was to intervene in the market on SCOR shares on behalf of SCOR. By codicil dated October 21, 2005, that liquidity contract was suspended as of October 11, 2005.
The repurchases of shares between January 2005 and July 2005 were made by Exane based on the previous liquidity contract signed on December 8, 2004. There have been no share repurchases since October 11, 2005, the date on which the liquidity contract was suspended.
                                                                 
                                         
  MONTH     (a) Total
number of
shares
purchased
      (b) Average
price paid
per share
      (a) Total
number of
shares sold
      (d) Average
Price per Share
Transferred
(excluding
allocation of
bonus shares)
      (c) Total number
of Shares
purchased as part
of publicly
announced share
repurchase plans
      (f) Maximum
Number of Shares
that might still be
acquired in
application of
plans (Subject to
L.225-210) (1) (2)
(3) (6)
   
                                         
 
Jan-05
      783,396         1.46         5,914,001         1.50         783,396         28,513,498    
 
Febr-05
      875,000         1.56         700,000         1.59         875,000         28,338,498    
 
March-05
      1,287,498         1.59         750,000         1.65         1,287,498         27,801,000    
 
Apr-05
      1,537,000         1.60         1,019,947         1.62         1,537,000         27,283,947    
 
May-05
      485,000         1.57         1,359,757         1.61         485,000         28,158,704 (4)  
 
June-05
      900,000         1.60         685,000         1.62         900,000         92,139,633 (5)  
 
July-05
      3,073,686         1.64         813,482         1.70         3,073,686         89,879,429    
 
Aug-05
      600,000         1.69         280,500         1.73         600,000         89,559,929    
 
Sept-05
      2,373,933         1.67         575,000         1.68         2,373,933         87,760,996    
 
Oct-05
      1,775,000         1.74         225,000         1.75         1,775,000         86,210,996    
 
Nov-05
      0         0         1,515,795         0         0         87,726,791    
 
Dec-05
      0         0         39,201         0         0         87,765,992    
                                         
(1) 2004 Share Repurchase Plan. The 2004 Share Repurchase Plan was publicly announced on April 28, 2004 and was subject only to the approval of the shareholders at the 2004 Annual Meeting to approve the accounts of fiscal 2003. That approval was given by the Shareholders’ Meeting. In May 2004, the shareholders of the Company authorized, within the limits of French law relating to the level of reserves and shares held by the Company at the time, the purchase of a maximum of 28,755,773 shares. As the repurchase of shares was authorized until the Annual Meeting of Shareholders to approve the accounts of fiscal 2004, which was held on May 31, 2005, the authorization for the repurchase of shares expired on that date.
(2) 2005 Share Repurchase Plan. In May 2005, the shareholders of the Company authorized, within the limits of French law relating to the level of reserves and number of treasury stock, the repurchase of a maximum of 76,722,376 shares. This amount had been adjusted in June to take into account the share capital increase of 149,500,000 shares.
(3) Under the terms of the 2004 and 2005 Share Repurchase Plans, the shares could be purchased in open market transactions or privately negotiated transactions. Repurchases were made by the Company in one-off transactions, prior to the expiration of the Plan, based on the Company’s evaluation of market conditions and other factors. The Company has used and continues to use existing cash to fund the repurchase of shares. All of the shares repurchased during the months identified above were purchased in open market transactions through this program.

Page 101 of 184


 

(4) These repurchases were under the 2004 Share Repurchase Plan. The program expired at the Shareholders’ Meeting to approve the accounts of fiscal 2004. Then, although there were still 28,158,704 shares remaining that could be repurchased under the terms of the Plan, the authorization was cancelled. However, the 2004 Annual Shareholders Meeting authorized the repurchase of 76,722,376 shares, as referenced in footnote (2) above.
(5) These repurchases were made under the 2005 Share Repurchase Plan.
(6) During the year 2005, the Corporation repurchased 13,690,513 shares (of which 7,466,580 under the liquidity contract), and resold 13,877,683 (of which 7,936,686 under the liquidity contract).
During the year 2005, the Company made net repurchases of 13,690,513 SCOR shares for the amount of 22,343,724.32 at an average weighted price of 1.63 each. The Company sold 7,938,686 shares under the liquidity contract at an average price of 1.62 each. 7,305,000 shares were allocated to certain corporate officers and to certain executives of the Group’s companies under the 2005 bonus share allocation plan authorized by the Shareholders Meeting of May 31, 2005 and by the Board of Directors on August 31, 2005.
As of December 31, 2005, the Company held 9,110,915 of its own shares.
7.11 INFORMATION CONCERNING THE COMMON STOCK
At December 31, 2005, SCOR’s common stock totaled 763,096,713, divided into 968,769,070 shares. SCOR’s bylaws have not set a nominal value per SCOR share.
By decisions of the General Shareholders’ Meeting and the Board of Directors on May 31, 2005 and the President on June 21 and 22, 2005, the Company proceeded to increase its share capital by the issue of 149,500,000 new shares with a nominal value of 0.78769723 each, plus a share premium totaling 115,459,264 overall, the share premium net of the share capital increase costs stood at 105,910,795.
7.12 AUTHORIZED SHARE CAPITAL
The Combined Shareholders’ Meeting of May 31, 2005:
- delegated to the Board of Directors, the authority to decide, exclusively for purposes of financing or refinancing by the Company of the minority interests in IRP Holdings Limited and the reinforcement of the Company’s capital base, to increase the common stock by issuing, while canceling shareholders’ preferential share rights, ordinary shares and/or securities giving access to the Company’s capital. The capital increase(s) likely to be carried out by virtue of this delegated authority cannot result in the issue of a number of shares greater than 150,000,000, or a maximum nominal amount of share capital increase of 118,154,584.50, that amount being charged to the overall ceiling for share capital increases set at a maximum nominal amount of 148,480,927.85, or for a maximum number of 188,500,000 shares with a nominal value of 0.78769723 each. Lastly, the maximum global nominal amount of securities giving access to the Company’s share capital issued by virtue of this delegation cannot exceed 250,000,000;
- authorized the Board of Directors to increase the number of shares and/or securities to be issued in case of an increase in common stock, with or without shareholders’ preferential share rights, within a period of 30 days following the closure of the initial issue’s subscription and within the limit of 15% of the initial issue and at the same price as that of said issue.
Making use of these authorizations, the Board of Directors decided on May 31, 2005 to delegate to its CEO, the power to decide to increase the share capital, cancel shareholders’ preferential share right, and, if applicable, increase the number of securities to be issued. Subsequent to this authorization, the CEO decided on June 21, 2005 to increase the common stock by a nominal amount of 102,400,640 by the issue of 130,000,000 shares of nominal value of 0.78769723 each, with cancellation of the shareholders’ preferential share right without a priority delay period. On June 22, 2005, the CEO decided to set the subscription price of new shares at 1.56 per share to be issued, that is, an overall increase in share capital (including share premium) of 202,800,000. On June 22, 2005, the CEO decided on a supplementary issue of 19,500,000 new shares at a price corresponding to the price of the initial issue, i.e., 1.56 per share to be issued, the amount of the share capital increase resulting from this supplementary issue (including share premium) was set at 30,420,000.
7.13 SECURITIES GIVING ACCESS TO SHARE CAPITAL
The Océanes issued in 1999 were fully redeemed in January 2005.
On June 21, 2004, the Board of Directors decided to issue a loan, represented by convertible bond options and/or exchangeable for new or existing shares of SCOR (OCEANEs), on authorization of the Combined Shareholders Meeting of May 18, 2004, and sub-delegated to its Chairman the powers required for that purpose. Issued on July 2, 2004, following the decisions of the CEO on June 23 and 24, 2004, the nominal amount of this loan is 200 million and is represented by 100 million OCEANEs with a nominal value of 2. The bonds yield 4.125% of interest payable at maturity on January 1 of each year. The loan has a term of 5 years and 183 days.
The gross actuarial yield is 4.125% on the date of payment. Amortization is as follows:

Page 102 of 184


 

  Normal amortization: the bonds will be fully amortized on January 1, 2010 at the price of €2 per bond.
 
  Early amortization: by purchase on or off the stock market or public offering and under other conditions detailed in the offering circular approved by the AMF under No. 04-627 on June 24, 2004.
At any time since July 2, 2004, bondholders may, up to the seventh day before their normal or early amortization date, request the allotment of new and/or existing Company securities, at the Company’s discretion, and which shall be paid and/or settled in consideration for their bond debt, at the rate of one share per bond. Any bond holder who has not exercized his right to the allocation of shares before that date shall receive an amount equal to the redemption price of the bonds.
In order to exercise the share allotment right, bondholders must forward their request through the intermediary where their securities accounts are registered. These transactions are centralized by BNP Paribas Securities Services.
Any request for exercise of the share allotment right that reaches BNP Paribas Securities Services in its capacity as centralizing agent during the course of a calendar month shall take effect (i) on the last working day of said calendar month or (ii) the seventh working day that precedes the date set for redemption. The bondholders shall receive delivery of the shares on the seventh working day following the date of exercise of the right.
7.14 PERFORMANCE OF “OCEANE” BONDS SINCE THEIR ISSUANCE
                                         
       
  Year     Month     Volume of       Highest price       Lowest price    
              transactions                    
                        (in €)       (in €)    
                             
 
 
    July       93,365         2.12         2.05    
                             
 
 
    August       1,055,067         2.10         2.03    
                             
 
2004
    September       675,868         2.17         2.10    
                             
 
 
    October       16,090         2.17         2.12    
                             
 
 
    November       653,151         2.23         2.05    
                             
 
 
    December       16,120         2.30         2.15    
                             
 
 
    Total       2,509,661         2.30         2.03    
                             
 
 
    January       592,469         2.32         2.13    
                             
 
 
    February       567,257         2.36         2.16    
                             
 
 
    March       123,599         2.35         2.25    
                             
 
 
    April       660         2.35         2.27    
                             
 
 
    May       3,506         2.35         2.15    
                             
 
2005
    June       225,024         2.32         2.13    
                             
 
 
    July       1,512,206         2.45         2.20    
                             
 
 
    August       1,380,156         2.40         2.30    
                             
 
 
    September       19,077         2.35         2.25    
                             
 
 
    October       66,000         2.55         2.34    
                             
 
 
    November       546,815         2.55         2.11    
                             
 
 
    December       627,689         2.43         2.22    
                             
 
 
    Total       5,664,458         2.55         2.11    
                             
 
2006
    January       52,621         2.39         2.34    
                             
 
 
    February       8,080         2.57         2.45    
                             
 
 
    March (to March 20)       310,335         2.58         2.58    
                             
Source Euronext
There was no conversion of bonds during the periods covered by the above table.

Page 103 of 184


 

7.15 SCOR SHARE SUBSCRIPTION OPTIONS
Based on the number of shares in circulation on December 31, 2005, the sum of the unexercized share subscription options on December 31, 2005 would lead to the creation of 16,812,193 shares, representing 2.20% of the share capital.
The Combined Shareholders’ Meeting of May 31, 2005 authorized the Board of Directors to approve share subscription and/or purchase options for the salaried personnel and directors and officers.
Using this authorization, the Board of Directors of August 31, 2005 set up a new share subscription options plan intended for corporate officers and certain executives of Group companies. Therefore, 7,260,000 options were issued under this plan in 2005, each giving the right to one share.
This authorization will expire on November 30, 2006, at the latest.
For supplementary information on the share subscription plans at December 31, 2005, see Sections 5.7 – Notes to Consolidated Accounts – Note 25, 6.5 – Notes to Corporate Financial Statements – Note 12, and 9.9 – Share Subscription or Share Purchase Options held by the Executive Committee members at December 31, 2005.

Page 104 of 184


 

7.16 CHANGES IN THE SHARE CAPITAL OF SCOR OVER THE LAST FIVE YEARS
                                                                       
     
              ISSUE PRICE                                   SUCCESSIVE        
  DATES     ISSUANCE OF                                             AMOUNTS OF     CUMULATIVE  
        SHARES                                             SHARE     NUMBER  
                    CHANGES IN SHARE CAPITAL     CAPITAL     OF SHARES  
                        Number of     Capital     Issue premium                  
                        shares                              
              (in €)               (in €)     (in €)     (in €)            
                                               
 
 
   
     Exercise of subscription options
      -         80,000         304,898         1,298,367                        
 
 
   
                                                       
 
 
   
     Creation of shares for the benefit of Groupama
      54.00         6,370,370         24,278,913         319,721,067                        
                                                   
 
12/31/2001
                                                    157,191,002         41,244,216    
                                               
 
 
   
     Exercise of subscription options
      -         16,158         11,023         249,464                        
 
 
   
                                                       
 
 
   
     Retirement of treasury stock
      -         (3,740,417 )       (14,205,013 )       (159,932,154 )                      
 
 
   
                                                       
 
 
   
     Capital increase
      3.85         99,024,888         377,284,823       -                        
                                                   
 
12/31/2002
                                                    520,281,835         136,544,845    
                                               
 
 
   
     Exercise of subscription options
      -       None       None       None                        
 
 
   
                                                       
 
 
   
     Capital reduction (1)
      -         -         383,691,014       -                        
                                                   
 
12/31/2003
                                                    136,544,845         136,544,845    
                                               
 
 
   
§     Exercise of subscription options
      -       None       None       None                        
 
 
   
§     Capital increase
      1.10         682,724,225         682,724,225         68,272,422.5                        
 
 
   
                                                       
 
 
   
§     Capital reduction(2)
                -         173,933,092       -                        
                                                   
 
12/31/2004
                                                    645,335,978         819,269,070    
                                               
 
 
   
§     Exercise of subscription options
      -       None       None       None                        
 
 
   
                                                       
 
 
   
§     Capital increase
      1.56         149,500,000         117,760,736         105,910,795                        
                                                   
 
12/31/2005
                                                    763,096,714         968,769,070    
                                               
(1) Capital reduction due to 2003 losses, estimated at an equivalent amount, pursuant to the decision of the extraordinary Shareholders’ Meeting of December 1, 2003, by reduction of the nominal value of the shares from €3.81 to €1, the amount of the capital reduction being allocated to a reserve account to which the losses will be charged once they have been definitely recognized.
(2) Capital reduction according to the decision of the extraordinary Shareholders’ Meeting of May 18, 2004, by reduction of the nominal value of shares from €1 to €0.78769723, the capital reduction amount being allocated to the unavailable reserves account, in order to discharge the fiscal 2003 losses not covered by (i) the reserve constituted in December 2003 after reduction of the capital by decrease in the nominal value of the shares, (ii) the special reserve for long term gain not affected by the legal reserve and (iii) the balance of premiums linked to corporate capital previously constituted.

Page 105 of 184


 

7.17 OWNERSHIP OF SHARE CAPITAL
(Number of shares, % of capital and voting rights)
                                                                             
 
        December 31, 2003     December 31, 2004     December 31, 2005     January 1, 2006  
                    Voting                 Voting                 Voting                 Voting  
        Number of     Capital     Rights %     Number of     Capital     Rights %     Number of     Capital     Rights %     Number of     Capital     Rights %  
        shares     (%)     (2)     shares     (%)     (2)     shares     (%)     (2)     shares     (%)     (2)  
 
Groupa ma/Gan
    25,656,535     18.79%     18.86%     155,260,343 (3)     18.95%     19.17%     155,246,370 (12)     16.03%     16.18%     155,246,370(15)     16.03%     16.18%  
 
Silchester
    11,729,332     8.59%     8.62%     70,375,992     8.59%     8.69%     81,375,992     8.40%     8.48%     76,771,648     7.92%     8.00%  
 
Marathon
    9,145,757     6.70%     6.72%     58,549,828     7.15%     7.23%     57,295,188     5.91%     5.97%     56,566,688     5.84%     5.89%  
 
Groupe MAAf-
    6,707,235     4.91%     4.93%     31,505,874     3.85%     3.89%     33,725,874     3.48%     3.51%     33,725,874     3.48%     3.51%  
 
MACIF
    3,966,628 (6)     2.91%     2.92%     26,941,535 (7)     3.29%     3.33%     29,908,937     3.09%     3.12%     29,908,937     3.09%     3.12%  
 
General (8)
    2,365,660     1.73%     1.74%     15,100,507     1.84%     1.86%     15,100,507     1.56%     1.57%     15,100,507     1.56%     1.57%  
 
MATMUT
    2,750,000     2.01%     2.02%     14,250,000     1.74%     1.76%     15,505,983 (13)     1.60%     1.62%     14,130,983 (16)     1.46%     1.47%  
 
Employees
    861,220 (10)     0.63%     0.63%     1,278,720 (11)     0.16%     0.16%     3,396,922 (14)     0.35%     0.35%     3,350,517 (17)     0.35%     0.35%  
 
Self-owning
    489,500     0.36%         9,298,085     1.13%         9,110,915     0.94%         9,110,915     0.94%      
 
Other
    72,872,978     53.37%     53.56%     436,708,186     53.30%     53.92%     568,102,382     58.64%     59.20%     574,856,631     59.34%     59.90%  
 
Total
    136,544,845     100%     100%     819,269,070     100%     100%     968,769,070     100.00%     100.00%     968,769,070     100.00%     100.00%  
 
(1) The data represent the position closest to 12/31/2003
(2) The percentage of voting rights is determined on the basis of the number of shares at closure, after deducting the Company’s treasury stock.
(3) Source: Groupama – this figure includes 139,439,070 shares held by Groupama S.A and 15,821,273 shares held by subsidiaries and the Regional Mutuals
(4) Source: Silchester, Marathon – these companies are shareholders through the funds and the mutual fund
(5) Source: MAAF-MMA
(6) Source: MACIF
(7) Source: MACIF – This figure includes 26,908,937 shares owned directly and 32,598 shares owned through funds managed by MACIF Gestion.
(8) Source: Generali
(9) Source: Matmut
(10) This figure includes 295,220 shares owned directly and 566,000 shares owned through a company-sponsored mutual fund.
(11) This figure includes 295,220 shares owned directly and 983,500 shares owned through a company-sponsored mutual fund.
(12) Source: Groupama – this figure includes 139,439,071 shares held by Groupama S.A. and 15,807,299 shares held by subsidiaries and the Regional Mutuals
(13) Source: Matmut – this figure includes 14,250,000 shares owned directly and 1,255,983 shares owned through their mutual funds.
(14) This figure includes 1,764,622 shares owned directly and 1,632,300 shares owned through a company-sponsored mutual fund
(15) Source: Groupama – this figure includes 139,439,071 shares owned by Groupama S.A. and 15,807,299 shares held by subsidiaries and Regional Mutuals
(16) Source: Matmut – this figure includes 12,875,000 shares owned directly and 1,255,983 shares held through their mutual funds.
(17) This figure includes 1,695,417 shares owned directly and 1,655,100 shares owned through a company-sponsored mutual fund
To the best of the Company’s knowledge, no other shareholder or group of shareholders holds more than 5% of SCOR’s share capital or voting rights.
In February 2005, the Company undertook a study on all identifiable bearer shares (TPI), concerning all shares. This study disclosed more than 37,000 shareholders. In January 2006, the study conducted on identifiable bearer shares concerned all of the Company’s shares and disclosed more than 34,000 shareholders. No agreement or clause stipulating preferential terms for the sale or purchase of shares admitted for regulated market trading, or for which application is pending, and representing at least 0.5% of the Company’s share capital or voting rights has been transmitted to the “Autorité des Marchés Financiers.”
There is no shareholder agreement or agreement to act in concert. No transactions have taken place between senior managers, directors or officers, and shareholders holding more than 2.5% of the share capital (or of the company controlling them) and the Company, on terms other than market terms.

Page 106 of 184


 

Groupama is the largest shareholder of SCOR. As of December 31, 2005, the Groupama/Gan group held approximately 16.03% of SCOR’s shares. To the best of the Company’s knowledge, no significant changes occurred in the share ownership of SCOR during the year 2005. Mr. le Pas de Sécheval (Financial Director of Groupama S.A.) was named Non-voting director by the combined Shareholders’ Meeting of May 15, 2003, then co-opted as manager by the Board of Directors of November 3, 2004, co-option ratified by the combined Shareholders’ Meeting of May 31, 2005. SCOR has business links with Groupama with which it carries out reinsurance transactions.
Groupama provided two guarantees in the context of the acquisition of SOREMA S.A. and SOREMA N.A. Groupama could indemnify SCOR in case of negative developments concerning significant corporate and tax liability items or connected to the underwriting reserves for 2000 and the prior year writings, as they will be valued on December 31, 2006. For additional information on the guarantees granted by Groupama, see Section [10.2] – Agreements approved during previous fiscal years, whose implementation continued during the fiscal year.
No SCOR shares have been pledged.

The number of SCOR ADRs in circulation at December 31, 2005 was 25,340,999.
At December 31, 2005, SCOR held 9,110,915 of its own shares.
To the best of the Company’s knowledge, the percentage of share capital and voting rights held by all members of the issuer’s administrative and management bodies was 0.07% as of December 31, 2005.

The total number of voting rights at January 1, 2005 was 809,970,985 and 959,658,155 at December 31, 2005.
Pursuant to Article 8 (“Rights attached to each share”) of the bylaws, each share gives its owner the right to one vote at the general shareholders’ meetings and the bylaws do not stipulate shares having the right to a double vote. In addition, there is no statutory limitation on vote rights. Therefore, the principal shareholders of SCOR do not have different voting rights.
7.18 EMPLOYEE SHAREHOLDING
1. Free Share Allotment Plan
The combined Shareholders’ Meeting of May 31, 2005 authorized the Board of Directors to freely allocate SCOR common stocks to members of the salaried personnel and directors and officers.
Making use of this authorization, the Board of Directors, on August 31, 2005, set up a plan for the allotment of free shares to directors and officers and certain executives of Group companies. 7,305,000 shares were allotted and will be transferred in September 2007, subject to compliance with the conditions of the presence of beneficiaries and they must be held until September 2009.
This authorization will expire on November 30, 2006, at the latest.
2. Employee Savings Plan
Group employees (excluding directors and officers) have the possibility to invest in the Employee Savings Plan. The principle, financing and conditions of the Plan are specified in an agreement. The Employee Savings Plan has four closed-end investment funds, two of which are entirely invested in SCOR shares. An employer’s contribution is expected on these last two funds. The funds receive several types of deposits: sums received from profit-sharing plans, collective incentive plans or any other voluntary contributions.
The combined Shareholders’ Meeting of May 31, 2005 delegated its authority to the Board of Directors for it to increase common stock by issuing shares reserved for members of the savings plans, with cancellation of the preferential share rights in favor of the latter.
During the course of fiscal 2005, the Board of Directors did not make use of this authority to increase the common stock.
This authorization will expire on November 30, 2006, at the latest.
7.19 IRP
General Comments
In December 2001, Scor, in partnership with other investors, created IRP Holdings Limited (“IRP Holdings”) and Irish Reinsurance Partners Limited (“Irish Reinsurance Partners”). Irish Reinsurance Partners is an operational subsidiary, wholly owned by IRP Holdings. The activity of Irish Reinsurance Partners was focused on 25% quota share retrocession of nearly all the Non-Life business underwritten or renewed by the Scor Group in fiscal 2002, 2003 and 2004. In 2004, the net income of IRP Holdings amounted to €50.1 million after taxes or €57.4 million before taxes. The shareholders of IRP Holdings decided not to renew the quota share treaties, which therefore expired on December 31, 2004.
SCOR contributed 41.70% of the €300 million initially invested in IRP Holdings. On March 20, 2003, SCOR acquired from certain of the initial investors in IRP Holdings, 4.98% of its shares for a total consideration of €17.2 million, thereby increasing its equity interest to 46.68% of IRP Holdings’ capital. In June and July 2003, the SCOR Group acquired an additional 6.66% stake in IRP Holdings, previously held by certain other initial investors, thus increasing its ownership in IRP Holdings from 46.68% as of March 31, 2003 to 53.35% as of June 30, 2003.

Page 107 of 184


 

In a shareholders’ agreement dated December 28, 2001 (the “IRP Agreement”), entered into upon the creation of IRP Holdings, SCOR committed to acquire from the minority shareholders of IRP Holdings, in principle no later than May 31, 2005, IRP Holdings’ shares not yet held by SCOR. SCOR had the choice of acquiring IRP Holdings’ shares either by exchange with SCOR shares, or for cash, or a combination of the two options. At the beginning of 2005, SCOR held 53.35% of the share capital of IRP Holdings, the balance being held by Highfields Capital Limited funds, Highfields Capital I, L.P., Highfields Capital II, L.P. and Highfields Capital SPC (the “Highfields Funds”).
Cash buyback of minority shareholders
Taking into account the different constraints connected to the manner of calculating the exchange value set forth in the Agreement, the schedule of procedure, as stipulated in the IRP Agreement was slightly modified. The independent calculating agent, appointed in application of the provisions of the IRP Agreement, transmitted its report to IRP Holdings on May 17, 2005. The report was finalized on May 24, 2005. On June 14, 2005, SCOR sent (i.e., in accordance with the procedure deadlines set by the Agreement but after the stipulated date of May 31, 2005) to the Highfields Funds, the notice of exchange required by the IRP Agreement, informing them of its intention to propose a cash settlement for the acquisition of their minority interest in IRP Holdings. On June 20, 2005, the Highfields Funds notified SCOR of their acceptance to withdraw from IRP Holdings’ capital in response to the exchange notice sent by SCOR on June 14, 2005. In this context, SCOR acquired the minority interests of IRP Holdings for an amount of €183.1 million, corresponding to the share of Highfields Funds owned by IRP Holdings on December 31, 2004, prepared by U.S. GAAP. SCOR, pursuant to the Agreement, paid a supplementary indemnity of €1.2 million linked to 20 days late performance of the formalities specified in the Agreement.
Following this transaction, SCOR became the direct holder of 100% of the share capital and voting rights of IRP Holdings and, indirectly, of Irish Reinsurance Partners.
In view, notably, of refinancing the acquisition of the outstanding IRP Holdings’ shares, SCOR carried out a capital increase by issuing 149,500,000 new shares with a nominal value of €0.78769723 each, with a total share premium of €115, 459,264. See Section 7.12 – Authorized Share Capital.
Capital Reduction
On November 1, 2005, IRP Holdings presented a request to the High Court of Dublin for authorization to reduce its common stock by canceling 299,365 common stocks with a nominal value of €1,000 each and the corresponding reimbursement of €299,365,000 to SCOR as the sole shareholder. By an ordinance on November 28, 2005, the High Court of Dublin authorized the reduction of IRP Holdings’ capital and the reimbursement to SCOR of the corresponding sum of €299,365,000. Moreover, on August 2, 2005, IRP Holdings distributed a special dividend of €90 million.
Certain Highfields Funds have filed lawsuits against SCOR in the United States. See Section 8.16 – Extraordinary facts and litigations.

Page 108 of 184


 

8. INFORMATION ABOUT THE GROUP’S ACTIVITIES
8.1 STRATEGY
At the end of 2002, SCOR reassessed its strategy and launched the “Back on Track” strategic plan.
Since the end of 2002, when it implemented its “Back on Track” plan, SCOR has shifted its underwriting towards:
- short-tail activities, which give a better forward-looking view of the activities that do not involve the same level of risk on future results and which avoid the difficulty of calculating future results and the related required reserves for long-tail activities exposed to disputes and to claims inflation; and non-proportional activities, for which the prices are defined by SCOR underwriters and actuaries; these activities are less sensitive to the negative effects that can result from the underwriting and rates of the ceding companies.
The “Back on Track” plan met its four major objectives by the end of 2004:
  strengthen the Group’s reserves;
 
  restore its equity through two share capital increases;
 
  resize the Group by reducing premium underwriting and implementing the Group’s new underwriting policy focused on short-tail underwriting in the Non-Life sector, either directly or through large facultatives, when capacity and pricing are adequate; and
 
  restructure the Group, particularly by appointing a new Board of Directors, new management and new procedures.
In 2004, the Board of Directors adopted the new “SCOR Moving Forward” strategic plan for 2005-2007. The “SCOR Moving Forward” plan sets out the means and methods to reach profitability objectives through an underwriting policy focused on profitability, optimum allocation of share capital through the activity cycle, and by maintaining SCOR’s client base in Europe, Asia, North America and the emerging countries in order to win back market share in treaties and in specialty risks when the premium levels and contract terms are consistent with the Group’s requirements for profitability.
As part of the “SCOR Moving Forward” plan, SCOR has modified its share capital allocation plan by market and by business line. Under this plan, the Group is trying to anticipate and manage its activity based on the various phases of the premium rate cycle in reinsurance. On the basis of this modeling of the underwriting policy in 2005/2007, the Group’s objective is to reach a trend in profitability that corresponds to the rate without risk +6 points.
In line with the “Back on Track” plan, the volume of gross written premiums declined 32% in 2004 primarily due to a reduction in premiums in the U.S. Non-Life sector and in the Major Corporate Risk sector as the result of more rigorous underwriting standards and the downgrading of SCOR’s financial rating in 2004. In addition, SCOR worked to rebalance its Non-Life activity by reducing its exposure to the American markets. The year 2005, with premium revenues of €2,407 million, was marked by quasi-stability in premium from 2004, because of the maintenance of underwriting rules in a poor market and the renewal of the Non-Life treaties in January and April 2005 affected by a rating of BBB+ (S&P) and B++ (AM Best), which were relatively unfavorable compared with our principal competitors.
8.2 HISTORICAL BACKGROUND
SCOR was founded in 1970 at the initiative of the French government with the objective of creating a reinsurance company of international stature. SCOR expanded rapidly on the world’s markets, building up a substantial international portfolio.
At the beginning of the 1980s, the government progressively wound down its interest in the Company’s share capital, held through the Caisse Centrale de Réassurance, and was replaced by insurance companies operating in the French market.
In 1989, SCOR and UAP Reassurances combined their Property-Casualty and Life reinsurance businesses as part of a restructuring of Scor’s share capital, and listed the Company on the Paris stock market. Compagnie UAP, which held 41% of the shar capital, disposed of its shareholding in October 1996 via an international public offering timed to coincide with the listing of SCOR’s shares on the New York Stock Exchange.
In July 1996, SCOR acquired the reinsurance portfolio of the American insurer Allstate Insurance Company, doubling the share of its U.S. business as a proportion of total Group revenues.
While maintaining an active local presence on the major markets and building up new units in fast-growing emerging countries, SCOR has continued in the following years to streamline its structure and rationalize its organization.
In 1999, SCOR purchased the 35% held by Western General Insurance in the Bermudan company Commercial Risk Partners, thus raising its interest in this subsidiary to 100%.
In 2000, SCOR acquired PartnerRe Life in the United States, thus providing it with a platform to expand its Life reinsurance business on the U.S. market.
In 2001, SCOR acquired SOREMA S.A. and SOREMA N.A. in order to increase its market share and take full advantage of the cyclical upturn in Property & Casualty reinsurance. That same year, SCOR and a group of international investors formed a

Page 109 of 184


 

reinsurance company in Dublin, named Irish Reinsurance Partners, with share capital of €300 million to strengthen the Group’s equity and increase its underwriting capacity to take advantage of the upturn in the reinsurance cycle.
In 2002, SCOR signed a cooperation agreement in the Life business with the Legacy Marketing Group of California, for the distribution and management of annuity products. In addition, it opened a Life insurance office in Brussels in order to take full advantage of the growth potential in the Life reinsurance market in Belgium and Luxembourg.
With a volume of written net premiums of €2,407 million, SCOR was one of the top 15 world reinsurers in 2005 on the basis of the estimates made by the SCOR management of the net premiums written by other major international reinsurers. The SCOR Group operates in 19 countries through its subsidiaries, branches and representative offices and provides services in more than 100 countries.
8.3 RECENT DEVELOPMENTS
Since the close of financial year 2005, there has been no significant change in the Group’s financial or commercial structure.
For more information on post-closing events, see section 11 - Annual Information Document.
8.4 THE REINSURANCE BUSINESS
Principles
Reinsurance is a contract under which a company, the reinsurer, agrees to indemnify an insurance company, the ceding company, against all or part of the primary insurance risks underwritten by the ceding company under one or more insurance contracts. Reinsurance differs from insurance, primarily because its inherent complexity linked to the broader range of activities and its international nature. Reinsurance can provide a ceding company with several benefits, including a reduction in net liability on individual risks and catastrophe protection from large or multiple losses. Reinsurance also provides a ceding company with additional underwriting capacity by permitting it to accept larger risks and a greater number of risks than would be possible without a concomitant increase in share capital. Reinsurance, however, does not discharge the ceding company from its liability to policyholders. Reinsurers themselves may feel the need to transfer some of the risks concerned to other reinsurers, in a procedure known as retrocession.
Functions
Reinsurance provides three essential functions:
1.   First, it offers the direct insurer greater security for its equity and guaranteed solvency, and stable results when unusual and major events occur, by covering the direct insurer above certain ceilings or against accumulated individual commitments.
 
2.   Reinsurance allows insurers to increase the maximum amount they can insure for a given loss or category of losses, by enabling them to underwrite a greater number of risks, or larger risks, without burdening their need to cover their solvency margin, and hence their capital base.
 
3.   It makes substantial liquid assets available to insurers in the event of exceptional losses.
In addition, reinsurers also:
a)   help ceding companies define their reinsurance needs and devise the most effective reinsurance program, to better plan their capital needs and solvency margin;
 
b)   supply a wide array of support services, particularly in terms of technical training, organization, accounting and information technology;
 
c)   provide expertise in certain highly specialized areas such as the analysis of complex risks and risk pricing;
 
d)   enable ceding companies to build up their business even if they are undercapitalized, particularly in order to launch new products requiring heavy investment.
Types of Reinsurance
Treaty and Facultative Reinsurance
The two basic types of reinsurance arrangements are treaty and facultative reinsurance.
In treaty reinsurance, the ceding company has a contractual obligation to cede and the reinsurer to accept, a specified portion of a type or category of risks insured by the ceding company. Reinsurers producing the treaties, as done by the SCOR Group, do not separately evaluate each of the individual risks assumed under the treaty. As a result, after reviewing the ceding company’s underwriting practices, they depend on the coverage decisions made originally by the policy writers of the ceding company.

Page 110 of 184


 

Such dependence subjects reinsurers in general, including the Group, to the possibility that the ceding companies have not adequately evaluated the risks to be reinsured and, therefore, that the premiums ceded in connection therewith may not adequately compensate the reinsurer for the risk assumed. The reinsurer’s evaluation of the ceding company’s risk management and underwriting practices as well as claims settlement practices and procedures, therefore, will usually impact the pricing of the treaty.
In facultative reinsurance, the ceding company cedes and the reinsurer assumes all or part of the risk covered by a single specific insurance policy. Facultative reinsurance is negotiated separately for each insurance contract that is reinsured. Facultative reinsurance normally is purchased by ceding companies for individual risks not covered by their reinsurance treaties, for amounts in excess of the monetary limits of their reinsurance treaties and for unusual risks. Underwriting expenses and, in particular, personnel costs, are higher relative to premiums written on facultative business because each risk is individually underwritten and administered. The ability to separately evaluate each risk reinsured, however, increases the probability that the underwriter can price the contract to more accurately reflect the risks involved.
Proportional and Non-Proportional Reinsurance
Both treaty and facultative reinsurance can be underwritten on a proportional (or quota share) basis, or non-proportional (excess loss) basis or on a stop loss basis.
With respect to proportional or quota share reinsurance, the reinsurer, in return for a predetermined portion or share of the insurance premium charged by the ceding company, indemnifies the ceding company against a predetermined portion of the losses and loss adjustment expenses, or LAE, of the ceding company under the covered insurance contract or contracts. In the case of reinsurance written on a non-proportional, or excess of loss basis or excess of stop loss, the reinsurer indemnifies the ceding company against all or a specified portion of losses and LAE, on a claim by claim basis or with respect to a line of business, in excess of a specified amount, known as the ceding company’s retention or reinsurer’s attachment point, and up to a negotiated reinsurance treaty limit.
Although the losses under a quota share reinsurance treaty are greater in number than under an excess of loss contract, it is generally simpler to predict these losses on a quota share basis and the terms and conditions of the contract can be drafted to limit the total coverage offered under the contract. A quota share reinsurance treaty therefore does not necessarily require that a reinsurance company assume greater risk exposure than on an excess of loss contract. In addition, the predictability of the loss experience may better enable underwriters and actuaries to price such business accurately in light of the risk assumed, therefore reducing the volatility of results.
Excess of loss reinsurance is often written in layers. One or a group of reinsurers accepts the risk just above the ceding company’s retention up to a specified amount, at which point another reinsurer or a group of reinsurers accepts the excess liability up to a higher specified amount or such liability reverts to the ceding company. The reinsurer taking on the risk just above the ceding company’s retention layer is said to write working layer or low layer excess of loss reinsurance. A loss that reaches just beyond the ceding company’s retention will create a loss for the lower layer reinsurer, but not for the reinsurers on the higher layers. Loss activity in lower layer reinsurance tends to be more predictable than that in higher layers due to a greater historical frequency, and therefore, like quota share reinsurance, better enables underwriters and actuaries to more accurately price the underlying risks.
Premiums payable by the ceding company to a reinsurer for excess of loss reinsurance are not directly proportional to the premiums that the ceding company receives because the reinsurer does not assume a direct proportionate risk. In contrast, premiums paid by the ceding company to the reinsurer under a quota share contract are proportional to the premiums received by the ceding company, and correspond to its share of the risk coverage. In addition, in a quota share reinsurance treaty, the reinsurer generally pays the ceding company a ceding commission. The ceding commission is usually based on the ceding company’s cost of acquiring the business being reinsured (commissions, premium taxes, assessments and miscellaneous administrative expense) and also may include a profit factor for producing the business.
Retrocession
Reinsurers typically purchase reinsurance to cover their own risk exposure or to increase their capacity. Reinsurance of a reinsurer’s business is called a retrocession. Reinsurance companies cede risks under retrocession agreements to other reinsurers, known as retrocessionaires, for reasons similar to those that cause primary insurers to purchase reinsurance: to reduce net liability on individual risks, protect against catastrophic losses and obtain additional underwriting capacity.
Brokerage vs. Direct Reinsurance
Reinsurance can be written through professional reinsurance brokers or directly from ceding companies. A ceding company’s selection of one market over the other will be influenced by its perception of such advantages and disadvantages relative to the reinsurance coverage being placed. For example, broker coverages usually involve a number of participating reinsurers that have been assembled by a broker, each assuming a specified portion of the risk being reinsured. A ceding company may find it easier to arrange such coverage in a difficult underwriting environment where risk capacity is constrained and reinsurers are seeking to limit their risk exposure. In contrast, direct coverage is usually structured by ceding companies directly with one or a limited number of reinsurers. The relative amount of brokered and direct business written by the Group’s subsidiaries varies according to local market practice.
Cyclicality
The insurance and reinsurance sectors, particularly in the Non-Life area, are cyclical and are characterized by periods of intense price competition due to excessive underwriting capacity and periods when shortages of underwriting capacity permit favorable premium levels. The movement in reinsurance premiums is closely linked to the yearly renewal of treaties and contracts in

Page 111 of 184


 

specialty lines. If the claims experience and the financial results of reinsurers is favorable in a given year, ceding companies will be inclined to ask for price reductions in the most profitable lines of business. At the same time, new entrants to the reinsurance market may seek to take advantage of the profitable situation of the business, thus increasing the capacity and exerting pressure on premium rates. This situation of downward trends may be offset by natural catastrophes or large claims affecting certain lines of business or certain countries. After three years of steady increases in premiums, and a year of price stabilization in 2005, the reinsurance industry saw the first signs of a downturn in the market in most of the business lines, with the exception of general liability. The high number and substantial cost of the natural disasters that occurred in the second half of 2005 will probably slow, or even reverse, this trend in most markets.
8.5 PRODUCTS AND MARKETS
General
Our operations are organized into the following two business segments: the Non-Life segment and the Life segment. Non-Life is further organized into two sub-segments: Property & Casualty and Large Corporate Accounts’ treaties underwritten on a facultative basis. For additional information on the contribution to SCOR Global P&C made by certain reinsurance casualty segments of SCOR in France and outside France, see Section 8.13 — Business. Within each segment, we write various classes of business, as indicated below. Responsibilities and reporting within the Group are established based on this structure, and our consolidated financial statements reflect the activities of each segment.
The Credit, Surety and Political Risks sector covers proportional or non-proportional reinsurance treaties with companies specialized in credit and surety insurance. SCOR has integrated its Credit, Surety and Political Risks business into its Non-Life division since it was a relatively small treaty business and, accordingly, its Credit, Surety and Political Risks business is no longer treated as a separate business segment in its financial statements.
The following table sets forth our gross premiums written by segment and class of business:
                                 
             
    2004     2005  
        %         %  
By business segment:
                               
Non Life
    1,396       55 %     1,383       57 %
Life Reinsurance
    1,165       45 %     1,024       43 %
Total
    2,561       100 %     2,407       100 %
 
                       
 
                               
By business sub-segment
                               
Non Life
                               
Property-Casualty Treaty
                               
Property
    611       45 %     591       43 %
Casualty
    396       28 %     299       22 %
Marine, Aviation and Transportation
    32       2 %     31       2 %
Construction
    90       6 %     131       9 %
Total P&C treaties
    1,129       81 %     1,052       76 %
Facultatives and Large Corporate Accounts (BS)
                               
Property
    167       12 %     180       13 %
Casualty
    31       2 %     36       3 %
Marine, Aviation and Transportation
    30       2 %     60       4 %
Construction
    39       3 %     55       4 %
Facultatives and Large Corporate Accounts
    267       19 %     331       24 %
Total Non Life
    1,396       100 %     1,383       100 %
Reinsurance-Life
                               
Annuities
    76       7 %     56       5 %
Reinsurance individual or group Life
    826       71 %     701       69 %
Accident
    67       6 %     54       5 %
Disability
    52       4 %     82       8 %
Health
    37       3 %     33       3 %
Unemployment
    29       2 %     16       2 %
Long-term care
    78       7 %     82       8 %
Total Reinsurance-Life
    1,165       100 %     1,024       100 %
Non Life
The Non Life segment is divided into two operational sub–segments:

Page 112 of 184


 

-  Property & Casualty Treaty; and
-  Facultatives and Large Corporate Accounts.
Property & Casualty Treaties
The Property & Casualty sub-segment includes damages to property and personal injuries; marine, aviation and transportation; and construction.
Property. These proportional and non-proportional treaties of the Group cover damages to the underlying assets or operating losses caused by fire or other events in the housing, automobile, industrial and commercial premises product lines and the damages caused by third parties under third-party liability coverage.
Casualty. The Group’s casualty treaties both proportional and non-proportional, cover personal injuries as the result of accidents or those caused by third parties. Accordingly, they include treaties covering auto liability and general third-party liability. Auto liability reinsurance covers bodily injuries and other risks arising from both private driver and passenger and commercial fleet auto coverage.
Marine, Aviation and Transportation. The Group’s marine, aviation and transportation treaty business relates primarily to shipping and onshore transport risks, as well as a limited number of aeronautics and aviation policies.
Construction. The Group’s construction treaty business, primarily written on a proportional basis, includes inherent defect insurance coverage, also known as ten-year insurance. As required by French and Spanish law, ten-year insurance covers major structural defects and collapse for ten years after completion of construction of a building.
Credit, Surety and the coverage of political risks are managed by teams based in Europe. In credit insurance, the insurer covers the risks of losses due to non-payment of trade accounts receivable, while surety insurance is a contract under which a guarantor undertakes with regard to a beneficiary to executive the obligation to ensure payment by or to pay the debt of the secured debtor. Political risk insurance covers the risk of losses due to measures taken by a government or similar entity that endangers the existence of a sales contract or commitment made by a public or private citizen of the country in which the covered operations are performed.
Facultatives and Large Corporate Accounts
The second sub-segment of the Non Life segment is Facultatives and Large Corporate Accounts, which is also known as SCOR Business Solutions, or SBS. In addition to Facultative Services to ceding companies, SBS is composed of four industrial business sectors: Energy and Utilities, New Technologies (including space risks) and Finances & Services, Industry, Construction and Major Projects; it also includes the Ten-Year Liability business. SBS consists primarily of facultative business, which is underwritten by specialized teams and was reorganized in 2000 to cover the activities of corporate buyers seeking global risk financing solutions that combine traditional risk coverage and other alternative financing solutions. The risks shared with the ceding companies are large-scale industrially or technically complex risks, such as semiconductor plants, chemical facilities, oil and gas exploration and production sites, energy production facilities, and boiler and machinery installations.
The Large Corporate Accounts policies are primarily underwritten in property, as well as, to a lesser degree, in third-party liability, transportation and offshore, space and construction.
Underwriting facultatives in the space and offshore sectors requires the application of sophisticated underwriting criteria and risk analysis. Offshore business relates to offshore oil and gas exploration and operations, while space business relates to satellite assembly, launch and coverage for commercial space programs.
Construction facultative coverage is typically provided against risk of loss due to physical property damage caused during the construction period as well as, in certain cases, business interruption or other financial losses incurred as a result of completion delays for large and complex construction and industrial projects. The Group has acted or is acting as lead or principal reinsurer on several world scale infrastructure projects. For these leading projects, SCOR takes an active role in all phases of the development, and works with ceding companies, brokers, insured, risk managers and project sponsors in optimizing the combination of risk management techniques and insurance solutions.
Industrial clients are particularly sensitive to the ratings of the reinsurers that cover their risks.
Life Reinsurance
Life reinsurance includes life insurance products, as well as casualty such as accidents, disability, health, unemployment and the risk of long-term care.
Life. The Group’s Life business, written primarily in the form of proportional and non-proportional treaties, includes individual or group Life reinsurance, reinsurance for annuity-based products, and life reinsurance, primarily with Life insurance companies and pension funds.
Accident, disability, health, unemployment and long-term care. This business is primarily covered by proportional treaties.
Competitive position of our Life and Non-Life businesses.
The SCOR Group is the twelfth largest reinsurer in the world according to the Association of French Reinsurers (ARF), based on gross premium income in 2004.

Page 113 of 184


 

The business of SCOR VIE gives the SCOR Group the rank of seventh in the world in gross premiums in 2004, based on the most recent classification published by Standard & Poor’s.
The top six reinsurers in the world in Life and the principal competitors of SCOR Vie are the following: Swiss Re, Munich Re, RGA, Hannover Re, Employers Re/GE Insurance Solutions and General Re/Berkshire Hathaway Re.
In the 2004 rankings, SCOR VIE is ahead of: Revios, XL Re and Transamerica Re.
In the French market, according to the rankings published in October 2005 in Argus de l’Assurance for 2004, SCOR Vie is the leading reinsurer in volume of gross premiums, ahead of the following (in descending order): Mut Ré, Hannover Re, Munich Re, General Re, Prevoyance Re, CCR, Partner Re, Swiss Re, GE Frankona Re, XL Re Life and Revios.
As reported in the same Argus article, SCOR VIE is also the leading operator in the French market in reinsuring long-term care risk, which gives the SCOR Group a major competitive advantage in the world markets for the development of this complex product. In fact, France, along with the United States and Japan, is one of the world’s three major markets for private long-term care insurance.
For the Non-Life business, the figures from the 2004 balance sheet published by the ARF place SCOR 12th in the rankings of the top twenty Non-Life reinsurers for 2004.
If one looks at the data published at the end of the renewals of January 1, 2006 by SCOR’s main competitors included in this classification, and which operate like SCOR with “non-Bermudan” business models, i.e. Munich Re, Swiss Re and Hannover Re, SCOR is positioned as follows:
- the European dominance in its portfolio is the most intense;
- the North American component is the lowest;
- the proportion of P&C premiums is the highest and, in contrast, the proportion of Third-Party Liability premiums is the lowest;
- the proportion of Special Risk premium is relatively high, which reflects SCOR’s leadership in the Ten-Year Liability business;
- the proportion of Credit-Surety premiums is in line with the competition.
8.6 DISTRIBUTION BY GEOGRAPHIC AREA
As part of its strategic refocus in 2002, the Group continues to reorient its Non-Life business portfolio by geographic region, particularly with a deliberate reduction of underwriting in the United States. The strategic reorientation pursued since September 2002 has allowed the Group to underwrite better quality policies and treaties. As the result of its efforts, SCOR has reduced the percentage of its Non-Life premium income in the United States from 42% in 2002 to about 10% in 2005.
In 2005, SCOR generated approximately 55% of its gross premiums written in Europe, with significant market positions in France, Germany, Spain and Italy, 25% of its gross premiums written in North America, including Bermuda and the Caribbean region and 20% of its gross premiums written in Asia and in the rest of the world.
The following table shows the breakdown by gross volume of Life and Non-Life premiums written by geographic area based on the country in which the ceding company operates:
                                                 
 
In million   Total     Life     Non-Life  
    2005     2004     2005     2004     2005     2004  
 
France
    519       469       340       294       179       175  
Europe (excluding France)
    817       878       224       253       593       625  
Total Europe
    1,336       1,347       564       546       772       801  
North America
    594       762       379       542       215       220  
Asia/Australia/rest of world
    477       452       81       77       396       375  
 
                                               
Total
    2,407       2,561       1,024       1,165       1,383       1,396  
 
8.7 FINANCIAL RATINGS
Financial ratings are very important to all reinsurance companies, including SCOR, as ceding companies wish to reinsure their risks with companies with satisfactory financial strength. Our Life Reinsurance, Facultative and Large Corporate Accounts business, and direct underwriting activities are particularly sensitive to the way our clients and our ceding companies perceive our financial strength and to our ratings. See Section 8.9 – Risk factors affecting the Company–Financial rating plays an important role in our business.
Currently, the ratings given by Standard & Poor’s, A.M. Best Co. (“AM Best”) and Moody’s, are as follows:
                       
                       
        Insurer’s financial strength     Senior debt     Subordinated debt  
                       
 
S&P
    A-     A-     BBB  
 
 
                   
 
August 1, 2005
    (stable outlook)              
                       
 
AM Best
    B++     bbb     bbb-  
 
 
                   
 
November 8, 2005
    (positive outlook )     (positive outlook )     (positive outlook )  
                       
 
Moody’s
    Baa1     Baa1     Baa3  
 
 
                   
 
October 7, 2005
    (positive outlook )     (positive outlook )     (positive outlook )  
                       

Page 114 of 184


 

On August 1, 2005, the ratings agency S&P raised SCOR’s financial solvency rating from BBB+ to A-. The rating for senior debt was also raised from BBB+ to A- and subordinated debt from BBB- to BBB. The outlook for the rating is stable.
On November 8, 2005, A.M. Best confirmed the financial solvency of SCOR (Paris) and its principal subsidiaries to “B++” (Very Good). The outlook for the rating is positive.
On October 7, 2005 Moody’s Investors Service announced that it had upgraded SCOR’s Insurance Financial Strength Rating from Baa2 to Baa1, its Senior Debt from Baa3 to Baa1, and Subordinated Debt from Ba2 to Baa3. The outlook for these ratings is positive.
8.8 GROUP EMPLOYEES
As of December 31, 2005, the Group employed 994 people, including 565 at its headquarters in Paris, 208 in North America, 62 in the Asia-Pacific region, 141 in other European countries, and 18 in other regions.
The total number of employees decreased by 5.5% from 1,052 at year-end 2004 to 994 in 2005. The largest decrease was in North America and in the staff and financial sectors in Paris.
As part of the restructuring of the Group and its personnel, a Jobs Protection Plan was initiated in France in September 2005. The effects will be seen primarily in 2006.
101 persons in Paris are benefiting from this voluntary plan and are expected to leave the Group.
The following table shows the breakdown of employees: 1)
  By geographic region:
                         
 
    2005     2004     2003  
 
France
    565       587       639  
Europe excluding France
    141       150       167  
North America
    208       233       293  
Asia/Australia
    62       63       70  
Rest of world
    18       19       18  
 
Total
    994       1,052       1,187  
 
By business sectors:
                         
 
    2005     2004     2003  
 
Global P&C
    416       455       553  
Life
    215       224       238  
Staff and financial sectors
    363       373       396  
 
Total
    994       1,052       1,187  
 
1) The calculation of the total workforce is based on the registered workforce as at December 31, 2005 with expatriates being counted in their country of expatriation. The figures published last year, 1,038 in 2004 and 1,162 in 2003, were based on the workforce present on December 31 of each financial year, with expatriates being counted in their country of origin.
8.9 RISK FACTORS AFFECTING THE COMPANY
You should carefully consider the risk factors described below in conjunction with the other information and the SCOR consolidated financial statements with the related notes included in this reference document, before making any decision to buy or sell SCOR securities.
1 The insurance and reinsurance sectors are cyclical, which may impact our results.
The insurance and reinsurance sectors, particularly in the Non-Life area are cyclical. Historically, reinsurers have experienced significant fluctuations in operating results due to volatile and sometimes unpredictable developments, many of which are

Page 115 of 184


 

beyond the direct control of the reinsurer, including, notably, competition, frequency or severity of catastrophic events, levels of capacity and general economic conditions. Demand for reinsurance is influenced significantly by underwriting results of primary insurers and prevailing general economic conditions. The supply of reinsurance is related to prevailing prices, the levels of insured losses, levels of sector surplus and utilization of underwriting capacity that, in turn, may fluctuate in response to changes in rates of return on investments being earned in the insurance and reinsurance industries. As the performance of financial markets and reinsurers improves and reinsurance capacity increases, however, ceding companies are more inclined to ask for price reductions in the most profitable lines of business and underwriting quality tends to decline. At the same time, claims may be higher when economic conditions are unfavorable, particularly for products that provide reinsurance coverage for a risk that is related to the financial condition of the company that is being insured. As a result, the reinsurance business has been cyclical historically, characterized by periods of intense price competition due to excessive underwriting capacity and periods when shortages of underwriting capacity permit favorable premium levels.
We may, therefore, experience the effects of economic cycles and there is no guarantee that changes in premium rates, the frequency and severity of disasters or other losses, or other factors affecting the insurance and reinsurance industries in general will not have a material adverse effect on our revenues, net income, operating income and financial position.
2 We are exposed to losses due to catastrophic events.
Like all reinsurers, our operating results and financial position may, as in the past, be adversely affected by natural and man-made catastrophes resulting in claims under the Property-Casualty and Life reinsurance coverage we provide. Catastrophes can be caused by a variety of events including hurricanes, windstorms, earthquakes, hail, severe winter weather, fires and explosions. In 2004 and 2005, SCOR, like most other reinsurers, but to a lesser degree because of its underwriting policy that tends to exclude treaties that only cover the consequences of natural disasters, was impacted by the extraordinary number of natural catastrophes, particularly the major hurricanes in the United States, Mexico and the Caribbean in 2004 and 2005 and numerous typhoons in Japan in 2004. The Group’s primary exposure to natural catastrophes mainly concerned earthquakes, particularly in Japan, Taiwan, Canada, Portugal, Israel, Chile, Italy and Turkey, and storms and other weather phenomena in Europe, Asia and, to a lesser extent, in the United States.
The frequency and severity of such events, particularly natural catastrophes, are by their nature unpredictable. The inherent unpredictability of these events makes forecasts and risk evaluations uncertain for any given year. As a result, our claims experience may vary significantly from one year to the next, which can have a significant impact on our profitability and financial situation. In addition, depending on the frequency and nature of the losses, the speed at which claims are made and the terms of the policies in question, we may be required to make large claim payments. We may be forced to fund these obligations by liquidating investments under unfavorable market conditions, or by raising funds under unfavorable financial terms. These elements could have significant consequences for our financial position.
We have succeeded in managing our exposure to catastrophes through a policy of selective underwriting practices, particularly by limiting our exposure to certain events which are now frequent in the Gulf of Mexico, and by monitoring the accumulation of risks by geographic region, and by retroceding a portion of those risks to other reinsurers (retrocessionnaires) selectively chosen based on their solid financial solvency margin. There can be no assurance that such measures, including the management of risks on a geographic basis or retrocessions, will be sufficient to protect us against major losses from catastrophes, or that retrocession will continue to be possible at commercially acceptable rates. Although we strive to limit our exposure to acceptable levels, it is possible that several concurrent catastrophic events could have a material adverse effect on our assets, operating income and financial position. To obtain a better picture of our possible exposure, we strengthened our modeling of our exposure to natural catastrophes by adopting the Eqecat model in 2005.
3 We may suffer losses due to our exposure to risk related to terrorist acts.
In the context of our business, we may be exposed to claims arising from the consequences of terrorist acts. These risks, the potential significance of which can be illustrated by the September 11, 2001 attack in the United States, can affect both individuals and property. The September 11, 2001 attack on the World Trade Center initially led the Group to fund reserves as a reinsurer, which were valued on the basis of the assumption that the attack on the two towers of the World Trade Center was a single event and not two events under the terms of the applicable insurance policy issued to the lessees of the WTC and other persons.
On December 6, 2004, a jury determined that the attack on the World Trade Center constituted two distinct occurrences and therefore our ceding company was liable for two events in application of the insurance policy it had written.
However, the jury did not determine the amount of the damages owed by the insurers. A separate appraisal procedure supervised by a court is in progress to determine the amount owed by the insurers for the damages resulting from the destruction of the WTC towers. Pending the final decision from the appraisal procedure, which is scheduled at the end of 2006 or early 2007, we have determined that it would be prudent to raise our reserves on the basis of the initial replacement value established by our ceding company. Accordingly, the gross amount of the reserves was raised from USD 355 million as of December 31, 2003 to USD 422 million as of December 31, 2004, and the net retrocession amount from USD 167.5 million to USD 193.5 million. Those amounts did not change significantly in 2005.
The jury’s verdict that the attack on the World Trade Center constituted two distinct occurrences and not a single occurrence under the wording of the insurance policy from our ceding company has been appealed in the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Second Circuit, and a decision is expected in 2006. See Section 8.16 – Exceptional events and litigation for a discussion of the current proceedings concerning the World Trade Center.
After the events of September 11, 2001, we adopted underwriting rules to exclude or limit our exposure to risks related to terrorism in our reinsurance treaties, in particular in those countries and for those risks considered as most exposed. Contracts entered into prior to the implementation of these measures, however, remain unchanged. In addition, it has not always been possible to implement these measures, particularly in our principal markets. For example, certain European countries do not permit excluding terrorist risks from insurance policies. Due to these regulatory constraints, we have actively supported the

Page 116 of 184


 

creation of insurance and reinsurance pools that involve insurance and reinsurance companies as well as public authorities in order to spread the risks of terrorist activity among the members of these pools. We are participating in pools that have been formed in certain countries, such as France (GAREAT), Germany (Extremus), and the Netherlands (NHT), which give us limited and known commitments. In the United States, although the “Terrorism Risk Insurance Act,” which initially (until the end of 2005), established a program of federal assistance to aid the insurance companies to cover the claims resulting from losses due to future terrorist acts and requires that terrorist acts be covered by insurers, was approved in November 2002 and extended in 2005, the American market continues to be exposed to certain substantial risks in this segment. However, SCOR has significantly reduced its exposure in the American market by substantially reducing underwriting of reinsurance treaties with the major national insurers (see also the section “Our results may be impacted by the inability of our retrocessionaires or other members of pools in which we participate to meet their obligations”). In addition to the commitments described above, the Group does reinsure, from time to time, terrorist risks, usually limiting by event and by period the coverage that ceding companies receive for damage caused by terrorist acts.
As a result, new terrorist acts, whether in the United States or other countries, could result in the payment of substantial claims and, therefore, could have a significant effect on our operating income, results of operations, financial condition and our future profitability.
4 We could suffer losses as a result of our exposure to environmental pollution and asbestos-related risks.
Like other reinsurance companies, we are exposed to environmental and asbestos-related risks, particularly in the United States. Insurers are required under their contracts with us to notify us of any claims or potential claims that they are aware of. However, we often receive notices from insurers of potential claims related to environmental and asbestos risks that are imprecise, as the primary insurer may not have fully evaluated the risk at the time it notifies us of the claim. Due to the imprecise nature of these claims, the uncertainty surrounding the extent of coverage under insurance policies and whether or not particular claims are subject to an aggregate limit, the number of occurrences involved in particular claims and new theories of insured and insurer liability, we can, like other reinsurers, only give a very approximate estimate of our potential exposure to environmental and asbestos claims that may or may not have been reported. In 2005, SCOR increased its reserves for asbestos-related risks by 13 million and reduced its reserves for environmental risks by 15 million following commutations based on old risks in Europe. As of December 31, 2005, we believe that we have sufficient reserves to meet our commitments for environment and asbestos-related risks, representing about eleven years of payments.
Nonetheless, due to the changing legal and regulatory environment, including changes in tort law, the evaluation of the final cost of our exposure to asbestos-related and environmental claims may be increasing in undefined proportions. Diverse factors could increase our exposure to the consequences of asbestos-related risks, such as an increase in the number of claims filed or in the number of persons likely to be covered by these claims. Evaluation of these risks is all the more difficult given that claims related to asbestos and environmental pollution are often subject to payments over long periods of time. Under these conditions, it is difficult to evaluate the amount of the reserves to be funded for these loss risks. We therefore rely on market assessments of survival ratios for funding our reserves although data currently available for the American market relates to old underwriting years for which we do not have a substantial exposure.
Because of the lack of information and uncertainties, we cannot exclude the possibility that we may have to pay significant environmental and asbestos claims, which could have a material adverse effect on our operating income, results of operations, financial condition and our future profitability.
5 If our reserves prove to be inadequate, our net income, operating income and financial position may be adversely affected.
We are required to maintain reserves to cover our estimated ultimate liability for Property-Casualty losses and loss adjustment expenses with respect to reported and unreported claims incurred as of the end of each accounting period, net of estimated related salvage and subrogation claims. Our reserves are established on the basis of the information provided to us by the insurance companies, particularly the level of their reserves and also on our knowledge of the risks, the studies we conduct and the trends that we regularly observe. For our Life business, we are required to maintain reserves for future policy benefits that take into account expected investment yields and mortality, morbidity, lapse rate and other assumptions. In our Non-Life business, our reserves and policy pricing are based on a number of assumptions and on information provided by third parties, which, if proven to be incorrect, could have an adverse effect on our results of operations. Even though we are entitled to audit the companies with which we do business, and despite our frequent contacts with these companies, our reserving policy remains dependent on the risk evaluations of these companies.
The inherent uncertainties in estimating reserves are compounded for reinsurers by the significant periods of time that often elapse between the occurrence of an insured loss, the reporting of the loss to the primary insurer and ultimately to the reinsurer, the primary insurer’s payment of that loss and subsequent indemnification by the reinsurer, as well as by differing reserving practices among ceding companies and changes in case law, particularly in the United States.
Furthermore, we have a significant exposure to a number of business lines for which we know it is particularly difficult to monitor reserves because of the “long-tail” nature of our businesses, particularly workers’ compensation, liabilities insurance, and environmental and asbestos-related claims. Our reserves for these lines of business represent a significant portion of our technical reserves, although the proportion has been decreasing as we have correlatively increased the proportion of our Property business relative to our Casualty and liability business. In relation to such claims, it has in the past been necessary to revise our estimated potential loss exposure and, therefore, the related loss reserves. Changes in the law, regulations, case law and legal doctrine, as well as developments in class action litigation, particularly in the United States, add to the uncertainties inherent in claims of this type.
We review our method and the amount of reserves annually and conduct portfolio audits if necessary. To the extent that our reserves prove to be insufficient, after taking into account available retrocession coverage, we increase our reserves and incur a

Page 117 of 184


 

charge to earnings, which can have a material adverse effect on our consolidated net income and financial condition. We strengthened our reserves on several occasions in 2002 and 2003 following internal and external actuarial reviews. At the accounts closure on September 30, 2003, the Group increased its technical reserves by 297 million. A large portion of those additional reserves, an amount of 290 million, was related to losses from business underwritten by SCOR US and CRP over the period from 1997 to 2001. Those additional reserves are primarily related to business lines placed in run-off, such as buffer layers and program business, or sharply reduced, such as workers’ compensation. If we have to raise our reserves in the future, it could materially impact our results and our financial position.
In addition, because we, like other reinsurers, do not separately evaluate each of the risks insured under reinsurance treaties, we are largely dependent on the original underwriting decisions made by ceding companies. We are subject to the risk that our ceding companies may not have adequately evaluated the risks to be reinsured and that the premiums ceded to us may not adequately compensate us for the risk we assume. To reduce this risk, we conduct risk audits and regularly visit our ceding companies, and carry out portfolio audits of our business.
6 Our results may be impacted by the inability of our retrocessionaires or other members of pools in which we participate to meet their obligations and by the ability to retrocede commitments under acceptable commercial terms.
We transfer a portion of our exposure to certain risks to other reinsurers through retrocession arrangements. Under these arrangements, other reinsurers assume a portion of our losses and expenses associated with losses in exchange for a portion of policy premiums. When we obtain retrocession, we are still liable for those transferred risks if the reinsurer cannot meet its obligations. We also assume credit risk by writing business on a fund withheld basis. Therefore, the inability of our retrocessionnaires to meet their financial obligations could materially affect our operating income and financial position. We periodically review the financial position of our reinsurers. Their financial strength may have deteriorated at the time they are asked to pay the amounts due, which can occur many years after the contract is signed. Accounts receivable for which a probable loss is recorded are depreciated in our accounts. Furthermore, since our reinsurers do business in the same sector as we do, events that have an adverse effect on the sector could have the same effect on all of the participants in the reinsurance sector.
To reduce these risks, we maintain a prudent policy for the selection of our retrocessionnaires. Moreover, a portion of the accounts receivable due from our retrocessionnaires is guaranteed by letters of credit or the deposits of our retrocessionnaires.
We participate in various pools of insurers and reinsurers in order to spread certain risks, in particular terrorism risks, among the members of the pool. In case of the complete default of a member of a pool, we could be required to assume a portion of the liabilities and obligations of the defaulting member, which could affect our financial position.
7 We operate in a highly competitive business sector.
The reinsurance business is highly competitive. Our position in the reinsurance market is based on several factors, such as the financial strength of the reinsurer as perceived by the ratings agencies; underwriting expertise; reputation and experience in the lines written; the jurisdiction in which the reinsurer is licensed, the premiums charged, as well as the other terms and conditions of the reinsurance offered, the services offered and the speed at which claims are paid. We compete for business in the French, European, American, Asian and other international reinsurance markets with numerous international and domestic reinsurance companies, some of which have a larger market share, greater financial resources and higher ratings from financial ratings agencies than we do.
When the supply of reinsurance is greater than the demand from ceding companies, our competitors, some of which have higher financial ratings, may be better positioned to enter into new contracts and to gain market shares at our expense. From 2003 to mid-2005, our rating had a significant impact on our competitive position. When S&P upgraded our rating on August 1, 2005, it improved our competitive position in our principal markets. However, the fact that we have not obtained an A rating from the AM Best rating agency is currently penalizing our operations and our competitive position in the United States, primarily in Life Reinsurance, but we cannot quantify the impact (see the risk factor “Financial rating plays an important role in our business”).
8 We are exposed to the risks of changes in interest rates and trends in the capital markets.
Investment returns are an important part of our overall profitability and changes in interest rates and fluctuations in the fixed income and equity markets could have a material adverse impact on our profitability, cash flows, results of operations and financial condition.
Interest rate fluctuations could have consequences on our return from fixed-income securities, as well as the market values of, and corresponding levels of capital gains or losses on the fixed-income securities in our investment portfolio. Interest rates are extremely sensitive to a number of factors beyond our control, including monetary and government policies, the economic environment and national and international policy.
During periods of declining interest rates, the Life insurance products and periodic-premium savings products, including the periodic-premium savings products invested in rate instruments (“fixed annuities”) of SCOR Life U.S. Re, may become relatively more attractive to consumers, and may result in increased premium payments on products with flexible premium features, and an increase in the number of insurance policies renewed from year to year. During such a period, our investment earnings may be lower because the interest earnings on our fixed-income investments likely will have declined in parallel with market interest rates.
In addition, our fixed-income investments are more likely to be prepaid or redeemed as borrowers seek to borrow at lower interest rates. Consequently, we may be required to reinvest the proceeds in securities bearing lower interest rates. Accordingly,

Page 118 of 184


 

during periods of declining interest rates, our profitability may suffer as a result of the decrease in the spread between interest rates credited to policyholders and returns on our investment portfolio.
Conversely, an increase in interest rates, as well as fluctuations in the capital markets, could also lead to unanticipated changes in the surrender methods for “fixed annuities” and other Life reinsurance products, including the fixed annuities of SCOR Life U.S. Re, particularly during periods of rising interest rates. This would result in cash outflows that might require the sale of assets at a time when the investment portfolio is negatively affected by increases in interest rates, resulting in losses.
We are also exposed to credit risks in the fixed-income securities markets since the financial difficulties of certain issuers and the deterioration of their credit quality could make payment of their obligations uncertain and lead to lower market prices for their fixed-income securities, which would affect the value of our investment portfolio.
Rate risk is managed within the Group primarily at two levels. At the level of each entity, we take into account the asset-liabilities backing policy and the rules of congruence, and local regulatory, accounting and tax constraints. At the central level, we conduct operations to consolidate all portfolios in order to identify the overall risk and return level.
Accordingly, the Group has analytic tools that guide both its strategic allocation and local distribution.
The sensitivity to changes in interest rates is analyzed generally on a monthly basis. The Group analyzes the impact of a major change in interest rates on all the portfolios and at the global level. In such a case, the Group identifies the unrealized capital loss if rates rise and then decides whether a hedging policy should be implemented. We measure the instantaneous unrealized loss for a uniform increase of 100 basis points in the rates or in the case of a distortion of the structures by interest rate terms. The primary risk measurement used is sensitivity or duration. An analysis of the impact on the portfolio may lead to decisions for reallocation or hedging.
The rate risk is monitored continuously by the Group. Because of an essentially medium-term investment activity that is tied to the duration of liabilities, portfolio rotation is moderate. Thus, the Group’s average duration is relatively stable, which allows rapid risk assessment.
For maturities and interest rates on financial assets and liabilities, and for an analysis of interest rate sensitivity, see Section 5.7 — Notes to Consolidated Financial Statements – Note 28 – Maturity and interest rates of financial assets and liabilities and Sensitivity to foreign exchange and interest rates.
9 We must face risks related to our equity-based portfolio.
We are exposed to equity price risk. The stocks of publicly traded companies represented about 9% of our investments as of December 31, 2005. The stock markets rose in 2005, generating capital gains. Conversely, a general and sustained decline in the equity markets would mean a depreciation of our stock portfolio. Such depreciation could affect our operating results and financial condition.
Stock investments are considered to be an asset class that is both traditional and strategic for the Group. The goal is to develop and manage a quality and diversified portfolio of stocks that will appreciate over the medium term (investment horizon greater than 2 years). We also look for stocks that offer high dividend pay-outs. Thus, our approach is basic.
Our exposure to the stock market is generated both by direct stock purchases and by purchases of units in mutual funds.
Because stocks are more volatile than bonds, this asset class is continually tracked. All stock positions (directly held or held in mutual funds) are aggregated and valued daily. This approach allows us to monitor changes in the portfolio and to identify the investments with higher than average volatility as soon as possible (alert signals). It also facilitates portfolio arbitrage or reorganization decisions.
The stock risk is controlled and measured. It is controlled at the level of the Group’s exposure, which is decided by management and regularly reviewed by the Investment Committee (generally once a month). It is also controlled by a maximum exposure defined by stock or by mutual fund, which is reviewed on a regular basis (the exposure to a large cap stock will generally be greater than exposure to a mid-cap stock). The control ratios on mutual funds are also reviewed regularly.
To measure the risk, a “stock” beta of 1 is generally used. This assumption consists of considering that the whole portfolio varies homogeneously and with the same magnitude as the stock market, which is true on the average. Therefore, the Group has a daily measurement of the change in the unrealized value of the stock portfolio for an instantaneous change of plus or minus 10% in the stock market.
10 Financial ratings are important to our business.
Our ratings are reviewed periodically. In 2003, the leading ratings agencies downgraded our financial ratings several times and placed them on watch, notably following the announcement of the increase in our technical reserves and the amount of our losses in third quarter 2003. Although S&P raised our rating from BBB+ to A- on August 1, 2005, we have not yet received an A rating from AM Best, which impacts our competitiveness, primarily in the United States.
Our Life, major account Facultatives and our direct underwriting businesses are particularly sensitive to the perception of our financial position and rating held by ceding companies and our clients. Our rating in 2004 made it difficult to renew certain contracts and certain treaties with existing clients and to obtain new clients, particularly in the Life and large account Facultatives business and in our direct underwriting segments. In addition, those ratings also led to a reduction by certain ceding companies of their shares in treaties or contracts in 2004. Finally, some of our reinsurance treaties contain termination clauses triggered by ratings.

Page 119 of 184


 

The timing of any changes to our credit ratings is particularly important to our business since our contracts and treaties in the Life and major account Facultatives are renewed according to a precise schedule throughout the year. In the United States, our contracts and treaties are generally renewed on January 1 and July 1. If our rating from AM Best does not improve before these renewal dates, it could have an adverse effect on our revenues in 2006 and 2007.
Moreover, a portion of our business is conducted with American ceding companies which, because of local regulations and market practices, require us to obtain letters of credit from banks in order to sign reinsurance treaties. If we are unable to honor our financial commitments under our outstanding credit facilities or if we suffer any further ratings downgrade, our financial situation and results could be significantly affected.
11 A significant portion of our treaties contain provisions relating to financial strength, which could have an adverse effect on our financial situation.
Some of our reinsurance treaties, notably in the Scandinavian countries, the United Kingdom and the United States, contain clauses concerning financial strength, and provide for the possibility of early termination for our ceding companies if our rating is downgraded, if our net financial position falls below a certain threshold, or if we carry out a reduction in share capital. Accordingly, such events could allow some of our ceding companies to terminate their contract commitments, which would have a material adverse effect, but which cannot be quantified, on our financial position.
Moreover, our principal lines of credit contain financial commitments and financial requirements which, if not met, constitute default and result in the suspension of the use of current credit facilities and a ban on obtaining new lines of credit, which could in some cases have a negative impact on our financial position.
12 We face liquidity requirements in the short to medium-term.
The main sources of revenue from our reinsurance operations are premiums, revenues from investing activities, and realized capital gains. The bulk of these funds are used to pay out claims and related expenses, together with other operating costs. Our operations generate substantial cash flows because most premiums are received prior to the date at which claims must be paid out. These positive operating cash flows, together with the portion of the investment portfolio held directly in cash or highly liquid securities, have always allowed us to meet the cash demands generated by our operating activities.
    In June 2004, we issued for a nominal amount of 200 million, OCEANEs, which are bonds convertible or exchangeable for new or existing shares. The OCEANE bonds will be fully redeemed on January 1, 2010. We used the proceeds from the OCEANE bond issue with available cash to repay 235 million on our 1999 OCEANE bonds that matured on January 1, 2005.
 
    In 2002, we issued 200 million of unsubordinated notes redeemable at maturity on June 21, 2007.
Despite the level of cash generated by SCOR’s ordinary activities, we may be required to seek full or partial external financing in order to meet some or all of the foregoing payments.
The amount of any required external financing will depend in the first place on the Group’s available cash. Our decision to withdraw from a significant number of business lines has significantly reduced our premium income, which may further affect our cash flow. A significant portion of our Life assets are collateralized, either to secure letters of credit obtained from banks to allow us to enter into reinsurance treaties with ceding companies, or to guarantee payment of loss claims made by ceding companies. These liabilities amount to 2,080 and limit our capacity to increase liquid assets through asset disposals. The credit agreements were renewed in 2005. The cash available in Group subsidiaries may not be transferable to the Company, in application of local regulations and because of the cash needs of those subsidiaries.
Moreover, access to outside financing depends on a large number of other factors, many of which are beyond our control, including general economic conditions, market conditions, and investor perceptions of our industry and our financial position. In addition, our ability to raise new financing depends on clauses in our outstanding finance contracts and on our credit ratings. We cannot guarantee that we will be in a position to obtain additional financing, or to do so on commercially acceptable terms. If we were unable to do so, the pursuit of our business development strategy and our financial condition would be materially adversely affected.
13 We are exposed to risks linked to foreign exchange rates.
We publish our consolidated financial statements in euros, but a significant part of our income and expenses, as well as our assets and liabilities, are denominated in currencies other than the Euro. Consequently, fluctuations in the exchange rates used to translate these currencies into euros may have a significant impact on our reported results of operations and net equity from year to year.
Fluctuations in exchange rates can have consequences on our results because of the conversion of those results into foreign currencies and the absence of congruency between assets and liabilities in foreign currencies.
We ensure that each legal entity of the Group is congruent for all currencies used and, as a result, currency fluctuations have only minimum impact on the Group’s earnings. Thus, as of December 31, 2005, the Group’s currency result was 8 million, compared with -13 million at December 31, 2004.
This congruence policy is achieved either through over-the-counter arbitrage or through the use of forward hedges.
In addition, the equity of most of the entities of our Group are denominated in a currency other than the Euro, often in US dollars.

Page 120 of 184


 

As a result, a change in the exchange rates used to convert foreign currencies into euros, particularly the weakness of the dollar against the Euro in recent years, has had and may have in the future, a negative impact on our consolidated equity. However, during 2005, the appreciation of the dollar generated a positive translation adjustment of 97.6 million in the Group’s equity. These changes in the value of the equity of our subsidiaries is not currently hedged by the Group.
For the consolidated net position of assets and liabilities by currency, and for an analysis of sensitivity to exchange rates, see Section 5.7 - Notes to Consolidated Financial Statements – Note 28 — Exposure to currency fluctuations and Sensitivity to currency and interest rates.
14 Our Non-Life subsidiaries in the United States have had to face financial difficulties and some of our American subsidiaries are subject to a regulatory review by U.S. insurance regulators.
The activities of our American Non-Life subsidiaries cover current activities and run-off activities. These run-off activities have deteriorated, primarily because of an increase in the claims rate for the years from 1997 to 2001, the terrorist attacks on September 11, 2001 and claims that have affected the workers’ compensation and credit-surety business lines. As the result of American regulatory solvency requirements, we had to strengthen the long-term capital of our American subsidiaries in 2003, 2004 and 2005 through share capital increases totaling USD 402 million or by granting loans.
As a result of those share capital increases, active management of the run-off activities, a reduction in the volume of premiums underwritten in 2004, and careful cost management, the total assets and solvency margin of our American subsidiaries were much greater than American regulatory requirements at December 31, 2005.
Our American insurance and reinsurance subsidiaries are required to file financial reports in the states in which they are licensed or authorized, prepared in accordance with the accounting principles and methods required by the New York State Insurance Department (NYID) or other supervisory authorities in the Federal states in which they are headquartered.
15 We face risks from changes in government regulations and laws and certain litigation matters.
As of this date, we are subject to detailed and complete regulations and to the supervision of the insurance and reinsurance regulatory authorities in all countries in which we operate. Changes in existing laws and regulations may affect the way in which we conduct our business and the products we may offer or the amount of reserves to be posted, including on claims already declared. Insurance and reinsurance supervisory authorities have broad administrative power over many aspects of the reinsurance industry and we cannot predict the timing or form of any future regulatory initiatives. Furthermore, these authorities are concerned primarily with the protection of policyholders rather than shareholders or creditors. The diverse regulations governing our industry would be reduced after the transposition of Directive 2005/68/EC of November 16, 2005 which confers control of a community reinsurance company exclusively to the regulatory authority in the country in which the company is headquartered. Moreover, under this directive, a regulation governing technical reserves, solvency margins and guarantee funds would apply to European reinsurers as of December 10, 2007 or, if national lawmakers use the option granted by the directive to provide an additional 12-month period to allow reinsurers already established to comply with new prudential requirements, as of December 10, 2008. The directive defines the minimum conditions common to all member States of the Community, and gives national legislators the option to set more stringent requirements. The national provisions adopted for the transposition of this directive, as well as other legislative or regulatory changes, could increase the harmonization of regulations governing reinsurers with the regulations governing insurers. Those new regulations and statutes may over time restrict our ability to write new contracts or treaties. Moreover, we are involved in legal and arbitration proceedings in certain jurisdictions, particularly in Europe and the United States. In particular, we are parties to an action filed by the former minority shareholder of IRP Holdings Limited in Boston (Massachusetts, United States) (See Section 8.16 – Exceptional events and litigation). Negative changes in laws or regulations or an adverse outcome of these proceedings could have a material adverse affect on our business, liquidity, financial position and operating results.
The reinsurance industry can also be affected by political, judicial, social and other legal developments, which have at times in the past resulted in new or expanded grounds of liability. For example, we could be subject to new regulations that would require an obligation for additional coverage beyond our intent at the time of underwriting, or which would increase the number or size of claims which we would have to meet. We cannot predict the impact of changing political, judicial, social and legal developments on our operations, and any change could have a material adverse effect on our financial position, operating results or cash flows.
16 Political, legal, regulatory and industry initiatives relating to the reinsurance industry, including investigations into contingent commission arrangements and certain finite risk or alternative risk transfer reinsurance treaties, could have adverse consequences on our business and industry.
Recently, the insurance industry has experienced substantial volatility as a result of current litigation, investigations and regulatory activity by various administrative and regulatory authorities concerning certain practices within the insurance industry. These practices include the payment of contingent commissions by insurance companies to their brokers or agents, the disclosure of such compensation, and the accounting treatment of finite risk treaties or other types of non-traditional risk transfer products. At this time, it is not possible to predict the potential effects, if any, that these investigations may have on the insurance and reinsurance markets and industry business practices or customs or what, if any, or the changes which may be made to the laws and regulations governing the industry and financial reporting. Any of the aforementioned effects or changes could have adverse consequences on the reinsurance sector.
In addition, public authorities in the United States and the rest of the world review very carefully the potential risks presented by the reinsurance sector in general, and the consequences of those risks on the commercial and financial systems. While these investigations do not appear to have revealed new significant risks generated by the reinsurance sector for the financial system

Page 121 of 184


 

or the insured, and although it is not possible to predict the exact nature of possible initiatives by public authorities, or the schedule or scope of such initiatives, it is probable that stricter regulations could govern the reinsurance sector in the future.
17 Our business, our future profitability and our financial position would be adversely affected by the run-off of some of our activities in the United States and in Bermuda
In January 2003, we placed the CRP operations in run off and, under the “Back on Track” plan, we elected to withdraw from certain business lines in the United States. Those operations are organized as run-off activities, and we installed a management team to implement the management and commutation of those activities. The costs and liabilities associated with these run-off businesses and other contingent liabilities could force the Group to pay additional costs, which could impact the Group’s operating results.
An essential element of our strategy for the run-off of some of our operations in the United States includes the commutation of the risks held by our Bermudan subsidiary CRP and some of the risks underwritten in the United States by SCOR US. The current level of reserves was substantially reduced between December 31, 2002 and December 31, 2005, since it declined about 55% over that period. The possibility of commuting all the reserves within a foreseeable time is uncertain, because it depends heavily on the attitude of the ceding companies.
18 Our shareholders’ equity is sensitive to the value of our intangible assets.
A significant portion of our assets consists of intangible assets the value of which depends in large part on our future operational earnings. The valuation of intangible assets also assumes that we are making subjective and complex judgments concerning items that are uncertain by nature. If a change were to occur in the assumptions underlying the valuation of our intangible assets, we might be forced to reduce their value, in whole or in part, which would have the effect of reducing our capital base.
The amounts of the goodwill included in our consolidated financial statements may be affected by economic and market conditions. As of December 31, 2005, we had goodwill in the amount of 200 million, resulting principally from our acquisitions of South Barrington in 1996 and SOREMA North America and SOREMA S.A. in 2001. If the assumptions underlying the existence of these goodwill items were called into question, we might be forced to significantly depreciate the value of the related goodwill, which would have a negative impact on our results.
In order to evaluate any impairment of goodwill, an impairment test of goodwill is performed every year on the same date and more frequently if an unfavorable event occurs between two annual tests. An impairment is recognized when the net book value is greater than the recoverable value. The result of the test performed justifies the goodwill recognized in our accounts.
As of December 31, 2005, we had a total amount of net deferred tax assets of 143 million. The recognition of deferred tax assets is based on the applicable tax legislation and accounting methods and also depends on the performance of each unit, which allows recoverability of these deferred tax assets in the future. Because of the losses suffered, we were forced in 2003 to depreciate all the deferred tax assets of SCOR U.S. In 2005, SCOR U.S. recorded a loss, but we did not activate the taxes. The deferred taxes generated by the other entities of the Group were maintained. The deferred taxes generated by the other units of the group were maintained. Nevertheless, the occurrence of other events could lead to the loss of other deferred tax assets, such as changes in tax legislation or accounting methods, operational earnings lower than currently projected or losses continuing over a longer period than originally planned. All of these developments or each of them separately could have a significant negative impact on our financial position and our operating earnings.
Acquisition costs, including commissions and underwriting costs, are recognized as assets up to a maximum of the profitability of the contracts. They are amortized on the basis of the residual term of the contracts in Non-Life, and on the basis of the recognition of future margins for Life contracts. As a result, the assumptions considered concerning the recoverable nature of the deferred acquisition costs are, affected by factors such as operating results and market conditions. If the assumptions for recoverability of deferred acquisition costs are incorrect, it would then be necessary to accelerate amortization, which could have a substantial negative effect on our financial position and our operating results.
19 Operational risks, including human errors or systems failures, are inherent in our business.
Operational risks are inherent in our business. Operational risk and losses can result from business interruption, misconduct or fraud, errors by employees, failure to document transactions properly or to obtain proper internal authorization, failure to comply with regulatory requirements, information technology failures, poor vendor performance or external events.
We believe our modeling, underwriting and information technology and application systems are critical to the correction operation of our business. Moreover, our proprietary technology and applications have been an important part of our underwriting process and our ability to compete successfully. We have also licensed certain systems and data from third parties. We cannot be certain that we will have access to these, or comparable, service providers, or that our technology or applications will continue to operate as intended. Our information technology is subject to the risk of breakdowns and outages, disruptions due to viruses, attacks by hackers and theft of data. A major defect or failure in our internal controls or information technology and application systems could result in management distraction, harm to our reputation, increased expense or financial loss. The potential impact of these risks is considered from a qualitative and not a quantitative viewpoint. We believe appropriate controls and procedures to minimize the impact of the faults or defects described above are in place and are appropriate, or are being formalized and deployed. If not, the unfavorable consequences for our business could be significant.

Page 122 of 184


 

20 Insurance and risk coverage (excluding reinsurance activity)
SCOR, both at the level of the parent company and the subsidiaries, operates a financial business. Therefore, it is not dependent, as industrial companies may be, on a production tool, and generates few physical risks for its immediate environment.
Some of SCOR’s major assets include its IT network and its communication tools, which are regularly updated to reflect technological progress.
In these fields, emergency solutions have been organized off-site such as system duplication and data backup, to allow business continuity in the event of a major incident. Catastrophic scenarios that could affect SCOR’s entire working tool are being studied and will lead to the revision of the business continuity plan.
The properties and other assets of SCOR and its subsidiaries are covered locally for replacement value through property and fire damage and comprehensive IT risk policies. The levels of self-insurance depend on the risks insured and are generally less than 15,000 in deductibles per claim.
Liability risks are covered at Group level in amounts considered to be sufficient.
Third-party liability risks related to the operation of the company because of employees and properties are insured for 15 million. Professional liability risks are insured for 20 million above a self-insurance charge of 2 million. The Group is covered against the civil liability of its officers and directors. In addition, it has 10 million in fraud coverage. All of these insurance policies are with first-tier insurers.
The management of the Group’s property and liability insurance is subject to a validation procedure during which a steering committee composed of specialist employees is asked to issue an opinion every six months. Assessment of the strategies taken is performed by the Chief Risk Officer (CRO).
8.10 UNDERWRITING, RISK MANAGEMENT AND RETROCESSION
Underwriting
Consistent with its strategy of selective market and business segment development, the Group seeks to maintain a portfolio of business risks that is strategically diversified both geographically and by line and class of business. Pursuant to the “Moving Forward” plan, SCOR has attempted to reduce its exposure to the U.S. market by declining to underwrite major national insurers and by reducing the percentage of its non-Life reinsurance premium income earned in the United States from 15% in 2003 to 10% in 2005. In addition, the Company has established general underwriting guidelines for its subsidiaries in order to ensure the diversification and management of risks based on sectors and business categories.
Underwriting is performed by the dedicated teams of the Facultative and Major Corporate Account divisions in its Non-Life Segment and by underwriting teams in the Life segment, with the support of technical departments, such as actuaries, claims mangers, and the legal, retrocession and accounting departments.
Underwriting, actuarial, accounting and other support staff are located in the Group’s Paris headquarters as well as in local subsidiaries and branches. While underwriting is carried out at decentralized (subsidiary or division) level, the Group’s overall exposure to particular risks and in particular geographic zones is centrally monitored from Paris. The underwriting policy and rules are validated every year by the Chief Risk Officer (CRO).
Property-Casualty Treaty underwriters manage client relationships and offer reinsurance support after a careful review and assessment of the ceding company’s underwriting policy, portfolio profile, exposures and management procedures. They are responsible for writing treaty business as well as small facultative risks in their respective territories within the limits of their delegated underwriting authority and the scope of underwriting guidelines approved by the Group General Management.
The underwriting teams are supported by a technical underwriting unit based in the Group head office. The technical underwriting unit provides worldwide treaty and small facultative underwriting guidelines, the delegation of capacity, underwriting support to specific classes or individual risks when required, ceding company portfolio analyses and risk surveys.
The underwriting teams are also supported by a Group actuarial unit responsible for pricing and reserving methods and tools to be applied by the actuarial units based in the treaty operating units. The Group audit department conducts frequent underwriting audits in the operating units.
Most facultative underwriters belong to the Business Solutions departments centralized in the Global P&C division, which operates worldwide from five sites (Paris, London, Toronto, New York and Singapore) and with underwriting entities located in some of the Group’s subsidiaries or branches. This division is dedicated to large corporate businesses and is geared to provide its clients with solutions for hedging conventional risks. Small Property and Casualty facultative underwriting is handled by the Property-Casualty Treaty team.
Life underwriting within the Group is under the worldwide responsibility of SCOR VIE. Our Life clients are life insurance companies worldwide. They are served by specialized Life underwriters familiar with the specific features of each of the markets in which they operate, including mortality tables, morbidity risks, disability and pension coverage, product development, financing and specific market coverage and policy conditions. Life underwriting consists of the consideration of many factors, including the type of risks to be covered, ceding company retention levels, product and pricing assumptions and the ceding company’s underwriting standards and financial strength.

Page 123 of 184


 

Life underwriters worldwide are supported by the Life Underwriting Department, or LUD, which coordinates underwriting activities at the Group level and conducts underwriting audits in the operating units, and by the Technical and Development Department, or TDD, responsible for pricing tools, reserving rules, product development and retrocession. These two departments set the underwriting guidelines, which are approved by the Underwriting Innovation Committee, comprising SCOR Vie General Management, and the heads of underwriting units LUD and TDD. This Committee periodically reviews and updates the four levels of underwriting authority delegated to each underwriter.
Catastrophic events and managing risk exposure
Like other reinsurance companies, SCOR is exposed to multiple insured losses arising out of a single occurrence, whether a natural event such as a hurricane, windstorm, flood, hail or severe winter weather storm or an earthquake, or a man-made catastrophe such as an explosion or fire at a major industrial facility or an act of terrorism. Any such catastrophic event could generate insured losses in one or many of SCOR’s lines of business.
In 2005, like most other reinsurers, SCOR was affected by the abnormally high frequency of natural disasters throughout the world, particularly a storm in Europe, five hurricanes in the United States and Mexico, and a number of large claims for natural occurrences that were smaller in scope. Hurricanes Katrina, Rita and Wilma generated a total claims expense estimated before taxes and retrocessions, at 177.6 million at the end of 2005. The storms Erwin / Gudrun generated a total claims expense estimated before taxes and retrocession of 21.5 million, while hurricanes Stan and Emily, the floods in Europe and the Mumbai flood in India generated a total claims expense estimated before taxes and retrocession at 40 million.
In 2004, SCOR, like most other reinsurers, was adversely affected by the unusually high frequency of natural catastrophes around the world, including four hurricanes in the United States and the Caribbean and a number of typhoons in Asia. Hurricanes Ivan, Charley, Frances and Jeanne generated a total claims expense estimated before taxes and retrocession at 45 million at the end of 2005, compared with 34 million reported at the end of 2004. Typhoon Songda in Japan generated a claims expense estimated before taxes and retrocession at 49 million at December 31, 2005, compared with an estimate of 30 million, reported at December 31, 2004. Typhoons Rananim, Chaba and the tsunami in December 2004 had an impact of approximately 6 million on SCOR’s total claims expense, compared with an estimate of 12 million reported at December 31, 2004.
In 2003, SCOR suffered no major losses because of natural disasters. The largest claim was generated by storms in the U.S. Midwest for a net cost of about 20 million at the end of 2004, which had not changed at the end of 2005.
For all its property business, SCOR prudently evaluates the accumulations generated by potential natural events and other risks. This evaluation includes the risks underwritten by corporate headquarters and by its subsidiaries in France and elsewhere. Pursuant to the rules and procedures established by General Management in Paris, each subsidiary monitors the structure of its portfolio for each region or country and the Group Risk Management department based in Paris consolidates this data for the Group.
Depending on the region of the world and the danger in question, SCOR uses a variety of techniques to evaluate and manage its total exposure at the occurrence of natural disasters that result in property damage in every region of the world. SCOR quantifies this exposure in terms of a maximum commitment. SCOR defines this maximum commitment, taking into account policy limits, as its potential maximum loss caused by a single catastrophe affecting a large contiguous geographic area, such as a storm, hurricane or earthquake, and occurring within a given return period. SCOR estimates that the Group’s current maximum risks for catastrophes, before retrocession, come from earthquakes in Japan, Italy, Israel, Turkey, Taiwan, Chile, and Portugal and other weather-related risks concentrated primarily in Europe, Asia and North and Central America.
The following table summarizes the main identified natural catastrophe exposures of the Group by geographic area:
     
Exposure to the catastrophe (1)   Countries concerned— December 2005
in million    
100 to 200
  Canada, United States, Mexico, Israel, Italy, Turkey
200 to 300
  Chile, Portugal, Taiwan,
300 and more
  Japan, Europe
(1) Calculated on a maximum potential loss for a given commitment period before retrocession.
The results are based on proprietary software.
For more than fifteen years, SCOR used its own internally-developed and regularly updated software program to evaluate maximum potential losses from earthquakes in twenty countries. SCOR currently uses SERN (System for Evaluation of Natural Risks) to simulate events and the resulting damages. SERN is an enhancement of existing models initiated in 1997 by SCOR and partners from prominent research institutes and recognized private IT companies. This software program is directly linked to our worldwide database and available to all of Scor’s subsidiaries and operating units. As of December 31, 2005, SERN can provide results for earthquake exposure in Australia, Algeria, Canada, Chile, Colombia, Greece, Indonesia, Israel, Jordan, Italy, Japan, Mexico, New Zealand, Peru, Philippines, Portugal, Taiwan, Turkey, the United States and Venezuela. For countries such as Japan and the United States, SCOR’s analyses are compared with other calculations performed using programs developed by specialized independent consultants.
In a similar manner and at the same time as what is done with SERN, the potential accumulations in the United States and in a growing number of countries are analyzed using external simulation tools; the principal tool used is World Cat Entreprise (WCE) developed by Eqecat. The potential accumulation due to typhoons in Japan is analyzed by combining (a) the arithmetic sum of the commitments for non-proportional treaties and (b) a scenario based on Mireille (major typhoon in Japan in 1991) for proportional treaties. The accumulations due to storms in Europe, the principal European earthquakes and the earthquake in

Page 124 of 184


 

Japan for the treaty portfolio are now evaluated using software and outside simulation tools, primarily WCE. If necessary, SCOR periodically completes these analyses with outside studies covering either specific exposures or complete portfolios.
The following table highlights losses due to catastrophes for the years 2004 and 2005:
                 
    At December 31
    in million
    2004   2005
Number of catastrophes during the year (1)
    2       3  
Losses and claim management costs due to catastrophes, gross
    40 (2)     215 (3)
Losses due to catastrophes, net of retrocession
    40 (2)     168 (3)
 
               
Group ratio of net losses (4)
    69 %     74 %
Group ratio of losses excluding catastrophes
    67 %     60 %
(1) SCOR defines a catastrophe as an event involving multiple risks and causing pre-tax losses, net of retrocession, of 10 million or more.
(2) Typhoon Sondga plus Hurricane Ivan
(3) Hurricanes Katrina, Wilma, Rita, storm Gudrun and floods in Eastern Europe
(4) Loss ratios are calculated on the basis of the Non-Life claims experience expressed as a percentage of Non-Life premiums earned.
Claims
The Group’s Claims Department, created in April 2003, is tasked with managing and processing claims for the Group on the basis of a global control and reporting system and management commutation of claim portfolios.
The claims handling function is performed by the subsidiary Claims Departments, which initially process and monitor reported claims. The Group Claims Division supports and controls their general activity and takes over the direct management of large, litigious, serial and latent claims. Additionally, periodic audits are conducted on specific claims and lines of business and claims processing and procedures are examined at the ceding companies’ offices with the aim of evaluating their claims adjusting process, valuation of reserves and overall performance. Technical and legal assistance is provided to underwriters before and after accepting certain risks. When needed, recommendations are given to underwriters, local claims adjusters and management.
The main objectives of the Group’s Major Claims Committee, chaired by the Chief Operating Officer, are to review the consolidated impact of major, strategic claims and to monitor the management of such claims among the various business lines and countries. It reviews on a monthly basis all reported new large and strategic claims and follows the development of all such claims.
Retrocession
The Group retrocedes a portion of the risks it underwrites in order to control its exposure and claims. It pays premiums based on the risks and the exposure of its treaties and facultatives which are subject to retrocession. For SCOR, retrocession is generally limited to catastrophes and major property risks. Retrocession reinsurance is subject to collectibility in all cases where the original business accepted by the Group suffers from a loss. The Group remains primarily liable to the direct insurer on all risks reinsured although the retrocessionaire is liable to SCOR to the extent of the reinsurance limits purchased. SCOR then monitors the financial condition of retrocessionaires on an ongoing basis. In recent years, the Group has not experienced any particular difficulty in collecting the amounts owed by its retrocessionnaires. SCOR reviews its retrocession arrangements periodically, to ensure that they fit closely to the development of its business.
The retrocession procedures are centralized in the retrocession department of the non life sector. The Group utilizes a variety of retrocession agreements with non-affiliated retrocessionaires to control its exposures to large property losses. In particular, SCOR has implemented an overall program set in place on an annual basis that provides partial coverage for up to three major catastrophic events within one occurrence year. A major event is likely to be a natural catastrophe such as an earthquake, a windstorm, a hurricane or a typhoon in a region where the Group has major aggregate exposures stemming from the business written.
IRP Holdings Limited was established in December 2001 to reinsure (as a retrocessionnaire) certain SCOR Non-Life businesses on a quota share basis from 2002 forward. The purpose of this vehicle was to increase the underwriting capacity in order to underwrite more contracts and treaties during a period when premium levels were considered attractive. The retrocession rate in 2004 was 25% under the quota share treaties.
The quota share treaties between Irish Reinsurance Partners Limited, SCOR and certain SCOR Group subsidiaries were terminated, effective December 31, 2004. All the liabilities, rights and obligations of Irish Reinsurance Partners Limited under the quota share treaties were transferred to SCOR in October 2005.
These substitutions were made under novation contracts dated October 17, 2005 and October 26, 2005.
SCOR acquired the minority interests of IRP Holdings Limited for 183.1 million, corresponding to the share of the Highfields Funds in the equity of IRP Holdings Limited at December 31, 2004 established under American accounting rules. See Section 7.19 – IRP.

Page 125 of 184


 

8.11 RESERVES
Significant periods of time may elapse between the occurrence of an insured loss, the reporting of the loss to the ceding company and the reinsurer and the ceding company’s payment of that loss and subsequent payments to the ceding company by the reinsurer. To cover commitments on losses and future benefits, insurers and reinsurers fund reserves, which represent on the balance sheet the commitments corresponding to the estimate of the amounts that will have to be paid in the future for known or unknown claims, as well as the related expenses.
The Group maintains reserves to cover its estimated ultimate liability for claims related to known events or events not yet reported. The reserves for estimates of final losses and claims management costs are reviewed by management during the year, using new information as soon as it is available and the estimates are adjusted if necessary. Management considers many factors when setting reserves, including the following:
-      information from ceding companies;
-      historical trends, such as reserve patterns, claims payments, number of claims to be paid and the product mix;
-       internal methodologies to analyze the Group’s experience;
-      the most recent legal interpretations concerning coverage and commitments; and
-       economic conditions.
Based on these considerations, management believes that adequate provision has been made for the Group’s Life and Non-Life loss and LAE reserves. Liabilities on contracts net of retrocession were 5,652 million for Non-Life and 3,214 million for Life at December 31, 2005.
General
-   Non-Life business
As part of the reserving process, insurers and reinsurers review historical data and anticipate the impact of various factors such as legislative enactments and judicial decisions that may tend to affect potential losses from casualty claims, changes in social and political attitudes that may increase exposure to losses, mortality and morbidity trends and trends in general economic conditions. This process assumes that past experience, adjusted for the effects of current developments, is an appropriate basis for anticipating future events. This method for valuing reserves implicitly takes into account the impact of inflation and other factors affecting claims, by taking into account changes in historical claim patterns and current trends. There is no precise method, however, for evaluating the impact of each specific item on the adequacy of reserves, because the accuracy of the amount depends on many factors.
The Group regularly reviews and updates its methods for determining incurred but not reported (IBNR) claims reserves. However, it is difficult to value the amount of reserves required, especially in view of changes in the legal environment, including civil liability law, which may impact the development of reserves. While this process is complicated and subjective for the ceding companies, the inherent uncertainties in these estimates are even greater for the reinsurer, primarily because of the longer time period between the date of an occurrence and the request for payment of the claim to the reinsurer, the diversity of contract development schemes, both treaties or facultative, dependence on the ceding companies for information regarding claims, and differing reserve practices among ceding companies. In addition, trends that have affected development of liabilities in the past may not necessarily occur or affect liability development to the same degree in the future. Thus, actual losses, LAE and future policy benefits may deviate, perhaps significantly, from estimates of reserves reflected in the Group’s consolidated financial statements.
When a claim is reported to the ceding company, the departments managing the claims establish reserves corresponding to the estimated amount of the ultimate settlement for the claim. The estimate reflects the judgment of the ceding company’s claims personnel, based on its reserving practices. The ceding company reports the claim to the Group entity from which it obtained the reinsurance, together with the ceding company’s suggested estimate of the claim’s cost. The Group records the ceding company’s suggested reserve and may establish additional reserves based on review by the Group’s claims department and internal actuaries. Such additional reserves are based upon the consideration of many factors, including coverage, liability, severity and the Group’s assessment of the ceding company’s ability to evaluate and handle the claim.
In accordance with industry practices, the Group maintains IBNR reserves. These reserves are determined on an actuarial basis and represent:
- the final amount of the claim that may be paid by the Group on losses or events that have occurred, but are not yet known to the ceding company or the Group; and
- the cost variation projected on claims already reported to the Group.
In determining the amount of its reserves, the Group generally uses actuarial techniques that take into account quantitative loss experience data, together with qualitative factors, where appropriate. The reserves are also adjusted to reflect changes in the volume of business written, reinsurance treaty terms and conditions, the mix of business and claims processing that may potentially affect the Group’s commitment over time. With the exception of the reserves for workers’ compensation benefits and most of the CRP reserves, which are discounted pursuant to American and Bermudan regulations, the Group does not discount Non-Life reserves.
-   Life business
In Life Reinsurance, reserves for policy claims and benefits are established on the basis of the Group’s best estimates of mortality, morbidity, and investment income, with a provision for an adverse change. The liabilities for future policy benefits established by the Group with respect to individual risks or classes of business may be greater or less than those established by ceding companies due to the use of different mortality and other assumptions. Reserves for policy claims include both mortality

Page 126 of 184


 

claims in the process of settlement and claims that have been incurred but not yet reported. Actual events in a given period may be more costly than projected and, therefore, may adversely affect the Group’s operating results for that period.
Change in reserves for damage claims
                         
                 
  in EUR million     2005       2004    
                 
 
Reserves for gross claims at January 1
      6,550         7,454    
 
 
                     
                 
 
Share of reinsurers in reserves for claims to be paid at January 1
      -536         -691    
 
 
                     
                 
 
Reserves for net claims at January 1
      6,014         6,763    
                 
 
Claim incurred, current year
      1,585         1,525    
 
Claim incurred, prior years
      -334         -419    
                 
 
Total claim incurred
      1,251         1,106    
                 
 
Claims paid, current year
      -753         -429    
 
Claims piad, prior years
      -896         -1,309    
                 
 
Total paid losses
      -1,649         -1,738    
                 
 
Currency fluctuations
      208         -118    
 
 
                     
 
Reserves for net claims to be paid at December 31
      5,824         6,014    
                 
 
Whereof Share for reinsurers
      -554         -536    
                 
Commutations
In 2005, the Group has pursued an active commutations policy for its portfolio, the main objectives being to reduce the volatility of claims reserves and to allow the freeing of capital. This policy will be continued in 2006, by focalizing efforts on the run-off activities and business exposed to Asbestos and Pollution risks.
Commutations on Non Life business were realized in the portfolios of SCOR US, CRP and European business.
Total commutations realized at SCOR US during 2005 amounted to gross reserves of 264 million. These commutations have contributed to the global drop in reserves at SCOR US of 10% to 1,461 million.
Regarding CRP, the commutations realized for a total amount of 50 million, as well as the normal payment of claims, have permitted a reduction in the amount of reserves to 210 million.
Finally, the commutations in Europe have totaled 25 million, reducing exposure to asbestos and environmental risks.
Commutations of Life business came to a total of 265 million.
Asbestos and environment
The Group’s reserves for losses and claims management costs include an estimate of its total liability for asbestos and environmental claims, the ultimate value of which cannot be estimated using traditional reserves estimate techniques and for which there are significant uncertainties in estimating the amount of the Group’s potential losses. SCOR and its subsidiaries have received and continue to receive notices of potential reinsurance claims from ceding insurance companies which have in turn received claims asserting environmental and asbestos losses under primary insurance policies, in part reinsured by Group companies. Such claims notices are frequently merely precautionary in nature and generally are unspecific, and the primary insurers often do not attempt to quantify the amount, timing or nature of the exposure. Due to the imprecise nature of these claims, uncertainties about the extent of coverage under insurance policies and whether or not certain claims can be capped, the potential number of these claims, and new theories about the liability of the insurer and the insured, like other reinsurers, we can only give a very approximate valuation of our potential risks for the possible environmental and asbestos claims that may be reported.
Nonetheless, due to the changing legal and regulatory environment, including changes in tort law, the evaluation of the final cost of our exposure to asbestos-related and environmental claims may be increasing in undefined proportions. Diverse factors could increase our exposure to the consequences of asbestos-related risks, such as an increase in the number of claims filed or in the number of persons likely to be covered by these claims. The uncertainties inherent in environmental and asbestos claims are unlikely to be resolved in the near future, despite several regulatory proposals in the United State to limit the financial consequences linked to asbestos claims, which have been unsuccessful to date. Evaluation of these risks is all the more difficult given that claims related to asbestos and environmental pollution are often subject to payments over long periods of time. Under these circumstances, it is difficult for us to estimate the reserves that should be set aside for these risks or to guarantee that the projected amount will be sufficient.
Case reserves have been established when sufficient information has been developed to indicate the involvement of a specific reinsurance treaty. In addition, incurred but not reported reserves have been established to provide for additional exposure on both known and unasserted claims. These reserves are reviewed and updated continually. In establishing liabilities for asbestos

Page 127 of 184


 

and environmental claims, Management takes into account the facts it knows and in particular, the current legal and civil liability environment. The Group may be forced to increase its reserves in the future if it becomes clear that claims should exceed the amount provisioned. As a result of these uncertainties, it cannot be excluded that the final settlement of these claims may have a genuine effect on the Group’s operating results and financial position. See Section [8.9] – Risk factors affecting the Company. We could be subject to losses as a result of our exposure to environmental and asbestos-related risks.
The following table compiles information concerning the Group’s reserves and payments for asbestos and environmental claims:
                                                 
    Year ending December 31  
    Asbestos (1)     Environment (1)  
    2003(2)     2004     2005     2003(2)     2004     2005  
    in EUR million  
       
Gross reserves, including IBNR reserves
    109       98       111       59       54       39  
% of Non-Life gross reserves
    1.3 %     1.6 %     1.7 %     0.7 %     0.9 %     0.6 %
Claims paid (including under commutations)
    15       15       12       13       5       7  
net % of Group Non-Life claims paid
    0.5 %     0.8 %     0.7 %     0.4 %     0.3 %     0.4 %
Asbestos and environmental (A&E) reserve data includes Scor’s estimated A&E exposures in respect of its participation in the Anglo French Reinsurance Pool, for which A&E exposures for the years shown were as follows:
The 2003 reserves were 19 million and 18 million for asbestos and environment, respectively. The claims paid for 2003 were 0.6 million and 0.9 million for asbestos and environment, respectively.
The 2004 reserves were 18 million and 16 million for asbestos and environment, respectively. The claims paid for 2004 were 0.3 million and 0.3 million for asbestos and environment, respectively.
The 2005 reserves were 15 million and 8 million for asbestos and environment, respectively. The claims paid for 2005 were 1.7 million and 1 million for asbestos and environment, respectively.
(2) The gross property & casualty reserves for 2003 are reported in French GAAP, and the 2004 and 2005 reserves are under IFRS.
The exposure to environmental risks has dropped significantly in the last three years because of agreements on major claims and the commutations executed by the Group on several policies related to pollution claims covering earlier years.
As a result, in 2005, SCOR’s exposure to asbestos and environmental risks fell by 11 million from the previous year because of the commutations carried out.
More generally, SCOR has developed a policy of buying back its commitments on asbestos and the environment whenever it is possible to do so on a commercially reasonable basis, i.e., whenever SCOR determines, based on a valuation of the Group’s commitments estimated using actuarial techniques and market practices, that the terms of the final negotiated settlement are potentially attractive because of a possible change in the liabilities in the future. Preference is given to selected treaties with regard to specific circumstances such as the maturity of claims, the level of claims information available, the status of ceding companies and market settlements. The Group intends to continue and expand its commutation policy in 2005 and in subsequent years. It is anticipated that the policy will affect settlement patterns to a limited degree in future years. These changes in settlement patterns should improve predictability and reduce the potential volatility of reserves.
SCOR’s exposure to asbestos and environmental liabilities stems from its participation in both proportional and non-proportional treaties and facultative contracts, which have generally been in run-off for several years.
Proportional treaties typically provide claims information on a global treaty basis, and as a result specific claims data is rarely available. With respect to non-proportional treaties and facultative contracts, normal market practice is to provide a specific proof of loss for each individual claim, making it possible to record total claims notified for such contracts. With respect to environmental liabilities, most of the claims identified by SCOR stem from the business of its U.S. subsidiaries, with less significant amounts recorded by its European subsidiaries. The claims costs are invoiced by the ceding companies at the same time as the claims themselves. No significant cost for litigation was incurred under these commitments.
                 
    Year ending December 31, 2005
    Asbestos   Environment
Number of claims notified under non-proportional and facultative treaties
    7,961       7,219  
Average cost per claim (1)
  14,689     4,338  
(1) Not including claims that were settled at no cost, and claims of a precautionary nature not quantified in amount.
8.12 INVESTMENTS
Over fiscal year 2004, the Group’s total investments, including cash, rose from 9,537 million to 10,034 million, an increase of 5% in market value.

Page 128 of 184


 

The portion invested in stocks increased from 2.1% of assets to 3.7% at the beginning of the year. At the same time, the portion invested in bonds fell by about 3% to approximately 57.8% of total assets. The duration of the bond portfolio generally declined over the year from 4.24% to 3.96%. With respect to the quality of credit, the bond portfolio continued to be heavily invested in AAA bonds (about 70%), i.e. in securities issued or secured by governments or in blue chip securities.
The portion invested in real estate remained stable at about 3% of the assets.
The currency allocation remained stable over the year, with about 50% invested in USD, and 36% invested in euros.
In fiscal 2005, total investments, including cash, dropped from 10,034 million to 9,743 million, a decline of 2.9% in market value.
As in the previous year, the portion invested in stocks was increased to 10.1% of the assets, compared with 5.4% at the beginning of the year. Most of the stock investments were in European large cap stocks.
At the same time, the portion invested in bonds dropped to about 55% of total assets. The duration of the bond portfolio also declined slightly over the year from 3.96% to 3.84%. In terms of credit quality, most of the bond portfolio continued to be invested in AAA bonds (about 70%) i.e. in securities issued or secured by governments or in securities of very high-quality entities.
The portion invested in real estate remained stable at approximately 3% of the assets.
The portion invested in USD rose slightly to 52% and the portion invested in euros dropped slightly to 33%.
In the first quarter of 2006, the policy to expand the portion invested in stocks continued.
The following table shows the bond portfolio as a function of the credit quality of the counterparty as of December 31, 2005 (excluding Horizon ad hoc entities, an AAA-rated portfolio of 83.2 million, and excluding consolidated mutual fund assets).
                                 
 
            Bonds at fair value             % of the  
In EUR millions   AFS bonds     by result     Total     portfolio  
 
 
AAA
    3,726       99       3,824       71 %
 
AA
    544       29       573       11 %
 
A
    596       25       621       12 %
 
BBB
    302       8       310       6 %
 
< BBB
    20       2       22       0 %
 
Not rated
    46       3       49       1 %
 
Total
    5,233       166       5,399       100 %
 
See Section 5.7 — Notes to the consolidated financial statements – Note 28 — for a breakdown of fixed maturities included in the Group’s portfolio by maturity as of December 31, 2005.
8.13 BUSINESS OPERATIONS
The Group’s Non-Life reinsurance operations are mainly conducted via the operating divisions of the Property-Casualty Treaty, Facultatives and Large Corporate Accounts segments, all part of the Global P&C sector, as well as through ten European, North American and Asian subsidiaries, each of which operates primarily in its regional market. The life insurance, accident, disability, medical, unemployment and long-term health care activities of the Group are conducted primarily by SCOR VIE, which was made a subsidiary on December 1, 2003. SCOR VIE carries out its business primarily through its branches in Italy, Germany and Canada and through SCOR Life Re U.S. Commercial Risk Partners (CRP) Bermuda is a subsidiary specializing in Alternative Reinsurance that has been placed in run-off since January 2003.
The current structure of the Group, as shown in the organizational chart on page 5 of this document, has been developed to facilitate access to local markets through local subsidiaries and branch offices, to provide better identification of profit centers in each major reinsurance market, and to develop local management and underwriting expertise in order to attract and provide better customer service, to maintain relationships with ceding companies, and to obtain a deeper understanding of the specific features of local risks.
Within the New SCOR project announced in June 2005, the Group intends to contribute to SCOR Global P&C (formerly Société Putéolienne de Participations), a wholly-owned SCOR company, certain SCOR casualty reinsurance business lines in France and abroad. The SCOR Extraordinary Shareholders’ Meeting will be primarily asked to approve this contribution to SCOR Global P&C on May 16, 2006. This spin-off operation is part of an effort to simplify the Group’s legal structures. Just as the Life reinsurance business was made a subsidiary within SCOR VIE in 2003, it will establish a subsidiary dedicated to Non-Life reinsurance activities.
The Group’s headquarters in Paris provide underwriting policy and risk accumulation direction and control claims, actuarial, accounting, legal, administrative, systems, internal audit, investment and human resources. The Group’s worldwide offices are connected through a backbone network and application, data and exchange systems, allowing local access to centralized risk analysis, underwriting or pricing databases, while at the same time allowing information on local market conditions to be shared among the Group’s offices worldwide. In addition, through regular exchanges of personnel between Group headquarters in Paris and its non-French subsidiaries and branch offices, the Group encourages professional development and training across its various geographic markets and business lines.

Page 129 of 184


 

SCOR wholly owns its operating subsidiaries (excluding the shares held by members of the Board). SCOR also makes loans to its subsidiaries. Lastly, and whenever necessary, SCOR acts as retrocessionnaire vis-à-vis its subsidiaries.
8.14 PROPERTY AND EQUIPMENT
On December 29, 2003, SCOR sold the building with more than 30,000 m2 of office space in which it is headquartered at 1, avenue du Général de Gaulle, 92074 Paris La Défense, to a German investment fund KanAm for 149,500,000. On the same date, SCOR and KanAm entered into a nine-year lease agreement for this same building for an annual rent equal to 11 million per year. Under this lease and in addition to the usual guarantees, KanAm asked for financial guarantees based both on SCOR’s financial rating and the term of the lease. For more information on these guarantees, see Section 6.5 – Notes to the parent company financial statements – Note 5.1.3.
The Group remains a tenant of these headquarters offices and also rents space separate from its home office for the purpose of safeguarding its data handling capability in case of emergency. The Group also owns offices in Hanover (Germany), Milan (Italy), and Singapore, which it leases to third parties as part of its investment management business and in which its local subsidiaries have their corporate headquarters. The Group leases office space for its other business locations. SCOR believes that the Group’s office space is adequate for its present needs. SCOR also holds property investments as part of its assets management related to its reinsurance operations.
8.15 INFORMATION TECHNOLOGY
SCOR uses the same Information System in all its locations worldwide (with the exception of CRP).
Its central back-office system is a custom software package known as Omega. Omega is designed to allow the tracking of clients and policyholders within the Group, grant online authorizations throughout the world, track claims, analyze the technical profitability of contracts, and perform quarterly closing based on the latest estimated results.
In addition to the reinsurance administration system, SCOR has implemented the PeopleSoft software package solutions for Human Resources and Finance. SCOR is promoting a paperless environment. Internally, imaging solutions have been implemented worldwide for document sharing within the Group. For its clients, SCOR is able to automatically process reinsurance accounts received in electronic format with the ACORD standard, without the need to re-enter them. In 2005, new electronic exchanges were installed with international brokers.
The SCOR technical environment is based on an international secured network. Corporate technical standards have been implemented in all locations, either on PCs or servers. The SCOR Group has also implemented an ambitious security plan based on stronger physical and logic access controls, protection against unauthorized access, and restarts in the event of a disaster.
The Group has begun to define a new strategic plan known as “IS2008,” which defines future upgrades to the information systems in line with SCOR’s commercial strategy. The strategy is the first component in the governance of information systems, which has now been extensively implemented, and provides indicators and criteria for assessing value creation by the systems.
Most of SCOR’s efforts in 2005 have been dedicated to front-office applications for an improved risk selection, anticipation and reactivity on markets and products. The steering system has been expanded to strengthen visibility for the development of product lines and markets. Accounting forecasts are developed from underwriting plans and comparative analyses are produced in adequate standard reports. A new P&C underwriting and rating system, which includes price modeling, profitability criteria, and claims simulation capacity, was installed in 2005, demonstrating the emphasis SCOR places on enhancing risk control.
The portal has been designated as the preferred media for sharing all information, both internal or from sources outside the Company.
8.16 Exceptional events and litigation
The Group is a party to one lawsuit concerning old claims related to the environment. However, the Group believes it is sufficiently funded on the basis of the information it has on this date.
In addition, we are involved in the following litigation:
In the United States:
  -  
In December 2002, a petition was filed by Dock Resins Corporation and Landec Corporation before a U.S. Federal District Court in New Jersey against SCOR’s subsidiary SOREMA North America Reinsurance Company (now General Security National Insurance Company or GSNIC), for an alleged denial of coverage by GSNIC concerning business interruption suffered by the plaintiffs. GSNIC filed a cross claim for fraud and misrepresentation seeking to void the policy and preserve GSNIC’s right to recover the costs incurred in litigating the case. The plaintiffs claim an unspecified amount of damages in excess of policy limits, which are capped under the insurance policy at an aggregate total of USD 15 million. The policy has been retroceded at 80% outside of the SCOR Group. GSNIC has

Page 130 of 184


 

     
paid the undisputed portions of the claim. On January 27, 2006, motions to obtain a partial provisional order and the cross claims filed by the different parties were upheld, and the rulings issued by the U.S. Federal District Court were in favor of the defendants. The Court granted the GSNIC motion seeking a partial provisional order and dismissed all arguments against the motion, which were based on an alleged bad-faith refusal of coverage and the allegation that GSNIC had conspired with its consultants to reject the insurance claim without grounds. In addition, the requests for compensatory and punitive damages and the motion for payment of attorneys’ fees were also dismissed. The plaintiff’s cross claim seeking a partial order dealing with the affirmative defense of GSNIC against the insurance fraud claim was also dismissed. As a result of those decisions, the plaintiffs now can only bring action against GSNIC on a contractual basis, based on the insurance policy. It is highly probable that the discovery procedure will be completed by spring 2006. The judgment date has been provisionally set at June 2006.
 
  -  
Certain Highfields Funds—Highfields Capital LTD, Highfields Capital I LP and Highfields Capital II LP (the “Highfields Funds”), as minority shareholders of IRP Holdings Limited, in March 2004 have filed a complaint against SCOR in the District Court of the State of Massachusetts. The complaint alleges raud and violations of Massachusetts law with regard to the acquisition by the Highfields Funds of a stake in IRP Holdings Limited in December 2001. The damages (including punitive damages) owed, if any, cannot be calculated as of this date and will be determined by the Court at the end of the trial which is scheduled to begin in May 2007. On September 28, 2005, the District Court of the State of Massachusetts rejected SCOR’s motion to dismiss and issued an order scheduling the timing of discovery and the trial. The discovery procedure has commenced and is scheduled to proceed until March 2007 based on the calendar set by the Court. The trial is scheduled to start in May 2007.
 
  -  
Beginning in October 2001, various lawsuits were brought and cross claims filed to determine whether the terrorist attack on the World Trade Center (WTC) on September 11, 2001 constituted one or two occurences under the terms of the applicable coverage issued to the lessees of the WTC and others parties. Although SCOR, as a reinsurer, is not a party to such lawsuits, the ceding company Allianz Global Risks U.S. Insurance Company (Allianz), which insured a portion of the WTC, and which is reinsured by SCOR, is a party to the legal action.
 
     
The first two phases of the trial were completed in 2004. At the end of the first phase, the court ruled that nine of the twelve insurers involved were bound by the definition of the term “occurence” that as a matter of law has been found to mean that the attack on the WTC constituted one occurence. Allianz did not participate in that first phase, but has participated in the second phase of the trialon December 6, 2004. The New York jury named in the second phase of the litigation determined that the attack on the WTC towers on September 11, 2001 constituted two occurences under the terms of the property insurance coverages issued by Allianz and by eight other insurers of the WTC towers. SCOR, a reinsurer of Allianz, considers the jury verdict to be contrary to the terms of the insurance coverage in force and to the intent of the parties. SCOR fully supported Allianz, in its efforts to overturn the verdict. The jury verdict has been appealed to the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Second Circuit and a decision is expected in 2006.
 
     
The verdict in the second phase of the litigation did not determine the amount of damages owed by the insurers. A separate, court-supervised appraisal procedure is in progress to determine the amount owed by the insurers for the damages resulting from the destruction of the WTC towers. The final decision from the appraisal procedure is expected at the end of 2006 or early in 2007.
 
     
In the Group’s original calculations of its technical reserves, the WTC attack was treated as one occurrence for purposes of the underlying insurance coverage since the terrorist attack on September 11, 2001 was a single, coordinated occurence. As a result of the jury verdict described above in the second phase of the trial, the Group has increased the reserves based on the initial replacement value established by the ceding company. The gross amount of reserves has accordingly been increased from USD 355 million as of December 31, 2003 to USD 422 million as of December 31, 2004, and net of retrocession from USD 167.5 million to USD 193.5 million. These amounts did not change significantly in 2005. In addition, the Company issued two letters of credit for a total amount of USD 145,320,000 to Allianz on December 27, 2004, as required by Allianz to guarantee payment to the ceding company if the jury verdict is not reversed by the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Second Circuit or if the appraisal process placed under court supervision in 2005 results in an increase in the amounts to be paid in the future.
 
     
Allianz has instituted an arbitration proceeding against the Company in order to clarify the extent of the Company’s obligations under the reinsurance treaty entered into with it. The arbitration proceedings has been stayed by the court responsible for evaluating the damages pending certain events related to the second phase of the lawsuit. The arbitration proceeding has not been reactivated.
 
  -  
The Group is also involved in various arbitration proceedings relating to the underwriting business, now in run off, primarily relating to the Bond risk. See Section 6.5 – Notes to the parent company financial statements– Note 16.
 
  -  
In January 2005, Continental Casualty Company (CCC), a CAN’s subsidiary, initiated an arbitration proceeding to obtain a declaration that six contracts signed with Commercial Risk Re-Insurance Company (CRRC) should contain the so called “insolvency” clause. CRRC issued a counter demand for arbitration proceeding to obtain from CCC access to all relevant books and records.
 
     
On November 2, 2005, the panel rendered its award stating that the six contracts were supposed to contain this insolvency clause. Following this ruling, CRRC filed motions to vacate the panel’s final award in the US Federal District Courts for Connecticut and the Northern District of Illinois seeking voidance of the arbitration tribunal’s ruling.
 
     
In its counter demand, CRRC is requesting, pursuant to the provisions of the contracts in question, an order giving it full access to all relevant books and records at CCC and its agent. The organization meeting on this second arbitration was held in October 2005 and the parties are presently submitting their respective schedule to the panel.
 
  -  
In August 2005, certain American subsidiaries of Royal & Sun Alliance (RSA) initiated four arbitration proceedings against Commercial Risk Re-Insurance Company Limited and Commercial Risk Reinsurance Company (Commercial

Page 131 of 184


 

     
Risk) relating to seven reinsurance treaties signed by RSA and Commercial Risk. RSA is alleging breach of the contracts and is seeking full payment of balances due under these contracts, plus interest and expenses, for a total of about USD 23 million. Commercial Risk has denied these balances due asserting that the losses are outside the scope of application and the terms of the treaties.
 
     
No significant activity has occurred in any of the arbitration. One panel was constituted and the organisational meeting was held on February 22, 2006. The parties are currently selecting panels for the remaining arbitrations.
 
  -  
At the end of February 2006, Security Insurance Company of Hartford, Orion Insurance Company and other subsidiaries of Royal Insurance Company (Security of Hartford) instituted a litigation against SCOR Reinsurance Company (SCOR Re) in the Supreme Court of the State of New York alleging breach of contract and seeking recovery of claimed loss balances of approximately USD 48.9 million allegedly due as losses under two quota share treaties between the parties (the “Treaties”).
 
     
SCOR Re is seeking to dismiss or stay the Supreme Court litigation and is demanding that the issues raised in the litigation be submitted to arbitration pursuant to the arbitration clauses contained in the Treaties. At the appropriate time in either the litigation or arbitration, SCOR Re will assert its own defenses and claims or counterclaims concerning the substantive issues raised in the litigation.
 
     
In February 2006, SCOR received an arbitration notice from the “captive” of a pharmaceutical laboratory concerning the settlement of a claim under civil liability for a laboratory product. SCOR denied owing this amount and claims that the captive is not required to indemnify the pharmaceutical laboratory. The maximum potential commitment of SCOR is USD 17.5 million.
In Europe:
  -  
SCOR VIE, as the reinsurer of an insurance company, is a party to a proceeding relating to a life insurance policy for approximately 4.5 million. The beneficiary of the policy was a person killed in 1992. In June 2001, a Spanish court ordered the ceding company to pay approximately 16 million under the insurance policy, including accumulated interest since 1992, plus damages. Following this decision, SCOR VIE recognized a technical reserve for 17.7 million for fiscal year 2001. Since a contrary decision was rendered in favor of the ceding company in May 2002 by the Court of Appeals of Barcelona, the dispute has been filed in the Spanish Supreme Court by the victim’s heirs. The provision was maintained at end of December 2005.
 
  -  
The French Autorité des Marchés Financiers (AMF), initiated an investigation on October 21, 2004 in connection with the financial information and trading activity surrounding the issue of the SCOR OCEANE bonds in July 2004. The Company has received no additional information about this investigation to date.
 
  -  
The AMF also initiated an investigation on October 5, 2005 concerning the market for the SCOR share as of June 1, 2005.
 
  -  
Since February 2005, the SCOR company has been the subject of an accounting audit for the period from January 1, 2002 to December 31, 2003. On December 21, 2005, this audit resulted in an initial adjustment proposal, excluding late penalties, for an additional assessment for the corporate income tax base for 2002 of 26,870,073.77, an assessment for the withholding stipulated by Article 119 bis 2 of the General Tax Code of 5,788,871 and an additional assessment for the employer’s payroll tax of 27,891. The Company has challenged this adjustment proposal. This proposal, which interrupts the statute of limitations, will be followed in 2006 with a definitive proposal also covering fiscal 2003.
 
  -  
The ACAM launched an audit of the SCOR VIE company in January 2006.
The Company is involved in legal and arbitration proceedings from time to time in the ordinary course of its business. However, other than the proceedings mentioned above, to our knowledge, there are no other litigation matters that are likely to have a material impact on the Group’s financial position, activities or results of operations.
8.17 REFERENCE SYSTEM
Because of its listing on the New York Stock Exchange, SCOR must meet the regulatory disclosure obligations specific to the USA.
Our consolidated financial statements included in this annual report have been prepared in compliance with IFRS standards as adopted. We are also publishing consolidated financial statements, not included in this annual report, prepared in accordance with US GAAP standards. There are differences between the IFRS and the US GAAP standards which can lead to different results according to the accounting reference system used. The differences between the US GAAP standards and the IFRS ones can affect the treatment of change (especially goodwill, shares or bonds), the classification of contracts or even investments, making provision for retirement commitments, covering deferred tax and the processing of certain fixed assets.
In practice, the Group financial statements drawn up according to the American reference system are available neither at the moment of publication of the consolidated financial statements for the 2005 period, nor at the moment of the registration of the document de reference for 2005 with the Financial Markets Authority (AMF).
The documents deposited with the SEC will be available on the SEC internet site (www.sec.gov) as well as that of SCOR (www.scor.fr). Publication of the document “Form 20-F” for the financial period closing on December 31, 2005 will be subject to a later announcement.

Page 132 of 184


 

9. CORPORATE GOVERNANCE
9.1 INFORMATION CONCERNING THE MEMBERS OF THE BOARD OF DIRECTORS
According to the by-laws, directors are required to be natural persons. There must be at least 9 directors and at most 18. Their term of office is 6 years at most. The age limit for director positions is 72 years old. If a director in office should exceed this age, his term will continue through the period established by the Shareholders’ Meeting. The average age of members of the board is 59 years old.
The General Shareholders’ Meeting may, in compliance with the provisions in the by-laws, appoint one to four Non-voting directors (Censeurs) to the Company. Non-voting directors’ terms are two years and are always renewable. If there are fewer than four Non-voting directors, the Board of Directors may appoint one or more Non-voting directors. The appointments made by the Board of Directors are submitted for ratification to the next Extraordinary Shareholders’ Meeting. The age limit for performing the functions of a Non-voting director is set at 72 years old. Non-voting directors are convened to meetings of the Board of Directors and participate in discussions in an advisory capacity only.
                     
                 
        Other terms and positions exercized in     Terms exercized during the last five years
 
 
 
    any company in France and abroad as of            
 
 
    December 31, 2005            
                 
  Denis KESSLER (1)     France     Chairman of:  
 
Chief Executive Officer
                 
 
 
    Chairman:       SCOR Life Insurance Company (U.S.)  
 
Birth Date:
    - SCOR VIE            
 
March 25, 1952
            Commercial Risk Partners Ltd (Bermuda)  
 
 
    Non-voting director:            
 
First appointment date:
    - FDC S.A.       Commercial Risk Reinsurance Company Ltd (U.S.)  
 
November 4, 2002
    - GIMAR FINANCE & CIE S.C.A.          
 
 
                 
 
Expiring term date:
    Permanent representative:            
 
2007
    - of FERGASCOR in SA Communication et       General Security Indemnity Company  
 
 
    Participation         (U.S.)  
 
 
                 
 
Professional address:
    Member:            
 
SCOR
    - Conseil Economique et Social       General Security Indemnity Company of Arizona (U.S.)  
 
1, avenue du Général de Gaulle
    - Commission Economique de la Nation            
 
92800 Puteaux
    - Conseil de l’Association de Genève            
 
France
    - Conseil du Siècle       General Security National Insurance  
 
 
    - Comité des Entreprises d’Assurance         Company (U.S.)  
 
 
                 
 
 
    Director:       Investors Insurance Corporation (U.S.)  
 
 
    - BNP Paribas S.A.            
 
 
    - Bollore Investissement S.A.       Investors Marketing Group Inc. (U.S.)  
 
 
    - COGEDIM S.A.S            
 
 
    - Dassault Aviation       Republic Vanguard Life Insurance Company (U.S.)  
 
 
                 
 
 
    Abroad            
 
 
                 
        Director:     Director of:  
        - SCOR Canada Reinsurance Company     - Commercial Risk Re-Insurance Company (U.S.)  
 
 
    - AMVESCAP Plc (UK)      
 
 
    - Dexia SA (Belgium)            
              Advisor:  
        Chairman:     Paribas  
 
 
    - SCOR Italia Riassicurazioni S.p.A (Italy)            
        - SCOR Life US Re Insurance Company     Member of the Supervisory Board:  
        (U.S.)     Cie Financière de Paris  
 
 
    - SCOR Reinsurance Company (U.S.)            
        - SCOR US Corporation (U.S.)     Member:  
              Fondation pour la Recherche Médicale  
 
 
    Member of the Supervisory Board:            
 
 
    - SCOR Deutschland (Germany)            
 
 
                 
                 
 
Carlo ACUTIS (2)
    Principal position:            
 
Director
                 
 
 
    Vice Chairman of Vittoria Assicurazioni S.p.A            
 
 
                 
 
Birth Date:
    Other positions:            
 
October 17, 1938
                 
 
 
    France            
 
First appointment date:
                 
 
May 15, 2003
    Member of the Supervisory Board:            
 
 
    - COGEDIM S.A.S            
 
Expiring term date:
                 
 
2009
    Director:            
                 

Page 133 of 184     


 

                 
                 
 
 
    - SCOR VIE        
 
Professional address:
             
 
VITTORIA ASSICURAZIONI S.p.A.
    Abroad        
 
Via Don Minzoni, 14
             
 
I — 10121 Torino
    Chairman:        
 
Italy
    - BPC INVESTIMENTI SGR S.p.A.        
 
 
             
 
 
    Director:        
 
 
    - Yura International Holding B.V.        
 
 
    - Yura S.A.        
 
 
    - Camfin S.p.A.        
 
 
    - Pirelli & C. S.p.A.        
 
 
    - Ergo Italia S.p.A.        
 
 
    - Ergo Assicurazioni S.p.A        
 
 
    - Ergo Previdenza S.p.a.        
 
 
    - Vittoria Capital N.V.        
 
 
             
 
 
    Vice-President:        
 
 
             
 
 
    - Banca Passadore S.p.A        
 
 
    - Presidential Council of the European Federation of National Insurance Companies        
 
 
    - Fondazione Piemontese per la ricerca sul cancro        
 
 
             
 
 
    Member of the Executive Committee:        
 
 
    - A.N.I.A. Associazione Italiana fra le Imprese di Assicurazione        
 
 
             
 
 
    Member of the Supervisory Board:        
 
 
    - Yam Invest N.V.        
 
 
             
 
 
    Member of the Board        
 
 
    - Presidential Council of the European Federation of National Insurance Companies        
 
 
    - Association de Genève        
 
 
             
                 
 
 
             
 
Michèle ARONVALD
    None     None  
 
 
             
 
Employee director
             
 
 
             
 
Birth Date:
             
 
August 15, 1958
             
 
 
             
 
First appointment date:
             
 
August 30, 2001
             
 
 
             
 
Expiring term date:
             
 
2006
             
 
 
             
 
Professional address:
             
 
SCOR
             
 
1, avenue du Général de Gaulle
             
 
92800 Puteaux, France
             
 
France
             
                 
 
 
          Member of the Tax Committee:  
 
Antonio BORGES (2) (3)
    Principal position:     - Banco Santander France  
 
Director
             
 
 
    Vice-Chairman of Goldman Sachs International (London)     Investment banking dean of INSEAD  
 
Birth Date:
    Other positions:        
 
November 18, 1949
             
 
 
    Other positions:        
 
First appointment date:
             
 
May 15, 2003
    France        
 
 
             
 
Expiring term date:
    Supervisory Board:        
 
2007
    - CNP Assurances        
 
 
             
 
Professional address:
    Director:        
 
GOLDMAN SACHS INTERNATIONAL
    - SCOR VIE        
 
Peterborough Court, 133 Fleet Street,
             
 
London EC4A 2BB
             
 
United Kingdom
    Abroad        
 
 
             
 
 
    Director:        
                 

Page 134 of 184     


 



                 
                 
 
 
    - Jérónimo Martins        
 
 
    - SONEAcom        
 
 
    - Caixa Seguros        
 
 
    - Heidrick & Struggles        
 
 
             
 
 
    Member of the Tax Committee:        
 
 
    - Banco Santander de Negocios Portugal        
                 
 
 
    Principal positions:     Partner, Sullivan and Cromwell (U.S.)  
 
Allan CHAPIN (1) (4)
             
 
Director
    Partner of Compass Advisers LLP (New     Managing partner of:  
 
 
    York, USA) since June 2002        
 
Birth Date:
          - Lazard Frères & Co LLC (U.S.)  
 
August 28, 1941
    Other positions:        
 
 
          Member of the Advisory board of:  
 
First appointment date:
          - Lazard Canada   
 
May 12, 1997
    France        
 
 
          Advisory Director of:  
 
Expiring term date:
    Director:        
 
2011
    -Pinault Printemps Redoute     -Toronto Blue Jays (Canada):  
 
 
    - SCOR VIE

       
 
Professional address:
    Abroad     Director of:  
 
COMPASS ADVISERS
          - Taransay Investment Ltd (Canada)  
 
Compass Advisers LLP
    Partner of Compass Advisers LLP (New     - Interbrew SA  
 
599 Lexington Avenue
    York, USA) since June 2002     - CALFP  
 
New York, NY 10022
          - SCOR US Corporation.  
 
United States
    Director:     - General Security Indemnity Company  
 
 
          - General Security Property and Casualty  
 
 
    Belgium:     Company  
 
 
             
 
 
    - InBev        
 
 
             
 
 
       USA:        
 
 
    - SCOR Reinsurance Cny        
 
 
    - General Security National Insurance Cny        
 
 
    - French-American Foundation        
 
 
    - President of the American Friends of the        
 
 
    Pompidou Foundation        
                 
 
Daniel HAVIS (2)
    Principal position:     Director of:  
 
Director
          - Ofima gestion  
 
 
    Chairman – General Director of MATMUT        
 
Birth Date:
    (Mutuelle Assurance des Travailleurs     Permanent Representative of MATMUT  
 
December 31, 1955
    Mutualistes)     and Chairman of the Supervisory Board of:  
 
 
             
 
First appointment date:
    Other positions:        
 
November 18, 1996
          - Gestepargne  
 
 
    Chairman:        
 
 
    - GEMA        
 
Expiring term date:
          Permanent Representative of:  
 
2011
    Vice-President:     - OFIVALMO Gestion and Chairman of the  
 
 
    - CEGES     Supervisory Board of E2 Espace Epargne  
 
Professional address:
             
 
MATMUT
    Mutual Insurance Code:        
 
66, rue de Sotteville
    Chairman of the Board of Directors:     Vice Chairman of MUTRE  
 
76100 ROUEN
    - SMAC (Mutuelle Accidents Corporels)        
 
France
    - IMADIES     Chairman of the Supervisory Board:  
 
 
          -       OFIVALMO Market  
 
 
    Director:     -       OFIVM  
 
 
    - Mutualité Française de la Seine     -       MUTRE  
 
 
    Maritime (MFSM)        
 
 
    - La Fédération Nationale de la Mutualité        
 
 
    Française (FNMF)     Member of the Supervisory Board:  
 
 
          - Alternative Derivative Investments (ADI)  
 
 
    Member of the bureau:        
 
 
    - Fédération Nationale de la Mutualité     Member of the Executive Committee of:  
 
 
    Interprofessionnelle (FNMI)     - IMADIES  
 
 
             
 
 
    Commercial Code        
 
 
    Chairman of the Supervisory Board:        
 
 
    - OFI ASSET MANAGEMENT (formerly        
 
 
    OFIVALMO Gestion)        
 
 
             
 
 
    Vice-chairman of the Supervisory Board:        
 
 
    -       IMA        
 
 
    -       OFIVALMO        
 
 
             
 
 
    Chairman of the Board:        
                 
Page 135 of 184

 


 

                 
                 
 
 
    -       Matmut Legal Protection formerly PMA        
 
 
            (Protection Mutualiste Assurance)        
 
 
    -       MUTRE S.A.        
 
 
    -       MDA        
 
 
             
 
 
    Director:        
 
 
    - SCOR Vie        
 
 
    - Matmut Vie        
 
 
    - OFIMALLIANCE        
 
 
             
 
 
    Permanent Representative of OFIVALMO        
 
 
    Gestion at:        
 
 
    -      OFIVALMO Net Epargne        
 
 
    -       OFI MANDATS        
 
 
             
 
 
    Permanent Representative Matmut at CS        
 
 
    -       OFI PALMARES        
 
 
             
 
 
    Permanent Representative of SMAC at CA        
 
 
    -       OFIMA Treasury        
 
 
    -       OFIMA Convertibles        
 
 
    -       OFI SMIDCAP        
 
 
             
 
 
    Insurance Code:        
 
 
             
 
 
    Vice-chairman of the Board of Directors:        
 
 
    -       Groupe des Mutuelles Associées        
 
 
             
 
 
    Others:        
 
 
    -       Chairman of the Comité National des        
 
 
            Réalizations Sanitaires et Sociales        
 
 
            (National Committee on Health and        
 
 
             Social Projects)        
 
 
    -       Conseil Supérieur de la Mutualité        
 
 
            (Higher Council on Mutual Insurance):        
 
 
            member of the “ Approval” Committee        
 
 
            and member of the “General Affairs”        
 
 
            Committee        
 
 
    -       Member of the Higher Council for the        
 
 
            Future of Health Insurance        
 
 
    -       Imadiès representative on the        
 
 
            Conseil des Mutuelles Santé        
 
 
            (Council of Mutual Health Insurance        
 
 
            Companies)        
                 
 
 
          Director of:  
 
Yvon LAMONTAGNE (2)
    Principal position:     - Gaz Metro (Canada)  
 
Director
             
 
 
    Director of AXA Insurance Canada (Toronto,        
 
Birth Date:
    Canada)        
 
June 14, 1940
             
 
 
             
 
 
    Other positions:        
 
First appointment date:
             
 
May 15, 2003
             
 
 
    France        
 
 
             
 
Expiring term date:
    Director:        
 
2007
    - SCOR VIE        
 
 
             
 
 
    Abroad        
 
Professional address:
             
 
AXA CANADA
    Director and non-executive chairman:        
 
2020 Université, Bureau 600
    - SCOR Canada Reinsurance Company        
 
Montreal (Quebec)
    (Toronto, Canada)        
 
H3A 2A5 Canada
             
 
 
    Director:        
 
 
    - Hydro-Québec (Montréal, Canada)        
 
 
    - Anglo-Canada General Insurance        
 
 
    Company (Toronto, Canada)        
 
 
    - AXA Pacific Insurance Company        
 
 
    (Vancouver, Canada)        
 
 
             
 
 
    Member of the Advisory Council:        
 
 
    - Office of the Superintendent of the        
 
 
    Financial Institutions (Ottawa)        
 
 
             
 
 
    Trustee:        
 
 
    Fiducie Henri-Paul Rousseau        
 
 
    (Montreal, Canada) (Chairman of the        
 
 
    Caisse des Dépôts)        
                 
Page 136 of 184

 


 

                 
                 
 
Daniel LEBEGUE (1) (2) (3)
Director

Birth Date:
May 4, 1943

First appointment date:
May 15, 2003

Expiring term date:
2009


Professional address:
Institut Français des Administrateurs
27, avenue de Friedland
75382 Paris Cedex 08France
    Principal position:

Chairman of the Institut Français des
Administrateurs
(IFA, French Society of
Directors)

Other positions:

France

Director:
- SCOR VIE
- Crédit Agricole SA
- Alcatel
- Technip

Member of the Supervisory Board:
- Areva

Chairman of the Board of Directors:
- Institut d’Études Politiques de Lyon

Chairman:
- Institut du Développement Durable et des
Relations Internationales (IDDRI)
(association)
- Transparence-International France
- Ecoda (Confédération Européenne des
Associations d’Administrateurs)

Co-Chairman:
- Eurofi (association)

Abroad:
- SCOR Reinsurance Company (U.S.)
- General Security National Insurance
Company (U.S.);

   
Director of:
- Gaz de France
- Thalès
 
                 
 
Helman LE PAS de SECHEVAL (1) (2) (3) (5)
Director


Birth Date:
January 21, 1966


First appointment date:

November 3, 2004 (co-optation as director
and ratification by the combined
Shareholders Meeting of May 31, 2005)



Expiring term date:


2009


Professional address:
GROUPAMA SA
Group Financial Management
8-10, rue d’Astorg
75783 Paris Cedex 08
France
    Principal position:

Chief Financial Officer of Groupama

Other positions:

France

Chairman of the Board:
- Groupama Immobilier
- Groupama Asset Management
- Finama Private Equity
- Compagnie Foncière Parisienne

Vice-chairman of the Supervisory Board:
- Banque Finama

Permanent representative of GROUPAMA
S.A. on the Supervisory Board:
- Lagardère S.C.A


Permanent representative of GAN
Assurances Vie on the Supervisory Board
of:

- Locindus

Permanent representative of Groupama
S.A. on the Board of Directors:

- Silic

Director:
- SCOR VIE

Non-voting director on the Supervisory Board:
    Permanent representative of GAN S.A. on the Supervisory Board of:
- Lagardère S.C.A
 
 
 
    - GIMAR Finance & Compagnie

Abroad
       
                 

Page 137 of 184


 

                 
                 
 
 
   
Director:
- GAN Italia Vita (Italy)
- GAN Italia S.p.A (Italy)

       
                 
 



André LEVY-LANG (1) (3) (4)
Director


Birth Date:
November 26, 1937




First appointment date:


May 15, 2003



Expiring term date: 2009

Professional address:
SCOR
1, avenue du Général de Gaulle
92800 Puteaux
France
   


France

Associate Professor Emeritus at the
University of Paris-Dauphine


Director:
- AGF
- SCOR VIE

Member of the Supervisory Board:
- Paris-Orléans

Abroad
Director:
- Dexia (Brussels)
- Schlumberger (U.S.)
    None
 
                 
 

Herbert SCHIMETSCHEK (2)
Director


   
Principal position:

Chairman of the Management Board and
General Director of UNIQA Versicherung S.A

    Chairman of the Board:
- UNIQA Versicherung S.A

 
 
Birth Date:
January 5, 1938



First appointment date:

May 15, 2003





Expiring term date:

2007

Professional address:
UNIQA International
Untere Donaustrasse 25
A-1020 Vienna
Austria
   

Other positions:

France

Director:
- SCOR VIE

Abroad (Austria)

Chairman of the Management Board:
- Austria Versicherungsverein auf
Gegenseitigkeit (Holding)

Vice-Chairman of the Supervisory Board:
- Bank Gutmann S.A.

Chairman of the Supervisory Board:
- Austria österreichische Hotelbetriebs
Aktiengesellschaft

Chairman of the Management Board:
- UNIQA Immobilien-Projekterrichtungs
GmbH

Vice-Chairman of the Supervisory Board:
- Bauholding STRABAG

Vice-President:
- Automobile Club of Austria
-Franco-Austrian Chamber of Commerce

Member of the Management Committee:
- Ludwig Boltzmann Gesellschaft

Member of the Board of Directors:
- Diplomatic Academy of Vienna

    Chairman of the Management Board:
- UNIQA International




Chairman of the Supervisory Board:
- UNIQA International VersicherungsHolding
GmbH

Chairman of the Board of Directors:
- Caisse d’épargne Erste Bank der
Osterreichische Sparkassen AG

Vice-Chairman of the Supervisory Board:
- BIBAG Bauindustrie, Beteiligungs- und
Verwaltungs-Aktiengesellschaft
 
                 
 

Jean-Claude SEYS (1)
Director



Birth Date:

   
Principal positions:

Chairman and Chief Executive Officer of
COVEA (SGAM)
    Chief Executive Officer of:
-      MAAF Mutuelles
-      MAAF S.A.
-      MMA IARD
-      MMA VIE
 
                 

Page 138 of 184


 

                 
                 
 
November 13, 1938
    Chairman of the Board of Directors of     Chairman of the Board of Directors of:  
 
 
    MMA IARD and MMA Vie (SAM)     – DAS (SAM)  
 
First appointment date:
             
 
 
    Other positions:        
 
 
          Director of:  
 
May 15, 2003
    France     – OFIGEST (subsidiary of OFIVALMO)  
 
 
          – GEOBTP  
 
 
    Chairman of the Board: - MAAF Santé        
 
 
    (Mutuelle 45)        
 
 
    - Force et Santé (Union Mutualiste)     Vice-Chairman of the Supervisory Board of:  
 
Expiring term date:

2009
    - COSEM (Association)
- Aide Médicale (Association)
- Fondation MAAF Assurances
- OCEAM Ré (SRM)
    - Fructi-MAAF (subsidiary of MAAF S.A.)  
 
Professional address:
             
 
MAAF ASSURANCES, MMA & COVEA
    Director:        
 
7, place des 5 martyrs du Lycée Buffon
75015 Paris
France
    - MAAF Assurances (SAM)
- MAAF Assurances (SAM)
- DAS (SAM)
       
 
 
    - AGMAA S.A. – Azur GMF Mutuelles        
 
 
    Assurances associés (Permanent Representative of COVEA)        
 
 
    - FIDELIA (S.A.) (subsidiary of Azur GMF)        
 
 
    - SCOR VIE        
 
 
    - OFIMALLIANCE (S.A.) (Permanent Representative of OFIVALMO)        
 
 
             
 
 
    Chairman of the Supervisory Board:        
 
 
    - Savour Club S.A. (subsidiary of MAAF S.A.)        
 
 
    - OFIVALMO S.A.        
 
 
             
 
 
    Member of the Supervisory Board:        
 
 
    - OFI Asset Management (subsidiary of OFIVALMO S.A.)        
 
 
             
 
 
    Vice-Chairman of the Board of Directors:        
 
 
    - ACMA (Association pour la
Coopération entre Mutuelles
Assurances pour Agriculture et
Artisanat)
       
 
 
    - SC Holding (S.A.S.) (Santéclair)        
 
 
             
 
 
    Permanent Representative of:        
 
 
    - COVEA (SGAM) in Covéa Technologie (S.A.S.)        
 
 
    - OCEAM Ré (SRM) in COVEA Groupe SAS        
 
 
             
 
 
    Abroad        
 
 
             
 
 
    - LMIH (the Netherlands) - PCS - CASER (Spain) – Vice Chairman        
 
 
             
 
 
    Director:        
 
 
    - COVEA Ré (Luxembourg)        
 
 
    - EURAPCO        
 
 
             
                 
 
 
             
 
 
    Principal position:     Chairman of:  
 
 
             
 
Jean SIMONNET (2)
Director
    - Chairman of MACIF (Société d’Assurance Mutuelle)*     - MACIF Gestion SA
- Macifilia SA
- OFIMA MIDCAP SICAV
 
 
Birth Date:
             
 
August 5, 1936
    Other positions:     Permanent Representative of:  
 
 
             
 
First appointment date: March 2, 1999
    France

Chairman:

- SOCRAM (société de crédit)*
    - MACIF on the Supervisory Board of GPIM SA
- MACIF on the Board of Directors of OFIMINTER SICAV
 
 
Expiring term date:
             
 
2011
    - SMIP (Mutuelle Code de la Mutualité)        
 
 
             
 
 
          Director of:  
 
Professional address:
MACIF
    Permanent Representative of MACIF on the Supervisory Board:     - Macif participations SA
- Union Mutualiste des Deux-Sèvres
 
 
2-4, rue de pied de Fond
    - I.M.A SA*     - Sicav Ofimaction  
 
79000 Niort
    - MUTAVIE*     - Sicav D’Ofivalmo  
 
France
    - OFIVALMO S.A.*     - Sicav Ofima Oblig  
 
 
             
 
 
    Permanent Representative of MACIF on the Board of Directors:        
 
 
    - Compagnie Immobilière MACIF S.A.*     Non-voting director:
OFIMACTION FOCUS PEA SICAV
 
                 

Page 139 of 184


 

                 
                 
 
 
    - Foncière de Lutèce S.A.*        
 
 
    - MACIF Mutualité* (Mutual Insurance     Manager:  
 
 
    Code)     - Port Lonvilliers SARL  
 
 
             
 
 
    Director:        
 
 
    - FORINTER S.A.*
- SICAV OFIMA EURO Moyen Terme
- Union Mutualiste des Deux Sèvres (Mutual Insurance Code)
- SCOR VIE
       
 
 
             
 
 
    Non-voting director:        
 
 
    - MACIFILIA*
- OFIMA MIDCAP SICAV
- OFIMA TRESOR SICAV
       
 
 
             
 
 
    Manager:        
 
 
    - Gironde et Gascogne SARL
- Château de Belcier SCEA
- Château Ramage La Batisse SCI
       
 
 
             
 
 
    Member (but not director) of the Board or Committee of:        
 
 
    - GPIM S.A.S.
- MACIF PARTICIPATIONS S.A.S.*
       
 
 
    - COMPAGNIE FONCIERE DE LA MACIF SAS*        
 
 
    - SIEM S.A.        
 
 
    - MACIFIMO S.A.S        
 
 
             
 
 
    Abroad:        
 
 
    - Permanent MACIF representative on the Board of Directors of EURESA        
 
 
    - Director: IMA IBERICA        
 
 
             
 
 
    * Companies consolidated in the MACIF Group        
                 
 
 
             
 
 
          General Director of:  
 
Claude TENDIL (1) (2)
Director
    Principal positions:     - Generali France Holding  
 
 
    Chief Executive Officer:     Director:  
 
Birth Date:
    - Generali France
       
 
July 25, 1945
    - Generali France Assurances Vie     - L’Equité  
 
 
             
 
First appointment date:
    Other positions:     - Continent Holding  
 
May 15, 2003
     
France
     
- Continent IARD
 
 
 
             
 
Expiring term date:
             
 
2007
             
 
 
    Chairman of the Board of Directors:        
 
Professional address:
GENERALI FRANCE HOLDING
Chief Executive Officer
7/9, boulevard Haussmann
75009 Paris
France
    - Assurance France Generali
- Generali Assurances-IARD
- GPA IARD
- GPA VIE
- La Fédération Continentale
- Europ Assistance Holding
       
 
 
             
 
 
    Director:        
 
 
    - Unibail
- SCOR VIE
       
 
 
             
 
 
    Abroad        
 
 
             
 
 
    Chairman of the Board of Directors:        
 
 
    - Europ Assistance Italie        
 
 
             
 
 
    Permanent Representative of Europ Assistance Holding on the Board:        
 
 
    of:        
 
 
    - Europ Assistance Espagne (Spain)        
 
 
             
                 
 
 
             
 
Daniel VALOT (1)
    Principal position:     Vice Chairman:  
 
Director
     
Chief Executive Officer of Technip
    - Technip Americas (USA)

Chairman:
 
                 

Page 140 of 184


 

                 
                 
 
Birth Date:
    Other positions:     Technip Far East  
 
August 24, 1944
             
 
 
    France        
 
First appointment date:
             
 
May 15, 2003
    Director:        
 
 
    - Compagnie Générale de Géophysique        
 
Expiring term date:
    - Institut Français du Pétrole        
 
2007

    - SCOR VIE        
 
Professional address:
    Permanent Representative of Technip in:        
 
TECHNIP
    - Technip France        
 
Tour Technip
             
 
6-8, allée de l’Arche
    Abroad        
 
92973 Paris la Défense Cedex
             
 
France
    Director:        
 
 
    - Technip Far East (Malaysia)

       
 
 
    Chairman:        
 
 
    - Technip Italy (Italy)        
                 
 
 
          Member of the Supervisory Board:  
 
Georges CHODRON de COURCEL (2) (4)
    Principal position:     - SAGEM  
 
Non-Voting Director
             
 
 
    Chief Operating Officer of BNP Paribas     Chairman of the  
 
Birth Date:
          Supervisory Board of:  
 
May 20, 1950
    Other positions:        
 
 
          - BNP Paribas Bank SA (Pologne)  
 
First appointment date:
    France     - Chairman of BNP U.S. Funding (US)  
 
May 9, 1994 (Director)
             
 
May 15, 2003 (Non-Voting Director)
          Director of:  
 
 
    Director:        
 
 
    - Bouygues S.A.        
 
Expiring term date:
    - Alstom     - Verner Investissements SAS  
 
2007 (Non-Voting Director)
    - Nexans S.A.        
 
 
    - Société Foncière Financière et de     - BNP Paribas Canada  
 
Professional address:
    Participations (FFP)        
 
BNP PARIBAS
          - BNP Paris Peregrine Ltd (Malaysia)  
 
3, rue d’Antin
    Member of the Supervisory Board:        
 
75002 Paris, France
    - Lagardère S.C.A.     - BNP Prime Peregrine Holdings Ltd  
 
France
          (Malaysia)  
 
 
    Chairman:        
 
 
    - BNP Paribas Emergis SAS     - BNP Paribas Securities Corp (US)  
 
 
    - Compagnie d’Investissement de Paris SAS        
 
 
    - Financière BNP Paribas SAS        
 
 
    all three subsidiaries of BNP Paribas        
 
 
             
 
 
    Non-voting director:        
 
 
    - SCOR VIE
- SAFRAN (since March 18, 2005)
       
 
 
             
 
 
    Abroad        
 
 
             
 
 
    Chairman:
- BNP Paribas S.A.
- BNP Paribas UK Holdings Limited (United Kingdom)
       
 
 
             
 
 
    Director:        
 
 
    - Erbé S.A. (Belgium)        
                 
(1)   Member of the Strategic Committee
(2)   Member of the Risks Committee
(3)   Member of the Accounts and Audit Committee
(4)   Member of the Compensation and Nominations Committee
(5)   Non-voting member of the Accounts and Audit Committee

Page 141 of 184


 

9.2 BIOGRAPHICAL INFORMATION ON MEMBERS OF THE BOARD OF DIRECTORS
Denis Kessler
Denis Kessler is a graduate of HEC business school (Ecole des Hautes Etudes Commerciales) and holds a PhD in economics and an advanced degree in social sciences. He was Chairman of the Fédération Française des Sociétés d’Assurance (FFSA) and Senior Executive Vice President and member of the Executive Committee of the AXA Group. Denis Kessler also worked for the MEDEF (French Business Confederation). He joined SCOR as Chairman and Chief Executive Officer of the Group on November 4, 2002.
Carlo Acutis
The principal position of Carlo Acutis, of Italian nationality, is as Vice Chairman of Vittoria Assicurazioni S.p.A. He also serves as Chairman and member of the Boards of Directors of a number of companies. This specialist of the international insurance market was formerly Chairman and Vice Chairman of the Presidential Council of the European Insurance Committee and director of the Geneva Association.
Michèle Aronvald
Michèle Aronvald has worked for 26 years in SCOR’s Finance Department. She has been serving her term as employee-elected director since 2001.
Antonio Borges
Antonio Borges is currently Vice Chairman of Goldman Sachs International in London. He is a member of the Supervisory Board of CNP Assurances and a member of the Tax Committee of Banco Santander de Negocios Portugal. Antonio Borges was previously Dean of INSEAD business school.
Allan Chapin
After being a partner at Sullivan & Cromwell LLP and Lazard Frères in New York, for many years, Allan Chapin has been a partner at Compass Advisers LLP in New York since June 2002. He also serves on the boards of directors for the Pinault Printemps Redoute Group, InBev (Belgium), and a number of subsidiaries of SCOR U.S. Corporation.
Daniel Havis
Daniel Havis is Chairman and Chief Executive Officer of the Mutuelle Assurance de Travailleurs Mutualistes (MATMUT).
Yvon Lamontagne
Yvon Lamontagne is the non-executive chairman of SCOR Canada and has served as Chairman and Chief of Management of Boreal Assurances (now AXA). Yvon Lamontagne has served on the boards of directors of various companies in Quebec.
Daniel Lebègue
Daniel Lebègue has directed the French Trésor and has been Chief Operating Officer of BNP and of Caisse des Dépôts et Consignations, Chairman of the Supervisory Board of CDC IXIS and Chairman of Eulia. He currently serves on the boards of directors for various companies.
Helman Le Pas de Sécheval
From 1998 to 2001, Helman Le Pas de Sécheval directed the financial information and operations department at the COB (Commission des Opérations de Bourse, now Autorité des Marchés Financiers or AMF), before being appointed Group Chief Financial Officer of Groupama in November 2001.
André Lévy-Lang
André Lévy-Lang was Chairman of the Management Board of Paribas from 1990 to 1999 and is now Director of various companies and an Associate Professor Emeritus at the Paris University of Dauphine.
Herbert Schimetschek
From 1997 to 2000, Herbert Schimetschek was Chairman of the Conseil Européen des Assureurs, then until June 2000, Vice Chairman of the Austrian Insurance Companies Association, and from 1999 to 2001, Chairman of the Management Board and Chief Operating Officer of UNIQA Versicherung S.A.
Jean-Claude Seys
Jean-Claude Seys has spent his career in the insurance industry. He was appointed Chairman and Chief Executive Officer of MAAF in 1992, then Chairman and Chief Executive Officer of MAAF-MMA in 1998. Today he is the Chairman and Chief Executive Officer of SGAM COVEA (since June 2003) and Chairman of MMA.

Page 142 of 184


 

In the context of the Crédit Lyonnais / Executive Life case, Jean-Claude Seys entered into a transaction with the California prosecutor under which he is subject to five years of probation, and during which he cannot travel to the United States without special authorization.
Jean Simonnet
Jean Simonnet is currently the Chairman of MACIF (Mutuelle Assurance des Commerçants et Industriels de France) and also serves as Chairman of SMIP (Mutuelle Complémentaire Santé) and of SOCRAM (a credit institution).
Claude Tendil
Claude Tendil began his career at UAP in 1972 and joined the AXA Group from 1989 to 2002, where he became Vice-Chairman of the Management Board in 2001. Claude Tendil is Chairman and Chief Executive Officer of Generali France, the holding company of the Generali Group in France and of Generali Assurances Vie. He is also Chairman of the Board of Directors of Assurance France Generali, Generali Assurances IARD, Gpa IARD, Gpa Vie, La Fédération Continentale, Europ Assistance Holding and Europ Assistance Italie. Claude Tendil is a permanent representative of Europ Assistance Holding, director of Europ Assistance Espagne. Claude Tendil is also a director of Unibail.
Daniel Valot
Daniel Valot was Chief Executive Officer of Total Exploration Production, then worked for Technip, where he was appointed Chairman and Chief Executive Officer in September 1999.
Georges Chodron de Courcel
Georges Chodron de Courcel is Chief Operating Officer of BNP Paribas in Paris and holds various non-executive positions in the subsidiaries of the BNP Paribas Group.
9.3 TERMS AND CONDITIONS FOR THE PREPARATION AND ORGANIZATION OF WORK OF THE BOARD OF DIRECTORS    
The report of the Chairman of the Board of Directors on the conditions for preparing and organizing the work of the Board of Directors and on internal control procedures, in compliance with article L.225-37 of the French Commercial Code, appears in Section 9.13.
9.4 COMMITTEES OF THE BOARD
See the following Chairman’s report on the conditions for preparing and organizing the work of the Board of Directors and on internal control procedures, in compliance with article L.225-37 of the French Commercial Code.
9.5 EXECUTIVE COMMITTEE
The following table presents the Company’s executive officers who comprised the Executive Committee (COMEX) at December 31, 2005 and their positions with SCOR, and the first appointment dates as executive officers of SCOR.
                         
                Executive    
Name   Age   Current position   since   Other offices
Denis Kessler
    53     Chairman and Chief Executive Officer     2002     See Section “9.1 — Biographical Information on Members of the Board of Directors”
 
                       
Patrick Thourot (1)
    57     Chief Operating Officer     2003     Chairman and Chief Executive Officer:
EUROFINIMO;
 
                      FINIMOFRANCE;
 
                      FERGASCOR;
 
                      SCOR AUBER.
 
                       
 
                      Director:
 
                      MUTRE S.A.
 
                       
 
                      Permanent Representative of FERGASCOR on the Board of Directors of the Société Putéolienne de Participations
 
                       
 
                      Chairman:
 
                      SCOR UK Group Limited;
 
                      SCOR UK Company Limited;
 
                      IRP Holdings Limited (Ireland);

Page 143 of 184


 

                         
                Executive    
Name   Age   Current position   since   Other offices
 
                      Irish Reinsurance Partners Ltd (Ireland);
 
                      SCOR Reinsurance Asia-Pacific (Singapore);
 
                      SCOR Deutschland (Germany);
 
                      Commercial Risk Re-Insurance Company (US);
 
                      Commercial Risk Partners Ltd (Bermuda);
 
                      Commercial Risk Reinsurance Company Ltd (Bermuda);
 
                       
 
                      Director:
 
                      SCOR Reinsurance Company US;
 
                      SCOR U.S. Corporation;
 
                      General Security National Insurance Company (US);
 
                      ASEFA (Spain).
 
                       
 
                      Offices held during the last five years:
 
                       
 
                      - Chief Executive Officer of Zurich France
 
                      - Central Technical Managing Director of AXA Group
 
                       
Yvan Besnard
    51     Deputy Managing Director of SCOR Global P&C     2004     Member of the Supervisory Board:
FCPE Actions SCOR;
FCPE Valeurs Mobilières Obligations.
 
                       
 
                      Director:
 
                      Groupement de Services d’Assurance et Réassurance;
 
                      Euroscor/Actiscor (Luxembourg);
 
                      SCOR UK Group Ltd;
 
                      SCOR UK Company Ltd;
 
                      SCOR Europe Mid Cap (Luxembourg);
 
                      SCOR Italia;
 
                      SCOR Picking (Luxembourg).
 
                       
 
                      Permanent Representative of SCOR in: Assuratome
 
                      (G.I.E.);
 
                      Assurpol (G.I.E.);
 
                      Tricast S.A.
 
                       
 
                      Member of the Supervisory Board and Deputy Chairman of SCOR Deutschland.
 
                       
Jean-Luc Besson
    59     Chief Risk Officer     2003     Director of the Institut des Actuaires.
 
                       
Romain Durand (2)
    48     Managing Director of SCOR VIE     1997     Chairman:
SOLAREH S.A.*
 
                       
 
                      Permanent Representative of SCOR VIE on the Supervisory Board of MUTRE*.
 
                       
 
                      Director:
 
                      SGF*;
 
                      Investors Insurance Corporation (USA)*;
 
                      Investors Marketing Group (USA)*;
 
                      SCOR Financial Services Limited (Ireland)*;
 
                      SCOR Life US Reinsurance Company (USA)*;
 
                      SCOR Italia Riassicurazioni S.p.A. (Italy)*.
 
                       
 
                      Member of the Supervisory Board:
 
                      REMARK B.V. (Netherlands)*.
 
                       
 
                      *Romain Durand resigned from his positions within these companies on December 31, 2005.
 
                       
Marcel Kahn
    49     Group Chief Financial
Officer
    2004     Member of the Supervisory Board:
FCPE Actions SCOR;
FCPE Valeurs Mobilières Obligations.
 
                       
 
                      Chairman:
 
                      Euroscor/Actiscor (Luxembourg);
 
                      SCOR Europe Mid Cap (Luxembourg);
 
                      SCOR Picking (Luxembourg).
 
                       
 
                      Permanent Representative of SCOR in SGF and SCOR Auber.

Page 144 of 184


 

                         
                Executive    
Name   Age   Current position   since   Other offices
Henry Klecan, Jr.
    54     President and Chief Executive Officer of SCOR U.S. and SCOR Canada     2003     Chief Executive Officer of:
SCOR Reinsurance Company (US);
SCOR U.S. Corporation;
General Security Indemnity Company of Arizona (US);
 
                      General Security National Insurance Company (US);
 
                      SCOR Canada Reinsurance Company;
 
                      Cal Re Management, Inc (US);
 
                      SOREMA N.A. Holding Corporation.
 
                       
Victor Peignet
    48     Managing Director of SCOR Global P&C     2004     Chairman of SCORLUX (Luxembourg; Company in the process of liquidation).
 
                       
 
                      Director of:
 
                      SCOR UK Co. Ltd. (London);
 
                      SCOR Channel Ltd. (Guernsey);
 
                      Arisis Ltd. (Guernsey);
 
                      General Security Indemnity Company of Arizona (US);
 
                      General Security National Insurance Company (US);
 
                      SCOR Reinsurance Company (US).
(1) Mr. Thourot was appointed by the Board of Directors on January 22, 2003 as Chief Operating Officer for the length of the term of the Chairman and Chief Executive Officer.
(2) Romain Durand resigned from his positions as Chief Executive Officer and Director of SCOR VIE on December 28, 2005. SCOR VIE’s Board of Directors approved his resignation on January 11, 2006. Upon a proposal of the Compensation and Nominations Committee, the Board of Directors unanimously appointed its Chairman, Denis Kessler, as Chief Executive Officer of SCOR VIE.
The professional address of all of the members of the Executive Committee is the registered offices of the Company, at 1, avenue du Général de Gaulle, 92800 PUTEAUX, France, with the exception of Mr. Klecan, whose professional address is SCOR Reinsurance Company, 199 Water Street – Suite 21000, New York, NY 10038-3526, United States.
9.6 BIOGRAPHICAL INFORMATION ON THE MEMBERS OF THE EXECUTIVE COMMITTEE
Denis Kessler, Chairman and Chief Executive Officer, 53 years old
See Section 9.1 – Information concerning the members of the Board of Directors.
Patrick Thourot, Chief Operating Officer, 57 years old
Patrick Thourot is a graduate of Ecole Nationale d’Administration, was chief executive officer of PFA (Athéna Group), worked for ten years with the French Ministry of Finance and worked for AXA, where he was Executive Vice President of the Group before he was appointed Chief Operating Officer of Zûrich France. He has been Chief Operating Officer of SCOR Group since January 2003.
Yvan Besnard, Chief Operating Officer of SCOR Global P&C, 51 years old
Yvan Besnard, a graduate of ESSEC, joined the SCOR Group in 1991, where he held various financial and international posts. Head of Development of SCOR since 2000, then Chief Internal Auditor of the Group since 2003, he was appointed Director of Non-Life Business for Europe in July 2004, then Deputy Managing Director of SCOR Global P&C.
Jean-Luc Besson, Chief Risk Officer, 59 years old
Jean-Luc Besson, an actuary, holds a PhD in Mathematics and has served as a Professor of Mathematics and was a Senior Vice President, Research, Statistics and Information Systems at the FFSA. He was appointed Chief Reserving Actuary of the SCOR Group in January 2003 and has been Chief Risk Officer since July 1, 2004.
Romain Durand, Chief Executive Officer and Director of SCOR VIE, 48 years old
Romain Durand is a graduate of HEC business school (Ecole des Hautes Etudes Commerciales) and Sciences Po (Political Sciences faculty in Paris). Romain Durand joined SCOR in January 1997, after spending several years in the international insurance industry. He was Director of SCOR’s Life Division in April 1998 and was Managing Director and Director of SCOR VIE until December 28, 2005.
Marcel Kahn, Groupe Chief Financial Officer, 49 years old
Marcel Kahn, an actuary, certified public accountant, and graduate of the ESSEC business school, was an external auditor and a certified public accountant for many years before joining AXA Group in 1988 as Group Director of Management Control. From 1991 to 2001, he was the Chief Financial Officer of AXA France, International Director, Europe, Group Director of Strategy and Development, and then Deputy Managing Director of AXIVA (life insurance). In 2001, he was appointed Chief Financial Officer (CFO) of PartnerRe Global and Managing Director of PartnerRe France. Marcel Kahn has been Chief Financial Officer of the SCOR Group since 2004.

Page 145 of 184


 

Henry Klecan, Jr., President and Chief Executive Officer of SCOR U.S. and SCOR Canada, 54 years old
Henry Klecan, Jr., a Canadian, holds a B.A. in philosophy from Sir George Williams University and a law degree from the University of Montreal. He is the co-founder of London Guarantee Insurance Company and managed Citadel Assurance Company. Since July 2000, Henry Klecan, Jr. has been President and Chief Executive Officer of SCOR Canada Reinsurance Company. He was also appointed President and Chief Executive Officer of SCOR U.S. Corporation on November 18, 2003.
Victor Peignet, Managing Director of SCOR Global P&C, 48 years old
Victor Peignet, offshore and shipbuilding engineer, joined SCOR’s Facultative Department in 1984. He was appointed Executive Vice President of the Business Solutions Division at its formation in 2000, then Chief Operating Officer of SCOR Global P&C.
9.7 STATEMENTS ON THE COMPANY’S CORPORATE GOVERNANCE
Since SCOR’s equities are listed on the Eurolist of Euronext Paris and on the New York Stock Exchange, the provisions relating to corporate governance applicable to SCOR include both French and US legal provisions, as well as rules dictated by the market authorities of both countries. SCOR believes that its application of corporate governance principles is appropriate and is in compliance with the best practices of corporate governance in effect in the United States and France.
To our knowledge, there are no familial relationships between the directors and the members of the Company’s executive management.
No loans or guarantees have been granted or established in favor of the directors or members of executive management by the Company or a company of its Group.
To our knowledge, there are no conflicts of interest between the duties of the directors and members of executive management with regard to SCOR Company and their private interests.
To our knowledge, during the last five years:
  no director and no member of executive management has been convicted of fraud;
 
  no director and no member of executive management has been associated with a bankruptcy, sequestration or liquidation;
 
  no director and no member of executive management has been the subject of an accusation or official public sanction issued by statutory or regulatory authorities; and
 
  no director and no member of executive management has ever been prohibited by a court from acting as a member of an administrative, management or supervisory body of an issuer or from participating in the management or business of an issuer.
To our knowledge, there are no service agreements binding the members of the administrative bodies or executive management to the Company or to one of its subsidiaries and providing for the granting of benefits at the completion of such an agreement.
9.8 Compensation and benefits of group directors, officers and members of the Executive Committee
Directors’ fees for board members as of December 31, 2005
The Shareholders’ Meeting of May 31, 2005 set the annual amount of directors’ fees at €800,000. By deliberation on May 15, 2003, the Board of Directors decided to distribute directors’ fees to each of the board members as follows: half as a fixed-share of €20,000, the other half distributed based on the attendance of each director, at a rate of €1,700 per meeting per participant. A percentage of the directors’ fees is transferred to the Advisors under the same conditions. The Chief Operating Officer of the Company does not receive directors’ fees. Furthermore, the amount of €1,700 is paid for participation in the Board’s Committees.
Directors’ fees are paid at the end of each quarter.
irectors’ fees paid to directors for 2005 and for 2004 are broken down as follows:
                 
In euros   2005   2004
Mr. Denis Kessler (1)
    0       0  
 
               
Mr. Carlo Acutis (2)
    18,825       20,100  
 
               
Mrs. Michèle Aronvald (3)
    31,900       28,500  
 
               
Mr. Antonio Borges (4)
    30,300       27,750  
 
               
Mr. Allan Chapin (5)
    31,575       26,475  
 
               
Mr. Georges Chodron de Courcel
    35,300       31,900  
 
               
Mr. Daniel Havis
    31,900       28,500  

Page 146 of 184


 

                 
In euros   2005   2004
Mr. Yvon Lamontagne (6)
    23,925       21,375  
 
               
Mr. Helman Le Pas de Sécheval
    37,000       35,300  
 
               
Mr. Daniel Lebègue
    43,800       43,800  
 
               
Mr. André Lévy Lang
    45,500       47,200  
 
               
Mr. Herbert Schimetschek (7)
    18,825       17,550  
 
               
Mr. Jean-Claude Seys
    30,200       31,900  
Mr. Jean Simonnet
    30,200       26,800  
 
               
Mr. Claude Tendil
    31,900       30,200  
 
               
Mr. Daniel Valot
    33,600       28,500  
(1) in accordance with the decision taken by the Board of Directors on March 21, 2006, the Chairman will in future receive director’s fees in the same way as the other members of the Board of Directors of the Company and with the same breakdown.
(2) the sum allocated to Mr. Carlo Acutis, initially €25,100, includes withholding established at 25%, or €6,275, in accordance with the provisions of Articles 117 bis, 119 bis 2, and 187 of the General Tax Code.
(3) director representing the employees.
(4) the sum allocated to Mr. Antonio Borgès, initially €40,400, includes withholding established at 25%, or €10,100, in accordance with the provisions of Articles 117 bis, 119 bis 2, and 187 of the General Tax Code.
(5) the sum allocated to Mr. Allan Chapin, initially €42,100, includes withholding established at 25%, or €10,525, in accordance with the provisions of Articles 117 bis, 119 bis 2, and 187 of the General Tax Code.
(6) the sum allocated to Mr. Yvon Lamontagne, initially €31,900, includes withholding established at 25%, or €7,975, in accordance with the provisions of Articles 117 bis, 119 bis 2, and 187 of the General Tax Code.
(7) the sum allocated to Mr. Herbert Schimetschek, initially €25,100, includes withholding established at 25%, or €6,275, in accordance with the provisions of Articles 117 bis, 119 bis 2, and 187 of the General Tax Code.
The Company paid an aggregate amount of €4,753.54 to the French government for pension benefits on behalf of its employee-elected director, Mrs. Michele Aronvald. No other amounts were paid for pension, retirement or similar benefits for the Company’s directors.
Moreover, certain SCOR directors participate, or have participated, on the Boards of Directors of the Group’s subsidiaries and received directors’ fees in 2004 and 2005 as follows:
                 
-SCOR U.S. Corporation:   2005   2004
Mr. Chapin:
  USD 27,000   USD 27,000
Mr. Lebègue:
  USD 14,700   USD 14,700
 
               
-SCOR Canada:
               
Mr. Lamontagne:
  CAD 40,000   CAD 40,000
Total Compensation for Members of the Executive Committee for fiscal year 2005
In 2005, total compensation to the Members present on SCOR Group’s Executive Committee was €4,019,557 as of December 31, 2005.
There is no employment contract between Mr. Kessler and SCOR. The terms and conditions of his appointment are described in the minutes of the meeting of the Board of Directors held on December 19, 2002 and in the minutes of the Board of Directors of August 31, 2005. The Appointments and Compensation Committee proposed to the Board that the compensation of the Chairman and Chief Executive Officer be comprised as follows:
    a fixed amount of €500,000 gross
    a variable portion for a maximum amount of €900,000 including: 3 per thousand of the consolidated net profit for SCOR, provided it exceeds €30,000,000, within the limit of €360,000, and a maximum amount of €540,000, determined by the Board of Directors, and linked to the achievement of objectives decided each year by the Board of Directors.
As for the Chief Operating Officer, there is no employment contract between Mr. Thourot and SCOR. His compensation was established by the Board of Directors on January 22, 2003. The Compensation Committee proposed to the Board that the compensation of the Chief Operating Officer be comprised as follows:
    a fixed amount of €410,000,
    a variable portion for a maximum amount of €410,000 including: 1.50 per thousand of SCOR’s consolidated net income, within the limit of €287,000, and a maximum amount of €123,000, determined by the Board of Directors, and linked to the achievement of objectives decided each year by the Chairman and Chief Executive Officer.
The following table presents gross compensation owing for fiscal year 2005 and fiscal year 2004 to the Chairman and Chief Executive Officer and to the Chief Operating Officer:

Page 147 of 184


 

                                                                 
 
        Fixed     Variable     Total     Fixed compensation     Variable     Total  
        compensation     compensation     compensation     paid for 2004     compensation     compensation  
        paid for 2005     paid and to be     paid for 2005               paid for 2004     paid for 2004  
                  paid for 2005                                          
 
 
    In euros     In euros     In euros     In euros     In euros     In euros  
 
Mr. Denis Kessler
      500,000         846,000         1,346,000         500,000         328,791         828,791    
 
Mr. Patrick Thourot
      410,000         289,450         699,450         410,000         164,477         574,477    
 
The following table presents the gross compensation paid in 2005 and 2004 to the Chairman and Chief Executive Officer and to the Chief Operating Officer:
                                                                 
 
        Fixed     Variable     Total     Fixed compensation     Variable     Total  
        compensation     compensation     compensation     paid in 2004     compensation     compensation  
        paid in 2005     paid in 2005     paid in 2005               variable paid in     paid in 2004  
                                                2004            
 
 
    In euros     In euros     In euros     In euros     In euros     In euros  
 
Mr. Denis Kessler
      500,000         495,364         995,364         500,000         150,000         650,000    
 
Mr. Patrick Thourot
      410,000         164,477         574,477         410,000         123,000         533 000    
 
The Compensation and Nominations Committee determines the variable compensation attributed to the other members of the Executive Committee on proposal of the Chairman. The variable portion of the compensation presented in the table below depends, on one hand, on the achievement of individual objectives and, on the other hand, on the achievement of the Group’s earnings objectives, which are based on return on equity or ROE.
The following table presents gross compensation owing for fiscal year 2005 and for fiscal year 2004 to the members of the Executive Committee (other than the Chairman and Chief Executive Officer and the Chief Operating Officer):
                                                                                     
 
        Fixed     Variable     Profit sharing     Total     Fixed     Variable     Profit sharing     Total  
        compensation     compensation     for 20052     compensation     compensation     compensation     paid for 2004     compensation  
        paid for 2005     paid and to be               paid for 2005     paid for 2004     paid for 2004               paid for 2004  
                  paid for 2005 1                                      
        In euros     In euros     In euros     In euros     In euros     In euros     In euros     In euros  
 
Marcel Kahn
      280,000         N/A         26,295         N/A         195,152         142,240         11,342         348,734    
 
Romain Durand 3
      280,000         168,169         -         448,169         255,000         142,240         -         397,240    
 
Jean-Luc Besson
      280,000         N/A         26,295         N/A         209,000         167,740         15,753         392,493    
 
Victor Peignet
      280,000         N/A         26,295         N/A         203,000         159,676         15,753         378,429    
 
Henry Klecan Jr4
      253,700         N/A         -         N/A         226,743         126,850         -         353,593    
 
Yvan Besnard
      197,000         N/A         26,295         N/A         157,000         90,226         12,397         259,623    
 
The following table presents gross compensation paid in 2005 and in 2004 to the members of the Executive Committee (other than the Chairman and Chief Executive Officer and the Chief Operating Officer):
 
1   The contractual bonus to be paid in 2006, which is one of the components of the variable portion of compensation, will be established at a later time by the Compensation and Nominations Committee based on financial and individual criteria.
2   The amounts corresponding to profit sharing paid in 2006 and for fiscal year 2005 are amounts estimated at the cap. These are likely to change based on the final budget allowance.
3   Romain Durand resigned from his functions as Chief Executive Offices and director of SCOR VIE on 28 December 2005. The Board of Directors of SCOR VIE accepted his resignation on 11 January 2006. From 28 December 2005, Romain Durand lost all his rights to share options and to a free distribution of shares.
4.   Exchange rate at 31/12/2005 1 USD = 0.8456 EUR and 1 CAD = 0.7448 EUR
5.   Exchange rate at 31/12/2005 1 USD =0.8456 EUR and 1 CAD = 0.7448 EUR

Page 148 of 184


 

                                                                                     
 
        Fixed     Variable     Profit     Total     Fixed     Variable     Profit     Total  
        compensation     compensation     sharing paid     compensation     compensation     compensation     sharing paid     compensation  
        paid in     paid in 2005     in 2005     paid in 2005     paid in 2004     paid in 2004     in 2004     paid in 2004  
        2005                                            
        In euros     In euros     In euros     In euros     In euros     In euros     In euros     In euros  
 
Marcel Kahn
      280,000         142,240         11,342         433,582         195,152         -         -         195,152    
 
Mr. Romain Durand 3
      280,000         148,774         -         428,774         255,000         79,635         -         334,635    
 
Jean-Luc Besson
      280,000         133,840         15,753         429,593         209,000         50,460         -         259,460    
 
Victor Peignet
      280,000         181,842         15,753         477,595         203,000         109,078         -         312,078    
 
Henry Klecan, Jr.6
      253,700         126,850         -         380,550         226,743         25,481         -         252,224    
 
Yvan Besnard
      197,000         90,226         12,397         299,623         157,000         11,700         -         168,700    
 
Like all Group senior executives, members of the Group Executive Committee are entitled to a guaranteed capped pension plan conditioned by a 10-year length of service in the Group, the payment of which is based on their average compensation over the last five years.
The amount paid or accrued by the Group for the departure of members of the Executive Committee in 2005 was €3,992,964.
They also benefit from the use of a vehicle for business purposes, the Chairman having a company car for his representational duties; all costs of insurance, maintenance and fuel as well as expenses for the chauffeur being charged to the Company.
In addition, the Chairman and the Chief Operating Officer receive the following benefits in kind:
(a) health insurance policy under the terms of a contract dated September 16, 1998;
(b) an “all causes” death or permanent disability insurance underwritten for the senior management of the Company on 30 June 1993. The Company is currently re-negotiating this contract, and it is emphasized that the Chairman and the Chief Operating Officer will benefit from any contract replacing the existing contract; and
(c) an insurance for death or permanent disability caused by an accident, underwritten on January 1, 2006. The Company is currently re-negotiating this contract and it is emphasized that the Chairman and the Managing Director will benefit from any contract replacing the existing contract.
The members of the Executive Committee do not receive directors’ fees in respect of their directorships of companies in which SCOR holds more than 20% of the share capital. They are reimbursed for justified business expenses.
Compensation of the Chairman and the Chief Operating Officer for the 2006 financial period
  §   The Chairman’s compensation
On March 21, 2006, at the suggestion of the Committee for Appointments and Compensation, the Board of Directors decided that the Chairman:
  will continue to receive a fixed annual compensation of €500,000 gross, payable in twelve monthly payments, and
  will receive, from the 2006 financial period inclusively, a variable annual compensation capped at €1,000,000 gross, consisting of:
    An annual variable compensation capped at €500,000 gross, the annual amount of which will be determined depending on the achievement of personal objectives, annually defined at the beginning pf the period, by the Board of Directors at the suggestion of the Committee for Appointments and Compensation.
 
    an annual variable compensation capped at €500,000 gross, the annual amount of which will be determined depending on the achievement of financial objectives defined annually at the beginning of the period by the Board of Directors at the suggestion of the Committee for Appointments and Compensation.
The variable compensation for N will be paid during the period N + 1, as soon as the Company financial statements for the N period are approved by the General Meeting.
For the 2006 period, the variable compensation of the Chairman will be determined according to the following criteria:
  Personal criteria: conclusion of strategic operations, return to the marking of level A- (A.M.Best) and maintenance of the marking A- (S&P), restructuring of the SCOR Group around the three companies being created, general management of the firm; and
  financial criteria: level of Return on Equity (ROE) achieved by SCOR, it being stated that the amount of the variable compensation will be progressive and proportional to the figure achieved by this ROE of between 0% and 10%, an ROE exceeding or equal to 10% giving the right to the maximum amount of variable compensation.
In the case of departure during period N:
  the whole of the variable part of his compensation relating to the period N-1 will be payable at the time of period N as soon as the Company financial statements for the period N-1 are approved by the General Meeting;

Page 149 of 184


 

  in addition, in the case of dismissal, the amount of the variable part of his compensation for period N will (i) be determined on the basis of the variable compensation relating to the period N-1 and quota share depending on his date of departure in relation to period N in course, and (ii) paid as soon as the Company financial statements for period N-1 are approved by the General Meeting.
In the case of dismissal, the Chairman will receive an indemnity corresponding to the sum of all the variable and fixed elements of his annual gross compensation paid by the Company during the two years prior to his dismissal.
In the case of a change in the structure of the common stock of the Company markedly affecting his responsibilities and making pursuit of his activity and the normal exercising of his powers difficult, and in the case of interrupting the professional relationship at his request, the Chairman will receive an indemnity corresponding to the sum of all the fixed and variable elements of his annual gross compensation paid by the Company during the three years prior to the interruption. This indemnity will be paid at the request of the Chairman presented within six months from the occurrence of the significant change in the structure of the common stockl of the Company.
Finally, it was decided at the time of the Board of Directors Meeting of March 21, 2006 that the Chairman will benefit from a specific death insurance aimed at covering the risks inherent in the functions of the Chairman of the Company for an amount equivalent to three years of fixed and variable compensation, an insurance which will be taken out by the Company for the benefit of members of the Executive Committee.
  §   Compensation of the Chief Operating Officer
The Board of Directors Meeting of March 21, 2006, at the suggestion of the Committee for Appointments and Compensation, has decided that the Chief Operating Officer:
  will continue to receive a fixed annual compensation package of €410,000 gross, payable in twelve monthly payments and
  will receive, from the 2006 period inclusively, an annual variable compensation with a ceiling of €410,000 gross, consisting of:
    an annual variable compensation with a ceiling of €205,000 gross, the annual amount of which will be determined depending on the achievement of the personal objectives, annually defined at the beginning of the period by the Board of Directors at the suggestion of the Committee for Appointments and Compensation, and
 
    An annual variable compensation capped at €205,000 gross, the annual amount of which will depend on the achievement of financial objectives defined annually, at the beginning of the period, by the Board of Directors at the suggestion of the Committee for Appointments and Compensation.
The variable compensation for N will be paid during the period N + 1, as soon as the Company financial statements for the period N are approved by the General Meeting.
For the period 2006, the variable compensation of the Chief Operating Office will be determined in accordance with the following criteria:
    personal criteria: conclusion of strategic operations, return to the marking of level A- (A.M.Best) and maintenance of the marking A- (S&P), restructuring of the SCOR Group around the three companies being created, contribution to the general management of the firm in the framework of his duties; and
 
    financial criteria: level of the Return on Equity (ROE) achieved by SCOR, it being stated that the amount of the variable compensation will be progressive and proportional to the figure achieved by this ROE of between 0% and 10%, an ROE greater or equal to 10% giving the right to the maximum amount of the variable compensation.
In the case of departure during the period N:
 
    all the variable part of his compensation relating to period N-1 will be payable at the time of period N as soon as the Company financial statements for period N-1are approved by the General Meeting; 
 
    in addition, in the case of dismissal, the amount of the variable part of his compensation for period N will (i) be determined on the basis of the variable compensation relating to period N-1 and quota share depending on his departure date in relation to the period N in course, and (ii) paid as soon as the Company financial statements for the period N-1 are approved by the General Meeting
In the case of dismissal, the Chief Operating Officer will receive an indemnity corresponding to the sum of all the fixed and variable elements of his annual gross compensation paid by the Company during the two years prior to his dismissal.
In the case of a change in the structure of the common stock of the Company markedly affecting his responsibilities and making pursuit of his activity and the normal exercising of his powers difficult, and in the case of interrupting the professional relationship at his request, the Chief Operating Officer will receive an indemnity corresponding to the sum of all the fixed and variable elements of his annual gross compensation paid by the Company during the three years prior to the interruption. This indemnity will be paid at the request of the Chief Operating Officer presented within six months from the occurrence of the significant change in the structure of the common stock of the Company.

Page 150 of 184


 

9.9 Stock options held by the members of the Executive Committee at December 31, 2005
The stock option plans for the years 1994 to 1997 then 2003, 2004 and 2005 are share subscription plans that will give rise to an increase in share capital if exercized. The plans for the years 1998 to 2001 are stock option plans to purchase existing shares.
In accordance with the authorization of the General Shareholders’ Meeting decided on May 18, 2004, the Board of Directors approved a plan on August 25, 2004, intended for a number of the Group’s directors and officers and senior executives, offering a total of 5,990,000 options, granted without discount, at a price of €1.14 per option. The options can be exercized all at once or several times but with a minimum of 1,000 shares each time, from August 26, 2008 to August 25, 2014. After August 25, 2014, any unexercized options will become null and void.
The Board of Directors of SCOR, in accordance with the authority granted to it by the General Shareholders’ Meeting of May 31, 2005, established a new stock option plan on August 31, 2005 intended for group directors, officers and a number of senior executives of the Group’s companies. The stock subscription price amounts to €1.66 per share. The 7,260,000 options may be exercized all at once or separately from September 16, 2009 to September 15, 2015 and will give the right to one share per option. After this date, the rights will expire.
Conditions for exercising the options include a condition based on presence, but not a condition based on performance.

Page 151 of 184


 

SUMMARY OF STOCK OPTIONS GRANTED
                                                                                                                             
 
                                                                              Including 10                           Number of            
                                                                              largest       Subscription       Number of       options       Number of    
        Date of the       Date of the Board                                               Including       employee-       or purchase       shares       cancelled       options    
        Shareholders’       of Directors’       Date of availability of       Expiration date       Number of       Number of       executives of       recipient       price       purchased or       during the       remaining at    
  Plan     Meeting       Meeting       the options       of the plans       recipients       options granted       the Group       distributions       in euros       subscribed       fiscal year *       12/31/2005 *    
 
1992
    June 24, 1992     Sept. 28, 1992     closed     closed       76         318,800         42,000         54,000                   -         -         -    
 
1994
    May 09, 1994     May 9, 1994     closed     closed       104         429,000         59,000         64,000                   -         -         -    
 
1995
    May 09, 1995     May 15, 1995     closed     closed       99         430,000         82,000         68,000                   -         192,782         -    
 
1996
    May 13, 1996     Sept. 05, 1996     Sept. 05, 1997 (30%)     Sept. 04, 2006       122         480,000         83,000         70,000         11.7         -         42,096         661,689    
 
 
                        Sept. 05, 1998 (30%)                                                                                            
 
 
                        Sept. 05, 1999 (40%)                                                                                            
 
1997
    May 12, 1997     Sept. 04, 1997     Sept. 04, 2002     Sept. 03, 2007       113         481,500         112,000         72,000         15.03         -         59,429         806,014    
 
1998
    May 12, 1998     Sept. 03, 1998     Sept. 04, 2003     Sept. 03, 2008       134         498,000         130,000         71,500         22.72         -         76,764         860,496    
 
1999
    May 06, 1999     Sept. 02, 1999     Sept. 03, 2004     Sept. 02, 2009       145         498,500         130,000         71,000         18.58         -         86,667         817,168    
 
2000
    May 06, 1999     May 04, 2000     May 05, 2004     May 03, 2010       1,116         111,600         600         1,000         19.39         -         25,647         161,601    
 
2000
    May 06, 1999     Aug. 31, 2000     Sept. 01, 2005     Aug. 30, 2010       137         406,500         110,000         63,000         18.17         -         86,420         675,049    
 
2001
    April 19, 2001     Sept. 04, 2001     Sept. 04, 2005     Oct. 02, 2011       162         560,000         150,000         77,000         19.39         -         137,430         1,000,418    
 
2001
    April 19, 2001     Oct. 03, 2001     Oct. 04, 2005     Oct. 02, 2011       1,330         262,000         1,200         2,000         13.73         -         60,137         385,175    
 
 
              Totals                                     4,475,900         899,800         613,500                                            
                  Totals recalculated after share capital increase of December 31, 2002       11,088,489         2,229,143         1,519,870                                            
 
2003
    April 18, 2002     Feb. 28, 2003     Feb. 28, 2007     Feb. 27, 2013       65         1,435,688         655,233         247,532         2.86         -         104,840         1,170,713    
 
2003
    April 18, 2002     June 03, 2003     June 03, 2007     June 02, 2013       1,161         2,266,927         420,441         177,787         3.94         -         2,026,386         1,628,777    
                            Granted conditional upon unrealized ROEs           2,266,929         420,441         177,787                                            
 
 
              Totals                                                                                                      
                  Totals recalculated after share capital increase of January 07, 2004       17,058,033         3,725,259         2,122,975                                            
 
2004
    May 18, 2004     August 25     Aug. 26, 2008     Aug. 25, 2014       171         5,990,000         1,335,000         920,000         1.14         -         450,000         5,540,000    
 
2005
    May 31, 2005     August 31     Sept. 16, 2009     Sept. 16, 2015       219         7,260,000         1,650,000         1,420,000         1.66         -         255,000         7,005,000    
                  Totals at December 31, 2005       30,308,033         6,710,259         4,462,975                             3,603,598         20,712,100    
 
* Volumes recalculated after share capital increase.

Page 152 of 184


 

    The following table presents the stock option plans in favor of the members of the Executive Committee as of December 31, 2005:
                                                 
                                    Potential    
    Options   Options to be                   transaction    
    exercized   exercized   Plan dates   Price (EUR)   volume (EUR)   Exercise period
Denis Kessler1
  None     364,019     Feb. 28, 2003     2.86       1,041,094     Feb. 28, 2007 to Feb. 28, 2013
 
  None     160,169     June 03, 2003     3.94       631,065     June 03, 2007 to June 03, 2013
 
  None     375,000     Aug. 25, 2004     1.14       427,500     Aug. 26, 2008 to Aug. 25, 2014
 
  None     450,000     Sept. 16, 2005     1.66       747,000     Sept. 16, 2009 to Sept. 15, 2015
TOTAL
            1,349,188                                  
 
                                               
Patrick Thourot1
  None     72,804     Feb. 28, 2003     2.86       208,219     Feb. 28, 2007 to Feb. 28, 2013
 
  None     60,064     June 03, 2003     3.94       236,652     June 03, 2007 to June 03, 2013
 
  None     180,000     Aug. 25, 2004     1.14       205,200     Aug. 26 2008 to Aug. 25, 2014
 
  None     200,000     Sept. 16, 2005     1.66       332,000     Sept. 16, 2009 to Sept. 15, 2015
TOTAL
            512,868                                  
 
                                               
Romain Durand
  None     19,809     Sept. 04, 1997     15.03       297,729     Sept. 04, 2002, to Sept. 03, 2007
 
  None     29,713     Sept. 03, 1998     22.72       675,079     Sept. 04, 2003 to Sept. 03, 2003
 
  None     32,188     Sept. 02, 1999     18.58       598,053     Sept. 03, 2004 to 02 Sep. 2009
 
  None     249     May 04, 2000     19.39       4,828     May 05, 2004 to May 03, 2010
 
  None     37,141     Aug. 31, 2000     18.17       674,852     Sept. 01, 2005 to Aug. 30, 2010
 
  None     49,520     Sept. 04, 2001     19.39       960,193     Sept. 04, 2005 to Sept. 03, 2011
 
  None     497     Oct. 03, 2001     13.73       6,824     Oct. 04, 2005 to Oct. 02, 2011
 
  None     43,683     Feb. 28, 2003     2.86       124,933     Feb. 28, 2007 to Feb. 25, 2013
 
  None     40,043     June 03, 2003     3.94       157,770     June 03, 2007 to June 03, 2013
 
  None     180,000     Aug. 25, 2004     1.14       205,200     Aug. 26, 2008 to Aug. 25, 2014
 
  None     200,000     Sept. 16, 2005     1.66       332,000     Sept. 16, 2009 to Sept. 15, 2015
TOTAL
            632,843                                  
 
                                               
Jean-Luc Besson
  None     43,683     Feb. 28, 2003     2.86       124,933     Feb. 28, 2007 to Feb. 28, 2013
 
  None     40,043     June 03, 2003     3.94       157,770     June 03, 2007 to June 03, 2013
 
  None     120,000     Aug. 25, 2004     1.14       136,800     Aug. 26, 2008 to Aug. 25, 2014
 
  None     180,000     Sept. 16, 2005     1.66       298,800     Sept. 16, 2009 to Sept. 15, 2015
TOTAL
            383,726                                  
 
                                               
Marcel Kahn
  None     120,000     Aug. 25, 2004     1.14       136,800     Aug. 26, 2008 to Aug. 25, 2014
 
  None     150,000     Sept. 16, 2005     1.66       249,000     Sept. 16, 2009 to Sept. 15, 2015
TOTAL
            270,000                                  
 
                                               
Victor Peignet
  None     9,905     Sept. 05, 1996     11.7       115,889     Sept. 05, 1997 to Sept. 04, 2006 (30%)
 
                                          Sept. 05, 1998 to Sept. 04, 2006 (30%)
 
                                          Sept. 05, 1999 to Sept. 04, 2006 (40%)
 
  None     12,381     Sept. 04, 1997     15.03       186,086     Sept. 04, 2002 to Sept. 03, 2007
 
  None     9,905     Sept. 03, 1998     22.72       225,042     Sept. 04, 2003 to Sept. 03, 2008
 
  None     12,381     Sept. 02, 1999     18.58       230,039     Sept. 03, 2004 to Sept. 02, 2009
 
  None     249     May 04, 2000     19.39       4,828     May 05, 2004 to May 03, 2010
 
  None     14,857     Aug. 31, 2000     18.17       269,952     Sept. 01, 2005 to Aug. 30, 2010
 
  None     19,809     Sept. 04, 2001     19.39       384,097     Sept. 04, 2005 to Sept. 03, 2011
 
  None     497     Oct. 03, 2001     13.73       6,824     Oct. 04, 2005 to Oct. 02, 2011
 
  None     26,210     Feb. 28, 2003     2.86       74,961     Feb. 28, 2007 to Feb. 28, 2013
 
  None     28,030     June 03, 2003     3.94       110,438     June 03, 2007 to June 03, 2013
 
  None     120,000     Aug. 25, 2004     1.14       136,800     Aug. 26, 2008 to Aug. 25, 2014
 
1  In the event of dismissal or a significant change in the capital stock of the Company that substantially affects their respective responsibilities and makes it difficult for them to pursue their respective activities and the normal exercise of their respective prerogatives, and if their professional relationship is terminated at their request, the Chairman and Chief Executive and/or the Chief Operating Officer shall retain the right to exercise the options allotted to them that have been fully vested within the periods defined by the stock option plan, and shall be entitled to an indemnity, for the options they would be unable to exercise under this plan, to compensate for the loss of the right to exercise the options under the terms of the plan. The amount of this indemnity will be determined by an independent expert using the option valuation method knowns as the “Black & Scholes” method on the date of their respective departures.

Page 153 of 184


 

                                                 
                                    Potential    
    Options   Options to be                   transaction    
    exercized   exercized   Plan dates   Price (EUR)   volume (EUR)   Exercise period
 
  None     200,000     Sept. 16, 2005     1.66       332,000     Sept. 16, 2009 to Sept. 15, 2015
TOTAL
            454,224                                  
 
                                               
Henry Klecan
  None     14,857     Sept. 04, 2001     19.39       288,077     Sept. 04, 2005 to Sept. 03, 2011
 
  None     497     Oct. 03, 2001     13.73       6,824     Oct. 04, 2005 to Oct. 02, 2011
 
  None     11,649     Feb. 28, 2003     2.86       33,316     Feb. 28, 2007 to Feb. 28, 2013
 
  None     16,017     June 03, 2003     3.94       63,107     June 03, 2007 to June 03, 2013
 
  None     120,000     Aug. 25, 2004     1.14       136,800     Aug. 26, 2008 to Aug. 25, 2014
 
  None     150,000     Sept. 16, 2005     1.66       249,000     Sept. 16, 2009 to Sept. 15, 2015
TOTAL
            313,020                                  
Yvan Besnard
  None     17,334     Sept. 04, 1997     15.03       260,530     Sept. 04, 2002 to Sept. 03, 2007
 
  None     17,334     Sept. 03, 1998     22.72       393,828     Sept. 04, 2003 to Sept. 03, 2008
 
  None     17,334     Sept. 02, 1999     18.58       322,066     Sept. 03, 2004 to Sept. 02, 2009
 
  None     249     May 04, 2000     19.39       4,828     May 05, 2004 to Mar. 05, 2010
 
  None     14,857     Aug. 31, 2000     18.17       269,952     Sept. 01, 2005 to Aug. 30, 2010
 
  None     17,334     Sept. 04, 2001     19.39       336,106     Sept. 04, 2005 to Sept. 03, 2011
 
  None     497     Oct. 03, 2001     13.73       6,824     Oct. 04, 2005 to Oct. 02, 2011
 
  None     26,210     Feb. 28, 2003     2.86       74,961     Feb. 28, 2007 to Feb. 28, 2013
 
  None     14,416     June 03, 2003     3,94       56,799     June 03, 2007 to June 03, 2013
 
  None     120,000     Aug. 25, 2004     1.14       136,800     Aug. 26, 2008 to Aug. 25, 2014
 
  None     120,000     Sept. 16, 2005     1.66       199,200     Sept. 16, 2009 to Sept. 15, 2015
TOTAL
            365,565                                  
 
                                               
TOTAL GENERAL
            4,281,434                       13,886,268          
The other group directors and officers were not granted stock options.
Taking into account the results recorded in 2003 and 2004, the stock options from the June 2003 plan with the condition of a 2003 ROE of more than 10% or 2004 ROE of more than 12% were cancelled.
9.10 OTHER STOCK COMPENSATION
On August 25, 2004, the Board of Directors approved, pursuant to the authorization of the May 18, 2004 Shareholders’ Meeting and subsequent to a proposal of the Nomination and Compensation Committee the principle of a stock compensation plan applicable to all employees, directors and officers of the Group. SCOR Group thus decided to grant shares at no cost to all of its employees up to an aggregate volume of 7,140,705 shares, subject to compliance with attendance conditions of the recipient employees of the Group. The shares transferred may be sold by their recipient as of the date the ownership is transferred, determined by the Chairman and Chief Executive Officer to be January 10, 2005.
Distribution from the stock compensation plan intended for group directors, officers and certain senior executives of the Group companies called for the transfer of the securities at two separate times, in equal shares on January 10, 2005 (Tranche A) and on November 10, 2005 (Tranche B), subject to compliance with conditions relating to attendance.
In the context of the transfer that took place on January 10, 2005 (Tranche A), the members of the Executive Committee collected one half of the shares entitled to them under the stock compensation plan.
The French 2005 Finance Act instituted a new incentive tax and company benefits system for free stock distribution, the purpose of which is to promote employee savings. As such, French recipients had the option of forfeiting the transfer of November 10, 2005 (Tranche B), in exchange for which the distribution was increased by 40% and subject to the new incentive arrangement (Plan 2004 – forfeiture – redistribution), under the 2005 redistribution plan approved by the Board of Directors on August 31, 2005 to that effect.
On August 31, 2005, SCOR’s Board of Directors, in accordance with the authority granted to it by the General Shareholders’ Meeting of May 31, 2005 and on the proposal of the Compensation and Nominations Committee, established a new free stock distribution plan, intended for group directors, officers and certain senior executives of the Group’s companies.
The 7,305,000 shares will be transferred in September 2007, subject to compliance with attendance conditions of the employee recipients of the Group, and will be required to be held until September 2009.
The table below presents the free share distribution plan in favor of the members of the Executive Committee dated December 31, 2005:

Page 154 of 184


 

                                         
    Plan   Shares   Price (EUR)   Transaction (EUR)   Date of transfer
Denis Kessler1
  2004 Plan - Tranche A     187,500       1.44       270,000     January 10, 2005
 
  Plan 2004 – Forfeiture - redistribution     262,500                   September 01, 2007
 
  2005 Plan     450,000                   September 01, 2007
TOTAL
            900,000                          
 
                                       
Patrick Thourot1
  2004 Plan - Tranche A     90,000       1.44       129,600     January 10, 2005
 
  2004 Plan – Forfeiture - redistribution     126,000                   September 01, 2007
 
  2005 Plan     200,000                   September 01, 2007
TOTAL
            416,000                          
 
                                       
Romain Durand
  2004 Plan - Tranche A     90,000       1.44       129,600     January 10, 2005
 
  2004 Plan – Tranche B     90,000       1.69       152,100     November 10, 2005
 
  2005 Plan     200,000                   September 01, 2007
TOTAL
            380,000                          
 
                                       
Jean-Luc Besson
  2004 Plan - Tranche A     75,000       1.44       108,000     January 10, 2005
 
  2004 Plan – Tranche B     75,000       1.69       126,750     November 10, 2005
 
  2005 Plan     180,000                   September 01, 2007
TOTAL
            330,000                          
 
                                       
Marcel Kahn
  2004 Plan - Tranche A     75,000       1.44       108,000     January 10, 2005
 
  2004 Plan – Forfeiture - redistribution     105,000                   September 01, 2007
 
  2005 Plan     150,000                   September 01, 2007
TOTAL
            330,000                          
 
                                       
Victor Peignet
  2004 Plan - Tranche A     75,000       1.44       108,000     January 10, 2005
 
  2004 Plan – Forfeiture - redistribution     105,000                   September 01, 2007
 
  2005 Plan     200,000                   September 01, 2007
TOTAL
            380,000                          
 
                                       
Henry Klecan
  2004 Plan - Tranche A     65,576       1.44       94,429     January 10, 2005
 
  2004 Plan – Tranche B     65,576       1.69       110,823     November 10, 2005
 
  2005 Plan     150,000                   September 01, 2007
TOTAL
            281,152                          
 
                                       
Yvan Besnard
  2004 Plan - Tranche A     51,842       1.44       74,652     January 10, 2005
 
  2004 Plan – Forfeiture - redistribution     72,579                   September 01, 2007
 
  2005 Plan     120,000                   September 01, 2007
 
                                       
TOTAL
            244,421                          
 
                                       
TOTALGENERAL
            3,261,573                          
 
1  In the event of dismissal or a significant change in the capital stock of the Company that substantially affects their respective responsibilities and makes it difficult for them to pursue their respective activities and the normal exercise of their respective prerogatives, and if their professional relationship is terminated at their request, the Chairman and Chief Executive and/or the Chief Operating Officer shall be entitled to an indemnity, for the bonus shares that would have been allotted to them and which they could not receive, to compensate for the loss of the right to the shares. The amount of this loss shall be equivalent to the produce of the number of shares in question multiplied by the average price of the SCOR share on the date of their respective departures.

Page 155 of 184


 

The other group directors and officers did not receive any no-cost shares.
9.11 Stock options granted to the top ten non-officer employees and exercized by them during fiscal year 2005
A total of 920,000 stock options were granted to the top ten non-officer employees under the August 25, 2004 plan. They received 1,290,000 options from the August 25, 2005 plan.
No options were exercized in 2003, 2004 and 2005.
No options have been granted by a related company as defined by article 225-180 of the French Commercial Code.
                                     
 
                                 
                               
  Stock options granted to top ten non-officer     Number of               Expiration        
  employee recipients and options exercized by them     options     Price     dates     Plan  
 
Options granted during the fiscal year by the issuer and by any company included in the option distribution scope to ten employees of the issuer and of any company included in this scope, (aggregate information)
      1,420,000         1.66       Sept. 16, 2009     Sept. 16, 2005  
 
Options held on the issuer and on the companies referred to previously and exercized during the fiscal year by the ten employees of the issuer of these companies receiving the largest option distributions (aggregate information)
      N/A         N/A       N/A     N/A  
 
9.12 Number of shares held by directors and executive officers at December 31, 2005
Article 10 (“Administration”) of SCOR’s bylaws requires that directors own at least one share of the Company during the term of their directorship.
               
 
  Group directors and officers     Number of shares    
 
Mr. Carlo Acutis
      60,000    
 
Mrs. Michèle Aronvald
      948    
 
Mr. Antonio Borges
      1    
 
Mr. Allan Chapin
      1,000    
 
Mr. Daniel Havis
      7,602    
 
Mr. Denis Kessler
      319,920    
 
Mr. Yvon Lamontagne
      4,460    
 
Mr. le Pas de Sécheval
      500    
 
Mr. Daniel Lebègue
      100    
 
Mr. André Lévy-Lang
      150,000    
 
Mr. Herbert Schimetschek
      6    
 
Mr. Jean-Claude Seys
      21,050    
 
Mr. Jean Simonnet
      2,736    
 
Mr. Claude Tendil
      1,506    
 
Mr. Patrick Thourot
      91,530    
 
Mr. Daniel Valot
      100    
 
Non-Voting Director
           
 
Mr. Georges Chodron de Courcel
      17,836    
 
Total
      679,295    
 

Page 156 of 184


 

     
9.13   Report of the Chairman of the Board of Directors on the terms and conditions for preparing and organizing the work of the Board of Directors and on internal control procedures in compliance with Article L.225-37 of the French Commercial Code
As provided in Article L.225-37 of the French Commercial Code, the purpose of this Report is to set forth the terms and conditions for preparation of organizing and holding the Meetings of the Board of Directors, as well as the internal control procedures established by the Company.
I- Terms and Conditions for Preparing and Organizing the Work of the Board of Directors
In accordance with the recommendations of Mr. Chapin made in connection with his evaluation of the performance of the Board of Directors in 2003, the Board of Directors has adopted the following principles, among others:
  the presence on the Board of Directors of a majority of independent Directors, in accordance with the standards adopted by the Board of Directors. Pursuant to this criteria, eleven out of the fifteen members of the Board of Directors are independent, i.e., Messrs. Acutis, Borges, Chapin, Havis, Lamontagne, Lebègue, Lévy-Lang, Schimetschek, Simonnet, Tendil, and Valot;
  diversity of abilities. In addition to two experts from the insurance and reinsurance industries, the Board includes members from financial services and industry;
  greater internationalization of the Board, with Italian, Portuguese, Austrian, Canadian, and U.S. Directors, having broad international experience;
  improvement in exchanges of information with the Boards of Directors of subsidiaries;
  reorganization of the Board’s Committees; and
  an in-depth evaluation, every three years, of the Board’s operations and a review every year in between.
Following the above-mentioned recommendations, Mr. Levy-Lang conducted an evaluation of the performance of the Board for 2004. The summary of the evaluation questionnaires filled out by the directors and the comments of Mr. Levy-Lang were given to the Board during its March 23, 2005 meeting.
The list of members of the Board of Directors to date appears in the following table:
                     
            Date of      
Name   Age*   appointment   End of term
Denis Kessler
    53     November 4, 02     2007  
Carlo Acutis
    67     May 15, 03     2009  
Michèle Aronvald
    47     August 30, 01     2006  
Antonio Borges
    56     May 15, 03     2007  
Allan Chapin
    64     May 12, 97 (2)     2011  
Daniel Havis
    50     November 18, 96 (2)     2011  
Yvon Lamontagne
    65     May 15, 03     2007  
Daniel Lebègue
    62     May 15, 03     2009  
Helman Le Pas de Sécheval (1)
    39     November 3, 04     2009  
André Lévy-Lang
    68     May 15, 03     2009  
Herbert Schimetschek
    67     May 15, 03     2007  
Jean-Claude Seys
    67     May 15, 03     2009  
Jean Simonnet
    69     March 2, 99 (2)     2011  
Claude Tendil
    60     May 15, 03     2007  
Daniel Valot
    61     May 15, 03     2007  
(1) Mr. Helman le Pas de Sécheval was co-opted as director in replacement of Mr. Jean Baligand by the Board of Directors on November 3, 2004 and his appointment was approved by the General Shareholders’ Meeting of May 31, 2005
(2) Office renewed on May 31, 2005
* At December 31, 2005
Mr. Georges Chodron de Courcel, 55 years old, Chief Operating Officer of BNP-Paribas, has held the position of Non-voting Director since May 15, 2003. His term was renewed until 2007 by the General Shareholders’ Meeting of May 31, 2005. Mr. le Pas de Sécheval held the position of Non-voting Director until November 3, 2004 and has not been replaced in this position.
At the Board Meeting held on March 31, 2004, an interim assessment was made of the Board’s organization and operation. A new set of by-laws was adopted to formalize and strengthen the strategic decisions made. The main provisions of these by-laws are set out below:
Mission of the Board of Directors

Page 157 of 184


 

Pursuant to these by-laws, the Board of Directors determines the policies of the Company’s businesses, oversees their implementation and supervises management’s administration. The Board meets at least 4 times a year. In accordance with legal provisions, it approves the financial statements, proposes dividends, and makes investment and financial policy decisions. The Board also determines the amount and the nature of the sureties, securities and guarantees that can be granted by the Chief Executive Officer on behalf of the Company.
Meetings of the Board of Directors
At least five days before any meeting of the Board of Directors, the Chairman and Chief Executive Officer is required to submit a work folder to the Directors including all information that will allow them to participate in the discussions listed on the agenda in a discerning and efficient manner. Furthermore, outside of Board meetings, the Chairman and Chief Executive Officer is required to submit to the Directors any information and documents necessary to complete their duties, and the Directors may submit requests for information to the Chairman and Chief Executive Officer. In addition, Directors may ask the Chairman and Chief Executive Officer to invite the principal top executives of the Company to attend Board meetings.
Meetings held by videoconference or telecommunication
At the Board of Directors meeting held on November 2, 2005, the set of by-laws was amended to allow the Board to hold its meetings via means of telecommunication in accordance with the provisions of the Act of July 26, 2005. As such, the Board of Directors may from now on hold meetings either via videoconferencing or telecommunication, under the conditions established by regulations in effect.
Independence of Directors
The idea of the independence of Directors is now analyzed on the basis of the following principal criteria. Independent Directors must not:
  receive a salary or hold an executive position within SCOR and must not have done so during the previous five years;
  have received from SCOR compensation greater than 100,000 during the five previous years, except for directors’ fees,
  be an officer in a company in which SCOR directly or indirectly is a director or in which an employee has been designated as such or in which an officer of SCOR (currently or within the last five years) is a director;
  be a significant client, supplier, investment banker, commercial banker of SCOR or of its Group or for which SCOR or its Group represents a significant share of the business. A significant share is a contribution to the business equal to the lesser of the following two amounts: more than 2% of the Company’s consolidated premium income, or an amount greater than 100 million,
  have a close family relationship with an officer of the Company;
  have been an auditor of the company during the previous five years;
  have been a Director of SCOR for more than twelve years,
  represent a shareholder of the Company owning more than 5% of the share capital or voting rights.
Rights and obligations of Directors
Directors may receive training at their request on the specific nature of the Company, its business lines and its business sector. They agree to regularly attend meetings of the Board, Committees of which they may be members, and General Shareholders’ meetings. Lastly, they are obligated to express their opposition when they believe that a decision of the Board of Directors is likely to be harmful to the Company.
Loyalty and conflict of interest
The by-laws prohibit Directors from accepting benefits from the Company or from the Group that are likely to place their independence in question, and require them to dismiss any pressure from other Directors, specific groups of shareholders, creditors, suppliers or other third parties. Directors agree to submit to the Board of Directors any agreement falling under the purview of Article L. 226-38 of the French Commercial Code. In the event of a conflict of interest, the Director will fully inform the Board in advance. He is required to abstain from participating in any Board discussions.
Accumulation of directorships
The set of by-laws requires that candidates for Director inform the Board of the directorships that they hold, as the Board has the duty to ensure compliance with the rules on accumulation of directorships. Once appointed, Directors must inform the Board of any appointment as a company officer within a period of five days following their appointment. Lastly, Directors must inform the Board within a period of one year following the end of the fiscal year of the list of directorships they held during that fiscal year.
Limitations and restrictions on trading SCOR securities
The by-laws set out the principal recommendations of the market authorities with regard to Directors trading the securities of their company.
First and foremost, the by-laws set out the legal and regulatory provisions requiring confidentiality with regard to privileged information of which Directors could have knowledge while performing their functions.
Then, the by-laws require Directors to register as owners of SCOR equities that they themselves or their un-emancipated minor children are holding at the time they enter office or those acquired subsequently. In addition, the by-laws lay down certain restrictions on trading SCOR securities:

Page 158 of 184


 

-   first, it is forbidden to trade in SCOR securities while in possession of information which, when made public, is likely to have an impact on the share price. This restriction remains in effect two days after this information has been made public by a press release;
 
-   on the other hand, it is forbidden to directly or indirectly conduct any transaction with regard to the Company’s securities during certain sensitive periods as notified to them by the Company or during any period preceding an important event affecting the Company and likely to influence its market price.
Lastly, Directors are required to declare to SCOR all transactions conducted with regard to the Company’s securities, directly or by an intermediary, on their behalf or on behalf of a third party, by their spouse, or by a third party holding a power of attorney.
During 2005, the Board of Directors met eight times, on March 23, April 12, May 9, May 31 (morning), May 31 (afternoon), June 14, August 31 and November 2.
The following table presents the attendance at Board meetings of members of the Board of Directors during 2005:
     
Members of the Board   Attendance rate (in %)
Denis Kessler
  100
Carlo Acutis
  50
Michèle Aronvald
  87.5
Antonio Borgès
  87.5
Allan Chapin
  100
Daniel Havis
  100
Yvon Lamontagne
  100
Daniel Lebègue
  100
Helman Le Pas de Sécheval
  50
André Lévy-Lang
  75
Herbert Schimetschek
  50
Jean-Claude Seys
  62.5
Jean Simonnet
  87.5
Claude Tendil
  87.5
Daniel Valot
  87.5
Georges Chodron de Courcel
  75
At the Board meeting held on May 15, 2003, the Board of Directors created four Committees in charge of preparing Board meeting discussions and making recommendations in specific areas.
The Strategy Committee consists of Denis Kessler, Chairman, Allan Chapin*, Daniel Lebègue*, Helman le Pas de Sécheval1, André Lévy-Lang*, Jean-Claude Seys, Claude Tendil* and Daniel Valot*. According to the by-laws, this Committee is comprised of six to ten members designated by the Board of Directors and chosen among the Directors and Non-voting Directors. The length of their term coincides with that of their term as Director or Non-voting Director.
This Committee’s mission is to study the Group’s development strategies and to examine any acquisition or disposal plan in an amount in excess of 100 million euros.
The Chairman of the Committee may call any individual to attend who is likely to shed relevant light on the clear understanding of a given point, this person’s presence and the information shall be limited to an agenda item concerning him. The Chairman of the Committee must exclude the non-independent members of the Committee from its discussions to examine points likely to pose an ethical problem or conflict of interest.
During 2005, the Strategy Committee met two times.
The following table presents the attendance at Strategy Committee meetings of the members of the Strategy Committee during 2005:
     
Members of the Committee   Attendance rate (in %)
Denis Kessler
  100
Allan Chapin
  100
Daniel Lebègue
  50
Helman Le Pas de Sécheval
  100
André Lévy-Lang
  50
Jean-Claude Seys
  100
Claude Tendil
  50
Daniel Valot
  100
The Accounts and Audit Committee consists of Daniel Lebègue*, Chairman, André Lévy-Lang*, Antonio Borges*, and Helman le Pas de Sécheval***. According to the by-laws, it is comprised of three to five members designated by the Board of Directors and chosen among the Directors and Non-voting Directors. The length of their term coincides with that of their term as Director or Non-voting Director.
 
*   Independent Director.
 
1   Mr. le Pas de Sécheval was appointed as a member of the Strategy Committee on November 3, 2005, in replacement of Mr. Jean Baligand, who resigned on August 18, 2004.

Page 159 of 184


 

This Committee’s task is to review the soundness of the Group’s financial condition, compliance with internal procedures, as well as audits and reviews made by the statutory auditors and internal control management.
The Accounts and Audit Committee has adopted a set of by-laws setting forth two essential tasks:
-      Accounting duties, notably with the analysis of periodic financial documents, examination of the relevance of the choices and proper application of accounting methods, examination of the accounting treatment of any significant transactions, examination of the scope of consolidation, examination of off-balance sheet commitments, steering the selection and compensation of statutory auditors, oversight of any accounting and financial reporting documents before they are made public; the Committee may consult with the Group’s chief financial and accounting officers, the Chief Internal Auditor, and external auditors on these subjects.
-      Ethical and internal control responsibilities. In this connection, the Accounts and Audit Committee is responsible for ensuring that internal procedures relating to collection and verification of data make it possible to guarantee the quality and reliability of SCOR’s financial statements. The Accounts and Audit Committee is also responsible for reviewing agreements with interested parties (“conventions réglementées”), analyzing and responding to questions from employees relating to internal controls, preparing financial statements, and treatment of internal accounting books and records.
The Chairman of the Committee may call any individual to attend an Accounts and Audit Committee meeting who is likely to shed relevant light on the clear understanding of a given point, this person’s presence and the information shall be limited to an agenda item concerning him. The Chairman of the Committee must exclude the non-independent members of the Committee from its discussions to examine points likely to pose an ethical problem or conflict of interest.
***     Me. le Pas de Sécheval is a non-voting member of the Accounts and Audit Committee.
The 2002 U.S. Sarbanes Oxley Act requires audit committees of registered companies in the U.S. to be composed exclusively of independent directors (as defined in the U.S. Sarbanes Oxley Act) and that their members shall only be responsible for the election of external accountants. The by-laws of SCOR’s Accounts and Audit Committee, approved by the Board of Directors on March 18, 2005, set out that all members of the Accounts and Audit Committee will be chosen among the independent Directors, subject to arrangements set out by applicable regulations.
During its six meetings in 2005, the Accounts and Audit Committee primarily discussed the following matters: Financial conclusion of IRP; progress and principal challenges relating to IFRS; obligations and progress relating to Sarbanes Oxley; 2005 budget and pre-approval of the assignments of the external auditors; audit of French GAAP parent company and consolidated financial statements at December 31, 2004; U.S. GAAP financial statements at December 31, 2004 and September 30, 2004; 2005 Group budget; compliance of the Committee’s by-laws with the Sarbanes-Oxley Act; agreement on the consolidation of SCOR – SCOR VIE resources; financial consequences of the exit of IRP’s minority interest; considerations on the organization of managing SCOR’s assets; IFRS financial statements at March 31, 2005; consolidated financial results of the first half of 2005; 2005 Audit Plan; Auditors’ Report; consolidated financial results at September 30, 2005; the Group’s exposure to and protection from natural catastrophes in 2005 and outlooks for 2006; certification of the CRP financial statements in 2004.
The following table presents the attendance at the Accounts and Audit Committee meetings during 2005:
     
Members of the Committee   Attendance rate (in %)
Daniel Lebègue
  100
Antonio Borges
  100
Helman Le Pas de Sécheval
  83
André Lévy-Lang
  83
The Compensations and Nominations committee comprises Allan Chapin*, Chairman, André Lévy-Lang* and Georges Chodron de Courcel**. According to the by-laws, it is comprised of three to five members designated by the Board of Directors and chosen among the Directors and Non-voting Directors. The majority of the members must be chosen among the independent Directors. The Chairman of the Board of Directors, the Chief Executive Officer [sic] The length of their term coincides with that of their term as Director or Non-voting Director.
This Committee’s tasks are to make recommendations on the terms and conditions of compensation for the Group’s officers and senior managers, retirement, and award of stock options and to make proposals relating to membership on and organization of the Board of Directors and its Committees.
Meeting four times in 2005, this Committee issued opinions on the implementation of stock option plans for all employees and senior managers of the Group, option plans and bonus plans to be awarded to senior managers of SCOR.
The following table presents the attendance of the members at meetings of the Compensation and Nominations Committee during 2005:
     
Members of the Committee   Attendance rate (in %)
Allan Chapin
  100
André Lévy-Lang
  100
 
*   Independent Director
 
**   Non-voting Director

Page 160 of 184


 

     
Georges Chodron de Courcel
  100
The Risks Committee consisted of Carlo Acutis*, Antonio Borges*, Daniel Havis*, Yvon Lamontagne*, Daniel Lebègue*, Herbert Schimetschek*, Jean Simonnet*, Claude Tendil*, Georges Chodron de Courcel** and Helman le Pas de Sécheval.
Its mission was to identify the major risks to which the Group was exposed on both the assets and liabilities sides, and to ensure that means had been set up to monitor and manage these risks. It scrutinized the main technical and financial risks to which the Group was exposed.
The Risks Committee did not meet in 2004 because all of the matters it would have acted upon were acted upon by the full board or the Audit and Accounts Committee. As a result, on March 23, 2005, the Board of Directors decided to disband the Risk Committee and to transfer the tasks of the Risk Committee to other relevant Group Committees.
II- Limitations on the Authority of the Chief Executive Officer
As provided under Article L 225-51-1 of the French Commercial Code and Article 15, as amended, of the by-laws (“General Management”), the Board of Directors, during its meeting held on April 18, 2002, decided that the Company’s general management would be ensured by a Chairman of the Board of Directors with the title of Chairman and Chief Executive Officer.
III- Internal control procedures
SCOR’s objectives
The purposes of these procedures are:
-      first, to ensure that management actions, or the conduct of transactions, as well as the conduct of employees are consistent with the policies given to the Company’s businesses by management, with applicable laws and regulations, and with the Company’s internal values, standards, and rules;
-      second, to verify that accounting, financial, and management information provided to SCOR’s corporate governance bodies accurately reflects the conduct of the Company’s operations and its financial condition.
The purpose of the internal control system is to prevent and manage all of the risks resulting from the Company’s business, errors, or fraud, in particular in the area of accounting and finance. Like any internal control system, it cannot, however, absolutely guarantee that such risks will be totally eliminated. Among the various limitations inherent in the effectiveness of internal controls relating to the preparation of financial documents, those involving decision-making errors based on human judgment are particularly high in a Group like SCOR. In fact, accounting data is subject to numerous estimations. The internal control system is the responsibility of the Group’s General Management.
The Group’s internal control relating to the preparation of financial and accounting data has been evolving since 2003 based on the COSO reference document. The three general objectives sought through this frame of reference are to ultimately achieve better operating efficiency and protection of assets, ensure compliance with applicable laws, and disclosure of reliable financial statements and statistical information. SCOR focused on complying with the internal control system relating to the reliability of financial information of the COSO reference document. The use of this reference requires us to cover the five components set forth by the COSO, i.e., define the control environment, evaluate risks, survey and formalize control activities, present the process of information and communication, ensure supervision of internal controls.
This report was prepared with the contribution of the Internal Audit Department, the Office of the Company Secretary (Secrétariat Général) and the Finance Department. It was presented to the Audit Committee and to the Board of Directors.
Concise description of the controls implemented
a) General Organization of the Participants Involved in the System of Internal Control
General Organization:
SCOR Group consists of SCOR and its subsidiaries, branches, and representation offices throughout the World. SCOR, the registered office of which is in Paris, has the following responsibilities:
  holding company,
 
  operating company for financial management and various reinsurance operations, the business of which is located in Paris,
 
  operating entity.
These operating responsibilities cover a broad field and relate to all of SCOR’s operations. They involve the Group’s Risk Control Department (Direction du Contrôle des Risques Groupe), Finance and Accounting Department (Direction Financière), Management Information Systems Department (Direction des Systèmes d’Information), Office of the Company Secretary and Legal Department (Secrétariat Général et Direction des Affaires Juridiques Groupe), Human Resources Department (Direction des Ressources Humaines), Public Affairs Department (Direction des Affaires Publiques), and the Internal Audit Department (Direction de l’Audit Interne).

Page 161 of 184


 

Following a reorganization completed in July 2005, the Group Loss Department (Direction des Sinistres Groupe) was consolidated with the Non-Life business segment, comprising the two former business segments: Non-Life treaties and facultatives in large corporate accounts (see comments below). In the context of the New SCOR plan, some reinsurance property and casualty business activity in France and overseas will be contributed to SCOR Global P&C, subject to approval by the SCOR’s Extraordinary Shareholders’ Meeting on May 16, 2006. SCOR Global P&C will thus become the subsidiary specializing in the Group’s Non-Life reinsurance business.
With regard to the Finance and Accounting Department, it includes the Planning, Budgets, and Results Department (PBR), as well as the Financial Communications, Capital Adequacy & Ratings and the Treasury and Asset Management Departments.
The Group Risk Control Department includes the Group Actuarial Department (Direction de l’Actuariat Groupe), the Group Sharing Department (Direction des Rétrocessions Groupe), and the Catastrophic Risk Control Department (Contrôle des Risques Catastrophiques), and the Non-Life Group Technical Department (Direction Technique Groupe Non Vie).
SCOR Group’s reinsurance business was organized until June 30, 2005 around three business segments reporting directly to the Chief Operating Officer. Since July 1, 2005 two business segments, Non-Life treaties (including Credit-Sureties business) and facultative business in Large Corporate Accounts (Business Solutions), were merged in the SCOR Global P&C business segment. The scope of the second business segment, Life Reinsurance (SCOR VIE), did not change.
In connection with the internal procedures adopted by SCOR, the subsidiaries manage one or more businesses in the areas that may fall within one or more business segments. Nevertheless, after the finalization of SCOR VIE in 2003, a legal and operational distinction is ensured by the creation of branch offices covering the Life Reinsurance business outside France falling directly under the responsibility of SCOR VIE.

Page 162 of 184


 

Participants in Internal Controls
(FLOW CHART)

Page 163 of 184


 

As summarized in the preceding diagram, the SCOR Group’s internal control system is organized as follows:
  Operating companies located in Paris and subsidiaries provide an initial level of control of all operations under their organizational responsibility,
 
  The Reinsurance, Investment and Treasury Management, and Group operating departments provide a second level of control in their respective areas over transactions and operations conducted by the operating entities,
 
  The Internal Audit Department provides a third level of control by checking the effectiveness and relevance of the internal control mechanisms of the first two levels in all areas and for all of the Group’s French and non-French companies.
Within this environment, control responsibilities are exercized as shown below by the following principal participants:
  The Board of Directors relies on various Board Committees, in particular the Accounts and Audit Committee, to exercise its control responsibility over the policies it has set for the Company.
 
  The Group’s operating Departments or areas having control responsibility have the task of defining and overseeing the implementation of rules for which they are responsible that apply to all of the Group’s entities. Thus:
  o   The Chief Actuary (Group Actuarial Department), reports directly to the Chief Risk Officer, who, in turn, reports to the Chairman and Chief Executive Officer, conducts centralized control of the methods, tools, and results of calculations of claims reserves funding for all non-life operations. His/her task is to implement standardized methods for funding claims reserves for the entire Group, except for life insurance operations, and to ensure the consistency of the Group’s reserve policies, working with internal actuaries and, when appropriate, external actuaries. the Chief Risk Officer, assisted by the Chief Actuary, supervises the establishment of reserves for all subsidiaries and branches and reports to the Accounts and Audit Committee of the Board of Directors,
 
  o   the Risk Sharing and Control of Catastrophic Risks Department, reporting to the Chief Risk Officer, prepares the plan of internal and external risk-sharing for non-life businesses and implements it. This Department is responsible for its proper application and monitoring the solvency of co-underwriters,
 
  o   control of the Group’s information systems is provided by the Group Management Information Systems Department, which has a “Security” manager. This Department reports to the Chief Operating Officer.
 
  o   the Strategic Planning, Budgeting, and Results Department ( (PBR), reporting to the Chief Financial Officer, is responsible for financial and accounting reporting and for verification and supervision of aggregate monthly and consolidated quarterly results of operations and the preparation of financial statements for the French companies and the consolidated financial statements under IFRS and U.S. GAAP.
 
  o   the control of all financial information intended for the market, investors, financial analysts, Security Committees of brokers and rating agencies falls under the responsibility of the Financial Communication and Capital Adequacy and Ratings Departments, reporting to the Chief Financial Officer.
  The general management of the two reinsurance business segments, reporting to the Chairman and Chief Executive Officer and to the Chief Operating Officer, jointly with the Group Risk Control Department, reporting to the Chairman and Chief Executive Officer, are responsible for drafting common guidelines for underwriting policies throughout the world within their areas of responsibility and overseeing their proper application. The reinsurance business segments are also responsible for defining loss management policy.
 
  The Treasury and Asset Management Department, within the Finance and Accounting Department, manages the assets of SCOR and of its European and Asian subsidiaries. It supervises application of the investment strategy decided by the Group’s General Management and Chief Financial Officer, is responsible for reporting on investments for the entire Group, and reviews all off-balance sheet commitments.
 
  The subsidiaries, as well as the Paris operating units for selling insurance and their branches or offices, must implement rules defined by the reinsurance business segments, the Treasury and Asset Management Department, and the operating departments. The subsidiaries implement all first-level controls relating to business management and ensure compliance with local regulatory, tax, and accounting requirements.
 
  The Internal Audit Department, reporting to the Chairman and Chief Executive Officer, has the primary responsibilities below:
  -   inform General Management and the operating units and functional departments of operating irregularities through implementation of an annual audit plan adopted by the Accounts and Audit Committee,
 
  -   advise managers of the operating companies on the preparation of their internal control plans and to work with them on implementation of the procedures and tools necessary for effective risk control,
 
  -   supervise relevance and compliance by the operating units and functional departments with internal control procedures.
 
      Since the internal control formalization plan is managed by the Internal Audit Department, numerous resources of this Department have been dedicated to this plan.
 
      The Chief Internal Auditor reports to the Accounts and Audit Committee of the Board of Directors.
b) Summary Information on Internal Control Procedures Implemented by SCOR

Page 164 of 184


 

The practical steps for implementing the strategy decided by the Board of Directors, the underwriting policy, the financial policy, the risk sharing and claims management policy, are defined by the Group’s General Management. Periodic meetings of general managers of the subsidiaries, reinsurance business segments, and operating departments make it possible to supervise and verify their proper application. Furthermore, the parent company is systematically present in the governance bodies of its subsidiaries.
A detailed analysis and charting of risks was made by SCOR Group in 2003 for Paris, and then broadened in 2004 to include all Group subsidiaries. This charting was supplemented where applicable based on detailed analyses of the operational processes conducted in 2005. SCOR’s risks and control procedures are listed and organized in the following business areas:
  issuance and management of reinsurance policies and loss management,
  accounting management (see c) below),
  asset management,
  “support” functions.
A monitoring tool linking risks to controls was implemented in 2005. This tool first covers risks that may place the reliability of financial data in question.
  The management and control procedures relating to the underwriting and management of reinsurance policies and loss management are defined by each business segment and apply to all underwriting departments, regardless of their location. The following steps strengthen internal controls in this area:
  o   SCOR uses a model for determining financial capital managed by the Group Risk Control Department, which is necessary to implement its underwriting policy. Financial capital is allocated to each reinsurance business segment and constitutes the reference for deciding and verifying the profitability expected for each of them;
 
  o   underwriting plans, by business segment, are approved annually by the Group’s General Management;
 
  o   operating budgets are prepared annually;
 
  o   a quarterly review of technical results by market/subsidiary is carried out and makes it possible to know technical results by underwriting period; The formalization of this review was reinforced in 2005 through meetings referred to as FAO and QBR (Quarterly Business Review) meetings;
 
  o   underwriting guidelines, defined by the Group Risk Control Department, or reinsurance business segments, specify the underwriting capabilities delegated to each entity, as well as the underwriting rules to be followed. Cases that go beyond the framework so defined are subject to special authorization procedures. These cases are examined by the Group Technical Department and/or the Technical Department of SCOR Global P&C for the Non-Life Reinsurance business segment, by the Underwriting Committee or the market manager for the SCOR VIE business segment. The Group Risk Control Department or the reinsurance business segments update the underwriting guidelines concerning pricing methods and tools;
 
  o   the definition of a global loss management policy for all of the cases falls under the responsibility of the SCOR Global P&C business segment, and a major loss management policy is provided by SCOR Global P&C’s Losses and Commutations Department. A SCOR Global P&C Major Loss Committee makes it possible to be informed quickly of major losses. In addition, audits of client loss departments are conducted by loss experts (adjusters) of the major SCOR companies, With regard to the SCOR VIE business segment, management of losses presenting a risk of disputed claims was overseen by this business segment’s Strategy Department until December 2005. Since that date, it has been handled by the Market Departments in question and overseen by SCOR VIE’s Underwriting Department;
 
  o   aggregation of catastrophic risks is monitored by each of the reinsurance business segments and verified by the Risk Sharing and Underwriting Department and the Catastrophic Risk Verification function within the Group Risk Control Department using various methods and tools. The principal earthquakes risks are managed by a specific tool based on the Group’s reinsurance management information system. As for storm risks, they are managed with a commercial tool (Eqecat) in the areas considered the most exposed;
 
  o   the risks specific to the management of policies are subject to audits and verifications at the level of the subsidiaries and branches based on the use of a system common to the Group and including multiple automatic controls; Formalized and systematic review systems have been implemented since 2005 and numerous control tools have been developed by the Management Information Systems Department;
 
  o   a procedure specific to Life reinsurance has, furthermore, been installed for the purpose of combating money laundering; it falls under the responsibility of the Fraud Prevention and Security Department, which itself reports to SCOR VIE’s General Management.
  Relating to asset management:
  o   investment guidelines are established and verified annually by SCOR’s General Management or that of each of its subsidiaries for the financial assets recorded on the balance sheet of the company in question. These guidelines are applied to both the asset management teams based in Paris and the management delegated to an external service provider for our North American companies;

Page 165 of 184


 

o   investment decisions are made during Investment Committee meetings. Such meetings decide on the options to be followed regarding the type of investments and to manage market risks (interest rates, exchange rate fluctuations, counterparties) and options regarding asset/liability management;
 
o   monthly reporting of operations allows tracking of changes in assets under management;
 
o   regular tracking of financial flows and the Group’s cash flow situation is centralized by the Treasury and Asset Management Department; othe systems used allow oversight of transactions in publicly traded securities (audit trail, valuation of securities);
  the “support” functions include both budgeting-forecasting activities and those relating to disclosure of non-financial information, plus management information systems, human resources, general services, and legal matters. Among these areas:
  o   the area of information systems is crucially important for SCOR, which, since 1995, has instituted and updated a worldwide information system including underwriting operations, accounting (technical, general, consolidated), financial administration, marketing (creation of a data base of SCOR clients). A Group manager is specifically responsible for all management information security matters. Periodic audits of computer and management information security procedures are conducted. An IT contingency plan has been established, including an emergency and back-up center located outside of SCOR’s headquarters. In 2005, SCOR improved its control procedures by basing them on the COBIT reference documents (“Control objectives for information and technology”) to cover risks, listed in the 12 major processes of COBIT, relating to the development of programs, changes in programs, and operation and access to data programs;
 
  o   the budget control system is organized as follows: an orientation letter is sent by General Management to each unit setting forth the general guidelines to be followed under the strategy adopted for the Group. Forecast validation meetings then take place involving the managers of the Group companies, General Management and the PBR Department, which is in charge of drafting a validation report. This Department is also responsible for verifying the consistency of the assumptions used, accounting items monitored, the proper use of budget worksheets, and the application of the schedule decided upon;
 
  o   regarding SCOR’s offices, very demanding regulations applicable to high-rise buildings require periodic verifications and audits, conducted either internally or by outside service providers;
 
  o   the Group’s Office of the Company Secretary – Legal Department provides a control function at various levels. It is especially responsible for ensuring compliance, both with applicable laws and regulations, and with internal rules, decisions, commitments, practices and policies of SCOR. This task particularly affects the legal organization of the Group’s companies, the making of agreements, and supervision of major litigation.
In addition, SCOR has adopted:
  o   since 1996, a Code of Ethics sent to all employees. This Code sets forth the Group’s fundamental values and principles and is a guide for resolving issues of ethics and law with which an employee may be confronted. It covers, among other things, business confidentiality, use of confidential and privileged information, financial disclosure, relations with our clients and our competitors, and conflicts of interest;
 
  o   since April 2003, an Audit Charter, setting forth the role, scope, principles and methods of operation of the Internal Audit Department and stating the responsibilities of the Group’s operating and functional units in controlling and supervising their operations.
 
  o   since July 2004, a Data Management Charter that sets forth the importance of computer data for SCOR and establishes the basis for using information technology resources. It especially sets forth the applicable security measures and the legal considerations involved in using information technology resources. The other purposes of this Charter are also to avoid misuse of professional and personal information and guarantee compliance with the confidentiality of said information.
These documents are available on SCOR’s Intranet.

Page 166 of 184


 

c) Internal Controls Relating to Preparation of SCOR’s Financial and Accounting Information
(FLOW CHART)

Page 167 of 184


 

The accounting and finance function reports to the Chief Financial Officer, who manages all the departments providing an overall view of the Group’s technical and financial results, oversight of its asset management policy, and the means for improving matching of the Group’s assets and liabilities, as well as maximizing cash flow management. The Chief Financial Officer is also responsible for financial disclosure and investor relations, as well as relationships with rating agencies and broker Security Committees.
The Chief Financial Officer, however, does not exercise direct control over all accounting information systems and relies on the finance and accounting departments of each subsidiary, or the technical accounting services in Paris and the various reinsurance business segments.
SCOR’s general accounting department in Paris relies on various auxiliary accounting functions:
  -   technical reinsurance accounting: premiums, losses, commissions, technical reserves,
 
  -   accounting for securities assets: securities, bank accounts, financial revenues and charges,
 
  -   auxiliary cash flow accounting,
 
  -   accounting for real estate assets,
 
  -   accounting for general and administrative expenses.
These auxiliary accounting functions do not report to the PBR Vice President, but are managed by the technical accounting services located in Paris, or in the subsidiaries, or in the Treasury and Asset Management Department (Direction des Placements et Trésorerie).
  Regarding reinsurance accounting services, several regular controls are conducted (automatic and systematic, or for consistency, or by testing) by the technical accounting groups that are located in Paris and in the subsidiaries by using both Group techniques and control formats developed either at the Group level or specifically. Quarterly inventories are also specifically verified. At the time of an inventory, the calculation of technical reserves (including IBNRs), largely based on contractual and accounting information, the relevance of which is verified at the source, has a significant impact on the balance sheet and income statement.
  o   It is subject to the following successive controls for SCOR Global P&C’s business:
  §   by the reserving actuaries, through control statements the proper implementation of which is verified by the Group Actuarial Department,
 
  §   by the Chief Actuary, in particular, in respect of methods, tools, and results.
      A “Major Risk Committee,” chaired by the Chief Operating Officer, meets monthly to examine the Group’s major risks, which are monitored by the Loss and Commutations Department within the SCOR Global P&C business segment. Technical reinsurance results are analyzed quarterly by the PBR Department, which checks its analysis against that conducted by the control units of SCOR Global P&C and the Group Actuarial Department.
  o   With regard to the SCOR VIE business segment:
  §   Reinsurance treaties are subject to either individual review or pooling within an affiliation treaty according to certain criteria defined in advance,
 
  §   The treaties are then subject to appraisals,
 
  §   These appraisals are reviewed systematically at each quarterly closing during meetings to which Underwriters, managers and possibly the Technical Department members are invited.
  Monitoring of current assets and cash flow is provided through various operating methods making it possible to limit risks. The computer systems used provide an audit path for completed transactions and have automatic alert systems. In the North American companies, accounting activities are delegated to external service providers. Controls implemented by these companies make it possible to verify the proper consolidation of accounting data and compatibility of the figures. In addition, these service providers can transmit an external evaluation of the internal control systems on the delegated activities. This evaluation is commonly called “SAS 70 type II.”
“Cash” reconciliations are made on a daily basis, for the most part, and securities are reconciled on a regular basis with statements from depositaries. Shares having a book value greater than market are reviewed quarterly.
To reduce the risk of fraud, the principle of segregating tasks of ordering and payment (losses, payments of invoices, etc.) is applied. Furthermore, the systems used limit the risk of internal fraud by electronic transmission of non-modifiable files, and the risk of embezzlement of funds by a third party is minimized by using secure internal payment systems.
Regarding the process of aggregating and consolidating accounting data by the PBR Department, present internal control is ensured:
  by using general accounting and consolidation software common to all companies of the Group,
  by defining the financial statement plan decided upon and verified by the PBR Department, which also establishes and updates the financial statement closing schedule and the tax schedule,
  by defining responsibilities for controlling the inclusion and consolidation of auxiliary accounts.
Control of the quarterly consolidation procedure under IFRS is provided in particular through:
  -   use of a tool common to the Group making it possible to limit the number of entries and the risk of errors,
 
  -   automated and formalized controls applicable to all Group companies (with regard to these first two points, see the comments below relating to the tool’s limitations).

Page 168 of 184


 

  -   at least two levels of control of consistency and exhaustiveness of consolidation forms, one by the company or unit involved, the other by the PBR Department,
 
  -   an exact schedule for, and definition of, the responsibilities of each party involved in the process,
 
  -   controls and verification of the consolidation process at various stages,
 
  -   documentation of restatements,
 
  -   final verification of entries affecting income and consolidated reserves,
 
  -   internal watch of changes in the law and in accounting standards, together with the Group’s outside counsel and statutory auditors.
Since the consolidation tool is old and cannot be upgraded, the changeover to IFRS demonstrated its limitations and required the accounting teams to have to re-enter data. They were not able to benefit fully from the automated and formalized controls. In order to ensure the quality of the consolidated figures, a system largely inspired by crosschecking was implemented in 2005. A project to refine the system is planned for 2006 (see below).
Furthermore, and without challenging the internal control rules of SCOR and its officers and senior management, the Group’s General Management, during 2004, refined the procedure for quarterly reporting and consolidation by requesting all local general managers of companies owned or controlled by SCOR, as well as the managers of the reinsurance business segments, to make certain statements to the Chairman and Chief Executive Officer and to the Chief Financial Officer of the Group in “management representation letters” relating to the reliability and accuracy of the financial statements of the companies and units they manage, as well as the effectiveness of internal controls.
Balance sheet activity for 2005 and action plan for 2006
SCOR plans to evaluate its internal controls relating to the preparation of financial and accounting information of certain companies and/or processes in 2006 and to gradually expand this evaluation. This evaluation will be the completion of efforts to improve and formalize internal control systems conducted since 2003. In fact, in 2003 SCOR established the charting of its risks and controls and thereby enhanced their management. These efforts were extended in 2004 to all companies of the Group.
In addition thereto, and to involve SCOR’s employees in the effort to formalize financial internal controls and bring them into compliance with the COSO reference document, General Management decided that this project was a matter of strategic importance for the Group. In this context, in 2004 General Management initiated, and in 2005 it finalized, the drafting of most of the internal control procedures involving the significant entities of the Group and the documentation of the principal processes generating accounting and financial data.
The steps planned by SCOR in 2006 are as follows:
  Finalization of drafting procedures in the companies considered to be significant,
 
  Deployment and implementation in Paris and in the significant subsidiaries of “standardized” control procedures reflecting the best internal control practices used within the Group,
 
  Definition of the evaluation system and the internal testing plans that make it possible to verify the proper application of control procedures and their effectiveness.
 
  Evaluation of financial internal control, of processes retained in a first coverage scope, based on a testing plans and consolidation of the results in a tool for monitoring risk control.
When the financial statements were prepared according to U.S. GAAP at December 31, 2004, some errors, including two major deficiencies mentioned in Form 20F available to the public beginning on April 29, 2005 were identified. These two deficiencies related to:
- accounting for real estate leasing generated during the 2002 accounting year that were not correctly captured in the U.S. GAAP financial statements;
- accounting for derivative products in fiscal year 2003.
For Ernst & Young, these errors resulted in inadequate controls relating to the financial statement closing process under U.S. GAAP and did not involve the financial statement closing process under French GAAP. The 20F report indicated that the following measures would be taken:
    Strengthening of the teams with individuals familiar with U.S. GAAP and training of staff in U.S. accounting issues;
 
    Strengthening of existing controls relating to the process of preparing consolidation forms;
 
    Improvement in the standard reconciliation formats between French GAAP, IFRS and U.S. GAAP; and
 
    Review and obligatory approval by certain managers of transactions that have an impact on SCOR’s financial position or on the consolidated operating results above certain thresholds.
This situation relating to U.S. GAAP, as well as the changeover to IFRS in 2005 and the need to change the information-processing tool, demonstrated the need for an in-depth review of the financial statement consolidation process. This project, planned for 2006, is widespread since it involves the implementation of new regulations and a new consolidation tool.

Page 169 of 184


 

9.14  
Statutory auditors’ report, prepared in accordance with article L. 225-235 of the French Commercial Code, on the report prepared by the Chairman of the Board of Directors of Scor, on information given on the internal control procedures relating to the preparation and processing of financial and accounting information
Year ended December 31, 2005
(Free translation of a French language original)
This is a free translation into English of the statutory auditors’ report issued in the French language and is provided solely for the convenience of English speaking readers. This report should be read in conjunction with, and construed in accordance with French law and professional auditing standards applicable in France.
To the shareholders,
In our capacity as statutory auditors of Scor, and in accordance with article L.225-235 of the French Commercial Code, we hereby present to you our report on the report prepared by the Chairman of the Board of Directors of your company in accordance with article L.225-37 of the French Commercial code for the year ended December 31, 2005.
In his report, the Chairman of the Board of Directors is required to report on the preparation and organisation of the work carried out by the Board of Directors and the internal control procedures implemented within the Company.
It is our responsibility to report to you our comments on the information given in the Chairman’s report on the internal control procedures relating to the preparation and processing of financial and accounting information.
We performed our work in accordance with the professional guidelines applicable in France. These require us to perform procedures to assess the fairness of information given in the report prepared by the Chairman of the Board, on the internal control procedures relating to the preparation and processing of financial and accounting information. These procedures included:
o obtaining an understanding of the objectives and the general organization of the Company’s internal control, as well as the internal control procedures relating to the preparation and processing of financial and accounting information, as set out in the President’s report; and
o obtaining an understanding of the Company’s work performed to support the information given in the President’s report.
On the basis of the procedures we have performed, we have no matters to report in connection with the information given on the internal control procedures relating to the preparation and processing of financial and accounting information, as described in the Chairman of the board of Directors’ report, prepared in accordance with article L.225-37 of the French Commercial code.
Paris, March 24, 2006
Statutory Auditors
     
ERNST & YOUNG AUDIT
  MAZARS & GUERARD
Pierre PLANCHON
  Lionel GOTLIB
 
  Jean Luc BARLET

Page 170 of 184


 

10 AGREEMENTS
10.1   RELATED PARTY-AGREEMENTS SIGNED IN 2005 as defined by Articles L. 225-38 et seq. of the French Commercial Code.
    Renewable credit facility agreement with a banking syndicate represented by BNP Paribas as agent and lead manager
At its meeting of May 9, 2005, the Board of Directors authorized the signature of a renewable credit facility agreement with a banking syndicate represented by BNP Paribas as Agent and Lead Manager (the “Credit Facility Agreement”), the purpose of which is to provide the Company with short-term cash facilities to finance its general cash needs.
The Credit Facility Agreement was signed on May 18, 2005 for a term of twelve months from the date of signature. The credit may be used in the form of revolving drawdowns up to a maximum of 75,000,000 over a period ending one month before the final expiration of the credit facility.
The breakdown of the banking syndicate and the share of each Lender in the total commitment is as follows:
                 
 
Lenders
    Credit     Commitment as a %  
 
 
             
 
BNP Paribas
    24,750,000     33%  
 
 
             
 
CALYON
    18,750,000     25%  
 
 
             
 
Natexis Banques Populaires
    15,000,000     20%  
 
 
             
 
Crédit Industriel et Commercial
    7,500,000     10%  
 
 
             
 
Ixis Corporate & Investment Bank
    5,250,000     7%  
 
 
             
 
Caisse Régionale de Crédit Agricole Mutuel de Paris et d’Ile-de-France
    3,750,000     5%  
 
 
             
 
Total Commitment
    75,000,000     100%  
 
To guarantee its obligations under the Credit Facility Agreement, the Company is required to pledge a first-tier financial instruments account to the Lenders and BNP Paribas as Agent under the terms of a pledge agreement signed with the Lenders and Agent and the related declaration of pledge, and to pledge, as a condition precedent for each draw and at the Company’s discretion, either French Treasury Bonds (OAT) in an amount at least equal to 105% of the draw amount, or shares for an amount at least equal to 125% of the draw amount, or bonds in an amount at least equal to 110% of the draw amount.
The Board authorized as needed the signature of an amendment to the Credit Facility Agreement providing for the pledge of Luxembourg open-end investment fund shares (SICAV) and a pledge agreement governed by Luxembourg law, between the Company, the Lenders and BNP Paribas as Agent, concerning the pledge of said Luxembourg SICAV shares (hereinafter referred to, with the aforementioned financial instruments pledge, as the “Sureties”).
The margin applicable to each draw is based on the type of securities pledged prior to the draw. If stocks are pledges (including shares of Luxembourg SICAVs), the applicable margin is set at 0.45% per annum; if bonds are pledged, the applicable margin is set at 0.25% per annum; and, if OATs are pledged, the applicable margin is set at the higher of (i) 0.15% per annum or (ii) the rate of the non-utilization commission applicable on the date of the draw in question.
The interest period is set at the Company’s discretion for each draw at 1, 2, 3 or 6 months. The interest rate applicable to the amount drawn is equal to the sum of (i) the EURIBOR for the relevant interest period, (ii) the margin applicable to the draw in question plus, as applicable, (iii) the required costs applicable under the terms of the agreement.
The bank fees stipulated under the Credit Facility Agreement are as follows:
non-use commission: payable quarterly when due on the basis of a rate applied to the amount of the credit available, which varies on the basis of the Company’s credit rate (“Counterparty Credit Rating”) given by Standard & Poors’:
     
BBB or lower:
  0.28% per annum
 
   
BBB+:
  0.20% per annum
 
   
A-:
  0.15% per annum

Page 171 of 184


 

     
A or higher:
  0.12% per annum
If, on the calculating date, Standard & Poors’ no longer gives a rating to the Company, the rate will then be determined on the basis of the credit rating (“Counterparty Credit Rating”) given by the Moody’s ratings agency as follows:
     
Baa2 or lower:
  0.28% per annum
 
   
Baa1:
  0.20% per annum
 
   
A3:
  0.15% per annum
 
   
A2 or higher:
  0.12% per annum
In the event Standard & Poors’ and Moody’s no longer assign the aforementioned credit ratings to the Company and in the event there is a Default Event, the applicable rate would then be set at the maximum applicable rate, i.e. 0.28% per annum.
    participation commission: 0.20% of the total commitments of each Lender, payable on the date of signature of the Credit Facility Agreement;
 
    Agent commission: 10,000 (excluding VAT), payable in one sum;
 
    Lead Manager commission: 0.10% flat (excluding VAT), calculated on the credit facility of 75,000,000 and payable in one payment.
The representations and warranties of the Company under the Credit Facility Agreement and the default events are similar in all points to those stipulated in the credit facility agreement useable through the issue of letters of credit, as amended, entered into on December 26, 2002.
The director concerned by this agreement is Mr. Kessler.
    Signature of an agency letter and an underwriting agreement between the Company and BNP Paribas within the context of a share capital increase on June 30, 2005
At its afternoon meeting of May 31, 2005, the Board of Directors authorized, pursuant to Article L. 225-38 of the Commercial Code, within the framework of the proposed share capital increase of June 30, 2005, the signature by SCOR and BNP Paribas of an agency letter and an underwriting agreement for the offering and placement of the shares to be issued.
The director concerned by this agreement is Mr. Kessler.
    Signature of a novation agreement (hereinafter the “Global Novation Agreement”) between SCOR, party of the first part; Irish Reinsurance Partners Limited (“IRP”) party of the second part; and SCOR, SCOR Italia Riassicurazioni, SCOR UK Company Ltd, SCOR Deutschland, SCOR Asia Pacific, SCOR Re Co (Asia) Ltd, SCOR Asia Pacific Australian Branch, SCOR Asia Pacific Labuan Branch and SCOR Re Asia Pacific PTE Ltd Korea Branch, (referred to as the “Subsidiaries”), parties of the third part.
At its meeting of August 31, 2005, the Board of Directors authorized, pursuant to Article L. 225-38 of the Commercial Code, the signature of the Global Novation Agreement, under the terms of which SCOR will be substituted for IRP in the rights and obligations resulting from the Quota Share Retrocession Agreements, the list of which is attached to the Global Novation Agreement.
The officers concerned are Messrs. Kessler and Thourot.
    Signature of a novation agreement (hereinafter the “SCOR Re Novation Agreement”) between SCOR, Irish Reinsurance Partners Limited (“IRP”), and SCOR Reinsurance Company (SCOR Re).
At its meeting on August 31, 2005, the Board of Directors authorized, pursuant to Article L. 225-38 of the Commercial Code, the signature of the SCOR Re Novation Agreement, under the terms of which SCOR will be substituted for IRP in the rights and obligations resulting from the Quota Share Retrocession Agreement defined by said contract.
The officers concerned by this agreement are Messrs. Kessler, Chapin, Lebègue and Thourot.
    Signature of a novation agreement (hereinafter the “Canada Novation Agreement”) between SCOR, Irish Reinsurance Partners Limited (“IRP”), and SCOR Canada Reinsurance Company (SCOR Canada)
At its meeting of August 31, 2005, the Board of Directors authorized, pursuant to Article L. 225-38 of the Commercial Code, the signature of the Canada Novation Agreement, under the terms of which SCOR will be substituted for IRP in the rights and obligations resulting from the Quota Share Retrocession Agreement defined by said contract.
The officers concerned by this agreement are Messrs. Kessler, Lamontagne and Thourot.
    Signature of a guarantee known as the Indemnity Agreement (hereinafter the “Guarantee” granted by SCOR to Irish Reinsurance Partners Limited)
At its meeting of August 31, 2005, the Board of Directors authorized, pursuant to Article L. 225-38 of the Commercial Code, the signature of a guarantee requested by the IRP Board of Directors from SCOR in order to guarantee any liability that might be incurred by Irish Reinsurance Partners Limited resulting from the execution of the novation agreements described above.
The officers concerned by this agreement are Messrs. Kessler and Thourot.

Page 172 of 184


 

Parent company guarantees
At its meeting of August 31, 2005, the Board of Directors authorized, pursuant to Articles L. 225-38 and L. 225-35 of the Commercial Code, the renewal of the parent company guarantees granted by SCOR to allow the Group’s reinsurance subsidiaries to obtain a financial rating equivalent to the rating for SCOR itself. SCOR stood surety for the obligations of said subsidiaries under the insurance and reinsurance treaties they signed, particularly under the parent company guarantee which the Board last authorized on December 19, 2002.
During the past 2004/2005 period, the subsidiary General Security Indemnity Company of Arizona had to produce the guarantee once for a specific intermediary.
In addition, the Board of Directors also authorized a new parent company guarantee granted by SCOR to Commercial Risk Reinsurance Company and Commercial Risk Re-Insurance Limited.
Pursuant to Article L. 225-38 of the Commercial Code and because of the positions they held on the Board of Directors of some of these subsidiaries, Messrs. Chapin, Lamontagne, Lebègue and Kessler did not participate in the vote. For the same reason, particularly for the parent company guarantee given to SCOR VIE, only Mrs. Aronvald was authorized to vote.
The benefit of the parent company guarantee was given to the following subsidiaries of the SCOR Group under insurance and/or insurance contracts entered into by these subsidiaries:
- SCOR Reinsurance Co. Ltd (US)
- General Security Indemnity Co. of Arizona
- General Security National Insurance Co.
- Commercial Risk Reinsurance Company
- Commercial Risk Re-Insurance Limited
- Investors Insurance Corp.
- SCOR Life Insurance Company (ex. Republic-Vanguard Life Insurance Co).
- SCOR Asia-Pacific Pte Ltd
- SCOR Canada Reinsurance Co.
- SCOR Channel
- SCOR Deutschland
- SCOR Financial Services Ltd
- SCOR Italia Riassicurazioni SpA
- SCOR Life U.S. Re Insurance Co.
- SCOR Reinsurance Co. (Asia) Ltd
- SCOR U.K. Co. Ltd
- SCOR VIE
This new authorization became effective on September 3, 2005 and will expire no later than September 2, 2006.
The officers in question were Messrs. Chapin, Lamontagne, Lebègue, Thourot and Kessler. With regard to the parent company guarantee granted to SCOR VIE, the directors concerned were Messrs. Kessler, Havis, Chapin, Simonnet, Seys, Levy-Lang, Borges, Schimetschek, Tendil, Acutis, Lamontagne, Valot, Lebègue and Le Pas de Sécheval.
Project Triple X
At its meeting of November 2, 2005, the Board of Directors authorized, pursuant to Article L. 225-38 of the Commercial Code, the issue of a parent company letter of guarantee intended to cover the financial obligations of SCOR VIE under the terms of an agreement to issue letters of credit that would be signed by SCOR VIE, SCOR Financial Services Limited (SFS) and CALYON.
These proposed agreements to issue letters of credit and a parent company guarantee are part of an operation intended to provide SCOR Life U.S. Reinsurance Company (SLR) additional financial resources so that it can satisfy the financial coverage requirements stipulated by the American prudential regulations known as Triple X.
Under the terms of the contract described above, CALYON has committed itself to issuing or causing the issue to SLR one or more letters of credit for a period of five years for a total commitment equal to the smaller of the following two amounts: (a) USD 250 million or (b) the sum equal to the difference between the (i) so-called Triple X reserves and (ii) 150% of the amount of the reserves required in the accounting plan (net of deferred acquisition costs).
The transaction was submitted to the Department of Insurance of the State of Texas (United States of America) insofar as it requires a certain number of amendments to the retrocession treaty (Automatic Coinsurance Retrocession Treaty) signed on

Page 173 of 184


 

December 31, 2003 by SLR and SFS. In a letter dated September 30, 2005, the competent authorities of the State of Texas indicated that they had no comments on the amendments that would be made to that agreement. The Irish administrative authorities (IFSRA) were also informed of the transaction and they also indicated their lack of any objection.
The transaction was finalized at the end of December 2005.
The directors concerned are Messrs. Kessler, Havis, Chapin, Simonnet, Seys, Levy-Lang, Lebègue, Borges, Schimetschek, Tendil, Acutis, Lamontagne, Valot and Le Pas de Sécheval.
    Approval of the Credit Facility Agreement
The Company terminated, effective December 31, 2005, the credit facility agreement as amended that was signed on December 26, 2002 with a banking syndicate represented by BNP Paribas (the “Bank”). The Company’s objective is to give priority to bilateral relations with one or more banking partners for coverage of its reinsurance commitments by letters of credit. The Company asked the Bank not to terminate certain stand-by letters of credit issued under said credit agreement and to assume on its own a portion of the related banking commitments (so that these letters of credit are automatically renewed for another year as of December 31, 2005) and proposed to the Bank, subject to approval by its own Board, that it issue new letters of credit under a new agreement.
At its meeting of November 2, 2005, the Board of Directors authorized, pursuant to Article L. 225-38 of the Commercial Code, the signature of a new credit facility agreement with the Bank (the “Credit Facility Agreement”), the purpose of which is to guarantee the performance of the Company’s obligations for its reinsurance operations. The credit facility is useable through the issuance of revolving letters of credit and/or counter-guarantees (stand-by letters of credit or “SBLC”) up to a maximum of USD 85,000,000 (USD Eighty Five Million) over a utilization period from January 4, 2006 to December 31, 2008.
In order to guarantee its obligations under the terms of the Credit Facility Agreement, SCOR pledged a first-tier financial instruments account to the Bank under the terms of a pledge agreement entered into with the Bank (and the related pledge declaration) and pledged (i) on the date of the signature of the pledge agreement, a number of OATs for a minimum amount equal to 5,000 (Five Thousand Euros); (ii) on December 30, 2005, an additional number of OATS for an amount equivalent to the value in euros of 105% of the Initial SBLCs (corresponding to the letters of credit issued under the old credit agreement and assumed and extended by the Bank); and (iii) is required to pledge before each new utilization a number of OATS for an amount equivalent to the value in euros of 105% of the amount of the new utilization.
The bank fees stipulated under the Credit Facility Agreement are as follows:
    non-use commission: 0.05% per annum as of January 1, 2006, calculated on the unused and un-canceled amount of the credit and payable quarterly when due;
 
    Utilization commission: 0.10% per annum as of January 1, 2006, calculated on the basis of the loan outstanding and payable monthly in advance;
 
    Other Bank fees:
    flat fee of USD 400 (USD Four Hundred) for each SBLC issued;
 
    flat fee of USD 100 (USD One Hundred) for each change in SBLC;
 
    flat fee of USD 100 (USD One Hundred) for each annual extension of SBLC.
The director concerned is Mr. Kessler.
 
 
10.2 AGREEMENTS APPROVED IN PRIOR FISCAL YEARS AND CONTINUED OR TERMINATED IN 2005.
    Underwriting agreement entered into with BNP Paribas, Goldman Sachs International and HSBC CCF for the OCEANE bond issue.
The Board of Directors, at its meeting of June 21, 2004, authorized the bond issue approved by the AMF on June 24, 2004 under Number 04-627, through the issuance of bonds convertible and/or exchangeable for new or existing shares (OCEANE) with a nominal unit value of 2 with normal amortization on January 1, 2010.
In the context of this operation, the Board at the same meeting authorized the signature of an underwriting agreement for the placement and subscription of the bonds convertible and/or exchangeable for new or existing shares which was signed on June 24, 2004 by SCOR and the BNP Paribas, Goldman Sachs International and HSBC CCF banks. This agreement specified a placement commission, a success commission and a guarantee commission. The total amount of these commissions is 4,175,000.

Page 174 of 184


 

The board members concerned are Messrs. Kessler and Borgès.
    SCOR AUBER Agreement in connection with a real estate acquisition
The Board of Directors, at its meeting held on June 21, 2004, authorized, pursuant to Article L. 225-38 of the French Commercial Code, the signature of a Loan Agreement with SCOR AUBER, dated June 29, 2004, in connection with the acquisition by SCOR AUBER of a real estate asset consisting of a logistics platform on June 30, 2004.
For this purpose, SCOR made available 23,570,000 to SCOR AUBER in the form of a loan at the market rate, knowing that, out of this aggregate amount, 10 million was capitalized by SCOR AUBER following a share capital increase.
The person concerned by this agreement is Mr. Thourot.
    Acquisition of SOREMA securities and grant by Groupama to SCOR of guarantees relating to SOREMA
It is recalled that the SCOR Board of Directors on May 10, 2001 authorized the signature of a plan for SCOR’s acquisition of the securities of SOREMA S.A. and SOREMA N.A. Under this acquisition, a guarantee of the technical reserves and a guarantee of liabilities were made by Groupama to SCOR for a period of six years.
In the context of the purchase of SOREMA S.A. and SOREMA N.A., Groupama provided two guarantees. Groupama could indemnify SCOR in the event of negative developments concerning significant liabilities related to social security and income taxes or related to the technical reserves for 2000 and the prior year writings, as they will be valued on December 31, 2006.
The amount of the guarantee charged to Groupama in the accounts as of December 31, 2004 amounted to 233.5 million. This amount may be increased or decreased at the end of the guarantee period that expires June 30, 2007.
The Board member concerned by this agreement was Mr. Baligand.

Page 175 of 184


 

11. ANNUAL INFORMATION DOCUMENT
11.1 Published information
A. Information published on the website of the French Autorité des Marchés Financiers (AMF)
           
 
  Date     Subject  
 
March 22, 2006
    SCOR pursues the implementation of the variable part mechanism of the employee after the ruling of the Versailles Court of Appeal – Press release  
 
March 22, 2006
    The SCOR Group records 75% growth in its net result, at 131 million – Press release  
 
February 28, 2006
    SCOR records 25% growth in its global premium income renewed on January 1, 2006 in Non-Life and Credit-Surety treaties – Press release  
 
February 15, 2006
    2005 Premium income: 2,407 million – Press release  
 
January 13, 2006
    Half-year balance sheet for the SCOR liquidity contract with EXANE BNP PARIBAS  
 
January 11, 2006
    SCOR records 25% growth in its global premium income renewed on January 1, 2006 in Non-Life and Credit-Surety treaties – Press release  
 
January 9, 2006
    Gilles Thivant appointed Director France for SCOR VIE – Press release  
 
December 20, 2005
    Hurricane Wilma – Press release  
 
December 8, 2005
    SCOR Group acquires renewal rights to Alea Europe treaties – Press release  
 
November 30, 2005
    SCOR Group is pleased to join La Réunion Aérienne and La Réunion Spatiale – Press release  
 
November 3, 2005
    First nine months of 2005: Net result of 83 million up 38%, moderate impact of natural disasters on results – Press release  
 
October 25, 2005
    Changes in resources allocated to the liquidity agreement  
 
September 26, 2005
    François de Varenne appointed SCOR Group Director of Asset Management and Corporate Finance – Press release  
 
September 21, 2005
    SCOR Group appeals court decision suspending variable portion of compensation for its employees in France – Press release  
 
September 1, 2005
    First-half 2005: Net income 72.2 million, up 18% – Press release  
 
August 23, 2005
    SCOR Group opens representative office in India—a high-potential market – Press release  
 
August 1, 2005
    Standard & Poor’s raises SCOR Group rating to “A- outlook stable” – Press release  
 
July 5, 2005
    Victor Peignet appointed director for all SCOR Property & Casualty Reinsurance operations – Press release  
 
July 4, 2005
    SCOR VIE: Embedded Value and analysis of changes at December 31, 2004 – Press release  
 

Page 176 of 184


 

           
 
  Date     Subject  
 
June 22, 2005
    SCOR issues new shares: Exercise of entire over-allotment option – Gross proceeds from the issue total 233,220,000 – Press release  
 
June 22, 2005
    SCOR issues 130 million new shares: capital increase is a huge success — Press release  
 
June 22, 2005
    Acquisition of the balance of IRP stock for 183.1 million – SCOR issues 130 million new shares – Press release  
 
June 22, 2005
    Offering circular – Public offering in a cash capital increase of 130,000 new shares which may be raised to 149,500,000 new shares without preemptive subscription rights or priority period  
 
June 10, 2005
    NEW SCOR Project – Press release  
 
May 31, 2005
    Combined Shareholders’ Meeting of May 31, 2005 — Press release  
 
May 31, 2005
    First quarter 2005: Confirmation of Group technical profitability and net profitability – Conversion to IFRS: a slightly positive impact – Press release  
 
May 11, 2005
    Offering circular – Stock buyback program  
 
April 29, 2005
    SCOR: Financial statements under U.S. GAAP 2004 – Press release  
 
April 19, 2005
    Reference Document  
 
April 13, 2005
    Renewals at April 1 confirm SCOR expansion in Asia – Press release  
 
March 24, 2005
    SCOR establishes additional reserves in fourth quarter 2004 following World Trade Center jury verdict – Press release  
 
March 24, 2005
    SCOR: 2004 Annual results– Press release  
 
February 14, 2005
    2004 Premium income: 2,528 million at current exchange rates (2,578 million at constant exchange rates) – Press release  
 
February 4, 2005
    SCOR: Satisfactory renewals in P&C reinsurance in a competitive environment – Press release  
 
January 11, 2005
    SCOR mobilizes to assist Tsunami victims – Press release  
 
B. Information published in the French legal paper, the Bulletin des Annonces Légales Obligatoires (BALO)
           
 
  Date     Subject  
 
February 22, 2006
    Periodic publications– Consolidated premium income for fourth quarter 2005  
 
December 5, 2005
    Periodic publications – Statements of business operations and results at September 30, 2005  
 
November 16, 2005
    Periodic publications – Consolidated premium income for third quarter 2005  
 
September 9, 2005
    Periodic publications – Consolidated premium income for first half 2005  
 
July 22, 2005
    Other notices – Voting rights  
 
July 1, 2005
    Issues and listings – Issue and listing for trading on Eurolist of Euronext Paris S.A. of 19,500,000 shares expected from a share capital increase without preemptive share right or priority period  
 

Page 177 of 184


 

           
 
  Date     Subject  
 
June 27, 2005
    Issues and listings – Issue and listing for trading on Eurolist of Euronext Paris S.A. of 130,000,000 shares, which may be raised to 149,500,000 shares to come from a share capital increase without preemptive share right or priority period.  
 
June 13, 2005
    Other notices – Voting rights  
 
June 10, 2005
    Periodic publications – Annual financial statements approved by the Shareholders’ Meeting of May 31, 2005  
 
June 3, 2005
    Periodic publications – Consolidated premium income for first half 2005  
 
May 13, 2005
    Notices – Notice of meeting for the Combined Shareholders’ Meeting of May 31, 2005  
 
April 29, 2005
    Notices – Notice of meeting for the Combined Shareholders’ Meeting of May 31, 2005  
 
February 14, 2005
    Periodic publications – Consolidated premium income for fourth quarter 2004  
 
C. Information published on the website of the U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC)
           
 
  Date     Subject  
 
January 27, 2006
    20-F/A – Annual and transition report of foreign private issuers  
 
January 6, 2006
    6-K – Hurricane Wilma – Press release  
 
December 22, 2005
    6-K – The SCOR Group has acquired the renewal rights to the Alea Europe treaties – Press release  
 
November 30, 2005
    6-K – The SCOR Group is pleased to be joining La Réunion Aérienne & La Réunion Spatiale – Press release  
 
November 25, 2005
    S-8 – Specific Stock Option Plan for the Subscription of Shares to be Issued, dated September 16, 2005  
 
November 25, 2002
    S-8 – 2005 Stock Award Plan (Foreign)  
 
November 3, 2005
    6-K — First nine months of 2005: Net income 83 million, an increase of 38% Moderate impact of natural catastrophes on the results – Press release  
 
September 26, 2005
    6-K – François de Varenne is appointed SCOR Group Director for Asset Management and Corporate Finance – Press release  
 
August 23, 2005
    6-K The SCOR Group opens a representative office in India, a high-potential market – Press release  
 
August 1, 2005
    6-K – Standard & Poor’s upgrades SCOR Group to “A-, stable outlook” – Press release  
 
July 4, 2005
    6-K Embedded Value and analysis of changes as at December 31, 2004 Press release  
 
June 10, 2005
    6-K – Project NEW SCOR – Press release  
 
May 31, 2005
    6-K – Technical and net profitability confirmed Transition to IFRS: a slight positive impact – Press release  
 
April 29, 2005
    6-K – 2004 U.S. GAAP Financial Statements – Press release  
 

Page 178 of 184


 

           
 
  Date     Subject  
 
April 29, 2005
    20-F – Annual and transition report of foreign private issuers  
 
April 13, 2005
    6-K – Renewals at April 1 confirm SCOR’s expansion in Asia – Press release  
 
March 24, 2005
    6-K Annual results 2004 Press release  
 
February 14, 2005
    6-K – 2004 Premium income Press release  
 
February 4, 2005
    6-K – Satisfactory Property & Casualty reinsurance renewals in a competitive environment – Press release  
 
January 24, 2005
    S-8 – Specific stock options plan for the subscription of shares to be issued, dated August 25, 2005  
 
January 1, 2005
    6-K – SCOR mobilized to help the populations affected by the Tsunami – Press release  
 
D. Information published on the website of the SCOR Company
All press releases and offering circulars published on the AMF site (point A.) are simultaneously published on the SCOR website. In addition, the following were published on the SCOR website
           
 
  Date     Subject  
 
February 2006
    Regards No. 14 – Dossier Katrina: are we heading toward doubts over modeling? — Group news – Newsletter for clients  
 
November 3, 2005
    Financial report at September 30, 2005  
 
November 3, 2005
    Results for third quarter 2005 – Presentation slideshow  
 
September 1, 2005
    Financial report at June 30, 2005  
 
September 1, 2005
    Half-year 2005 results – Presentation slideshow  
 
September 2005
    Regards No. 13 — New SCOR – The risk of nuclear, biological and chemical terrorism: the French case study –Group News – Newsletter for clients  
 
September 2005
    Facts and Figures – Newsletter for Clients  
 
July 4, 2005
    Presentation of SCOR VIE to financial analysts (in English only) – Presentation slideshow  
 
July 4, 2004
    Presentation of SCOR VIE Embedded Value at December 31, 2004 – Presentation slideshow  
 
June 10, 2005
    Group strategy and outlook – NEW SCOR Project – Presentation slideshow  
 
May 31, 2005
    Retransmission of the presentation of earnings at March 31, 2005 to analysts and the press–Audio document  
 
May 31, 2005
    Conversion of the consolidated accounts to IFRS– Presentation document  
 
May 31, 2005
    Financial report at March 31, 2005  
 
May 31, 2005
    Results for first quarter 2005 – Presentation slideshow  
 
March 24, 2005
    Retransmission of the presentation of annual earnings to analysts and the press–Audio document  
 
March 24, 2005
    2004 annual results – Presentation slideshow  
 

Page 179 of 184


 

           
 
  Date     Subject  
 
February 2005
    Regards No. 12 – Transport insurers in the face of sustainable development – Agricultural Disasters Reform in France: Coming or not – Fighting fraud & money laundering. — Newsletter for clients  
 
11.2 Information availability
In electronic format
All the information listed above can be downloaded from the following sites:
    Autorité des Marchés financiers (AMF): http://www.amf-france.org
 
    Bulletin des Annonces Légales Obligatoires (BALO): http://balo.journal-officiel.gouv.fr/
 
    Securities and Exchange Commission: http://www.sec.gov/
 
    The SCOR Company: http://www.scor.com/
In printed format
Complimentary copies of the documents listed above can be obtained from the Company on request addressed to:
SCOR
1, avenue du Général de Gaulle
92800 Puteaux
     
Godefroy de Colombe
  + 33 (0)1 46 98 73 50 – Director of Public Affairs
Stéphane Le May
  + 33 (0)1 46 98 70 61 – Investor Relations
12 PERSON RESPONSIBLE FOR THE DOCUMENT
Mr. Denis KESSLER, Chairman of the Board of Directors
12.1 CERTIFICATION
I certify, after having taken all reasonable measures to that effect, that the information contained in this document de référence (shelf registration document) is, to the best of my knowledge, a true and accurate representation of the facts and contains no omissions likely to impair their significance.
I obtained from the statutory auditors of the financial statements, a letter confirming the completion of their assignment. In this letter, they indicated that they had audited the information concerning the financial position and financial statements provided in this document de référence and had read the entire document.
Without calling into question their opinion on the financial statements, the legal auditors, in their report on the annual parent company financial statements presented on page 95 of this reference document, issued an observation concerning a change in accounting method relating to the recognition of assets by components pursuant to Regulation 2002-10 of the Accounting Regulatory Commission, as described in Note 1.21 to the parent company financial statements.
Chairman of the Board of Directors
Denis KESSLER
12.2 INDEPENDENT AUDITORS RESPONSIBLE FOR THE CONTROL OF THE ACCOUNTS
                   
      Date of            
      first appointment     Next expiration of the term     Representatives
                   
Incumbent statutory auditors
                   
Cabinet MAZARS & GUERARD
Le Vinci – 4 Allée de l’Arche
92075 LA DEFENSE CEDEX France
    June 22, 1990     From April 18, 2002 to the Shareholders’ Meeting that will approve the financial statements for the fiscal year ending December 31, 2007     Mr. Lionel GOTLIB

Mr. Jean-Luc BARLET
CRCC de Paris
                 
                   
ERNST & YOUNG Audit
Tour Ernst and Young
11, Faubourg de l’Arche
92037 Paris la Défense Cedex France

CRCC de Versailles
    May 13, 1996     From April 18, 2002 to the Shareholders’ Meeting that will approve the financial statements for the fiscal year ending December 31, 2007     Mr. Pierre PLANCHON
                   

Page 180 of 184


 

                   
      Date of            
      first appointment     Next expiration of the term     Representatives
                   
Alternate statutory auditors
                   
Mr. Pascal PARANT
Cabinet MAZARS & GUERARD
    May 13, 1996     From April 18, 2002 to the Shareholders’ Meeting that will approve the financial statements for the fiscal year ending December 31, 2007      
                   
Mr. Dominique DURET-FERRARI
ERNST & YOUNG Audit
    May 13, 1996     From April 18, 2002 to the Shareholders’ Meeting that will approve the financial statements for the fiscal year ending December 31, 2007      
                   
12.3 FEES PAID BY SCOR GROUP TO THE AUDITORS
The following auditors are presented in decreasing order according to the global amount of fees paid to them by the Group. All amounts are in euros.
                         
 
  Ernst & Young     2005     2004  
 
Audit
      4,331,500         3,414,303    
 
Auxiliary assignments
      624,520         406,396    
 
Other services
      346,000         476,295    
 
                         
 
  Mazars & Guérard     2005     2004  
 
Audit
      779,000         358,432    
 
Auxiliary assignments
      334,871         354,649    
 
Other services
      -         -    
 
12.4 FINANCIAL INFORMATION
Mr. Christian MAINGUY
Director of Investor Relations and Ratings
SCOR
1, avenue du Général de Gaulle
92800 Puteaux FRANCE
Tel: 33(0)1.46.98.70 95
E-mail: actionnaires@scor.com
http://www.SCOR.com
12.5 INFORMATION INCORPORATED BY REFERENCE
Pursuant to Article 28 of Commission Regulation (CE) n° 809/2004, the information below is incorporated by reference in this shelf-registration document (document de référence):
- the consolidated financial statements and the corresponding Statutory Auditors’ report on pages 10 to 54 and 55 of the shelf-registration document for fiscal 2004 registered with the Autorité des Marchés Financiers on April 19, 2005 under n° D.05-0481;
- the consolidated financial statements and the corresponding Statutory Auditors’ report on pages 17 to 54 and 55 of the shelf-registration document for fiscal 2003 registered with the Autorité des Marchés Financiers on April 9, 2004 under n° D.04-0460.
The parts not incorporated in these documents are either immaterial for the investor, or covered by another part of the shelf-registration document.

Page 181 of 184


 

13 CONCORDANCE TABLE
The concordance table below refers to the principal headings required by European Regulation no. 809/2004 implementing the “Prospectus” 2003/71/CE Directive of the European Parliament and the Council of November 4, 2003 as regards the prospectus to be published in the event of a public offering of marketable securities or for the admission of marketable securities for trading. The information not applicable to SCOR is indicated by “N/A.”
         
    This document de
Annex I of European Commission Regulation (EC) 809/2004 of April 29, 2004   référence
 
       
1. PERSONS RESPONSIBLE
    180  
 
       
2. STATUTORY AUDITORS
    180-181  
 
       
3. SELECTED FINANCIAL INFORMATION
       
 
       
3.1 Historical information
    8-10  
 
       
3.2 Interim information
    8-13 and 73-77  
 
       
4. RISK FACTORS
    59-61 and 115-125  
 
       
5. INFORMATION ABOUT THE ISSUER
       
 
       
5.1 History and Development of the Issuer
    18 and 72; 97-98 and 109-110  
 
       
5.2 Investments
    128-129  
 
       
6. BUSINESS OVERVIEW
       
 
       
6.1 Principal business operations
    110-114  
 
       
6.2 Principal markets
    112-114  
 
       
6.3 Exceptional factors
    8-9  
 
       
6.4 Possible dependency
    115-123  
 
       
6.5 The basis for any representations made by the issuer regarding its competitive position
    113-114  
 
       
7. ORGANIZATIONAL STRUCTURE
       
 
       
7.1 Brief description
    5 and 129-130  
 
       
7.2 List of subsidiaries
    84-85  
 
       
8. PROPERTY, PLANTS AND EQUIPMENT
       
 
       
8.1 Existing or projected tangible assets
    N/A  
 
       
8.2 Environmental issues that may affect the utilization of tangible assets
    N/A  
 
       
9. OPERATING AND FINANCIAL REVIEW
       
 
       
9.1 Financial Position
    8-10 and 18 and 70  
 
       
9.2 Operating Results
    8-13 and 73-77  
 
       
10. CASH AND CAPITAL RESOURCES
       
 
       
10.1 The issuer’s capital resources
    15 and 87 and 102-107  
 
       
10.2 Source and amount of cash flows
    14 and 17 and 59  
 
       
10.3 Borrowing requirements and funding structure
    48-49 and 103  
 
       
10.4 Information regarding any restrictions on the use of capital resources that have materially affected, or could materially affect, the issuer’s operations
    N/A  
 
       
10.5 Anticipated sources of funds
    N/A  
 
       
11. RESEARCH AND DEVELOPMENT, PATENTS AND LICENSES
    N/A  
 
       
12. TREND INFORMATION
    8-9  

Page 182 of 184


 

         
    This document de
Annex I of European Commission Regulation (EC) 809/2004 of April 29, 2004   référence
 
       
13. PROFIT FORECASTS OR ESTIMATES
    N/A  
 
       
14. ADMINISTRATIVE, MANAGEMENT, AND SUPERVISORY BODIES AND SENIOR MANAGEMENT
       
 
       
14.1 Administrative and management bodies
    133-146  
 
       
14.2 Administrative, management, and supervisory bodies and senior management conflicts of interest
    146 and 158  
 
       
15. COMPENSATION AND BENEFITS
       
 
       
15.1 Amount of compensation paid and benefits in kind
    146-156  
 
       
15.2 The total amounts set aside or accrued to provide pension, retirement or similar benefits
    52 and 87 and
146-150
 
 
       
16. OPERATION OF ADMINISTRATIVE AND MANAGEMENT BOARDS
       
 
       
16.1 Date of expiration of current terms of office
    133-141 and 143-145  
 
       
16.2 Service contracts binding members of the administrative bodies
    146  
 
       
16.3 Information on the Audit Committee and the Remuneration Committee
    159-160  
 
       
16.4 Corporate governance in effect in the issuer’s country of origin
    146  
 
       
17. EMPLOYEES
       
 
       
17.1 Number of employees
    115  
 
       
17.2 Profit-sharing and stock options
    56-58 and 151-156  
 
       
17.3 Agreement providing for employees’ participation in the issuer’s capital
    90-91 and 107  
 
       
18. MAJOR SHAREHOLDERS
       
 
       
18.1 Shareholders holding 5% of the share capital or voting rights
    106  
 
       
18.2 Existence of different voting rights
    107  
 
       
18.3 Control of the issuer
    N/A  
 
       
18.4 Agreement, known to the issuer, the implementation of which may at a subsequent date result in a change in control of the issuer
    107  
 
       
19. RELATED PARTY TRANSACTIONS
       
 
       
20. FINANCIAL INFORMATION CONCERNING THE ISSUER’S ASSETS AND LIABILITIES, FINANCIAL POSITION AND PROFITS AND LOSSES
       
 
       
20.1 Historical financial information
    8-94  
 
       
20.2 Pro forma financial information
    N/A  
 
       
20.3 Financial statements
    11-94  
 
       
20.4 Auditing of historical financial information
    180  
 
       
20.5 Date of latest financial information
    N/A  
 
       
20.6 Interim and other financial information
    N/A  
 
       
20.7 Dividend policy
    7 and 58 and
87 and 91
 
 
       
20.8 Legal and arbitration proceedings
    63-65 and 93-94 and 130-132  
 
       
20.9 Significant change in the issuer’s financial information or trading position
    109  
 
       
21. ADDITIONAL INFORMATION
       
 
       
21.1 Common stock
    102-107 and 151-156  
 
       
21.2 Memorandum and Articles of Association
    97-98; 107; 133;
156 and 161
 
 
       
22. MATERIAL CONTRACTS
    65-69; 130; 171-175  
 
       
23. THIRD PARTY INFORMATION AND STATEMENT BY EXPERTS AND DECLARATIONS OF ANY INTEREST
    2  
 
       
24. DOCUMENTS ON DISPLAY
    98 and 180  
 
       
25. INFORMATION ON HOLDINGS
    55; 82-88; 88;
107-108; 120; 122
and 129-130
 

Page 183 of 184


 

(AUTORITE DES MARCHES FINANCIERS LOGO)
This “document de référence” was filed on March 27, 2006 with the AMF (Autorité des Marchés Financiers), in accordance with Article 212-13 of the AMF general regulations. It can be used as a support document for a financial operation as long as it is presented together with a “note d’opération” validated by the AMF.

Page 184 of 184