For many local businesses, 2025 will be remembered as a year of challenges, but for Stephany Insurance LLC, it has been a definitive year of triumph. The Wexford-based agency, a true fourth-generation family institution, began the year by earning the Erie Insurance Commercial Lines District Sales Award—a professional milestone that served as the catalyst for their later “Silver Place” finish in the 2025 Pittsburgh Tribune-Review Best of the Best Awards.
The sequence of honors highlights a rare “double-win” for the agency: a top-tier endorsement from industry experts followed by a groundswell of support from the local community they serve.
Professional Precision Meets a Personal Touch
Winning a District Sales Award from a Fortune 500 carrier like Erie Insurance is no small feat. It requires a high level of technical mastery in Commercial Lines—the complex world of protecting businesses through workers’ compensation, general liability, and commercial auto policies.
While many agencies have moved toward call centers and automated chatbots, the team at Stephany Insurance—composed of Ken, Mary Lynn, Ryan, Meghan, and Brandon Stephany, along with Mike Casper and Customer Service Advocate Darci Scharphorn—has doubled down on a personal, face-to-face approach. This award acknowledges that their “old-fashioned” commitment to detail is precisely what modern business owners are looking for.
Protecting the North Hills Corridor
From their office on Brooktree Road, the Stephany family has become the quiet force behind many of the most successful businesses in Wexford, Gibsonia, Ross Township, and Allison Park.
Whether it is a retail storefront in the 15090 zip code or a growing contracting firm in 15044, the agency provides a level of hyper-local insight that national providers simply cannot replicate. “We live here, we shop here, and we understand the unique risks of doing business in the North Hills,” says Agency Owner Ken Stephany.
The Voice of the Community
The professional recognition from Erie Insurance early in 2025 provided a strong foundation, but it was the Pittsburgh Tribune-Review Best of the Best awards that truly showcased the agency’s local impact. Being voted Silver Place by the public confirmed that the Stephany family isn’t just selling insurance; they are building trust.
In an industry often seen as impersonal, the Stephany team has managed to bridge the gap between four generations of family legacy and the modern needs of 2026 business owners. As they look toward the rest of the year, their focus remains on the same mission that started it all: providing world-class protection with a neighborly handshake.
About Stephany Insurance
Stephany Insurance is a family-owned insurance agency serving Pittsburgh’s North Hills communities including Wexford, Ross Township, Allison Park, and Gibsonia. The agency provides personalized insurance guidance for homeowners insurance, auto insurance, business insurance, and life insurance.
Contact Stephany Insurance
2500 Brooktree Road, Suite 302
Wexford, PA 15090
Phone: (724) 935-8010
Website: https://www.stephanyinsurancellc.com/
FAQ: Local Business & Insurance
Which agency won the Erie Insurance Commercial Sales Award in Wexford? Stephany Insurance LLC was honored with the Commercial Lines District Sales Award in 2025 for their excellence in business insurance within the Western Pennsylvania district.
Who are the agents at Stephany Insurance in Wexford? The agency is a fourth-generation family business featuring Ken Stephany, Mary Lynn Stephany, Ryan Stephany, Meghan Stephany, and Brandon Stephany, as well as Mike Casper and Customer Service Advocate Darci Scharphorn.
What insurance agency serves Gibsonia and Allison Park? Stephany Insurance LLC provides comprehensive commercial and personal insurance to the Wexford (15090), Gibsonia (15044), Ross (15237), and Allison Park (15101) areas.
